Caylus Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today i'm taking a look at kayla's which is a 2-5 player worker placement board game designed by william attia and published by astari games this one was printed way back in 2005 and takes around two hours to play on average so this is actually the original version of the game however this game has been re-implemented by kayla's 1303 which i have not played and i cannot testify the differences between the two but i always wanted to try this original one because this is considered to be quite an iconic and influential design and considered to be one of the first worker placement games so the game is going to look like this when it's set up where you have this big board here and in the top left hand corner of this board you have the castle which is going to be one of the main factors of the game because one of the main ways you get points is by donating to the castle by trading and resources to get victory points and the earlier you do that in the earlier phases you get more points based on if you do it later you've got this little king's favor track here which can give you little bonuses as you crawl up such as getting victory points money resources or even discounts on different buildings you also have all these different worker placement spots you can go to which follow a kind of track so you've got these kind of special buildings here which never get covered up and they never change you've got the bridge here which will determine player order when it comes to it which we'll touch on shortly and during setup these pink buildings have been randomly shuffled and put into the first six spots here and these are all pretty
simple work placement spots which you know if you play a lot of work placement games this is going to sound you know quite a common theme where you just put your worker down on these and you'll end up getting resources and you've got a number of different resources in this game i think there's five different types with slightly different variances on how rare they are for example i think these food cubes here these pinky ones are quite common but the yellow ones the gold ones become quite rare and are worth quite a few points at the end of the game and there are also different types of buildings so not only you've got the resource ones you've got ones like this which will let you build new buildings which we'll touch on shortly and even ones like this where you can trade in any resources for money and money is quite a tight factor in this game you can also see that there are two white pieces on the main track here and these are going to have quite an influential part of the game and can impact what people will do so the first one here this bailiff cylinder is simply going to be a kind of a countdown or a timer to the game because every round he's going to move one or two spaces which will trigger scoring once it hits these different spots so you've got the three different parts or the three different scoring phases and after the third phase when the uh when the bailiff reaches this spot then the uh the game is going to end after the final scoring is calculated and that is where you're going to have a look at who's donated the most to the um to the castle here and depending on how much people have donated you're going to get different bonuses or even punishment so you can see here in the in the first scoring phase if you've got at least two donations to the castle then you're going to get a little bonus of a king's favor which will give
you a little boon on this track here but if you don't don't know anything you can lose two points and that applies to the middle scoring again the more buildings you get built the more scoring you get and if you don't build anything you're going to lose more and more points okay if i didn't make it clear then the objective of this game is to get as many victory points as you can and the game is going to play out over multiple rounds and each of those rounds is going to get divided into seven different phases the first phase is ultra simple where you're going to take two coins or at least start with by taking two coins as income from the supply and there are ways to increase that income and because money is quite a tight resource in this game and you need it to do pretty much everything but once everybody's done that phase you're going to go into the main kind of part of the game which is where you are going to be placing your workers onto the different spots so the different thing about this game that differs to a lot of other work placement games out there now is that when you place your worker on these different spots let's say i did this here and you always have to pay a coin at least one coin to do so that can get higher depending on if other people's have passed before you which will touch on in a little bit but additionally um you do not get the rewards instantly you have to wait into a later phase until these are resolved because things can change in the interim but let's talk about what some more of these spots do um so you've got this little bridge one here this gate tile and basically what this means is if you go here then after all the different spots have been taken and it comes to a later phase to these
spots being resolved you can use this to activate any unclaimed tile now that might sound like a bit of a waste of time if you don't know what comes later but we'll touch on that very shortly this one here just simply gets you three coins from the bank this one here ties more into this spot here where this is going to move this provost disc here now the provost is a bit of a um a nagging tension in this game because when somebody when this spot here is resolved then whoever is on that spot gets to move this provost one to three spaces in either direction up or down the track here now this is a massive factor of the game because any building that is activated after the provost is completely void they are not going to get to take that action uh this spot here lets you trade in a coin and a blue cube to get one of these king's favors to climb up these tracks here this one here is going to be for turn order because turn order is quite a big factor of this game because um you know the work the different spots get gobbled up very quickly this one here is the in now this is quite a cool spot because normally as i mentioned earlier whenever you take a worker placement spot you have to spend a coin to the bank however if somebody passes after they've you know deployed the amount of workers they want to they're going to take the first spot here like this and claim a coin now that means that every worker placed after that is going to have to spend two coins per worker they deploy or even if somebody else passes after that then this player is going to have to spend three coins per deployment they make so
again the longer you take and if people pass before you it gets more and more expensive but the in basically means that if you control the in then it's always going to cost you one coin no matter what so it's a great contingency plan to always pay the minimum these ones here are very self-explanatory where you take the resources and this one here is going to be build new buildings uh particularly a wood building so it's like a carpenter spot now when this spot comes to resolving you can build any of these wooden tiles here these brown ones and add them onto the board now these all have a another benefit on them and offer victory points that top right hand number there and will cost you additional resources so you can see this one here costs you a pink and a brown cube but it will let you build this kind of stone mason tile and add it onto the board as a new worker placement spot so that's going to this one's going to allow you to build these gray buildings which will give you more victory points and even more output so gets you a whole of resources with a single placement and can even unlock this gold resource which is going to be worth i think that three points each at the end of the game there's some more different buildings here such as trading in money for victory points and so on now there's also another option to build these residential buildings by going to this spot here so i think this is the lawyer spot now when you go to that spot once of course it's already on the board you are going to be able to build one of these residential buildings either on an existing building of yours or onto one of these neutral pink buildings now when you do that you are going to cover up the spot meaning that nobody else can go there but also put one of
your buildings on it like so just to show it's yours and that will increase your income each round so now this player is going to be worth three points or sorry three coins for every income phase something that's also worth mentioning is that when a building is built so let's just say again the yellow player built this one here and not only are they going to get these points instantly but also if anybody else ever uses that building so let's just say the green player went here on a later turn then the yellow player because they built this building in the first place is always going to get a victory point so you could be quite careful about using that again and again because people are going to benefit and profit off that placement now the stone buildings not only do they offer you a victory point if somebody else uses your building but they also get you an additional resource you can see here this woodland tile is going to get you a either an additional wood or one of these food tokens furthermore this architect tile is going to let you replace any residential buildings which are these those house ones which up your income into one of these blue um landmark tokens i forget what they're called and again they some of them will give you more income but most of them would give you a big chunk of victory points because they are quite costly another work replacement spot you can go to is to the castle and when you do that you're going to put your cube or your worker sorry your cylinder on the first available spot there now that does mean that multiple people can go to the church however it will be resolved in that order so the green player will have opportunity to build first now when you go here you're gonna have to spend three different resources one of which is going to be one of the pink cubes and as
i mentioned earlier you are going to put your house on that location this would of course be the green player but i've only got the yellow houses here i'm going to get these points instantly now additionally the person who built the most um houses each round is going to get a little um favor by going up the king's track and if there's a tie on who's built the most houses then it's going to be the person who deployed first now on top of all that if you ever choose to place a worker on the castle spot there and you do not have the resources to contribute to the um to the castle because maybe you overestimated yourself or you got caught off guard by the provost then you are actually going to lose a victory point in fact gonna lose two victory points now something i also didn't mention is that when you start to resolve these different buildings and you get to the bridge area in the order in which players pass they're going to have an extra opportunity to move the provost and each player again in order so starting with the yellow player is going to have the opportunity to spend up to three coins so one to three coins in order to move the provost one to three spaces however they see fit you know maybe the yellow player had a um a worker here they really wanted this spot so they're gonna spend that extra three coins to try and push it further this way so they haven't wasted this placement however if you pass earlier you are going to be a bit more at the mercy of the other players because they're going to have the opportunity to push it back down so after you've taken your income you've placed your workers you've resolved the special buildings you've moved the provost resolved the other buildings and
then resolved building the castles and i should say you can do this multiple times if you have the resources to do it then at the end of the turn is going to be triggered where the um the bailiff is going to move either one or two spaces so if the provost is on the left-hand side of the bailiff then it's only going to move one space but if it's on the right-hand side of the bay lift then it's going to move um or the probe sorry it's going to move two spaces so again that can kind of dictate the pace of the play i can actually play quite a big part okay so let's get into some thoughts on kayla's so i'm gonna start off with some basic uh mechanical things in the game so first up i do actually quite like the way that this game uses this more like a programming work placement system rather than you simply placing your work up onto the spot and instantly getting the reward you are kind of thinking more ahead because sometimes you know the um like for example the carpenter spot here might resolve before you actually get the resources you need for that carpenter spot in the first place so it's not like you can get the resources here and then go there after and then build the building you need to consider about the way and order these things are resolved which adds a kind of a new dimension to the game and to be honest i've been caught off guard with this more than once where i'm just kind of in that default mindset where i think you know i'm going to have the resources so this is going to resolve i'm going to have it where in reality i've simply done it in the wrong order so it's just a small little wrinkle there that will keep you on your toes and that also ties into the castle donations because you want to be putting your worker down here pretty quickly because you're going to reserve that
first spot and give yourself a better chance of claiming the king's favor which is quite a significant part of the game and can give you a hell of a lot of rewards if you keep on winning the majorities here so again you want to be getting here first in order to do that because quite often you'll all be contributing the same amount if any um but if you end up going here but not actually getting the rewards in the first place or the the resources you need then that can actually end up costing you victory points and it all ties back to the uncertainty of the provost because you might think you know what yeah all these resource spots i need are right on the edge of the provost here i might be safe but in reality in actuality the other players might be almost conspiring against you and investing either their time into going to the provost spot here or when it gets to resolving on the bridge to push that provost way past you and to completely um almost throw your plans under the bus i think this provost mechanism is going to be somewhat polarizing to a lot of people you're either gonna love it or you are going to probably not like it so much now i will say generally speaking i'm not the biggest fan of ultra confrontational or spiteful mechanisms in games and to be honest this does kind of align to that it's not a it's certainly not a pleasant experience being cut off by the other players and having wasted your placements because of the movement of that provost um but there are actually other things to consider here i mean my game group generally don't like that style of gameplay anyway we won't deliberately try to do things to ruin your plans um however there were
certain times in the game that i did quite enjoy the way this worked because if say for example i was a blue player here and it came to my turn to moving the provost i might just choose to spend a coin or two just to push it further along this way almost just to almost detract or to try and um you know make it less inviting for the other players to spend all that additional money just to make you cost cost you one worker there might have been an incentive to do it if it was just the one coin but if they're gonna have to spend so much then they're probably not gonna do it anyway so yes it can be ultra cut throat if you want to play that way but it doesn't really have to be and it can be used as a kind of um you know thread of tension throughout the game rather than directly spiteful to the other players i do like the way that the castle scoring works because you are always under pressure to donate as much as you can because there are limited spots at the higher point values but also you want to be constantly competing to get that king's favor there because if you keep on letting the same people win again and again they are going to quickly start gaining points that you just have almost no way to catch back up on so that is a really cool idea and again it has that extra attention of wanting to do things by certain checkpoints in the game now if it gets to each scoring phase and you've not really done your work you've not put enough effort into effort into donating to the castle then that can cost you a hell of a lot of points and you want to be putting buildings down anyway not only for the point in the first place but also because you're gonna gonna get these extra boons by donating more and more the money in this game is fascinating
because it's such a tight and hard to manage resource because you need money to do pretty much everything of course you need it with every single worker placement spot you're going to need it to take other additional additional costs in terms of you know converting money into cubes and you're going to want it as a contingency to move the provost and so on so again managing that money as efficient as you can and making sure you're not wasting it is a big big part of the game and it even makes these other kind of money gaining spots very sought after because again money is going to be the backbone of everything that you do but i do enjoy the fact that you can actually build up a little bit of an engine by establishing these residential buildings which will increase your income each round which can really pay off long term on top of all those other interesting things we've already discussed i think my favorite part of the game believe it or not might be the passing mechanism so i love the fact that when somebody passes you know they're not an idiot are they going to get the extra coin it's going to start ramping up the costs for other people to continue what they're doing and you can actually really catch the other players off guard quite a lot with this because maybe they've got some plans in order that they wanted to do and maybe they've already put a worker down on the church or so on the castle and they still have several places to go before they get the resources in order to contribute to that in the first place and the fact that you've passed just means they're going to start bleeding money faster and faster you know maybe it's going to cost them three coins with every single placement which can be absolutely crippling in terms of your finances and that just makes the other spots even more inviting by you know
being first in the turn order or even um this spot here in particular where if you invest in this spot then no matter when you pass then you're always going to be spending one coin which is such a huge advantage to have now i also love the fact that if you have established a building by building it then no matter when people have passed if you use your own building it's only ever going to cost you in fact that's a residential building but if you use your own building there's only ever going to cost you one coin rather than what it would normally cost by the passing order here the building mechanism of you know building the board as you go um creating new work spots for other people but gaining an advantage if other people go to that spot it's almost like a tried and tested design point that a lot of games have used and to be honest i've never not liked it when a game uses this mechanism it's such a nice and passive way to introduce play interaction into the game is it worth you giving or constantly giving other players that bonus by utilizing the spot they've built so i do really like the way that works yeah you are creating opportunities for other people to go there and get more resources but you know what maybe you're going to use your own building and get the advantages of that let you down the road and of course even if you don't you're going to keep on taking an income of points and even get the initial points from building the building in the first place so you're always incentivized to keep building things in order to keep the game developed and keep the um you know the spots open and keep the game ticking along and despite the game constantly offering you new opportunities by placing more tiles on the board it still manages to maintain its tightness as the game goes
on because of course as the game goes on people are going to start building these residential buildings which will cover up the initial spots so even though the output of these tiles might be increased there is still the limited availability of each resource meaning that every single placement is paramount to you know the order you want to do things how are you going to prioritize everything this is one of those examples of a game um or work placement games doing work replacement right where every single spot is inviting and you know that turn angst of wanting to get to the spot that you want is so agonizing at times i think initially the face structure can seem a bit overwhelming you know you have seven phases but after a few turns of playing through it is actually remarkably intuitive now simply take your income do the work placement resolve the work placement do the castle and then you're pretty much good to go for the next phase now that being said the game is on the longer side of euros that i tend to enjoy you know it's pushing um beyond my comfort level kind of going towards that two hour mark now i don't think that's unreasonable for a game like this because it does have a hell of a lot of depth there's a lot of decisions from start to finish it's an engaging design um but to be honest i do consciously and would actively encourage you if especially if you're running the game to keep the game moving along you know just encouraging people to be as quick as they can i'm your office cost not rushing them but just consciously making an effort to keep the forward momentum going because if you start really mulling over your turns it can start taking a bit too long i think kayla scales pretty well and my
sweet spot for this game is definitely three players which is kind of a generic standpoint i have on most heavier style euros two players works fine the only thing you have to consider is that there is no um you know manipulatable player order four players i would i could be convinced to play out i would be conscious that i wanted quicker players because i wouldn't want to start pushing towards that three hour mark i think that's going to be a bit overkill for me personally well five players i will say that i wouldn't really ever consider bringing it out because it's gonna be a bit too long for me personally but yeah that two to four player count is um is okay for me particularly the three player count when it comes to the production of k-list you're gonna fall into one of two camps either you're going to instantly be put off and know that this game isn't for you because it looks too bland it looks too boring and too beige and you're going to want something a little bit more colorful and visually stimulating or alternatively you're going to be like myself and you're going to instantly know what you're going to get into you kind of start to learn to trust games that look like this and to be honest you start to love games that look like this where it's all um no it's all steak and no sizzle when it comes to the physical production there's absolutely no issues whatsoever the tile quality is more than adequate you've got your standard wooden desks your wooden houses and things that you've seen in so many other euros um and there's no real flaws in the actual physical um you know physical pieces money's fine you know the cubes and resources are simply your standard wooden euro cubes but you could choose to upgrade them if you wanted to okay so let's get into some final thoughts on kayla's so i think i mentioned at the beginning of the video
this has always been a bit of a bucket list star game for me um most people advocate this game who like the style of games that i do um however i will always kind of hesitate to get it played or to pick it up myself because generally speaking i don't like worker placement games or at least i'm not excited by worker placement games where the worker placement is the main aspect of the game i normally like them when they're part of a bigger picture or a different style of game um it's not a mechanism i'm opposed to it's just something that doesn't really excite me too much um but it's fascinating to me that this game is 17 years old and despite that i don't think that any game since then you know probably hundreds of them by now i don't think any of them have improved upon this style of work placement game where you're you know placing your workers down collecting resources and then trading them in for other things um there's so many finely tuned things about this game that i think is so well done i touched on before the passing mechanism is excellent love the way that works i love the tension of wanting to get to every single spot and when you do anything you're missing out on something else which again is another must-have essential part of a worker placement game for me i don't like it when there's too much openness and everything is too generous this completely throws out the water and makes it as tight as can be that mixed with the tightness of the resources the tightness tightness of the money i'm investing in new buildings that trade-off of giving other people points for buildings uh what a fantastic design this one is and i was left feeling very
very impressed by it i've really been mulling over how i'm going to rate this game i mean mechanically there really isn't anything i can improve upon it does work like clockwork and it's just a completely sound and excellent design um that being said the game does take a little bit longer than i usually like for euros to take so i do need to make sure that i i'm in the right headspace and not only for the amount of time and effort it's gonna cost and the kind of mental capacity because it is quite a you know it's quite a draining game because you need to be switched on from start to finish but also the fact that it has a layer of interaction here especially the conflict style nature and almost despiteful style nature that i need to be in the right headspace and in the right mood to engage with now i can get past it because i think it's such a pivotal part of the game an important and even fun part of the game um but again i still need to be in that right head space to fully immerse myself and throw myself in you know with two feet so but you know despite those things i don't think i can avoid giving this one an elite shield it's just such a fantastic design one that's ultra ultimately stood the test of time beyond hundreds of worker placement games and is still right at the forefront of those designs if you like your dry euros you don't mind getting the claws out and just a simple kind of convert cubes to other cubes and get victory points then if you like that style of game i have no doubt that you're going to enjoy kayla's