Abomination: The Heir of Frankenstein Review
Transcript
who should probably give a content warning here this game has some intense violent imagery but if you have a problem with grotesque mutilated body parts being assembled into a horrific visit and I may have a solution for you paper doll Fashion Show oh yes Stacy summer dresses are so in this year in Haun's I didn't know what cardigan can look so good abomination is a unique blend of highly thematic storytelling and resource management worker placement it just so happens that the resources are human remains with a touch of animal parts and use them to make an abomination unto gods and men as is typical in worker placement throughout around you send your pawns to different locations so they can collect stuff usually cadavers listing their various parts and freshness after all making a recently executed body will work far fresher ingredients than digging up at the cemetery though in a pinch murder will do what follows the normal placement is the more mechanically unique and thereby interesting part of the game you can pay resources create monster parts eventually upgrading them with fleshy goodness then finally throwing the switch rolling some dice based off a stored electricity in your lab hoping to reach each parts final upgrade read animation for big points at the end of the game main gameplay struggle in abomination is opportunity cost because you only have a few actions to work with every round and sometimes there's just a really juicy cadaver that you want to
take advantage of gives you all sorts of resources you'll figure out what to do with them later I mean a spare liver or two ain't gonna hurt nothing so you consolidate but the problem is is that this game has an incredible resource degradation system where unless you purchased one of these ice blocks to degrade instead your resources at the end of the round are going to end up sliding down a stage meaning they give you less points when you use them to build monster parts and after you cross certain thresholds then you're going how to discard resources because they expired I mean this is organic Tyrael we're dealing with here and there are other resources in the game too there's money or these Leyden jars which are the capacitors for your electricity that you'll end up having to charge and then the other really fantastic feature of this game the dials on your player board representing humanity reputation and your expertise humanity is a measure of well I guess your soul do good stuff and humanity goes up granting you points and rewards do bad stuff like murder and you suffer penalties do both and it probably cancels out just like in real life right reputation is how you get more in upgraded workers to play with you may have noticed that workers come into shapes scientists and Lackey scientists can perform any job whereas these little fellas sometimes reap lesser rewards or blocked off phone
spaces entirely then there's your expertise each monster Park requires a level of expertise degree and going higher on this track let's use blue dice when throwing the switch generating more living successes and less damaging electricity which can downgrade parts of your monster I guess the lesson here is that some crimes against humanity are precision jobs better get the good dice sounds pretty straightforward right well it is I'm a mechanical standpoint but plaid hat wanted to install some of the magic that was oh so successful in their hit game dead of winter here and thus the monstrous experimentation begins the setup Frankenstein's monster which they really want you to know this is inspired by the original novel by Mary Shelley is recruiting a group of scientists to create another monster replicating his own Genesis meanwhile captain Walton is hunting the monster and as a consequence hunting you but as you play events and encounters happen every round based on a deck assembled during setup these cards are double-sided so they can have a different effect depending on how far in the game you are and in order to not spoil the surprise you have to put a cover card on top of them go speaking and sometimes these cards will present players with a grim dark super brutal story choice with ambiguous consequences that the target player will have to make directing them to a result in the rulebook where you see the thematic and mechanical outcome look I appreciate the ambition in trying to integrate an emergent story into a
strategy game but there are two things here first off this is a huge game it can take as many as 12 rounds to play and when you're playing through an entirety of 12 rounds the whole setup and execution of the encounter deck feels clunky and like a pain to manage it undermines the fluidity of a game the second thing is that dead of winter which clearly is the inspiration for this is a semi cooperative hidden traitor game where the story elements are surprising and fun and generally affect everyone at the table it just pulls you into the story more here this is a competitive strategy game and if you care about the story then the abstraction involved with moving resources and maximizing efficiencies it's going to pull you out of that story but if you care about the strategy then having story elements happen that suddenly give a benefit or a detriment to a player or all players at the table that that disrupts your plans can be really frustrating so the way that always included doesn't make me like the story more but it makes me care about the strategy less abomination is a weird be site seems to undermine its conveniences on its surface it's really intriguing worker placement game you have different characters with variable powers variable bonus scoring multi-use cards which can include dice
manipulation some limited worker bumping and a really fantastic completely original resource management system on the other hand it's systems require a lot of upkeep yet the previously mentioned event deck and then every round you're refreshing cards in several areas whether they were used or not and between the gobs of resources you'll be scooting along your tab hello the ice blocks the money in the dials the jars that need to be refilled ultimately for a payoff that has managed through dice rolls which not only can fail to help you but can actively hurt you and the fact that there's no real scaling mechanism to account for increased player account other than one extra bump that can happen per round scheming feels the opposite of streamlined but that's ok for as cumbersome as it can be actually like a lot of the mechanical structure of abomination but then there's this and this and all of these oh and don't forget about the little pieces a piggy you're mixing with your human remains but I'm sure it's fine just go to the church and give a little to charity your humanity will still end up on the positive end of things this is a gruesome game with really graphic imagery and concepts that don't feel entirely earned don't get me wrong I love horror and think verbal violence can be used for powerful dramatic and yes even comedic effect but how many people want to play a game with realistic depictions of slit throats and severed heads how do you feel when you make a choice to lose three humanity committing murder or fresh body parts and it's not just that it's graphic it's that the game is so nonchalant and
making you the perpetrator of this gratuity with few hints of humor irony or anything interesting to say about the horrifying nature of man this is a dark game that I imagine will pose a problem for some potential players at the table ultimately the theme becomes a metaphor for the game it's ambitious and original but it's also unwieldy and made of disparate parts and for every really good idea in this game like the fantastic decaying resource system or those awesome dials on your player boards there's just something that holds it back and while conceptually I really wanted to like this game it has a fresh horrific theme it had an intriguing mix of competitive strategy with emergent storytelling and it's also a worker placement game which is one of my favorite mechanics but it just didn't do it for me so this is an OK game with a lot of really good ideas that should have been great but much of this abomination should left on the cutting-room floor and that is our view thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard herald calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold