Advice from Board Game Designers at Protospiel Madison!
Transcript
Well, hello everyone. I am on the way to the proto spiel event in Madison, Wisconsin, the thriving metropolis of Madison. Uh, why am I going there? Well, it's because I'm going to this proto spiel. It is a chance for uh board game designers to get together with other board game designers as well as play testers to try out each other's games, give each other feedback, and try to make all of our games uh to the next level to get them even better than they already are. It's a fantastic event. Very, very chill, very, very fun. Basically, I'm going to do a little bit of a vlog over the course of the 3-day weekend. Maybe show you some cool games, maybe talk to some designers and give uh some little mini interviews, things like that. So, stay tuned. I'll give you all kinds of little tidbits as the weekend goes on. All right, so right out of the gate, I'm going to introduce you to my good friend Justin. We have worked on game designs together. Uh, but I want to ask you, what would be some advice you would give to a first time board game designer?
First time board game designer. Uh, I think I'll spit off a couple of quick ones. I think you always hear right away. I started listening to the Dice Tower more. they just to get a bunch of influx of different board games to learn about without having to play them necessarily, right? Just hearing about the rules and the ideas behind them.
Makes sense.
Uh in they also talk about like things that Tom always says if you want to design board games, play a lot of board games. And then also I would say personally for me what I did was just write down a bunch of different ideas. Um just even paragraphs get all those bad ideas out of the way first. Um that kind of helped me then focus in on okay which one of these do I actually think has legs maybe has some market potential and move forward with that one.
What's your favorite thing about designing board games? Uh, I think definitely just the community behind it. Uh, that's something that I noticed right away was not only online, the channels, I'm like, "Oh, there's actually like seems like really really nice people behind this." Um, but also going to these protospill events, uh, different board game conventions, you just meet a lot of really nice people in them. What's the weirdest theme that you have seen in a board game?
Uh, besides the ones that you've come up with.
Hey, that's off limits.
Yeah. Yeah. Um,
that's a separate video.
Uh, I would say Well, there's that new uh Night Soil game. Have you heard of this one?
No. No. Tell me about it.
Uh, you're collecting poop in medieval Europe at night and cleaning up the streets, I think. So,
okay.
Yeah. Yeah.
Well, that one's exciting. Uh
uh yeah, I'll I'll go with that one for now. I'll try and think of more.
That counts.
I'll I'll jump back in later.
Well, thank you for your time, even though you're trapped in my car, so you have no choice.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm I'll be here for a while.
So, that is where we're headed. That is the Manona Terrace, the convention center. This is actually a Frank Lloyd Wright design uh built after he died postumulously. So, it is a very very cool uh property overlooking the lake. Uh and it's like one of the coolest places to have a convention. I'm pretty excited. All right. I'm here with my friend Stan Cordonski. We just got a chance to play test one of his new games that he's working on. Uh but I have a question for you. If you were talking to a brand new first-time game designer, what would be some advice that you might give them? Well, my advice if it's your first game you're designing, pick a topic that you're really passionate about, whatever that can be, because you're going to spend a long time working on something where you're not going to know necessarily if it's going to bear fruit.
So, at least you're going to have a lot of enjoyment working on a topic that you really like. Uh if it's healthcare, if it's insects, if it's um history of China, just pick a thing you're really interested in. That way, you'll guarantee to have fun along the way and not burn out. And then just um just see what happens. Just see what happens. There's probably a lot of people who would find the thing you're find interesting interesting as well.
Awesome. Thank you so much.
All right. So, I just got done playing uh a game with my new friend Jacob. And I have a question for you. If you were talking to a firsttime board game designer, what advice would you give them?
There are no truly bad ideas. The main problem is you're going to face always execution. So, if you have something that seems like a bad idea, it's probably just the wrong game. Put it on a shelf, grab it again later when you find a game that it actually works for.
Awesome. I love it. Great advice. Thank you. All right, so I'm with my friend Andrew Styles. Uh, and we about to play one of his games. But first, I have to ask him a couple questions. Uh, number one being, what would be your advice for a first time board game designer? One, I would say make the game that you think don't ex doesn't exist yet. Number one, but also play as many games as you possibly can. You need to have a tool belt of what exists currently before you can make stuff that doesn't exist yet.
That makes a lot of sense. All right. What's your favorite part about designing games, being part of this community?
It's the community, but that's the easy answer. So, I'll follow this up by saying I think it's the mental challenge of creating something and then watching it evolve and change through time to get to a place where you couldn't bring it yourself. Like for instance, if I play tested my own game a 100 times, the changes I would make would be based on my taste only. But when I bring in other people, they show their tastes and their preferences and the game can organically grow to a place that I wouldn't be able to take it by myself.
Awesome. Thank you, sir.
All right, so I'm here with my friend Calvin, and we just got done playing one of our games. But now it's time to ask you a question. What's one piece of advice that you would give to a firsttime board game designer?
So, I think when you're designing games, it's really important to determine the audience that you're designing for. If you're designing a game for yourself, make sure it's fun for you. If you're designing a game to sell or to publish, make sure that you determine what the publisher or the audience wants and try to get feedback from that audience.
Awesome. Thank you so much.
Of course. Thanks for playing.
All right. So, I'm here with my friend Andrew. We just got done playing one of his new games. Uh, but I have a question for you.
Do you have any advice for first time board game designers?
Yeah, I would say you should get your hands dirty. It's very easy to think and spend all this time in your head and not get anything down on paper, but get out the markers, get out the crayons, don't take yourself seriously. Just start sketching and messing around with scraps. Even if it's like 5% of a game, just like get in there and do it.
I love it. Thank you so much.
All right, so I'm here with my friend Ross. We got a chance to play one of his games. So I am asking you, what would be some advice you might give to a firsttime board game designer? Yeah. So, I think that having some sort of design, graphic design, thematic design to what you're testing is helpful so people don't get too distracted by um you know, things that might not be clear. Um having something that excites people um and kind of like takes away the question marks of trying to understand um how things work and having some sort of like a clear visual perspective. It's very helpful.
Awesome. Thank you so much.
Thanks.
All right. So, we just got done playing a couple of Carl's games, but I have a question for you. What advice might you give for a first time board game designer?
Uh, I would definitely suggest that you go to Protest and if you really want to make games, going to a prototy.org, word. There's a page there with information on what to do to plan for your first protospiel and tips on what to do when you're there.
Oh, perfect. Thank you so much.
All right, so I just got back home from the proto spiel. Uh there's a ton of information to absorb. If you are a first-time game designer, I hope you really enjoyed hearing those little tidbits from all these fantastic designers. Uh take that to heart because they know what they're doing and it's really fun to get feedback from them playing games as well. So be sure to check out Proto Wheels in your area if you're interested in game design. Uh I had a lot of fun. It was a great time meeting with all my friends in the community. Uh, and yeah, can't wait for the next one. See you guys later. Bye you guys. Thanks for watching our shenanigans. As always, we appreciate it. Over here, if you follow this link, you're going to find a playlist we've hand selected, handcrafted just for you, uh, because you watch this video.
And if you check over here, this is a video that YouTube thinks you might like. So, you can check that out if you want as well.
All right, we appreciate it, guys. Thanks so much for watching, and we will see you next time. Bye
bye.