Curating My Collection (Ep. 4) | 7 More Games Leaving
Transcript
hey how's it going everyone carlo here from all you can board and today i'm doing another curating my collection video uh i'm gonna be getting rid of seven more games from my collection i didn't expect to be doing another one of these this soon uh i'll be honest out of these seven games um five of them were games that i didn't think i was quite ready to part with yet um i kind of waffled back and forth on a lot of these here but i am going to be moving by the time you see this video i might already be in the middle of a move and i just kept thinking i don't want to keep moving with stuff that i might never use again so i'm kind of trying to downsize i wish i could have had some some of the biggest heaviest boxes but some of those games i've only played maybe once i think i gotta give this at least one more shot before i get rid of it even these some of these aren't very big games i kind of felt like with a lot of these that i kept delaying getting rhythm for a while thinking no i should play it one more time oh i should play with another player count i should see if maybe so and so likes it and then maybe keep in my collection and anyway i'll get more into the individual reasons for these as we go on i think this is either my fourth or fifth video on this dylan has done a couple as well so you can go check those out uh to see what other games that he's got whatever that i've gotten rid of um otherwise i'm just gonna get right into it uh this first one here is going to be a bit of a cheat pick which i'll explain and that is exit the abandoned cabin so it's published by cosmos and the reason this is kind of a cheat pick is this is kind of a one-time play i don't this is the only one in the exit series that i've played but there are a bunch of these frames doesn't know exit the game and there'll be a little uh like subtitle or whatever so this one the abandoned cabin was the one that i universally always kept hearing reading
online about like if i haven't played the series what's the best entry point where it's you know not too easy but still challenging and interesting and i thought about it for a long time because i knew that these were like you know they're inexpensive games i think like 12 bucks 15 bucks something like that maybe 20. but i knew that this isn't something i mean maybe there's ways to avoid ruining the components and being able to use it but i think it would have been tough and would have kind of defeated the fun of it so it's basically an escape room in a box so you're where it plays one to four players um you have a time limit or you're setting a timer and you can kind of you know determine how well you did as a team or solo or whatnot based on you know uh how long it took you to do and or and if you whether you even completed it in the time limit and all that kind of stuff so my wife and i played this together um actually at uh our family cabin um a few months back so we tried to make it a little thematic and actually the funny part about it was that we were in the okay it's a cabin it's not like in the middle of the woods or anything but like there's a lot of people in my wife's family who will like there's basically a rotating cast of people who go to this cabin and so i think we don't really know the neighbors all that well no one ever just shows up and knocks at the door and we're sitting there playing this thing with the timer on and suddenly there's a knock at the door and it totally startled us caught us off guard and it's just some you know neighbors looking for my wife's mom or whatever it was or someone who else in the family that we didn't know and then kind of took the momentum out of our sales a bit halfway and we had to kind of go back and reset the time and get back into it so that might have hampered the experience i did enjoy it but as someone who really really really likes uh actual escape
rooms like i was conflicted because i was really impressed with how well it pulled it off like i was very skeptical i kept thinking you know i'm probably not gonna like these games that much but i feel like i should give them the shot because what if they are really good there's a whole series of them and maybe i'll just do one every once in a while you know at the cabin or whatever and it was pretty fun like we enjoyed it but it wasn't like an extremely memorable thing i wouldn't say that we got to the end and said oh we have to play another one i remember we both got looked at each other and went well now that like the box serves no purpose for us anymore like i don't know if i would go buying more and i'm going to probably leave it at that in terms of the mechanisms of the game i'm going to shift the discussion here very very shortly or very briefly here just to like the environmental impact of um you know so like board gaming in general as a hobby is not the most environmentally friendly hobby you know there's uh companies that obviously like sometimes by no fault of their own will you know get games manufactured that have faulty components that then need to be potentially scrapped entirely or then they just have to make new ones there's a lot of plastic a lot of the time like a lot of publishers are making the effort to move towards you know more environmentally friendly recyclable products getting away from plastics uh you know wrapping things in paper with a rubber band rather than having them in shrink wrap et cetera et cetera et cetera um and even though like it is a fairly small box it's still like it's kind of useless to me now like i thought i'd keep it for a while to be like oh maybe you know the memory of it on the shelf or we pull up the components every once in a while but like it has just sat there since i played it so
again i call this a cheat pick in a way because you know i'm not going to play it again anyways so it's a pretty easy choice to get rid of it we'll maybe take out a couple of little components and put them in a box somewhere or whatever maybe look back on them someday but overall i think i don't think i'll revisit these again um i i think to me it feels too inferior to the experience of an actual escape room even though i think the design team uh inca and marcus brand like they absolutely nailed i i don't know if it could be done better in a board game format or a table top format like this i just don't think that's the way that i want to ideally experience sort of the escape room type type feel so yeah that is exit the abandoned cabin all right uh next up and by the way from here on out i kind of am doing these in the order from my enjoyment level from least to most enjoyable so the next one we're going to go into is a very popular game one i haven't played in forever and that is risk um i feel kind of bad getting rid of this one because this was a part of a christmas gift from my brother probably six seven years ago or something like that and i haven't even played this copy and i that's part of the reason why i struggled so much to get rid of it i have first off like i always feel guilty moving on from something that was a gift from someone um especially if i like can't even say well i got my enjoyment out of it over the years so you know now i'll let someone else have a tournament or whatever i haven't played it once and
part of the reason is like i'm not a huge fan of risk and i always said i remember when my brother would invite me to join him and his friends for risk nights or i know i have friends that play too or people who played online and all that kind of thing and a big thing for me was always like the player elimination the length of the game all these kinds of things and i thought like as i'm getting more and more into these modern day hobby hobby games that have no player elimination that are quicker experiences all this kind of stuff i thought am i really gonna play a risk but i thought i'll give it a shot it's you know faster i know a lot of people who would be open to playing it kind of thing but it sat on my shelf and i'm realizing more and more that the people that i know like my friends and family that want to play risk they have their own copies of risk and i would be open to going to someone else's house and then refreshing me on the rules and i would happily give it another shot with other people at their place but like if someone comes over to my place and looks at my you know 100 plus games goes oh we should play risk i'm gonna be like really i don't even remember the rules and also like i would rather play so many other games here and maybe it's because i just haven't had a great experience with it yet but the idea of having people in my house for a game night and either me being eliminated like if i'm eliminated from a game of risk if i played someone else's house i can go home if i don't want to watch but i'm not just gonna like i guess i'll go upstairs or watch you guys play or kind of thing but i also would feel so bad i know i would find it tough to enjoy the game if someone else got eliminated like early on in the game and they're at my house and i'm like can i can i help do you want to watch some tv can i you know i just i would feel so so guilty and i wouldn't be able to actually enjoy the game so yeah if i play risk again i can play someone
else's copy who owns it who really wants to play it but otherwise unfortunately i've just been carrying this game around for too long and i'm not going to move with it and expect that i'm going to play it when i have so many other games that i either haven't played yet that i want to play first um or games that i have played that i just want to revisit rather than going into some unknown that might be a lot longer than i think or might have player elimination or whatnot so risk will be leaving my collection next up is a game called vulcanut so this is designed illustrated and produced by the same gentleman luis bruet i apologize if i mispronounced that uh fellow canadian who i believe his company uh i think they're called vesuvius media and i think they're in halifax um very hard-working guy he's designing a lot of games putting out a lot of games over the last few years he's done the uh i think they're called dwarfs fall and dwarfs something series uh there was another one recently on kickstarter called keep the heroes out um you'll probably recognize the kind of art style if you're familiar with those games and this was actually for years and years and years and years i never backed anything on kickstarter and then around i think it was march 20th it probably ran around the start of the pandemic i backed my first game ever on kickstarter and this was actually it um it was a late pledge so not maybe not official but i did get in there and it's basically there's an ancient game from i remember how many hundreds of years ago called uh hanefa tofu i'll try to remember to put a link in the description below or or just spell it out in case you want to look into it um but it has it's basically sometimes known as viking chess and it was a game where basically all the pieces it looked just like kind
of like a a chessboard i think it was bigger and i think it was if i'm not mistaken ace not asymmetric in terms of the pieces move differently but i think one player had a certain number of pieces and the other player had more and there was a slightly different goal but the idea is that all the pieces move like a rook in chess so just in a straight line and you're trying to kind of sandwich your opponent's pieces to take them off the board this is basically an updated take lewis the designer mentioned in his you know designer uh write-ups or whatever for this game on the kickstarter page that he loved nephatophel and was very inspired and wanted to kind of pay tribute to this game that was very special to him and that was part of what like you know as someone used to really like playing chess a lot as a kid i still have a lot of respect for the game even though i don't play it um the idea of having something that was a very classic sort of ancient game but reimagined in a format that had you know uh these ones actually do have like variable player powers or asymmetric like you know there's the uh the dragons there's the dwarves there's whatever any i think there's nine of them in the base game and you're also doing something here where you're building out the map so on your turn there's a a row of cards and you basically pick one of the three cards you add it to the main terrain and then if you have these symbols you can place more pieces on the board and you have these units that go out every faction has a different number of units different abilities a lot of interesting stuff it plays two to four players the reason this is that you might collect well there's a few reasons leaving my collection first off i don't think it's a particularly good three or four player game i would only ever really play this with two and i had a couple issues with the kind of the way
the terrain develops with cards like there's some times where it's really hard to make use of your powers or sometimes you look around in the cards like in some ways it felt like it didn't play quite as quickly as i would have liked and at times there were a couple of games i played of it where the randomness of the way the cards came out and where you could build the territory just felt a bit unsatisfying so i liked the idea i liked the concept there were a couple times i liked it but when i look at it on my shelf i haven't gone back to it now in a long time and when i look at all the other two player games on my shelf and i'm more likely to play ahead of it there's just way too many other games that this is never really gonna get to the table i've pointed it out to people who've come over and people said oh that sounds cool let's play battle line or oh that sounds cool let's play santorini so i just don't see it getting played and i'd rather this go to someone else who will play it that is valknut all right now these are the four these ones are a lot tougher um let's get right into the next one though project l if you're a fan of our channel uh you might think this is blasphemy i know there's a lot of people who really like this game a lot and to be fair like i don't dislike the game um i think it's a great game there's a lot of things i do like about it uh if anyone doesn't know it's basically a polyamino engine building game so i personally can't think of like there might be polyamino games where you kind of build an engine throughout obviously like something like spring meadow which i've talked about on the channel which i really like because you have the connection of all the the burrows that you're getting bigger and bigger rocks every turn if you chain these bros together so some engine but like this game is almost more it's an
engine building game that uses polyaminos uh rather than feeling like an actual polyamino game to me and that's part of you know what is making it leave my collection to be honest with you is i can't think of another just straight up polyamino engine builder game and if i'm gonna play a polyamino game this is nowhere even in the top like five or probably even in the top ten like even in my own collection in terms of the one i would reach for because usually when i want to play a polyamino game i'm not looking for something where i'm trying to like you know mid-max and make the most efficient move every turn like it's usually kind of more of a relaxing game where i'm just trying to like sort of do a puzzle fit these pieces in see the best i can do and like you know sure i'm still playing to win like with any game you should still be trying to win even if winning isn't you know it doesn't determine your enjoyment of the game but there was just something a little i don't know it felt like it falls short for what i wanted a polyamino game and then also it's nowhere near one of my favorite engine building games it follows a bit shy of like there's other engine building games there's games that fall under engine and tableau building it's hard to classify where you would say the more but it like you know race for the galaxy res arcana um you know the century games which i don't even own um anyways there's there's just so many other games that are going to come ahead on either one and i kept thinking oh well maybe i'll play it with my wife one day and i asked him like hey what if i got rid of this game and she's like well what is it what's it about what's the theme i'm like there isn't really a theme and i can already see her going well and i was like and it's not really like one of those ones where you just fill up your board and
you're trying to do stuff like in you know patchwork or or spring that or whatever i was like started explaining there's an engine build and she was like ah we have enough polyamino games so probably not gonna play it with her um i've only played it solo i will say to be fair and i do think it's gonna be much better with like i don't think a soul is the ideal way to play it but i got enough of a sense from the game to know that i don't feel the need to own it and it's never gonna be the one that i choose to play personally so i'd be happy to play it again uh you know dylan still has a copy i'm sure i'll play his every once in a while if someone else you know one of my friends or family members wants to buy this off me for very very cheap i might even just hand it off to someone so there's a good chance i'll play it again sometime but i don't feel the need to own it so that is project l uh by the way i didn't mention really nice quality of components the tiles are very satisfying um and there are some very satisfying moves when you chain together things and you get these tiles like it can be very satisfying to see that engine build and have that efficiency but yeah just not something i feel i need to play all the time next up is coddle uh this is i think it's the only game so far that this company synapsis games has published uh i talked about this pretty in depth in one of our own it play it skip it videos where we uh do six sort of mini reviews of games and i mentioned that this was a play it it wasn't a must-own it wasn't a skip there's a lot of things i like about this game it kind of falls in that in terms of like the rules complexity how long it takes to play you know the level of strategy involved all that kind of stuff um it kind of and the quality of components and all that it kind of feel feels like it falls into that kind of like azul sagrada kind of range where like it plays in probably about 45 minutes you
could it feels like a family weight gain but also something that you could play with people who want something like a maybe a little bit more of a strategic experience like um it it's not really like a very complex game but there are interesting decisions to make still on every turn you're basically uh getting these pieces uh there's either head tail or body pieces by the way a quaddle is um like a feathered snake and so you're basically collecting these pieces off this board you're drafting with other players you're collecting these pieces taking them to your supply and you're putting them together to make these quaddles when someone completes their third one it triggers the end game and at the end of the game everyone's counting up the points that they get for them based on the cards they've assigned which might say like if this quaddle has you know for every alternating red blue red blue section you get five points so you're and you can make those as long or short as you want those quartz it might be a five piece quartal it might be an 18 piece squad it's totally up to you so there's a bit of that push your luck and race element of you don't know when the game is going to end who is going to kind of push for that end or if you see someone getting really close to ending their third oh well i didn't meet that goal yet but i got to cap this thing and put a tail on it and do all these things so and there's little powers that you can get and there's other pri uh public objectives you can be the first one to beat players to and there's some hand management stuff so there are some cool things going on i've played it four or five times uh i have not played the solo mode but i did play it with two three and i think four and i enjoyed it on all of my plays but it's one of those games that's like it's a good game it might even be a great game but it's not something again that i feel like i'm gonna like i've gotten my enjoyment out
of it i'm never gonna be the one to suggest it at this point neither is my wife i just don't think it has a place in my collection long term um and i know enough people that i think would be interested in giving this a shot and i'm willing to let it go for a very reasonable price so it will be leaving my collection but i'm definitely curious about what these designers and what this uh publishing company will do in the future so i will be keeping an eye out for them but uh yeah for now kwaddle will be leaving my collection okay now these last two are actually really tough because these i think stand sort of you know if i was giving these games ratings i'd probably rate these at least a half point or a full point higher than these these are great games and i'm going to give you my reasons why i'm getting rid of them the first one is the red cathedral this one i really really really struggled with because i've only played it solo as well you'll notice the theme some of these i've only played i guess this is only the second one i'm talking about that i've only played solo um during the pandemic and stuff but i've talked before about this game because it's for what's in the box what you get the bang for your buck is among the best you'll see in board games this was like a 30 game and i remember opening up and just seeing like wow the quality of the components there's these really nice quality like jewel pieces you know the art on the cards and the board is really nice the quality of like the wooden components like there's a lot of really high quality stuff in here the rule book is there were more rules than i thought the game had a lot more of a decision space and i was like and it took a lot longer to play and i kept thinking normally when you get a game that gives you this much to think about in this quality components not only is the game
usually 10 15 dollars more but it's usually the box is usually twice the size so like you know this box is smaller than the box for cuaddle that i just showed you and it's a much kind of like meatier thinkier game and it's less expensive so before we go any further credit to davier games i would love to see more publishers do this kind of thing there's like no wasted spot space in the box um but it's basically a game where there's this rondelle where you're you have these dice that get rolled and then they stay there and have a number on them obviously and you have a private board and you're basically trying to with the other players you're building up this cathedral and there's going to be these cards that come out and you're going to be basically reserving um parts of the cathedral your your builders that are all working together to try and impress the the czar and so you're basically trying to you know reserve things that you think you can complete before other players but depending what order you complete different sections in you might gain or lose other points there's area control stuff for every majority where at the end of the game every sort of segment of the tower whoever has the most pieces whoever contributed basically the most to the tower is going to score the most points so every single spot that you try to invest in and which parts you invest in because you don't always have to start at the bottom necessarily there's all these really interesting things going on but it's a game that it says around the box 80 minutes i think that's pretty fair but i could see it coming in at under an hour and a half i think it's not a game that's gonna be best uh solo or two players it's probably best of three or four and it's just now i played it once eight or nine months ago i've already forgotten the rules um and when i just
think about how many other games in my collection that i want to get back to the table or play for the first time you know if i were to like go to a cabin and take 20 30 40 games for my collection right now like this wouldn't make the cut and then i keep thinking well how long am i going to hang on to this just to play it one more time like i know it's not going to be i got enough out of my one play to know it's not going to be an all-time favorite so why am i trying to hold on to this game just to be like well maybe i'll play it one or two more times and then i'll do some sort of mini review on it or something and like i think it's just time to let it go and because of how relatively inexpensive it was for me i'm sure someone i know will probably take this off my hands for like 15 20 bucks and i'm if they really like it then that's a steal of a deal for an excellent game uh it's just not one that i'm personally itching to play again and the other thing is i've had people come over and say oh what about that game red cathedral but i've already forgotten the rules and i don't feel like i want to always no i don't want to keep reading the rule book and be like okay well i should be ready just in case someone wants to play this but if someone asks me on the spot do you want to play this and i don't feel like i know the rules well enough the rule the rules are heavy enough in this that it's not one that i'm just going to want to say yeah sure we'll just read the rules together and i'll re-teach you so just falls into a weird spot um but i think it's a really really good game very well designed and i will happily play anything else that these designers put out as well as this publishing company just on the strength of kind of the overall package and just how impressive it is for what it has in there so yeah it's a tough one i'm kind of potentially even regretting it as we speak but uh yeah hopefully no regrets long term that's thread cathedral
and now last but not least uh i already having doubts about this one too the search for planet x um this one ah so again i've only played this one solo and i might actually like from what i understand about the game at higher player counts and how played solo it might be a one that i'm i might actually enjoy it most as a solo game and the reason why strictly has to do with the fact that it is an app based game you need the app to play it's not like oh there's a companion app and you can play without it but it's a deduction game and the basic idea is you have a little private uh screen and you have like a sheet of paper behind it and this app when the start of the game it determined it picks a random location for all these different things there's a you can play on the standard side where there's 12 spaces or you can flip it onto the expert side of the sheet which has 18 spaces and basically it assigns planet x to a random spot and then there's like dwarf planets comets asteroids uh or what else is there i can't remember gas clouds and all these things and if you're familiar if you remember any of those kind of like logic slash deduction puzzles you might have had these in school where it's you know uh timmy is sitting next to jenny and jenny is sitting four spots away from billy and billy can't sit next to tabitha because of this reason and then it asks you where is billy sitting and how many seats away is jenny from tom and you're like what and you got to
start figuring out this deduction that's basically what this game is but you're going around the table taking turns and there's a few different actions you can take you can say and you're going to punch it into the app so everyone has their phone out or whatever their tablet on the table and i'll get to that after because that's why i'm getting rid of it from my collection but so everyone has their thing and on your turn you're basically punching in a secret question some of the information gets revealed to the other players and some of it doesn't like they know what you asked but you don't the result isn't revealed to everyone else so you get this information and you can make a note on your sheet so you can target say i want to know what's in sector nine and it'll tell you what's in there um or you can say i wanna scan between sectors four and eight um and i wanna see how many gas clouds are in there it'll tell you oh there's one gas cloud you're like okay so i don't know where it is but because i already know there's no gas clouds from the last round in these regions well it means that maybe the gas cloud is in one of these because there's only one of them and you're slowly crossing things off your sheet trying to do this process of elimination and figure out what's going on the interesting thing is you're trying to locate planet x but and that kind of triggers the end of the game when someone has located planet x but you don't actually necessarily win you just get a big i think it's 10 points if you're the first person to come successfully locate it but you can win with having done other stuff even if you didn't locate planet x and it's hard to know when you have located planet x because it kind of tells you that you're just in like i don't remember what it's called um uh uh i'm gonna forget the term but it's like
uh it's the same as there's nothing there or it might be planet x and so there's still an added level of like deduction that you have to do to figure out is it really planet x there or not there's a lot of cool stuff but the reason this hasn't hit the table for me again is that when i play board games and i get to play tabletop games with people it's an escape from screen time and in my full-time job i spend way too much time looking at screens all day in my spare time you know we we run a board game youtube channel i watch other board game stuff on youtube uh i like watching movies i like playing video games i play board games on board game arena et cetera et cetera the last thing i want when i sit around a table with people playing games like i don't like having my phone at the table even if i get a phone call message i always feel guilty i'm like oh it's kind of rude to have my phone at the table i really don't want that and the idea of inviting people over and having everyone's phone on the table is just not appealing to me and that's what's going to make me get rid of this even though i i think they absolutely crushed it on this design i really like these the design team they've also uh this is uh ben rossett and matthew o'malley and they've also designed between two cities and between two castles of mad king ludwig which are two other games i really enjoy uh and i really enjoy this and i will happily play it with other people again um there might even be maybe there's a digital version in the future and maybe that feels more easy to wrap my head around because the whole game is digital rather than inviting people over to gather around a table and pull our phones out i don't know there's something about it that just makes you realize i'm not going to play it again anytime soon so i think it should leave my collection go to someone who will really enjoy this um great game we'll happily play it
again but yeah i just i don't own a single app-based game where an app is required and if i did i think it might have to be a solo one and even then i would maybe i would rather play this with other people i don't know very conflicting um but i am going to get rid of it that is the search for planet x so that is seven games um you know before you know it it could be you know two months four months down the line i'll probably be getting rid of some more i know dylan just told me that he's probably gonna do a video of games leaving his shelf soon so i'm curious let me know what you think of any of these uh do you think i'm making too rash of a decision and if so why which of these games is your favorite which these are the lead your least favorite or are you interested in trying yeah always be curious to hear from you all but otherwise thank you so much for watching and we'll see you next time