Skip to main content
Loading video...

Star Realms: Rise of the Empire - Discussion

Transcript 24:03

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games onl and today I'm doing a discussion over Star Realms rise of the empire I was going to say Emperor and that would have been wrong uh yeah so this is the newest I guess expansion to Star Realms technically a standalone EXP expansion because uh it comes with a campaign but after the campaign you can play it um like on its own it comes with enough to play like regular Star Realms but the primary focus of this review is going to be over the actual Campaign which to my surprise cuz I had backed this I don't know like a while back and I was surprised to find out that it was a legacy Campaign which I had not heard that ter it's a term I haven't heard in 84 years uh because it just feels like Legacy campaigns have gone away not like their pseudo Legacy or Legacy light games where you make changes but it's very resettable or if you do make changes like put stickers on and stuff there's pretty much a reset pack and there's a reset pack here but they called it a legacy campaign and I was intrigued because it's like okay that should entail some sort of obviously card manipulation card changing and a story that um that is told over the course of several games and with a deck builder like Star

Realms I figured that there's a lot of interesting ways that they could have actually taken this and boy did they steer as far away as possible from anything interesting like this is the most like bog standard Legacy campaign I've I've played in a very long time like there's something to be said about bad games versus like boring games like mediocre games uh like which one is worse and I would honestly argue that a very flat boring game is worse it's kind of like watching you know a really bad movie you can have fun with a bad movie but if it's just a nothing movie and you get nothing out of it you're more miserable in my opinion at least I am um and that's just kind of how I felt pretty much from game one there are 12 games in the campaign and anything Legacy of it is pretty much done after game four and it's like really they were just phoning it in at the end and like this isn't a dog necessarily on Star realm Star Realms is a fine deck builder like it's not my favorite by any means um like it it it was serviceable at the time it's a it's a decent enough 1V one deck builder but pretty much like I feel like this campaign is going to be for people who love Star Realms like Star Realms is something they play every

night before bed with their significant other or with someone and they're just really into it because that's how you're playing this game like the campaign is 12 games of Star Realms with very minor changes to each game like the first four games has the the air of like excitement because you're you're putting stickers on it but the stickers are so lame like what really kind of set the tone for me of the rest of this campaign was you so you have your faction upgrades and you can upgrade both bases and ships and basically it costs two more you know gold to be able to upgrade a ship and three more gold to upgrade a base but you can only upgrade a certain cost so if you get a cost one ship it would cost you three gold to to take it and upgrade it but you can only upgrade it when you actually buy it from the market so you buy it from the market spend your money and then you acquire it okay you got your ship but now you are no longer able to upgrade the a level one base so pretty much each sticker sheet you are only allowed to uh use five of them on on on a sheet so one it's incredibly limiting and the the upgrades are so whatever they're so lame like that honestly the when

acquired effects are more exciting like some of them are hey when acquired deal two damage okay that's cool well that's probably a little bit better than you know me what is that that's a cost two that's better than me actually taking this cost two up gr putting it on there and now I can scrap it for four damage there there's like there's almost nothing to the sticker element it's it's as simple as you could have made it like when you were just like oh we have to make that rise of Empire expansion I don't know make make you know the the upgrades a coin and some some healing like whatever we'll just do that for four games it's painful that none of these are exciting like literally it's just oh I can upgrade it so I guess I will like that's really it there's not a whole like a whole lot of thought because it's a deck builder at the end of the day and here's what really rub me the wrong way with these stickers so not only do you put the sticker on you take one of your factions and there are three other factions in the game the Consortium the kingdom and the Scavengers so if you are the one who you know Acquired and upgraded this Archer you would take you would put a sticker on it and you would take your blue if you were the Federation you would take a blue and the purple and you would put it up at the top left so now this card counts as a

blue and a purple for terms of Ally things so they you know pop off for more things like hey this will be good for my blue cards as well as my purple cards all right well that's kind of interesting but what was extremely lame is after your first game and you realize oh I don't keep these cards they still go back into the market and that to me was was really kind of what killed the campaign because in my head a legacy campaign was going to for a deck builder like this was going to be something like oh I'm actually going to be modifying my starting deck I'm really going to build out a a deck like I'm gonna construct a deck as well as do deck building throughout the the entire course of the campaign no you still start with your 10 cards your standard 10 well it's actually 11 cards you started out with your 11 cards every single game every single all 12 games you start out with the same 12 cards and you play 12 games of Star Realms with a little and it's like okay well why am I thematically trying to coers these three factions to help me win my war against the the star Empire or my war against um the Trade Federation when on my opponent's turn they can just acquire that card there is

nothing stopping them from being like Oh you acquired this Archer well it's my turn I have two gold I'm just going to buy it so now your faction like your enemies factions can also be used with you why what is the point of that like why isn't it Cooler why isn't it better to be like hey I'm actually going to acquire these cards so they stay in my personal deck or something on theong along the lines of okay for all the cards that you've um that you've modified this round keep one of them in your starting deck uh so that eventually you will have unique cards that stay with you and you kind of do some deconstruction as the game goes on as you're building your Fleet to take on the enemy Army not like okay thanks for this battle I know you're on my side but not I don't know if you're going to be tomorrow that it's so stupid like it's it's it's as lazy of a legacy campaign as I I could even think of cuz like I remember when seaa came out and that was a bad Legacy game but at least it was trying to do something unique make a unique not take a previously done IP and put Legacy on top of it like pandemic did it was this whole fleshed out thing it just didn't work here it's like oh you like Star Realms well what if you put stickers on cards and played Star Realms oh yeah what if well what if you didn't do that and you just played regular Star Realms and actually just

had a better time because here's the other thing this game comes down to kind of like the rich get richer every single campaign or every single game there's these victory points cards and these Victory Point cards are really how you win the overall campaign that doesn't really matter no like it just determines what paragraph you read at the end but if you win the next game you have a the scenario sheet and you flip it to your side cuz you won and there's a little thematic blurb of of what happens because you won the last one and then the person who won gets to pick a benefit it's either hey you can start like the trade one game the Trade Federation could be like they can start with 60 but the um the other team can start with an Explorer instead of 50 Health you start with 60 so it's like well I won but I also get to pick a benefit for myself for the next game you also get to pick events uh that go into into the the trade deck the only semblance of kind of a catchup mechanism is for every game that your opponent has won over three you get a Gambit card uh so if one person is really like landsliding that say they've won you know five games then the opponent's always going to be able to get two Gambit cards on their turn that's it so it's like okay great I won now I'm going to get a benefit to help me probably win next game um and

until you start getting Gambit cards which at that point it might be too little too late even though it's still a deck builder and it's completely random so you could just get completely swamped where it's like oh man yeah I just didn't draw well and you did now you win and now we go to the next game and here's what's so infuriating is the first four games you're getting new stickers but then you look at them and you're like okay these are basically the same type of stickers like they don't get even they don't get more it's not like the first game they have these basic whatever stickers that kind of get you into the into the campaign all of them are like that all of them are are oh this is two damage and heals three oh look one coin and two damage oh look this base is two damage and heals two like it's it's it's not like they get more exciting the only thing that changes is the cost of what is available to you and then if someone just happens to be on their turn and they draw well it's like okay cool I can keep upgrading stuff um there's a two-point Victory reward for the first person who gets all 20 of their upgrades out so it's like great I'm going to have more victory points at the end of the game and there there's these there's like a majority rule for each of the three factions at the very end of the campaign that's like hey if you have more controlled cards of a certain faction then you get an extra point it it doesn't matter like it's so it's just so

stupid um but at the beginning it's like okay it'd be nice if the first four games kind of gave you more interesting more exciting combinations of abilities really like focus on the Legacy aspect of making you decide how what cards you want again not that it would really matter because your opponent would just get the benefit anyway but after like the first five games it doesn't change like the next six games are literally scenario sheet and the Victory point card they quit giving you unique cards they quit giving and the rest of the cards that get in other scenarios are just reminders based off of a decision you make it's like oh hey I can decide to make vipers do an extra two damage oh here's the reminder card of that they quit giving you stickers they quit giving you any semblance of Legacy stuff so you're just sitting there doing the exact same game because the the scenario card only changes the beginning like what DEC like okay like you gave up trying to make a campaign uh and only modified it in the slightest sense where you basically are playing so many games that you're just done by the end of it like by the end of five like game five once probably game six when I realized they were just doing the same

thing I was just trying to get through this campaign as quickly as quickly as possible and then you get to the finale uh which spoilers I guess for anyone who wants to play this the very end on scenario 12 they shoehorn in this semi Cooperative element it's like oh hey you've been fighting each other for 11 games are you tired of that good now we're going to make you fight a boss and it becomes pretty much Cooperative because they tell you hey you can fight each other still but whoever you make like a truce in the story and you can fight each other but whoever attacks the other person gets a negative one Victory condition um because I guess you could do it in a way where if you defeat them and you solo the boss then you're the one who gets you get three victory points but you also actually lose a victory point so you only gain two victory points and the opponent who's defeated but still won uh because the the boss was defeated they get zero points so you could do that I don't see what why you ever would unless you take this campaign way too seriously you're just sitting there and you're like okay like whenever we got to the final boss I was like okay we can attack each other do you just not want to do that in any way and just focus on the boss and he's annoying all he does is

basically take consume cards from the market and then you know does an ability and then attacks everyone for however many consumed cards and he kind of splits it if both people are are alive but if you have ways the star Federation their only uniqueness is their special ability kind of focuses on making your opponent discard cards and it's like oh if you make the blob discard a card you actually just heal three so the star Empire was just kind of built to fight it and it's like okay great every time I attack I get to do I get to heal and then the Trade Federation their special thing is they can heal so the beginning of the fight just become it starts off rough um but then as the as you actually start getting a deck going it's like all right I'm doing 20 damage each time and I'm healing and we end with 40 health and it it dies so it was super easy if you fully cooperate and then if you both cooperate you both get three points so it's a wash so it turns the final scenario into a semi-cooperative basically Cooperative experience but then you still have to count up victory points and be like okay well whoever had the most wins The Campaign let's read our thing and move on the only benefit that I that I can think of from actually getting this um is if again if you love Star Realms this is pro everything I'm saying is probably you know honey you're like oh man oh I get to play 12 games of Star Realms that sounds amazing um which is fine that's

great like then this would be this would be a blast for for you um but if you don't love Star Realms the only thing about the Legacy campaign that I can that I can see is that at the end of The Campaign you now have a unique Star Realms deck that you can play um and that's it it's base Star Realms I mean I guess with events and gambits and stuff but it's basic Star Realms and and that's it like they give two rule new rule sheets the the I mean a lot of in a lot of Legacy games you get new rules like that's kind of how they get around um printing a whole bunch of stuff like you have your rule book that has blank stuff it's like oh now in this in you know scenario 5 we add these rules and now this is going to carry over from from the rest of the game nope not here that rule book is what it is and and and then you just have rule changes for the given scenario it's not as if it carries the entire campaign it's just okay hey this game vipers let you draw a card only this game and that's it so I'm completely completely under like

underwhelmed by by this I don't really know what I was expecting going into it like I said I was surprised that there was a legacy campaign um and the thing is is I have everything for Star Realms like I have all the the packs I have all the scenario stuff that they have and I have no reason to ever throw this stuff in and no reason to ever play the campaign again because it wasn't exciting it wasn't why would I do this when I can just add basically what this is doing from the mini decks into regular star Realm but I guess if you don't have anything of Star Realms this could be a good starting off point would give you a a uh if you've never played any Legacy game or if you've never played any deck builder or you like Star rums this could be fun but man I am just so whatever on this wasn't great was wasn't wasn't great I'm I'm tired after after after playing 12 games of Star RS and I probably never want to play it again um but that's it yeah that's pretty much it on on Star Realms rise rise of the empire like I'm not trying to be like a dick to this but I feel like this had so much more it could have done like there's so many more creative cards like

you could have had it to where you get Heroes like there's heroes in the in the B game you could have had it to where you get more unique ships in your starting deck the fact that that you don't get to modify your starting deck at all blows my mind there is no that could have been yeah I get it it's a deck builder and they're trying to keep it core to Star Realms but you could have done so many more cool things really H because it's not like you have to manage four other players this game campaign is designed for two so you're so you could have made it to where each person gets to really customize their own personal deck and build their army of the Trade Federation and try and make them go a different route or really focus on the healing aspect or the the the star Empire have them focus on unique ships hey here are the next scenario there are these Alliance ships that come in and whoever won the last scenario gets the gets first pick out of five cards and that's the one that's in my starting deck cuz they have Vault sheets they have ways for you to put in your stickers and your deck so you can be you could have been way more unique and really hone in and be like okay I'm going to take this card it's it's only good if I get it with another card because I have that one so if I can get it that's going to be an awesome swing you could have done so

much more uh like better and fun deck constructing but the fact that you just put stickers on trade Deck cards and those just come out man that is just so whatever of a of a system and really really just feels like they they're I mean they're running out of ideas at this point with with Star Realms they I really are am like just why can you just admit it's over like this is not doing anything for for anyone I feel but maybe I'm wrong maybe I'm wrong but I don't know that's it everyone that's that's my thoughts on Star Realms rise of the empire on a scale of one to 10 four like I think it it's like I mean Star Realms and this is mainly over the campaign again not over Star Realms I mean again I'm not the huge like the biggest fan of Star Realms I think it's fine if somewhere like I could bring the base game into just play it but I I probably wouldn't honestly or if you have the app it's just going to be quicker and and easier on the app uh but I so I probably give like maybe Bas Star Realms like a six at this point but it drops so many points for me because the campaign just sucks and

there's so much missed opportunities here it's really just hey what if we made them pay and they played 12 games of Star OBS with a mediocre story that doesn't really get any emotion or feeling out of anyone it's just some it's it's really an excuse to just have them play 12 games and we had to shoehorn in a story for it um yeah I'm not I'm really not digging this so that is my thoughts on Star Realms rise of the empire let me know what you think of the the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other runthrough or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful for whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved