Star Trek: Captain's Chair - To Boldly Go + Second Contact | Solo Review
Transcript
Engage.
Hello everyone. Welcome. I'm Robert and this is a solo review of Star Trek Captain's Chair to boldly go and second contact. So last year I reviewed the original Star Trek Captain's Chair box and I'll leave a link to that review if you're interested, but I'll give you a quick summary here. Basically, I reviewed it from the perspective of someone who has enjoyed Imperium a lot, which Star Trek Captain's Chair is basically an iteration of the Imperium system. And ultimately, I ended up quite enjoying Star Trek Captain's Chair despite the fact that I really didn't have any attachment to the IP at the time. I did point out initially that the learning curve was a bit brutal despite the fact that I had experience with the Imperium system. So much so that I almost gave up on it, but I'm glad I persevered because like I said, I did end up loving it a lot. Also, I pointed out that this game compared to Imperium is much more wordy. So, in order to parse the board state and figure out what cards you want to buy and what actions you want to take, it takes a bit more effort due to how much more text you have to read. And also, it is definitely a bit more complex. And also, I really appreciated how the scoring was much more streamlined here compared to Imperium. Oh, and I also like this game so much that it made me start watching Star Trek. All right. So, now what have I played from this new release? So, I played six games in total. I played four games as Kirk where I started as cadet and then I progressively tried harder
difficulties, all of them against the Georgiou bot. I also played a game as Georgiou against Kirk in lieutenant difficulty. And finally, in order to try these second contact content, I played as Riker versus Freeman and both of these decks are themed around the Star Trek Lower Decks and animated TV show. And this was in lieutenant difficulty as well. Also, keep in mind that I did not mix the contents of To Boldly Go with the original contents when doing this. All of my games were played with just the To Boldly Go contents except of course my Riker versus Freeman game. And I do not plan to mix everything together because I've heard that it can mess with balance. So, all of these games took me about 4 hours each and that's not including setup or teardown.
So, I estimate that I've spent about 20 to 30 hours with this game since my pre-order arrived within the last month. Of course, your mileage may vary but I like taking my sweet time for making decisions in this game. Oh, and final thing before I move on to the proper review, I made a video on how I stored the contents of the game plus expansions and how I reduced the amount of boxes. So, if you're interested, I'll leave a link to that. And now, let's move on to the review. All right. One of the first things that I want to point out about the system in general is that it was relatively painless to come back to. I had only tabled the game a couple times between my review from last year and the arrival of my pre-orders. So, I was pleased not to have to spend too much time refamiliarizing myself with the system. I do have a couple cheat sheets, of course. Some of them are just highlights from the rulebooks and others are files from the BoardGameGeek section.
So, so I just wanted to point that out. Once you go through that initial barrier of learning the system, it's not the worst to come back to, at least in my experience. Next, I want to point out that To Boldly Go cleans up the rulebook in a few areas. Now, I think in most cases, it shouldn't be anything too impactful, but I do appreciate the developers tidying up the rulebook and improving the wording for clarity. So, that's awesome. And also addressing other interactions that could happen. So, obviously that means that the To Boldly Go rulebook is superior to the original. So, if you're going to learn a game, I probably would go with this rulebook. And also, there is a one improved component that I wanted to note, and that's the stardate cards. These have better wording for clarity.
So, if you're going to combine sets, I suggest that you keep the stardate cards from To Boldly Go. All right, now let's talk about the captains. Let's start with Kirk. So, at the time when I played him, he was the most complex captain that I have tried. The only captains that I had experience from the original box, of which I still have a lot of content to tackle, were Shawn and Picard. But like I said, I like going through the difficulty levels starting at cadet, and that is quite a big time commitment, especially for me because I take my time making decisions. But yeah, Kirk was very fun, and he has a very sweet spot level of complexity. I loved learning his nuances and figuring out how to accomplish his missions and everything. So, Kirk was extremely fun to experience. Unfortunately, I haven't seen any OG Star Trek content. So, sadly, I can't understand the references, but one day, that's definitely on my list. Now, Kirk is not the most complex captain. He has a complexity rating of four. The most basic captain in this set, uh would go to Georgiou. Georgiou is from, I believe, Star Trek Discovery, and uh I have not watched that, obviously, and I don't think I plan to because there's a lot of people who really dislike it, so much so that they refuse to play content from the box uh that has anything to do with that show. Uh so, now I can tell you, since I don't have a horse in that race, that uh you're missing out because she was very fun to play. So, I think I'll keep it that way. I'm not going to watch it so that I don't develop any
strong feelings for anything related to the show. Um so, I had a blast with it, and yeah, even though she's on the more basic side, uh she was very different and distinct. So, I had a blast with my play-through of her against Kirk. And moving on, we have Riker from Lower Decks against Carol Freeman, also from Lower Decks. Now, he is the most complex captain that I have played to date. He is ranked at a complexity rating of six out of 10. And uh he has an insane ability that allows you to bring cards from your discard pile by uh activating him and putting a card from your hand on top of your deck that matches the type of card on the discard pile that you want to draw. And this just opens up so many possibilities for combos and replaying cards. I just loved it. Some of the combos that I pulled while playing as Riker were insane. In fact, I think the most insane combo that I pulled, as in a sequence of actions that was very, very tough to uh crack, but uh that I managed, was while playing as him. It was insane. I wish I had actually recorded it, but I was so concentrated trying to figure out if I could accomplish what I wanted to do at that moment that I didn't think of like recording it, but it really made me appreciate, and I think this has to do with him being a higher complexity captain, it really made me appreciate the types of insane combos that you can pull in this game. It was wild. Part of
it is due to the fact that I had cards that interacted with the junk. When you interact with a junk pile, that opens up a lot of possibilities of how you can accomplish your goals. Combined with his ability of being able to bring just about any card from the discard pile, yeah, you're going to be having some very, very thinky turns with Riker. Now, I wish I had played with him, and also I wish I could have swapped places, and played as Carol versus Riker. Problem is I do want to watch Lower Decks at some point, and I feel like I'm going to get some spoilers from playing with these. So, I would rather not. That makes me sad cuz I wanted to keep playing with them, but I decided to stop, and I'll just play with other captains in the meantime, cuz I do really want to watch that Lower Decks show at some point.
Also, little commentary on Second Contact as far as the contents of the market, it brings just about every type of card, I think except encounters, and a new type of card. I didn't get to experience the new type of card, which is a reward. But, with my game as Riker, I did get to try all her cards, and it's just nice to have variety without potentially breaking balance by combining two full sets. So, if you want to add a little bit of variety to the market, Second Contact is a nice sweet spot. Oh, and also, Second Contact comes with a new mechanic, which is the Lower Decker card class, and their signature is the support ability, which basically lets you play them from your hand at any point, even during your opponent's turn, if the condition is met. Uh so, it's a very nice way of playing cards at specific times. And yeah, they stick around until your turn comes around, so that's pretty cool.
Also, a little side comment, but I really have been itching to experience the campaign in this game. I've mentioned in other reviews that I don't care for campaign elements, uh but the campaign here seems genuinely interesting. Thing is, it would be a big time commitment because as I said, most games take me about 4 hours, so if I wanted to play a full campaign of this game, it would be about a 20-hour commitment. And I do have other games in my collection that I want to give some love to. So, so for now, I'm going to stick with the one-off nature of this game. And [clears throat] I also want to comment that I really have fallen in love with this system. The more that I played, the more that I appreciate its insane depth, its compotastic nature, the amazing variety due to the market, the basic and the advanced side of each captain, the different difficulties, all of the different captain pairings, and just how much content this game has to offer. And I really can't wait for more.
I just love this. Please, guys, keep making more. I love this game. And just one of my favorite things, I've mentioned this already, is just having a captain and making them go through that progression, starting at cadet, and then picking up a bot and starting at the smallest difficulty, and working my way through higher difficulties. That whole process will give you at least 15 to 20 hours of content with each captain. And that doesn't even factor in the different captain combinations that you could do while doing this. And so, with that said, I think that unlike last time, where I was a bit more indecisive about whether I like this over the other, the way I saw it last time was Imperium is a bit less demanding mentally and a bit quicker to set up. And because the decisions are not so excruciating every turn, I am much less uh analysis paralysis prone with Imperium. So, that has its place, right? But despite how much more streamlined and speedier Imperium might be, not to mention its awesome civilization theme, I can't deny that Captain's Chair is definitely the much crunchier game that also happens to improve in a couple areas, especially the scoring. So, now I undeniably much more prefer Captain's Chair. This is also helped by the fact that I've started watching Star Trek. So, that makes me love it even more. Now, I did not award this last time to the game because the learning experience almost
made me give up, but again, I'm glad I persevered. But now that I've acclimated myself with the system and I can very easily table this and just enjoy it without wrestling with the rules, I am going to award this game a dopamine seal of approval. And I know that that intro obviously is a bit hyperbolic, but folks, listen, I could play this all day. I barely notice time passing when I play this. Once I start, it is tough to pull myself off the table. It really is just so amazing and it just sings for me. The types of puzzles that David and Nigel create with this, man, it's just unreal. And I just love that it accomplishes this from the very first turn and it just gets better and better and it crescendos into just an ecstasy of crunchy decisions towards the end.
Just those last turns, there's just so much going on with how many things you put on your board. Man, like the combos that you can pull with this is just insane. I can confidently say that David and Nigel are one of the best design duos in the industry. In fact, I am scared to play my copy of Voidfall. I've had that on my shelf of shame for some time. Only reason why I've held off on playing it is because I want to get my triple-layered hex boards from the latest campaign. But what the hell's going to happen once I play that game? Is my brain going to explode or something? Am I going to ascend into godhood? Who knows? All right. So now let's move on to some final thoughts. So in conclusion, To Boldly Go and Second Contact are amazing additions to the system. I really don't think that you can go wrong if you want to go either with this or the old box. The rulebook is slightly better here, but I can confirm that the captains here are just as fun to play. And that's without mentioning the other captains that I haven't gotten around to trying yet, which have much higher complexity levels. I have to work my way through them. I also love how Second Contact allows you to add a bit of variety to either box without necessarily mixing everything. I know some people want to mix everything, and you totally can do that. The rules do allow for it. I personally prefer keeping sets isolated, and I just kind of apply that across the board with other systems, not just this
system. And yeah, now I've changed my mind, and I do think that this is the superior game to Imperium. But I still appreciate Imperium a lot for being a bit more streamlined and having the civilization theme. If you want to be eased into the system a bit more, I still recommend the other. This could be a bit tough to recommend to someone who's completely new to solo board games. It can be a bit of a brutal first experience. There's a lot to learn. So this game is not going to hold your hand or ease you into the deck-building genre or super crunchy games. But yeah, like I said, you can't go wrong. This is an amazing product line, and I truly cannot wait to see what else they cook. And uh finally, just as a a let me give you a a bit of an update on my Trekky status. Uh so, since last year, uh I've managed to watch the first two seasons with my wife. I was pleasantly surprised to see that she's enjoyed it cuz I really didn't want to watch it by myself cuz I don't really watch as many shows by myself. Honestly, I mostly watch TV with my wife. So, it's been awesome watching Star Trek. I've adored it. I know that some people say that those first couple seasons are rough, but uh you know, like we we loved it. So, it's just been super fun and I just love the characters so much. I love the episodic nature where there's usually not a thread between episodes. It's just very uh self-contained per episode. I love that most modern shows are not like that. Everything is written around having like this binge-watching hook
where you can't wait to see the next episode or whatever. There's always a cliffhanger at the end of every episode. So, I just love how quaint this is in comparison to that. I also was lucky enough to attend a Star Trek panel at MegaCon and I got to see the Star Trek fandom firsthand. And yeah, it was magical. Like, I'm all in with like the whole Trekky thing. I'm I just, you know, I'm a bit of a newbie cuz I have a lot of material to go through, but like I'm I'm all in. I I just loved attending that and hearing the actors talk about behind-the-scenes stories and also all the fans sharing stories about how Star Trek uh you know, helped them in rough times or how their family watched Star Trek with them. And I and I saw a surprising amount of young people saying that like very young people saying how they watched Star Trek with their parents.
So, that's pretty classic that their parents are showing kids Star Trek. That's awesome. And also, I got a little TV guide to the first five seasons of The Next Generation where it has a bunch of trivia and behind-the-scenes talk. So, I've been immensely enjoying that. But yeah, little by little, we'll get through all of that Star Trek content. We have a lifetime of Star Trek content to watch. There's so much ahead of us. But, yeah, I want to thank you all so much for watching. If you have any comments, questions, feedback, go ahead and put them in the comment section. And if you enjoyed this content, make sure to like and subscribe, and I'll see you in the next one.