Skip to main content
Loading video...

Satchel Quest Review: Turn the Paige

Transcript 18:10

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.

I'm Joey Evans.

And I'm Mike Delisio.

And today we're playing a game called Satchel Quest. Which is a name uh that's not that's different, right?

It is different.

a dungeon crawler, but it's called Satchel Quest because this is a bag building game where you're pulling chips from a bag and placing them out and you're anthropomorphic animals, but you're drawn by Vincent Dutrait, so it evens out.

Doesn't feel like anything really like the other games that this design trio has really come out with. This those have been mostly the cozy games like Cascadia. I guess there's a puzzle element, so that's similar.

the animals are more like I Yeah, I guess you're right.

But it is weird such background.

It is weird city games which is different than the normal That's not flat out which the normal company that that this is Molly Johnson, Robert Melvin, and Sean Stankevich the designers of this. Anyway, I'm going to show you how this plays and then we'll be back.

In this game you're going to start with picking a hero. Each of these heroes is asymmetrical and they're going to come with special abilities. You'll start with a special ability and as you gain levels, you'll get more special abilities. You also have a bag with chips that you're going to be pulling from this bag and these chips are different per player that at least the starting ones are going to be so. And you would come with a reference guide which tells you all your different abilities that you might have as you level up in this game as you get experience, you can spend for example three experience and then you can take both of these level one chips and pick one of them as a special ability that you'll have in play. But there actually three level one chips, so you only ever have two possibilities per game randomly. So you might not have the same special abilities from game to game. A game takes place over five rounds and each round you're going to turn over a path card. You can use path cards from the same set. There's multiple sets included in the game or mix them. But you'll turn this over and it will give you maybe here's a quest you need to defeat four monsters in a single round without dying.

Um but it also the first one tells you how much money you start with, your starting health, and some equipment. Here you start with two torches. So this will be the first thing you turn over. It might have some special rules. Like this one says start with a dungeon depths instead of a dungeon entrance. So there might be some special rules that it applies to that round. Then everyone's going to draw a dungeon. So there's a big pile of dungeon cards here. Whenever you draw from these or when you draw from any, you know, the chips in this game that are dual sided, you always draw from the bottom and then you're going to pick which side of this you would like to start with. So perhaps I would like to start with this side. You're then going to simultaneously be going through your dungeon. The way that works is you place your hero on the stairs in the top floor. You then draw chips one at a time. When you draw a chip, you can use either side of that chip. So perhaps I'll put that chip here like this on this spot. And then I draw the next chip and hmm I'll put that chip here on this spot.

And I draw the next chip. It's a monster or a gold. I think I'd rather have the gold. And you're going to continue to do this. And once you have completely filled a row, you have a choice to stop if you want to or you can move down to the next row and keep pulling chips from your bag until you're done. If you finish your whole dungeon you want to keep exploring, then you'll pull one from the dungeon depths and you'll put that underneath. And when you you'll stick it here although you are allowed to slide it one space in either direction if you want to. And you can keep going farther down in the dungeon if you want to. When you finish and when you stop, once everyone stopped, you're going to resolve your dungeon, but you only resolve the floors that you've descended to as a hero. The first thing you'll do is you'll resolve your potions. Everyone will get hit points equal to however many potions you have. So, I have one potion here, you get a hit point. Then you're going to check any chests. So, this chest here is going to give me seven gold and a ladder and it will do two damage to me unless I have these symbols next to it.

So, I need a couple of these symbols and that purple symbol. I have the purple one, but I don't have the other symbols next to it. So, I would only take the damage from it, two damage. And in this game you can die or lose all your hit points and get knocked out, I guess, which is not great for that round, but you'll come back and be able to come back in a future round. You get some hit points back. If you do it exactly have these symbols next to it exactly, then you'll get the rewards. If you have these symbols, but you have more symbols than you need, you'll get the rewards, but you'll also take the damage. Then monsters, you'll deal with monsters. You'll take damage from them. So, this monster does two damage to me. However, fortunately, I have blocked it with one of the damage with this shield. So, shields will block things that they are directly next to, but the game also has armor in it, which will block damage or help block damage in an entire row. You can see this one helps block one damage in a whole row. So, in this case I only block one damage, so I'll take a damage from the monster. Then you need to do this much damage to defeat the monster. So, I need to do five damage. Now, swords only do damage of things that they're next to. So, this would do three damage to him.

Arrows do damage diagonally, so this in a in the entire row, too. So, this is one. So, I'm only doing four damage to him, except I happen to be Ironhide and my special ability is my swords do one damage in all directions. So, these two swords, so I would take that and that gives you four gold, four victory points, and four experience. After you're done with fighting the monsters, then you're going to get money equal to all your coins. Your green gems are going to give you a reward. This one, for example, gives experience equal to the number of adjacent coins. So, it's next to a single coin, so that would give me one experience. And then these purple artifacts are going to give you things per group. So, if you have more than one artifact next to each other, you will get, for example, that you get one reward for each type of artifact. So, I have two artifacts, so I might take experience and health.

And then with the group is a size two, so I'd get two experience and two health. If they are both the same thing, I would just pick two experience, two health, two points, or two money, my choice. So, everyone's going to go through resolving their dungeons one at a time. You have a little guide that walks you through all the different steps. After that, there's a chance for players to level up and to heal if they've been knocked out, basically going to camp. And then players are going to go to the village here, and everyone's going to get three turns in player order. And on your turn, you can take one browse action and one shop action. A browse action is basically refreshing one of the shops or peeking at the other side of a chip here. The other action, a shop action, you can just buy one of these chips. It has the costs underneath them, or you can take one of these actions where you can heal two health, get two experience, and get a special ability, or you can take one of the different items that are in the game. So, there are three different items. There's keys, uh torches, and ladders. Ladders let you move to levels before you're done filling them up. A torch lets you, after you draw a chip from the bag, draw two more chips and pick one of them. And a key can be used as one of the requirements for a chest when you open it.

And there's all [snorts] sorts of things that you can buy, different items. There are other ways to attack like magic wands. These will do a damage in a horizontal line in any of the directions it will do damage and you'll just get better items of the things that you've already seen. After five rounds, whoever has the most points is the winner.

There's a couple things I really like about the production of this game. I think that the art that they did your tray, I think it's very well done. Great. I think that the each player having a little thing that tells you exactly how your special powers work is very good.

Crucial.

And also a walk through on how to do the combat which is nice.

Mhm.

Then they said, "Hey, but you know the player aid on how a turn works, you just need one of them." Confuses to what that is. It is a little bit confusing sometimes. I I found everybody I maybe this is just me being a bad teacher, but the traps and the icons needed to trigger a trap, people be like, "What does this icon stand for?" I'm like, "I think that's a monster." But it's not particularly it's like well it's the same color.

It's close to the to the weapon color.

Yeah, it's so that was the up but other than that again, I think it's good. The bags, the chips in this game, this has gone through a couple small conventions and the initial 10 chips are pretty worn at this point, sure, but it doesn't matter because you're just pointing from a bag and looking at them. So it's not I mean they're just worn on the edges that you can still easily read them.

Yeah, and you're not going to feel a difference in the bag between those and the ones you're buying from the market.

No. No, so let's so let's talk about the gameplay itself. Let's talk about the the high level of player interaction.

All right, that's Yeah, I think it's compared to After Us as far as like there's so little.

There's a couple times you interact when you have to hand the dungeons out maybe you'll get to that point, but yeah, it's it's kind of head down.

They'll try to inject a little bit of that and the main point of interaction is maybe taking a tile that somebody wanted at the market before them. But, this is very high on the multiplayer solid solitaire

Well, you played it solo.

Yeah.

Did it feel particularly different?

No, it didn't. No, the the the changes that were made were really just having fewer options in the market, but otherwise you're playing it exactly the same way. You know, the difference is that you don't have a score that you're trying to beat as far as like another player.

Yeah.

You're trying to hit a threshold and do achievements. It's one of those types of solo modes.

And so, that leads to my biggest issue with this game, which I like. Um, and I want to talk about the the mechanics of the game in a second, but the the problem with this game is is that there's so little player interaction, and you're simultaneously playing at the same time. And then you go to the market phase, and the game slows down to an absolute crawl as Mike sits there and thinks for a long time about which chip he wants to buy, and then I'm like, "Well, I know what chip I'm going to buy." Mike goes, "This is the row I'm going to wipe."

Yeah. Yeah.

And I'm like, "Well, all right. So, now I need to rethink." And that market phase just felt so long compared to the rest of the game.

Right, cuz you're you're I'm sorry.

No, no, go ahead.

You're taking each player's taking three turns in turn order. So, it just it feels like it's such a a disconnect pacing-wise from the rest of the game.

It's weird because it feels so out of place in a game that happened in so quick. Like, "Wow, bam, bam, bam, bam, bam."

Mhm.

Now someone's writing the check.

You know, it's

like it's like, "Ah, slow." And then he's like, "All right, you almost done?"

I got one item.

Yeah, it's it it does feel like disconnected.

And it's also possible in a game in a multiplayer game that I go through my dungeon, I stop, I'm ready, and I notice the other person's still on their top floor.

Yes.

And there's nothing I can do. I just have to sit there and wait. So, keep that in mind. More players will lengthen the game because the market player phase is longer, or or town phase, whatever it's called. And you will play at the rate of the slowest player.

That's the thing cuz it is a puzzle. As you pull those, it's not just a push your luck cuz I love push your luck bag building games. This is it has a puzzle element on top of that decision to push your luck.

And it will get longer as the game goes on because you now have more path cards you have to account for, right? They can all change things up. You have more tiles you're pulling from the bag, meaning more decisions. Uh so the game length increases as it goes on.

Yeah. The game also does some weird things. So they have these the path cards.

Mhm.

And there's a there's a certain set that they say, "Use this for your first game." Okay, great. I use it. The very first thing it says is kill four enemies in the same turn and then you get a certain amount of points, which isn't a ton of points, by the way. Just some points.

Yeah.

You're not going to do that till turn four maybe. You you only have maybe one or two enemies that are available out there.

You might have one pre-printed in your starting

And you're not going to kill them both.

And then they kill four also without dying. It just seemed like an odd thing. It was almost like they're like, "You'll get to do this later."

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You you're really pushing it to do it even by the second round, you know. Uh

And they use some weird things with those cards. Like it will turn So one of them turns the card this way and you're going down the long way.

Right.

One you use a little card instead of the big card initially, which I don't love. But I don't mind that stuff. It's it's diverse. What you said is interesting. I want to know what you guys thought about it. It's not push your luck, which I'm okay with because when you pull a chip, this really cool you can use either side. You're like another monster. Oh. It's more of when you pull stuff like, "I really need a weapon right now. Come on. Where's the weapon?" You can use a torch maybe to get more pulls, but it's more about that than pushing your luck cuz they're like, "You can stop when you want to." You know at that point if you should stop or not.

Yes. Yeah, it's more I guess like risk mitigation, that type of a thing, closer to that than push your luck. Although it I I I do have to say, to Joey's point, sometimes it feels it gives you a similar feels to push your luck without it being strictly mechanically push your luck. You know what I mean?

Right. And I like the objects that can kind of mitigate things. Like the ladders, the torches, and all that type of stuff. I do I like when those come into play.

Mhm.

And if you remember you have them, that's the biggest thing.

Well, that's another slight issue I think is that there's a lot of things that you have to kind of keep track of and account for, especially again as the game goes on and different things you're having to kind of make sure you're keeping on top of. It's a very procedural game. I mentioned that, you know, when I talked about the resolution phase, but just in general it's it's a very procedural game.

It's a game that makes me think a lot about it.

Mhm.

Um I I'm really interested in the puzzle and you want to push in different ways and you want to do the traps, you want to kill the monsters, you want to get the weird string of gems.

You want to upgrade the right way, the right weapons, and all that.

Right.

It it also has a a building effect. You said there's more to go on, but it's almost like the first turn I'm almost twiddling my thumbs because you have those initial 10 chips and it's not that interesting, but starting with turn two I bought maybe two more chips to throw in the bag. Now I got 12 that I'm pulling and then on turn three I have 13 or 14 and it really ramps up and it gets much more juicy. I almost wish you could do a fast start to the game.

Well, I I wish you could do a fast start and a fast end.

Because I think conversely, not that I don't like the game, I do like the game. It's too long. I feel like it's too long. I feel like it needs a prelude uh you know, expansion and a shorter game total game length.

I might be with Mike. If you could cut the final round just for sheer time and then cut the first one and you start with a market phase and some money, buy some chips to get your initial seed and then play three rounds.

Right.

That feels like it'd be a perfect length. I think you could just do that.

You could, yeah. You'd have to mess around with balancing and you'd change your path cards, too, but

Now this this review overall with all the things we're saying has a slight negative tilt and I don't mean it to be that way, but I also think a a lot of people are going to bounce off this game. Um in fact, we know some people here bounced off the game that we played with. Not everyone has enjoyed it that I played it with. I like it, but I'm giving it a seven. Um I think it's a very interesting puzzle. It is straightforward. I like the idea of going I just don't know if I need the other players at the table. I haven't played the straight solo thing which you have done, but I feel like I have. I feel like I've done it myself. So, it's an interesting puzzle and pull the chips out and everything and like, "Ooh, I got Oh, and some of the chips feel great like the armor protect myself on a whole row. Yeah." You know, or the And and I also like that they're asymmetrical. They're just They're just different enough with the special powers. Leveling up, all that stuff is fun.

It just feels like it almost should have just been a solo game, but still a seven. I liked it.

I'm going to go with I think this is a game that the the rating could almost be adjusted by player count. I'm going to give it its rating at its at its highest form uh in in my opinion, which is going to be a 7.5, which is I think is the one or two player game.

Okay.

I I I I think that that's the game at its best because you're either just playing it solo, which it essentially is, or you're playing against one other opponent, and unless you're way off on your pacing, it's going to be about the same amount of time. It'll be relatively more quick, still probably around too long, but I like the game. It's one I want to come back to. I feel like it's so close to being a much better game, but it's still something I recommend. Just know it's not for everybody. It's 7.5.

I'm at a seven on it. And And I think Mike said the right too. It's like it's so close. A couple things you shorten that market phase that hit that kind of sludge. You fix that because there's so much I love about it. I love bag building games. This is fantastic. And then that puzzle when you pull it, you're hoping to get certain chips that you just put in there cuz like I would love to have that now. And the weapons and things the abilities are pretty cool. You know, be able to hit different areas. a lot to love about this game, but a couple of things should have been shaved off, you know? It could have sped up more, shortened it down, make it tighter, and I see this going straight up. But, I think people would enjoy it. But, like you said, I see people bouncing off because of those flaws.

There you go. Let us know what you think in the comments. That's Satchel Quest. I'm Tom.

I'm Joey.

I'm Mike.

See you next time.

Pulling chips.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games,

we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved