The Legacy of Mars Campaign Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip - Just Whelming Enough!
Transcript
So, do I want it? Uh, I do. I love Terraforming Mars, but I need to try and set that aside. Do I feel like they convince me? The prices feel reasonable, right? One's like an over the moon deluxified 109 stupid little tiles that are fantastic, amazing trade and resale value in the future. It feels fine. And the other one, 130 bucks for a legacy game based off one of the most critically acro acclaimed board games of all time, which once again just just it just blows my mind they didn't choose to do that because and I just want to do this for my own personal interest. Like I do want to see how many awards it would be and nominations and stuff like that because it's Yeah. Like that. Look at that. Look at that list. That's for the base game.
Right. You could also list the stuff for the expansions. You could also list the stuff for the dice game. Yeah. Look at There we go. There's six more to throw on the pile. The dice. Let's see what people surely love. The dice game. No, nobody the dice game. All right. Get the hell out of here. But I'm just saying I feel like the number nine game ever, right? And I want to point towards Brass Birmingham and I feel like they did a really solid job of spotlighting that if you want to see a company that I feel like did a good job as opposed to them who like, "Yeah, here's a couple play testers who think it's really really good." And it's it's just I feel like that that whole section there could have been very very very easily beefed up with just with a little bit more. It's not a huge thing, but I think it is a thing. So final grade, do I want it? Yes, but if I don't know enough about terraforming Mars, like I don't know if you got me there. Can you do it? Yeah. You're not going to have a black eye on this. How much is it? And I feel like that's where it is. That's really where it is. I'm just so preconditioned for legacy games to have more than four games. Heck, if you told me you had a campaign game, not just a legacy game, but a campaign game, and I was like, "How many games did you say?" Four.
Like, oh, okay. like it just doesn't feel like a lot and I'm surprised more people like that's not a more common thing people are complaining about. But at the end of the day, Final Grade for Terraforming Mars, I think is a solid one because I always look at this from the perspective of how I think the publisher is running the the Kickstarter. And at the end of the day, I see them making tens of thousands of dollars on promo cards, if not more, right? Like those are those are salaries. Those are potential salaries of people paid for in promo cards. And that's what you're buying. They're buying them in an even larger bulk so they can sell them in the back end, so they can sell them in the future. And then there's like and and I just from a company perspective of keeping your baby alive because terraforming Mars Legacy is its own separate thing. But by doing this choice, they are essentially just just just jacking some adrenaline into their ability to keep their Evergreen game going. And it's just I think it's fantastic. I love it. just a weird nerdy forest thing. But final grade is uh I think whatever my grade in my head is, I need to go one grade lower than that because I think I've definitely got Terraforming Mars bias here. And I do
like a lot of stuff they've seen because I swear I've seen them run other crowdfunding campaigns and I've been unimpressed. I know when we started at the beginning I could only find one, but I swear I feel like I've seen them do some other ones. Um, so I'm gonna go with a I'm gonna go with a B+. I think a B+ is fine because the bottom line is the scenario that I laid out of like, oh, what if I don't know that much about terraforming Mars? I don't think that's going to be the majority of people that come here, right? I think you're going to come in here knowing like, okay, this is like one of the creme to the creme of all time like that. And if I come into it from that perspective and I say, "Hey, the legacy version of GameX that you love is $19 for the standard version. You go up to $130 for the when you got shipping and you want the stupid deluxified, you know, put it on your shelf, display it forever is 280, 290." I think you'd say those prices feel reasonable. It's just that four that four games is what I think is keeping it from from an A minus for me because a lot other than that I like a lot of what they're doing here. I definitely feel like the video could have been better. I feel like the main image could be better. Like there's a lot of things that could be better. And so since I say B+ and I said I'm grading the setup curve, I'm going to go with a B. I'm going to go with a B+ because those promo cards I Yeah, B+. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Terraforming Mars. The legacy of bars.