Formaggio Review: It's Italian for Fromage
Transcript
Hey everyone, I'm Tom Vassel
and I'm Chris Ye.
And I have a cheese problem. I'm not kidding. I mean, I really like cheese a lot. Um, if the doctor ever tells me I can't have it, I'm going to I don't know if I might just die. Um, we have someone coming over for dinner and they said they can't have cheese and I was like, but what what are we going to make? I don't know what to do. Maybe
does it feel good to get this off your chest?
I just like cheese. Anyway, this is a game about cheese. Um, and this is actually a sequel. Foragio is a sequel/standalone expansion for a game called Fromage. Uh, both games designed by Ben Rosset. Um, they are about worker placement and making different kinds of cheeses.
Yeah. Um, I do like cheese. I really do. Okay, let's move on to the game overview. In this game, you're going to build these four sections of the board. This whole board can rotate. And in each of these sections, you will put a sheet uh for the number of players. So, this is for four players. Here, I have one for one or two players. And there's two sides. So, when you stick these in the board, they'll show different cheeses through the slots. And in fact, there's one here for four players that's already printed on the board, so you don't even need to put one in if you're doing that. You can also mix and match these different sections. They can be in any order, and you can mix and match them with the first game formage. Each player gets 15 cheese tokens and one of the three different types of cheese plastic pieces here. There are different resources you'll be collecting throughout the game. The the different shapes in them doesn't really matter.
You'll be collecting these livestock here. You'll be collecting fruit that gets put into your basket. And you'll also be collecting cards that are over here. And then finally, buildings that can be placed here. Everyone's going to have a different board at the beginning of the game that has some preprinted buildings on it. And you can also draw and or draft other buildings that will go in each of these spots. So you can start the board with your a unique building setup. On a player's turn, the first thing you'll do is you'll retrieve workers. You have three workers. And so if any worker is pointing towards you, you will take those back and get them. If they're pointing in any other direction, you will leave them on the board. Then players are going to put pieces on their section of the board. Between each turn, the board's going to rotate. So you can place these on the board. You can always place them in the middle here to get resources. So when I place a worker here in the middle, I'm going to get one, two, or three fruit here. One, two, or three livestock. One, two, or three buildings. one, two, or three order cards. Why am I doing this?
Well, I mean, obviously, why would I take the three? Because, as you can see, the three takes three turns before I get it back. While if I take the one, I'm going to get it back on the very next turn. You also can place down here, but when you place down here, your piece that you have needs to match the cheese that's underneath it. And you also might need some fruit. You'll notice when there's fruit, it's either going to show jam or sliced fruit. And when that happens, you need to have a fruit to spend. And you're going to put the fruit in either here with the the cheese that's in the fruit or over here as jam. If you don't have any fruit, you can't place in those spots. Also, when you place in one of these spots here, you're going to be placing one of your cheese tokens there. And so, even when you remove your worker later on, that will stay there and block that area off. And at the end of the game, the way you place these pieces on the board, each section is going to score differently.
The other resources, if you have livestock, you can spend a certain amount of livestock. And you'll see here two, three, four, or five. When you spend livestock, you put on a space, and then you can put one of your cheese tokens out on a cheese in that direction and that color that that softness, soft blue or hard cheese, and you don't even have to put a worker there. Buildings can be built and they're going to give you special abilities. So maybe if I go here, that means anytime I put something out in the blue cheese, I will get a livestock. Some give you endgame points. Order cards are put over here. And when you put out that particular cheese, this is a hard cheese silver, which means it's a hard cheese and it's pointing away from me when I put the piece on. I can move it over here. And at the end of the game, you're going to get points for the number of cheeses you have over here. The game ends when someone puts out their 15th cheese token. And then you're going to score each of the different sections. This one here, for example, uh you're going to count, you'll see there's different regions here. You'll count the number of regions you're in and multiply that by the number of flags you have, which it shows right here for points at the end of the game. In this region, you're going to be collecting wine bottles.
As you take each cheese here, you'll take the wine bottle token that's underneath it and you'll put them in front of you. And then you're going to be putting them next to each other trying to complete wine bottles for points at the end of the game or even during the game. If you connect these, you'll get a wild resource of your choice. In Venice, you every time you put a cheese piece out on the board, you're also going to be putting some gondas out. And you can put them wherever you want, but usually you're going to want them connected to your restaurants. And at the end of the game, you're just going to count the number of your cheese pieces with gondas attached to them. Although, if I have this piece, and it's this this gondola here is connected to this piece here. So, it's adjacent to two of mine. So, you can see if you get a lot of them, you can score quite a few points.
And then finally, in the last section, you're going to score points for having rows and columns. You can see that in each of these different rows in this piece if you put one here counts as all three columns. So if you have two in a column you get four 10 and 18. And if you have two in the same row you will score the points that it shows here on the side. So you're going to add up all these points plus any possible points that you have from endgame buildings. And whoever has the most points is the winner. I should mention also there is at the end of the game you will also get points for your cards here and for you'll multiply the number of sliced fruit pieces that you have times the number of jam and that will also give you victory points.
If you've seen our review of Formage, there's not a lot of differences that we're going to say here because it is 90% the same game.
Yeah, I agree. Structurally, it's the exact same type of a thing. Um, you know, the, you know, you place out in the wedge in front of you, it rotates eventually get your workers back, so on so forth. U, if you're not familiar with the original game, then, uh, I would think it's safe to say that pretty much all of us who have played it enjoyed it. Enjoyed it plenty. It's fastm moving, simultaneous play, uh, and yet it's it feels clever. feels different from anything else that's that's been out there.
I agree. The the idea that it's simultaneous play is a really big just fantastic thing. Everyone's working at the same time. You spin the board. It plays so quickly, too. This is a game that you'll be surprised. You're like, "Oh, it's almost over."
Yeah. Oh, we've almost put out the LA, you know, that person's almost put out the last cheese block or, you know, um I think that the biggest weakness that's going to be the same between both games is if you want interaction, it feel it's it is interactive because spaces are getting blocked up, but it feels a lot less direct because you know, whatever the person across from you at the table does, it's going to take two rotations before you go, "Oh, you dastardly fiend. You took the spot I wanted. I'll just do something else." That's good.
There is one spot on each board that I think has more interaction on on each in each of the games. On this one, I would say it's the one with the the flags and this you might go, "Well, I'm going to go there just so Chris doesn't get that." I suppose
um I there's a few minor things I would say for your first game, never use anything but the preprint buildings. I agree because you can draft specialty things. Yeah, just preprinted's great. And there's the occasional time where like does the preprinted building mean exactly on on the back of the other ones. You're like it tells you what that does and and but there's no FAQ on them. So you might wonder what they do. And I feel that that just adds some extra unnecessariness to the game. I would have to have played this game. I've played with the buildings and without them. I've done both. But I would have to play this a lot with people for me not to go n let's just use the pre-print. That's I'm going to say most of the time I don't think it adds that much. I mean, they're cool, but you're all And then I would say we're have to draft them and it adds, you know, time to a game that's benefit is it could be 30, 45 minutes.
Yes. Now, if you play this game a lot, then you're going to welcome that variability. And it's nice that it's there. If you're teaching this a lot, man, it's great that they're preprinted. You don't have to do those extra steps. So, I I applaud that. Um, I think that one of the strengths of this particular box is that everything's cross-co compatible with the original. There's not too many new concepts. So, even if someone is playing for the first time, out of the eight wedges, you could just pick and choose four random ones, your four favorite ones. The only major differences I can tell in this game, uh, are there are seasons on those middle on the little middle thing there, and some buildings reference seasons. So,
ah, yeah. Okay.
You get that once every four movements. That's fine. Uh, and then the other thing is the platinum level cheese or the whatever that highest level is. Um, and that's honestly not even that different. It's it takes a full four uh, you know, movements, rotations before you get that workout.
So good.
And they're really good.
You don't got to cheese. I eat platinum level.
But outside of that, I mean, it's it's pretty much the same game structurally. So you could someone could sit down if you know how to play this game for your first play. You could play this one easily. You've never played Formage. I wouldn't really worry about it. You could play this one first.
I have I People are going to ask, you know, what's it like to mix them? I haven't yet. And so I don't It doesn't take a very strong imagination to know what it'll be like. I'm like, "Oh, I've just picked my four favorite of the things." Here's why I haven't though. It's kind of tricky. You need both boxes and then I'm like, "Which one goes back in which box?" I
I almost wish there was a better source solution because the game for us barely fits in here as it is. Now I upgraded some of the containers. There's nice containers that hold everything. You'll fit it in, but this one is slightly better. This is the limited edition version, so it came with a playmat. The middle piece that holds them together is better in this one.
Yes, it lays flat.
It lays flat. That's a huge difference for me. That's that was one of my complaints about the first one. If I was telling you to get one or the other, I would say foragio. Now, I' I've read online a lot of people say Fromage is for the new gamers. Foragio is for people who are already gamers. I don't know that the I don't think the boards are particularly more complex than the other. And it it seems like in both of them there's one board that takes longer to to explain to people and for me this one is easily the rows and columns. You think that would be easy,
but because there's one cheese that's in multiple columns.
Yes.
And you need only two and I don't know why that but it's still not that complex. And I think I like these back and forth. I especially like the wine one where you put them together. I I I like these a little better. Barely, right? I'll play either. It doesn't matter to me. That's kind of where I'm at, too, is that if I think I think the strength is that you can mix and match and pick your favorites and stuff because
there's not a dud in all eight of them between there's not a dud and you're going to have your favorites and such. And I like the little the little extras that come. I like the gondola one. I think that that's maybe the most interactive, so to speak.
Yeah. where you know it just kind of gives you a little extra layer of decisions of where you're going to put those bonus scoring pieces, the gondilas around because it'll affect other players. I think that's good.
Yeah, you basically just want to put it so it touches your It's not It's not heavy strategy either.
No, not at all. Not at all. But other players are going to be able benefit based on what you do. I think that's a nice touch. That makes that probably my favorite board in this box.
This is a fun expansion. I mean fun game whether you have the first one or not. If you have the first one, do you need both? You don't. You only need both if you want to mix and match them. And and if you're not going to,
I just don't see why you would want to have both unless you for like today I'm in a Formagia mood. Today I'm in a for whatever. Uh but I still think it's just as good as the first one. So it's an 8.5 for me. An excellent game. The simultaneous play of it really sells it. And the idea of spinning a board and when the cheese points towards you, you pull it off. Such an easy concept for people to get other than explaining how fruit works for the 100th time. there. It's a It's such an easy game to teach and play.
I give this one a 7.5, which is a which is a little bit higher than I gave the original one uh which was a seven. I think that this one is a nice, like you said, little improvements, teeny improvements here and there. Some of the board spaces are more fun. Uh just the physical uh you know, the physicality of it, it works a little bit better and the fact that it's going to create more variety in your plays. Great. I think that's a that's a nice addition. So, a step up 7.5 for me.
There you go, folks. That is foragio. I'm Tom Basil
and I'm Chris Ye.
Here are some other people who like cheese or support people who do like cheese who backed our game found. Thank you to Michael and Jennifer McDade,
also known as Queso,
Mac and Daisy, not a cat,
Quesa,
Thog, the Unfathomable, also known as Gart
and Lupy Seas.
Thank you all for supporting us and thank you all for watching. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.