Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sleeping Gods Review: Make Friends, Grab Totems and Find Bigfoot - By Board Of It

Transcript 16:20

hello farrell here from boardvip and this is tally and today we are going to be reviewing the wondrous new adventure exploration game sleeping gods which is for between one and four players now this was designed by a man who can apparently doodle ryan lockett as he designed the game he did the artwork i think he even wrote the majority of the story and it is terrifying to me that somebody could do all that sleeping gods is a choose your own adventure narrative experience you'll be guiding the crew of the manticore through a strange world that they've been transported to in an attempt to get them home the players choose where to go and what to interact with on the map which will result in reading passages from a terrifyingly large rulebook making decisions and performing skill checks in many ways sleeping gods is one of the best board game adaptations of an expansive rpg video game uh

in sleeping gods there are eight crew members plus captain odessa with each crew member being represented by a crew board the crew boards are distributed according to how many players there are with captain odessa being set aside you'll begin the game with your ship the manticore on the world map a typical turn will firstly have a player choosing a ship action which will usually get them some command tokens an ability card as well as other various benefits next the player will draw an event card from the event deck and they'll have to resolve that event which usually requires them to pass a challenge lastly the player will take two actions and there are only really two actions to choose from moving the ship and interacting with a location on the map interacting with the locations on the map is going to provide you with story and conversations to read out loud and will often have you making choices and passing challenges in sleeping gods there are different kinds of attributes which are assigned to the characters such as strength cunning savvy and so on these attributes are pre-printed on the crew boards but can also be supplemented with ability cards so a challenge will say something like cut your ropes with a sharp rock strength six you can firstly choose to involve any characters you control or the captain who is shared by all by placing a fatigue token on them so if raphael has a strength of two i can fatigue him to add two to the challenge then you'll draw a card from the fate deck and these cards have a value on them between

one and six in the top corner and you add that number to any strength that you already have then if by this point you are still short of six you can use command tokens to activate character abilities or use adventure cards to get you over the line if you fail a challenge bad stuff happens like your character taking damage or gaining negative conditions the aim of the game is to gather enough totems to awake the sleeping gods who brought you into this world in the hope that they will then send you home but how do you find totems well the old-fashioned way you just have to adventure by interacting with locations on the map you'll be talking to inhabitants who might give you quests to help them might give you rumors about totems or just point you in a direction where they seem likely and you'll adventure and hopefully at the end of these quests you will get a totem and then hopefully at the end of the game you have enough and the game will end when you run through the event deck three times or when every character has taken damage equal to their health or if your ship has been destroyed now before we dissect sleeping gods it's worth juxtaposing exploration in other board games a game we played a lot and really wanted to like was seventh continent which is similar to sleeping gods in many ways in both you have a sprawling map filled with icons that you can interact with and the point is to survive and to lift a curse through exploration

both will often have you performing challenges to explore and as a way to progress now we actually didn't like some continent very much and this came down to the fact that these challenges were often more luck based on something you could control because to do a challenge you would draw cards from a deck and you need to get a certain number of stars and these stars will be pre-printed on the cards you draw so maybe you get half a star or one star two stars no stars which can make things difficult and then if you fail you often don't get to progress and you've also wasted part of your life which was that deck you were drawing cards from and an even bigger sim was that often you would interact with places on the map and they would just have a negative event or effect and you guys would laugh in your face and it was like the game was laughing at you for wanting to interact with its richly detailed world and this isn't something that's just seventh continent is just the best example because it's one of the games we've played the most in this genre but it's a problem throughout the genre now imagine a game where the designer knows that the reason you're playing the strong right is for adventure exploration and storytelling they know that discovery is the driving force welcome to sleeping gods what is wonderful is that progression is navigated off behind challenges you can almost always complete a challenge based on the resources you have at your disposal but if you don't

you lose you know the usual amount of health and you might get some negative effects but you still progress onwards story wise it might be a little different than if you'd succeeded but you still get to move forward speaking of succeeding the fact that challenges allow players to add their characters to a challenge before then draw a fake card then you can use character abilities or adventure cards to boost that number means that passing or failing is usually within your own hands you won't always want to succeed at any cost either because you don't want to fatigue your character or you'd rather save your adventure cards for when you really need them and what's great is that you'll still get an outcome a piece of story to read rather than just being locked out the final point of comparison is the exploration you see each icon on this map will have a location that is filled with interesting characters dangerous enemies or just people in peril and you're never punished for being inquisitive but rather rewarded it's a really wonderful experience made all the better by the sublime quest system you see often you go to a location and it will ask you for a keyword and this is because the quest cards have keywords on them like stink or dog farts so the location will go if stink go to 11.3 and then you'll get story associated with that quest but what this does is if you don't have those keywords you write those keywords down on your

map and then you set sail to find the matching quests because now you know where you need to go you just need to find where to start and all of this creates a vibrant living breathing world that is wonderfully intertwined another design feature that we love is the fluidity rather than lock what you can do when behind rules and strict timing you actually feel like a crew you're allowed to help other players out in challenges by spending a command token or perhaps you'll spend one on an adventure card if the draw didn't quite go your friend's way in combat everyone participates no matter whose turn it was when it started often you'll have multiple choices when engaging with locations and this really opens up the discussion around the table at times the game totally blends together and feels like one continuous turn for all the players involved let's talk about the combat because this is something you'll be coming up against time and time again in these types of games it can often be quite hard to design an engaging combat because the game isn't based around it and often it will just feel more like an interruption than a mechanic that anyone's looking forward to well we have to say that here the designer has made a really nice attempt at making combat that is engaging and gets players to think the monster cards have a variety of symbols on them arranged in a grid and each successful hit from you allows you to cover up one space once all of the heart icons are covered

up that monster is toast however some spaces have damage icons or end of round effects so already you have an interesting dilemma in that every time you attack you'll be hit back so if you don't cover up the damage tokens you might not survive the retaliation secondly when placing damage it has to be dealt adjacently so this creates another dilemma thirdly you can deal splash damage to monsters that are adjacent so you might score a cheap hit on a strong monster without having to take a mountain of damage and all of this will combine together to make players think and be tactical which then means that you can never be complacent about the combat it's very smart and interesting however we have to say that as clever as the combat is for us it still does in the end feel like an interruption and it gets repetitive you see every time you try and land a hit you're essentially just doing a challenge which is something you'll do thousands of times in the game and you'll be using the same characters every time and the same weapons and it all just blends together a bit and the uniqueness of each monster card isn't really unique enough to prevent the combat over 10 or 20 hours from just getting banal because each time you you face a monster it's kind of straightforward so let's cover the writing the characters and the ending which are all linked together the writers have a magnificent talent in being able to prime your imagination

to envision a scene with limited text allowing the stories to come to life it's very hard in these games not to have your writing fall into the corny or cliched which for us not one single passage ever felt like that it all feels genuine and this makes what is missing more noticeable you see leaving the captain out of it because all of the text is from her point of view you have eight crew members in the game and some of these in our experience we we saw a lot of over the story in the campaign you know mac she was there the most which makes sense because she's your guide to this world you find yourself in i think audrey always had two cents to chip in and raphael was always on hand to give some classic new yorkerisms but some of the other characters and crew members i honestly don't think we had one line of dialogue from the entire time and of course you can say that we haven't seen everything but there are several occasions where we went to every location across two pages of the map and they didn't come up it feels weird and disappointing to go through a 20-hour game and never really hear from some of the main characters like marco or kanan or experience any aspect of their personality you as a player are much more engaged with them than you are the captain because you are using them in moment-to-moment gameplay and become empathetic with them

one suggestion from us could be which is of course much easier to say and probably harder to implement but there could be personal quests for each character so you have the choice of getting to know them better and this lack of characterization led to issues for us with the finale of the game as we're going to be speaking about that please if you want to avoid any spoilers then just jump ahead although we are going to be speaking about them as vaguely as possible but what the game tries to do in the ending is it arbitrarily for us is ratcheting up the tension you see it will say oh if you make this choice over that character dies if you draw a fake card of five instead of a fake card of one this character turns on you but because some of these characters have never spoken in all of our playthrough or they've just had no build up of motivation of turning on you it does not land at all so i don't care that that character died or i don't understand why this person has turned on us because there's no signs speaking of being turned on another issue was that the motivation for that character doing so was that they didn't want us to pick option y to end the game but everyone would spoke to in our entire play through including when we discussed it about two passages before this happened which said we're going to do ending x which is the complete opposite so it made no sense that this character had turned

on us for this reason in terms of our gameplay and it completed halted everything because we thought we'd misread something and we're like this can't be right we have to go back forth and it just kind of ruined the whole experience and then when you actually get to the ending because the game has no way of knowing what has happened in this preceding kind of passages of the ending it can't give you a cathartic ending you know i think we got the best ending possible we were just like is this it and then we went and looked at the other ones and they're all pretty much the same because the game can't tell you what happened to specific characters because it doesn't know so you get a very underwhelming ending that really says a lot of nothing and it was just for having such an incredible experience for 20 hours it's just really disappointing that that was how it ended but i mean you could say that the journey is the real game and that was incredible but just be aware that we found the ending very disappointing but moving on to our final thoughts sleeping gods is for us the pinnacle of exploration and storytelling mechanics in board gaming it understands what people who like this genre want and gives them everything they want and more like a lot more because you have to play multiple times in order to see all the content our main issues were that the ending was a bit disappointing especially when you invest 20 hours into a game and also that the characters who you

spend your entire time with your crewmates did feel underdeveloped on occasion however if you compare this to everything that sleeping gods does right these are very small issues and we can't wait to play again to see all of the content that we didn't get to see the first time around so that is our review of sleeping gods it's a definite recommendation from us if you're into storytelling choose your own adventure exploring or just you know classic uh video games like breath of the wild fallout skyrim these kind of things we like exploring questing but thanks for watching and it would mean a lot to us if you could like comment or subscribe particularly subscribe um because that's our favorite metric but we also love interacting with everyone so please um feel free to ask us any questions we're happy to tell you about our playthrough tell some stories etc etc but thank you

Progress saved