Ancient Knowledge Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
at number two I have ancient knowledge now this is a card driven engine building game um with a really neat structure actually if I have to um really give the game the most praise it would be in respect of that simple turn structure and the bones of the game because this one despite having so much scope of different Combos and things to do it really is broken down into a really nice structure as in playing cards from your hand which don't even cost anything they simply um you know you can play them directly you know sometimes you have to give up other cards but there isn't a currency per se in this game um then you are triggering any end of round cards and then you are sliding all the cards down from the kind of right hand side to the left hand side in kind of like a typewriter fashion which kind of demonstrates the passing of time as this knowledge is flowing through your civilization and Grading and going you know into um you know ancient times but when these are active on your player board they give you some kind of ongoing ability which can synergize with each other um but the downside of that is that generally speaking the more powerful cards you play will come with these knowledge tokens on them which you are trying to kind of extract from these cards before they wither away because every bit of knowledge on those cards that is um taken off the board by the passing of time is going to start building up negative points so you're constantly trying to figure out ways to again har trying to Sol that knowledge as quickly
as possible trying to synergize cards with each other and so on so not only are you trying to manage your hand of cards but there are also some public cards available which will give you other engine building benefits um and different things to collect and synergize with other cards Etc and you got permanent abilities you've got end of game abilities end of round actions and so on so different lots of different moving Parts here for different experiences each time you play now the game it's itself is quite subtle um this game isn't a bombastic game you know when you think of lot a lot of other engine building car driven games you get these big boisterous turns that will give you lots of power powerful things you can do this one is a little bit more rained in again a little bit more subtle with what you can do but there are still a lot of um you know a lot of clever decisions to be made um and the game actually does put you under a lot of pressure as well because sometimes you can bite off a bit more than you can chew it puts you under stress at times because you might not be able to get everything you want done and then you by clever play you can get everything you want done so I do like the way this game does reward um playing things in certain orders and you know generally speaking the best player will win in a game like this my main bug bear in this game is very similar to what I just mentioned with thieves where the card the pool of cards that you're drafting from is quite small and basically the way it replenishes can be quite frustrating because you can be saving towards something and then a
player will draft one of those cards from the center of the table which are like your technology cards and the remaining one that you wanted is just taken off the board and you didn't really have a say so also particularly when it comes to the second half of the game that you're getting end of game scoring cards the game sometimes rewards you for things that you weren't anticipating so for example it might say um you can take this card if you have three of these particular particular um monuments in your ancient area and three of these particular monuments you had no idea that that card was going to come out and some player unwillingly played all those cards and had them you know pass through time and they could take those cards and give them a a really healthy amount of amount of points and nobody really knew that was going to happen so I felt like this game was like neck and neck the whole way I played it and everyone played equally but it worked out in the favor just by happen stance that the the winning player managed to play all those cards during the game and those end game scoring cards just came out so in that respect I felt like that was quite jarring and it was quite swingy now I haven't played this much at all so maybe that will start to level out the more I play it but that particular experience did leave me feeling not disgruntled but I thought that it it kind of hurt the game um just that little bit and I thought that yeah you can play as well as you like but you know it's going to come down to Which special technology card come out who's going to determine the winner so again I'm not terribly experienced with this game I could be
wrong but from the slight few times I've played it it does seem to be that can be a factor of course the more you play this one you might start to know those cards a bit more but as it stands you know I play a lot of different games rather than playing the same game time and time again um that one is going to leave a little bit of a sour taste in my mouth so um again game structure decisionwise fantastic a really well-designed game um maybe can be a little bit long if you drag your heels but I think as long as players are playing with a good Tempo I think the the statements that are out there about this game taking too long are maybe a little bit overstated I don't think it's too bad at all we played a three playay game in this recently and only took us about 75 minutes if that and that's including a teach which I think is perfectly fine for a game of this depth but yeah I would love to see that be maybe a wider open pool of cards so that people can strategize a bit more and just not react tactically on decisions they had no idea where they were making at the beginning of the game so that is ancient knowledge at number two