Skip to main content
Loading video...

SETI Review - An amazing houseguest who out stays their welcome a bit

Transcript 27:21

The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence from CGE is currently the 17th highest rated board game ever to exist. I played it about 3 weeks ago and I thought it was brilliant. I thought it was going to be in my top 10 games that I've ever played in my life. I thought it was going to usurp Orleans is my favorite Euro game ever. Then I played it four more times over the last few weeks and I got a chance to try it at every single player count, including solo. But every single time I played it, I liked it slightly less. That being said, it's still a fantastic experience that I recommend you check out. But let's talk about it.

What does that even mean? Bowers game corner. Oh there YouTube. I'm back again today for another game review and today I'm very excited to check out SEI the search for extraterrestrial intelligence from CGE who is also one of my favorite publishers of all time. A lot of bangers. Go go go go go play and buy Kahora so I get an expansion please. This is for one to four players ages 14 plus take about 40 minutes to play and in SETI this is your typical Euro where you are going to have a variety of different ways to win the game all circling around the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. You'll be launching probes, moving them around the galaxy, sending out radio signals and scanning and collecting data and putting them into your computer and upgrading your computer and upgrading your probes and upgrading your scanning capability and and worrying about your popularity and all sorts of cool stuff like that.

But let's take you to the table. I'll give you an overview of exactly how it works and then I'll give you my thoughts. And before you, we have STI in all of its glory. It is quite a table beast. As you can see, it looks incredibly daunting, but at its core, it's really quite a simple system. On your turn, you are only going to take one action, and then you can do as many free actions as you'd like, and then it goes on to the next player, and they're going to do that. And if you're playing a two-player game, you go back and forth and back and forth, and then eventually someone will pass. They'll do a couple things for the passing, and then it will go back to whoever has not passed, and they're going to get to go as many times as they want. And when they pass, you'll go to the next round. So, it's quite a simple flow. And once you learn the main actions, you'll kind of have an idea of what's going. So, let's just talk about it and then we'll we'll explain everything else as we go. So, first, two gold is going to let you launch a probe.

What that means is wherever Earth is, you're going to take one of your cool little plasticky probe pieces right here and you're going to put that out there. And that, if you wanted to be would be your whole turn. Now, what you could also do is you could also do some free actions if you wanted. The one that I really want to pay attention to is right there. That is the movement action. As you can see, you could spend energy to move. energy are going to be these little tokens right here. At the beginning of every round, you're going to have a certain amount of energy you're going to collect and you can uh alter this. So, you can you can start gaining a whole bunch more. Uh there's this thing called income, which is really sticking cool, and a path to victory if you want, where essentially you're going to be able to tuck cards down underneath here, and then as we end rounds, you're going to get all that income. So, uh, one way I won the game was I had like eight cards tucked underneath here. And that could be a totally viable strategy if you wanted to win the game. But that's your probe. You got it around. You'll be moving around the galaxy trying to get it to different planets because if you do get to different planets or if you go to different spots, you're going to gain popularity on this chart right here.

Now, this chart is super awesome because it's how popular you popular on Earth. And the higher you go up on the track, the more you will be able to get. So, for this one, you can trade in six of your stuff and you can get one of these tech upgrades. And these tech upgrades are really the star of the show, at least for me, and how I like to play, but we'll talk about those later. What they will do, though, is enhance your actions. Actually, we'll talk about it now. So, we talked about launching a probe, right? It's going to cost you two gold, but if you get some tech upgrades, you can start getting some cool stuff like this one, which means you can have two probes out at once, or this one, which is going to make it cheaper to land on different planets. So let's talk about that action. In fact, land. Typically, it would cost you three energy to land on a planet. Now, how this works is you need to kind of look at this big chunk of components, and you need to really break it down to three separate boards. First, you have this board right here. This is where you're going to be traversing around the galaxy. Uh you'll be scanning, which is an action we'll talk about later, which will give you these little tokens right here to get data. But we're on Mars right now. What does that mean? Well, we take a look at this board over here and we look specifically for Mars. So Mars is right there. And if we happen to land on Mars, we would get this, this, and this. Well, we probably this, this, and this. But you get what I'm saying. And all these different planets have different works. Now, you also notice that there's stuff on the planets, but there's stuff around the outside, which leads us to our next

section, which is orbit. Instead of landing on the planet, you might just pay a coin and a energy to orbit around the planet. And they will have different perks. Like for instance, how we talked about income, how you could get a whole bunch of cards stacked underneath here. That's how you do it. That symbol right there, that symbol is going to allow you to collect data at specific uh areas around the galaxy. And you'll see there are two yellow, two black, two blue, and two red. And this is an area control aspect. So essentially uh let's just pretend we went here. We would get one data. So this would go plop into our computer data area right down there. We get one resource for wherever Jupiter is. So we take a look at a Jupiter which is right here. And we take one of these.

That's a data. We put one of these in there. And now we are one. We have one of the control we need for the area control aspect because each one of these is a different area control. That should be filled up. Ignore that one. But the other cool thing about this is if you launch a probe out into orbit, it physically goes off the board. It goes up to here. You get all the goodies and then that changes how much it costs to land on that planet. So instead of it costing three, it only costs two and that's cheaper for everybody. So by doing that, it's awesome. You get some awesome special abilities, but it makes it other people easier for other people to do. Also, you'll notice uh we're continuing on the tech upgrades. There's planets, planets, but some of them have moons around the outside because, you know, that's how planets work. And the moons, that's a special tech upgrade.

Uh, asteroids, you saw asteroids around the outside. Typically, to leave those, it's going to cost you two movement. However, if you get the tech upgrade, it will only cost you one movement. The other cool thing about the tech upgrades is that the first person to get them gonna get two points, whatever. But you also immediately gain the benefit on the back of the card. And sometimes you'll get a tech upgrade just to get the benefit on the back of the card because that's really the crux of this game is just trying to squeeze out as many efficient and good moves as you can. So those are the tech upgrades for your probe. Moving on over here, let's talk about the next action, which is scanning. Once again, it's one of the main actions you have down here. It cost you one coin, two energy, but when you scan, you get to do these two every single time. So you'll take a look at where Earth's rotation is, which is right here. So, you'd be taking one of these. And by the way, yes, this does move. There's three layers that move.

And this is a huge aspect of the game, actually, which is really stinking cool because the galaxy is going to move around you. Every time you get a every time you see this symbol, you're going to move the galaxy. Uh, the first player who passes is going to move the galaxy. A variety of different cards, and every single card in this game is unique and different, is going to get you. Some of them, yeah, will have movement on them. Right. So, the galaxy's going to be constantly shifting, but you're going to scan where Earth is. You'll get rid of a card in the buy row. There'll always be three cards up here. You look in the top right hand corner because these are multi-use cards, which is awesome. You'll get rid of that and you'll grab something from the yellow. So, scanning. It's a way to get a tons of data. Now, what do you do with data, right? So, what are we doing with data? You're going to put data here and whenever you want to, free action on your turn, you can move data over to these slots right here. And you're trying to fill it up all the way. However, once you cover something, you immediately gain that bonus. Now, you also notice dual layered board here because you guessed it, there are tech upgrades for your computer.

These are really cool as well because now whenever you put data in your computer, so before it did nothing, it was just it was there. Now, it's automatically gave you two points. And you also have the chance if you want to immediately, well, not immediately, the next time you play a data to go down here and get a coin. And it's really hard to get money in this game sometimes. So, you can upgrade to get more coins, more energy, more cards, more popularity. Moving on up to here, there's also the tech upgrades for purple. And uh honestly, if you're trying to teach the game, I think go describing the tech upgrades is a great way to do it. I feel like that made it a lot easier when I was teaching the game. So, scanning, it's area control. It's important. It's also every just for scanning, you're going to get popularity once it once once it finally fills up. But the main star of this show, because if that was just the game, you're going around searching for extraterrestrial intelligence. You got these different action. I think people would love this game. But the thing that I think really sets this game apart and makes it why it's the top 20 alltime game on Board Game Geek are aliens. So, let's scoot this out over here. Cuz at the beginning of every game, you're going to have two of these alien tiles that are going to go out. And eventually people are going to put their little tokens onto these spots right here. There's three spots right there. And once someone does that, it gets flipped over and you have an alien race that you're going to now immediately just learn what they do. And they each have their own little pamphlet. It's super cool. Those Wait, those are references. Look at the

pamphlets. They're each going to have their own little pamphlet. Oh, they're over here. And you will stop. you will explain what they do. They'll have their own different components. A and they're really fascinating aspects to the game. And every time you do it, you're going to have two separate alien races. But how do you get these out? Because this is also really important. And this is the main way you're probably going to win the game. You get the blue ones, which as you can see, those ones are blue. By running data through your computer, acquiring data, running it through your computer. That's how you get the blue ones. You get the yellow ones by visiting planets. Bloop. and you get the red ones by going and doing the scan action. The other really cool thing about the aliens is they obviously have their own weird asymmetric rules. Some of them like the yellow ones will have you like taking things, returning them back to Earth. Uh the blue ones will have you trying to get like higher up on this track right here. And then as the Earth rotates, you'll slowly start gaining some prog some slight bonuses uh from time to time, which is really nice. But the really really cool aspect though that I love about this are undoubtedly these right here. These are special cards for each alien race. And each the blue ones are quite the lamest. They're nice cards, but I think they're the lamest cards, but each of them has their own unique quirks, their own unique symbols, like endgame stuff. And you never know which two you're going to get. And the game has some clever ways to push you towards unlocking the aliens. and it really does uh take a great game and really shift it to the next gear in my

personal opinion once you start unlocking those aliens. There's a lot more to talk about with this game, but I feel like overall that's that's the basics. You know, there's also some endgame scoring here. The the cards, I can't speak enough to them. The multi-use cards will also like give you certain bonuses that when you complete missions and you'll uh you'll start gaining stuff throughout the game and those are endgame scoring as well. And it's just absolutely fantastic. Now, if you're here for solo, the solo is good. It has It's a pretty clean system once you learn how to do it, which I do like. They have some special alien cards that integrate into there. They have this system where you have to complete these tiles and turn these tiles in. And it's very difficult, I will say. And if you want to see more on that, you flip this over and there's this is it'll take you like 20 30 minutes to figure out how all this works, but honestly, once you know how to run the Solo system, it is a relatively smooth system most of the turns, but I'll talk more about that in my thoughts. That is a big old overview of what is with SETI. All right, so that was SETI. There's a lot going on there.

I clearly didn't get to everything because, you know, it's a 40minute per player game and I'd say that is that's being very kind. Let's go over the pros, let's go over the cons, and we'll we'll talk a little bit more about the game plays regress for that. Starting off on the con side, I feel like five rounds is too much. Now, I will say they quote unquote fix this if if you feel like it's a big issue in the expansion, which makes it so it's only four rounds. They get asymmetric special abilities. I have not tried it tried that at all. One of these days I plan on it. Uh I've heard it's brilliant, but I just feel like and it's weird for me because I love engine building games and I always feel like engine building games end too soon. I'm always like, "Ah, I just wanted to see the next, you know, like the next cool thing that my engine was going to do because I've been working on it this entire time." Whereas with STI, every single time I played the game, we'd get to like near the end of round three going into round four and I'd be like, "Okay, yeah, yeah, this could wrap up pretty soon." And that'd be just fine with me. I feel like I've squeezed all the steady juice out of there. Maybe I didn't see as much of the second alien race as I'd like to, but I feel like I've squeezed enough out of this, right? But then that round four and that round five just drag on. Now, I don't have as much of a problem with this personally. I take very quick turns most of the time, which means I'm used to a lot of downtime between turns just naturally because that's just how I play games most of the time. However, with this one, the added combination of once you pass, you're out and then everyone

else just gets to keep going and going and going and going. Um, I think that's really something that a lot of people are going to hate with this game. Matter of fact, I played at two players with my buddy Ronnie who's big into Euro games and he was not the biggest fan. Like he liked the core concepts and everything, but there was it's just this is a finicky game if you're not at an even skill level and people can just absolutely blast you. Like I said, I played this five times now, right? I have gotten my face stomped into the dirt so insanely hard two of those times, losing by nearly 100 points. And then the two of the other times I won both of those times by 80 to 100 points. Right? So it's like either I'm on the not fun end or someone else has been on the not fun end. 80% of the games that have played this and granted that's five games. It's a smaller sample size, but it just it's one of those games that really does best when everyone knows what's going on and everyone's on a relatively even skill plane because even if you're the one that's on the end of the yeah, I got to take another turn and oh, that gives me enough publicity that I can do this tech upgrade and now that I got this tech upgrade, it's going to give me another card and this other card is a symbol that I turn in the top left corner which means I'm going to be able to do this thing and do this and it's like you keep trying to string ing out every single little turn. And it has the Dominion problem. It's a reason I love

Dominion. I HAVE FIVE BOXES OF DOMINION over there, but people don't like to play Dominion with me, especially people that are close to me, because I love to go for the strategy where you have all the actions. You just play out your entire hand or as close as you can every single time. And that's not what this feels like necessarily, but it has that same LIKE LIKE JUST GET DONE WITH YOUR turn. But with this one, it's just get done with your four or five turns that you get to take after the fact because it's like a domino effect. It's like, oh, now I visit this planet. Oh, if I go to this moon, then I'm going to get these two, you know, I get to put these things up here and oh, now we met the aliens and so I got this alien card. And it just keeps going and going and going potentially. And I don't hate that that much, right? I can zone out. I can get on my phone. I can go to the bathroom cuz I got a small bladder. But the when the other people were on the other side of it, I actively felt bad for them. It's like, do I want to keep being efficient?

And it's it's like, yeah, if I keep being efficient, you might sit there for another 5 to 10 to 15 minutes potentially depend like if someone has analysis paralysis. And I think it's the main issue with the game honestly. Just just the the ability for the game stretches out and then the ability for someone to have so many extra turns that someone else if they're inefficient and this game values efficiency. And that's the main con. And I wanted to really hammer home on that one because I think a lot of people that are have problems with this game are going to have a problem with that exact aspect. One of those two things. Any other cons that I have with the game? Um, I would like to see more variety in the scoring tiles. I think like there's some endgame scoring and you get you get these tiles and you flip them over. I'd like to see maybe another one of those in the future, but every other complaint I think I have is is a slight nitpick.

Um, yeah, it's a beast to set up. The rules for solo are fine. I don't think they're I would I don't think I wouldn't say they're good. I definitely wouldn't say they're great, but they're fine. And I don't really have any other cons. I mean, there's a reason that this is the 17th ranked game on Board Game Geek right now. It's because it's generally very, very, very, very well made. Moving on to the pros, STI is great. I thoroughly enjoy STI and I would play SEI at the drop of a hat, especially if you have the expansion. Why? Well, first I feel like the theme comes across pretty well. This could have been a very mechanical game. I I I point to another game that I really like. Uh Pulsar 2849. Also another CGE game.

Great game. Felt way more mechanical than this. And it probably is one day going to go up my shelf because of that. I like to feel at least a little bit of the theme and this one does that. I like looking at the cards. I like how the cards make sense. If you read the flavor text in the cards, what they do, um, the the components feel pretty top-notch quality. The rotation of the Earth is just super cool. When you rotate the galaxy and trying to plan for that is a lot of fun. And I think that's my favorite aspect of this game is that like the first time you play it, you're probably not going to get everything. And the second time you play it, like, oh, now I understand why this aspect is so important. And maybe, just maybe, I think a lot of people will, but after that second game, you'll be like, "All right, this next third game, I'm gonna be locked in. I'm gonna know exactly what I'm gonna do." And you get to that third game, you're gonna have a much better knowledge of everything. But once again, I feel like that's going to lead to the cons if you're playing against someone who's playing on the first or second game. Because you'll just know like, "Oh, this is super important. Oh, you probably don't want to spend that."

Or, "Oh, you don't just go throw around your cards all willy-nilly because if you pass too early, then um it's one of those games which just it sucks. It sucks when brilliant games are only played best at certain conditions where everyone's on the same skill plane, but if that's the case, this game's a banger. Another con, solo mode. Um, I don't feel like it was captivating enough for me to go back to it just cuz, right? like maybe if I want to try out the expansion, some asymmetric factions to see how they play, or maybe if you really want to see the aliens and what they do, but it was a clean enough system, but there would come times on the AI's turn where their turn would just take longer than you want it to.

And I don't know. I I once again, I'm looking for cons and they're not abundant. It's a fine solo game. It's good. If you like solo experiences, I think you will enjoy it. But as someone who doesn't love solo games, I don't think this is going to be one that's going to be like, "Oh yeah, that was the game that really got me into solo games." I just don't think it has enough in the chamber. Also, uh, but I will say it has five different difficulties. I tried it on the third difficulty and it smashed my face in. So there there's plenty of room to grow there. Also, on those five levels of difficulty, once you get to a certain level, I think it is the third. I think that's why I went to it. Uh, you start to get an extra crinkle added to the solo version, which, you know, the solo is pretty good. But I still I think if you love solo games, this one is great for you. But I think if you don't love solo games, it will be good.

It'll be a nice way to learn the game before you teach it. And I don't think you're going to want to revisit it because and honestly I think the main reason now that I've really thought about it is just the interaction with the aliens is I think a lot more fun with people there. Especially some of the aliens where there's where there's like things that you're competing for specifically. So, like the blue ones, for instance, have these cool little things that are on the outside. And as the Earth goes around the galaxy, you'll whoever is uh once it lines up with one of those cool little alien things out in the atmosphere, whoever is highest on one of these tracks here, and it'll depend like red, yellow, blue is going to gain whatever that benefit is. And so, it it it really creates like this. That's it. That's it. I know exactly why I think this game is 17. And it's because the amount of choices that you have is just always a lot. And I guess that's another con really that I should have mentioned and I kind of did with the time length is if you have analysis paralysis, this game can really mess you up because it's constantly changing the position of the galaxy. It's constantly changing in between turns, especially at three and four players, the area control aspect of the game. when you scan out in the galaxy. And so you might think you know what you want to do on your turn, but then it's like you get to your turn and you're like, "Ooh, but if I scan in the galaxy, then I'll get two points here and two points there and two points here. Oh, but if I do this and and and it becomes like it becomes that choice

of like, oo, I could do this really cool move that's going to take three turns to do and it's probably the most efficient. Or I could do this kind of cool move that's going to like strike while the iron's hot. I'll pick up two points here. I'll pick up two points there. I want to get the moon upgrade. want to race because at the end of the day it is multiplayer solitary E not 100% but I'd say like 70ish%. Right, which I guess that's another con now I think about it. Um but there's just always choices, right? And you're always trying to squeeze that last little extra juice of your card like oh maybe I should just discard this card to get up what's in the top lefthand corner. And I mean, end of the day, it's great and I'd recommend everyone try it. If you don't mind this, I I feel like I'd recommend everyone to try it, but at the end of the day, I don't feel like it's as solid of experience at two players because I like it at the higher player count. The scans feel like scanning just feels a little bit more viable at the higher player count and I think funner because it's an area control game and when you have four people vying for control of an area, it's just fun. Plus, there's all these cool little things. I can just talk about this game all day. Like when you get second place on the scanning ring and it's like, "Oh, I didn't get the cool special ability where I got to talk to the aliens and maybe get an alien card victory points, but I still get my one cube there, my one little cube there, cuz I was in second place, which means the next time we go through it that, you know, I'm going to have a leg up and it's just the game rewards striking while the iron is hot. The game rewards long-term planning. The game

rewards being able to kind of tweak your strategy on the drop of a hat. The game rewards, you know, getting these cool upgrades and using them to their maximum ability. The the game just it does it's brilliant. IT'S A BRILLIANTLY DESIGNED game and it's great. I'm not putting up best sale on it though. I thought I was I thought I was in my top 10 and then I just realized how difficult it would be to get to the table compared to other euros and whether or not I would really want to as much. And for that I got to ding it a little bit. But at the end of the day, SETI is still great. Like as much as it sounds like this is a negative review, it's really positive. It's just I wanted to make that review like which I used to do. I used to be bad about this sometimes where I do reviews after not playing it enough way back in the day like this is great and like two more game plays like man that was the exact same game as before and this one it's a literally the opposite like I was like I kept playing it I kept playing I kept playing like man this lost a little bit of shine a little bit of shine I'm still having a blast but it's like when someone goes to the bathroom when they pass they go to the bathroom they're gone for a while they come back and you still are like yeah I still got a lot I can and you feel like you should just kind of do inefficient stuff to get back to them playing the game. It's not great.

Not a great feeling for anybody. And I think that's really the main thing that dinged this from being a Bower's best seal to being a really great game that I highly recommend. So there you go. That's the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. I'll play it at the drop of a hat. Especially got the expansion. I can't wait for future expansions. I want more cards. OH, BY THE WAY, CARDS AMAZING. Like there's so many more amazing things in here. Like the different level of strategy. Like next time I go, like I want to do an all income strategy. I want to do an all. That's great. Get out of here. Si go check it out. It's no cota. That's not fair. Kohora is an expansion. Cutor is another CG game. That's why I'm comparing it. Let me know in the comments below. If you played Si and Kohora, which one do you prefer? And Si, I know it's number 17th at all times.

So, not just, you know, bowing down to the game is going to make some people mad. But what do you think about that fourth and fifth round thing? I just feel like it stretches longer than it needs to. And yeah, way longer than it needs to, especially if everyone is not on an even playing field. But if you enjoy the content, please click on the subscribe button down below or consider supporting the Patreon for only a dollar a month because it really does help me an awful lot. from I've been running Powers Game Corner for 15 years. It's always just been on the back burner. I've had three kids in that time. I graduated from college. You know, I I got married, did a lot of stuff in that time period. And Powers Game Corner just always been always just been kind of simmering on the back burner. Now hopefully kicking at the front burner. I could use your help doing that. But thanks for your time.

Bye-bye. This video is brought to you by all of my amazing Patreon supporters. And I would love it if you would join their ranks and HAVE YOUR NAME IMMORTALIZED in the end of many of my videos for the end of time. But consider for only a dollar a month.

Progress saved