Skip to main content
Loading video...

Unconscious Mind - Expansions Review - Beyond The Base Game

Transcript 26:17

hi everyone I'm Lor and this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to raving and ranting about board games but let's be honest it's usually more the ranty part this is going to be a fairly quick video of beyond the Bas game where I'm basically talking about the unconscious mind modules and expansions that you can get most of these were available via the kickstarter so I presume that when it gets to retail you're going to other buy these separately but if you got the kickstarter like Allin or Deluxe pledge and that you would probably be able to get these thrown in some of them were stretch goals some of them were just you know specific pledge level ones and I've basically gone through them all and I'm going to give you a quick rundown as to what they do and whether I think they're worth it there won't be a great deal number of pictures for this one but uh you know you're basically going to get my explanations so we're going to start with the main event I think so far which is the nightmares expansion so this one is a small expansion it introduces two modules um the pets module and the madness module so the Pet's module is basically these four cats I think not baby puppy the idea is with this is that you essentially have a separate track for your uh emotional support pet and it can be combined with the madness side or the normal side but what happens is when you do your ink pot movement at the end of a round end of a turn you can basically spend some of that movement instead to move up here you can cash it in for the bonus which can be pretty sizable bonuses and you know you bring it back down and then you move it back up again this is a very simple module to throw in and you could even throw it into a new player frankly but the module

does one thing that I'm not a fan of I like the idea that on your board you have this Trixie mechanic with the ink pot where you need to think right this is the action I want to do but ah it doesn't move the inkpot as far as I want to maybe I should go to the space above it and do that you know you can get around it but there's still an element of tactical play there if you throw in pets you effectively remove all tension of that because if I can simply just go well I don't want to move four spaces on this thing oh well that's fine I'll just give two to my pet yay I land on the the best space that I can in everything it it feels like you're playing unconscious mind on easy mode at that point which I don't particularly want to do you know I feel that you know the base game as it is is just fine with its difficulty level and for its complexity but you know even though it could have used a little streamline in here and there check out the review but pets kind of just makes it too easy you know you can just pretty much get the best location for your ink pot every single time pretty much without fail and you know the bonus you get from here can certainly supercharge the game and some way CU getting heart-shaped containers or extra treats you know on a whim is pretty powerful stuff so it's a fine module it's easy enough to throw in it's really going to be a case of do you want easy mode or not I personally don't so it's not one I really use but if easy mode if you want to make it a little bit more flexible bit more easier for new players to get their stuff done then by all means throw it in whether you're using Madness or not all right so the madness module this is the big expansion although I say big it's not huge but it

does introduce s more bits in general so there's quite a few bits here that I'm going to collect as such because it sort of comes in multiple Parts but predominantly it revolves around a new resource called madness now this is not culu Madness type thing it's just general Madness of nightmares and dreams and thematically it's a pretty good fit for this game you know the idea of psychotherapy dealing with you know horrible night terrors and stuff you know that's pretty cool but mainly it's just an Aesthetics perspective the idea is is that you now have this cracked Insight dial which functions like a normal Insight dial but now you can put I'll just use one of the special beads for illustration but as well as putting them on the minor median and major you can also put them into these cracked sections on your dial which you know hold more insights but then they give you Madness tokens the idea is that Madness tokens as the game progresses can get to you various bonuses as you level through so if you've got at least eight or more madness tokens you can freely transfer median Insight you know pretty powerful if you've got three or more you can move an extra couple of spaces counterclockwise on the map rather than clockwise so it gives you some cool benefit while you're mad the problem is as soon as somebody gets the 13 Madness or as soon as the reputation marker passes a certain point and I think there's one other area I can't remember the third trigger off top of my head but basically three triggers in the game are going to cause you to take a Madness check which means that whoever's got whatever Madness level you have you essentially lose that many VP it's and you can even put it on two VP per Madness Point that's quite damaging

to lose a good chunk of VP although it depends how often you're using it I mean if you're losing three or four whoopy do but if you're losing 12 or 13 that's quite a sizable chunk and bear in mind that's happening three times in the game that could be a size of amount of EP you lose if you happen to go down this madness route but you know other than that mainly it just resolves around a few tweaks to some other rules so for example you now have another uh Journal that you can produce the Book of the Dead which you know based on Madness you've got another location goal again based on Madness you've got uh you know some a resource called Dark Insight which is basically black beads or navy beads it seems and these can come from you know different research cards that now have that are grave volumes which basically give you Madness and some of those insights now and again you've also got a few uncanny clients which are just basically some more routine clients that you throw into the mix and they can get you these dark insights as well but the predominant use of the dark insights is via these so you've got a few more grief layers and you got a few more dream cards to do and the dream cards can let you spend dark insights in order to generate the kaasa effect so you can get like a pretty sizable bonus from these things and The Uncanny clients that you have when you get these end up with these metamorphosis layers on them which is basically the idea that you're it's not so much a RW Shack painting it's more that you're your person is transforming into something horrific and uh yeah horrific is the word I'd use um there is some serious nightmare fuel in these

images you like it I mean this definitely fits the theme of nightmares so much so there are two cards that I effectively ban from this set if you are like me and arachnophobic then is a grief flayer and a card in here that you must ban from the game you know the grief flayer has somebody like metamorphosing into a spider so it's got the spider face with you know fangs and hair and that that's nightmare fuel in itself there is also a card in here I'm not going to show either of them don't worry but basically there is a card in here that basically has a giant walking spider on the horizon or something like I mean a big one best way I could describe it think the old giant spider B movies or if you've ever played a computer game called Limbo remember the spider that appears at the left hand side of the screen in yeah think that it's basically like that it is terrifying if you're a arachnophobic to see those two so you have to hide them out of the game if you don't want to scare yourself rigid and finally for the nightmares one you've got an extra module called the gramophone and this one is a module I will refuse to use Point Blank it's a small module very easy rules all it is is that you give up a Madness token or a heart-shaped container and you grab this this allows you to do one extra action for all the stuff that's limited so you could do three main actions rather than just two if you put two ideas down or you could do six location actions if you have to tags rather than just five I will never use this module again the problem with this one is that it's basically just adds more downtime more length to the game without actually you know being worth it because there's already a lot of downtime between turns particularly

in a four player game when people are triggering just one action let alone two let alone fraking free when you've got somebody causing God knows how many triggers with three of on their turn you know particularly if they're doing like free location moves or free you know notebook tile Gaines or something that or free sets of publishing cards and know like playing cards and Publishing journals three of those in quick succession the turns just take forever and there's just too much going on as you watch somebody struggle to try and deal with all the triggers that are going on it's too much there is plenty enough triggers and combos in that in the base game this basically just turns like the the fiddlin level up to 11 and just makes the downtime worse and in some cases the length longer as a result the amount of people that might have to take baxes because they've messed up part of their thing and it's very difficult to do with two actions let alone three don't bother with this module your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't stop to think if they should so overall the madness expansion just feels a bit like a let down it's it's there but the pets module makes the game too easy for me but I could probably see it being the best part of the expansion for some you know the gramophone I will never use even though it's a very tiny element and this whole Madness scene is just not necessary it works but the rules layers on top Aren't Enough the the rules layers are too much to Warrant any extra enjoyment cuz it's not a huge amount of extra enjoyment the madness stuff is basically a few bonuses

and some slight Variety in the cards and it's like I would have simply just taken more variety in the dreams and the clients and all that but using base game elements why do we need to throw in an entirely new mechanic to make some of this little bit of extra variety work it's not like you get tons I mean you only get you know this many extra grief layers you only get this many new clients you get a decent amount of dreams but that's about it so yeah I mean you get one more Journal that's it one more Journal really you could like do more one more location goal I feel like you could have expanded this one a bit well not I'm saying that if you're going to make this expansion with a new mechanic then add more variety with it but failing that don't give me a whole new mechanic before you've even let the base game settle in our minds you could have released this a year later and it would have been fine but now with the base game as complex as it is you don't need this it's a five out of 10 for me it's average at best you know you get some fun out of it you get a little bit from the pets module more and I can see the pets module being good for some particularly new players but the gramophone no way and the madness stuff it's just not necessary I will play the game if somebody throws it in I don't have a problem with that but I'm pretty much just going to let this sit and take up space in the box and never really take it out myself now what do you think now we get on to the free association modules this is basically like a collection of mini modules that are very easy to throw into the game they don't add a lot of rules the question is do they add enough impact or do they unbalance things in some ways in

order to make the game worse so let's see what each of these do so first up you have the illusion dream cards this is literally just six dream cards Hollow foil so they look really nice really cool pictures you know one with a big lobster on a plate you know stuff like that but basically these are just shuffled into the main deck and what they do is the same thing they require a collection of identical insights as well as a you know crap on of coffee to basically do two things trigger the reputation track and move the hearts as far as necessary to cure the client these are far too powerful it's over 9,000 they really are too powerful if I see one of these in the mix I'm grabbing it literally off the get-go because automatically curing a client that is worth 6 seven8 points is pretty powerful in itself but then on top of that you know the idea of all you need is I mean in this case what do I need I need two identical Medan insights and four coffee coffee is not that hard to get a hold of in this game it's a pretty easy resource to get a lot of and two insights that's it two of any ident iCal insights again that's not difficult to get even the ones that are two majors I mean you know two majors and a bright idea a bright idea really that's a major cost no and two major insights again you might argue with hang on don't the normal dreams do that yeah that's the thing the normal dreams have costs like these but they don't give you such ridiculous powerful effects as autoc Cur Decline and triggering your reputation track these

are too much it's like as soon as one of these gets thrown out they are just instant picks everybody grabs them and they're just too powerful particularly if your reputation track is quite high it's easy to throw in I mean literally you could just shuffle them in and forget they even exist but yeah they're just a bit too unbalanced for me your mother next up we have the mirror clients mirror clients are basically a collection of five clients that are double-sided and each one is used in as a difference to the starting clients you normally get because normally you draft a bunch of routine clients and you shove them out and that's all good here you no longer get location tags on them but what you get is basically a fat number of points and a starting like ability that you can have that is based off the reputation track so that every time you trigger the reputation track you get some additional bonus like in this case a heart-shaped container a notebook tile an Elevate and a transfer Move freid Free spaces an Insight you know a chance to play a card to draw a card a bright idea that kind of thing and these are basically used instead of your starting ones and they differentiate the colors a little bit more than just simply the four that are in the game although there is a fifth one which I suspect is for it's yeah it's for Freud himself so you could technically be using this character instead of one of these four it's kind of weird but this is actually a pretty cool little module because just having a random routine client you know uses up some of the main deck and that's kind of it I like the idea that you can now have something that makes the reputation track that just a little bit better cuz some people think the reputation track is a weak part of the game like it doesn't it's not lucrative enough now I have one using the reputation track before so I can dispute

that to an extent but I think if you were to throw this little mini module in and say that you start with something that is based entirely off the reputation track it might just make it a little bit more powerful for people easy to include not a bad little module at all I might even start using this on a very regular basis without even telling people that it's a mini expansion module because I just think it's a nice easy one to do you don't have to touch the main routine client deck you can just let it do its thing it's pretty neat and I think I'll use it quite often okay that's a start that's very Earth friendly next up we got bricka bra notebook tiles I'm not entirely sure what brick orra actually means but uh essentially this is another starting notebook tile that you put into your board next door to your previous ones let's take one of the madness ones here for illustration let's say this is the one that I started the game with whichever one you decide to pick essentially goes you know to the right of it and the idea is is that when you complete your second column you flip over the token gain the bonus on it and then it basically just clogs up the space and doesn't do anything that's literally all the expansion does why was this a thing it's completely unnecessary you know I mean yeah it's cool to get a big bonus although the ability to get some insights in two heart-shaped containers might be a bit better than getting six coffee or you know being able to you know get a couple more cards I don't know it really depends on what you're doing but yeah this just feels unnecessary I mean at some point in the drawing room somebody thought you know how many more ways can we tweak this game all right yeah let's throw in this tiny little thing and I know it's super

tiny and not worth really getting worked up about but lot of these little mini expansions kind of feel like that it's like we didn't need all these extra bits that have literally just been fought up on the spot you know you didn't need these little bits so yeah the expansion functions it's there it doesn't make the game any more or less enjoyable frankly I mean uh I mean if anything it makes it a little bit easier to get the points from filling up your notebook because now you have a second space taken up with these from the get-go whereas normally you only have one so you remove that kind of challenge to be honest so yeah I just wouldn't really bother with these they're just not needed you know nothing John Snow four out five now we have the scholarly research cards you simply shuffle them into the main game and they basically are dual volumes so you know what they do they vary most of the time they allow you to play more cards so you can basically spam a bunch of these research cards if you're you know play your cards right and then there's a few that are double volume so they actually count as two Green books or two uh red books that kind of thing and the idea is is that if if you use one of those to immediately publish a journal treaties B which is one of the effects on the cards then you have to use these as the two like you know first playing books and it's like okay fine but I'm not sure I like the idea that a lot of these enable you to play more cards easier because you're meant to use action economy in order to play the cards and again this one makes it a little bit too easy to spam the extra cards although there are only 12 of them they're in a deck that's reasonably big so you're not going to see a ton of them

during the game so they are an easy include but yeah I would have probably just not bothered with the whole double volume thing and just had you know I mean this didn't even need to be an expansion really cuz I mean you've got this is the double volume ones right one two three there you go there's three cards that require another rule explanation in order to utilize correctly the rest of these are literally just scholarly cards they're research cards that's it with the effects that allow you to do a a journal or play more cards why not just include these in the base game and forgo these three this didn't even need to be an expansion do even feel like an expansion I mean you know I'm in two minds as to whether I leave these out permanently or just shuffle them into the base game and don't even worry about it you know it's not going to dilute the deck it's got an equal amount of symbols across the board so there's an even amount of distribution for these so why don't I just simply throw these into the deck and not worry about it it just doesn't even feel like an expansion why is it included as another mini expansion when all it is is basically effectively three cards with an extra rule I'm not a big lover of this one this one just feels like wholly unnecessary what the hell was that and then finally we come to rendevu objectives now this one is actually an interesting expansion actually cuz this one basically gives you public goals that you can go for which you've seen in every single game but there's a couple of little knock on effects with this one it doesn't look like much there's only

six of them but what you effectively do is that you layer one on top of another card so the requirement is always the same you need to have a spare IDE and you need to have yourself where froy is that's always the first bit but then you essentially have a bonus on one side and the requirement on the other so let's take an easy one for now uh I rund deu with Freud and I have three major insights in my dial okay cool and then when that happens I put one of my ideas on the card and I trigger the effect which in this case is draw two cards and play two cards cards and you can create some you know various combinations with this so even though there's only six cards there's more than six combinations here but your idea stays on the card permanently so you don't have that for the rest of the game you're reducing the number of workers you have although to be honest I don't usually need all six workers to be able to do stuff especially when bright ERS are a thing but sucking up one of these when you're early in the game or something can still you know make you recall a little bit more often than not but this one I don't mind throwing in if people are more familiar with the game you know the bonuses on here are not crazy powerful I mean you you get to trigger a bunch of notebook tiles play some cards move your ink pot a couple of spaces trigger the reputation marker a couple of times get a ton of coffee trigger locations I mean they're powerful effects but everybody gets a chance to do them once and there's three of them out so you know you've got effectively three different cool bonuses that you can get based on free criteria but if you do more of them you're going to lose more ideas from your stash and have to work with what you've got so this one I actually kind

of like I almost feel like this one probably should have just been in the base game but uh alongside the mirror clients this is probably I'd say the second best little module in the setup you know so I will throw this one in every now and again possibly even for new players because with a new player what you got to do to say it's a public goal people understand what a public goal is um you've got to be where Freud is straightforward easy just got to go to his location and it gives people an objective they don't score you points in this but being able to do these cool effects will allow you to do cool stuff and typically it makes the location like the map element a little bit more interesting as well because I said that the map was probably the weaker element of the game but with this now you have a reason to move more often on the map particularly to where Freud is like chasing him down particularly when you know when you want to trigger one of these bonuses so this is pretty neat want to throw in in probably 80% of your games I would throw this one in hooray so that's all the modules in free associations you get a little rule sheet to explain them all and they are basically just a side box now I don't know if this is coming out to retail like after the fact I suspect it will but at the moment it was mainly in the kickstarter a lot of this does feel unnecessary like they could have easily just thrown this in as base game uh modules the illusion dream cards are far too powerful not a fan of those the Bricker notebook tiles are so inconsequential and they sort of cheapen the need to fill up all your rows and columns and that that I find them just unnecessary and I won't use them the

scholarly research cards the double volumes just aren't necessary and the rest of them you might as well just Shuffle with the base game cards anyway it doesn't feel like an expansion so the only two that I would really give any props to are the mirror clients which I think are definitely worth considering or and and these uh like new objectives so overall the Box itself again is probably a five out of 10 you know a lot of yeah five out of 10 and that's mainly because of these two modules being actually half decent but you know one I would throw into you know these on I could actually sorry I could actually consider throwing these two in with new players and the other three just seem like a waste of space but you know that's the way I go so with all of these modules like sort of mentioned about I mean you get a couple of modules in the base set but I'm not talking about those cuz they're in the base set and they're not particularly amazing anyway but you know you have got here a nightmares expansion and a free associations module thing so there's a lot of little individual modules for this game to customize it and honestly Publishers sto doing this you need to make an expansion fine make it a while after the base game has settled let us enjoy the base game for a bit and then when you get feedback about the base game then you can start thinking about an expansion because the best expansions are made based on customer feedback you know there are times where we've you know said like oh this element in the base game is a bit annoying or this one could be streamlined a bit more this one needs fixing and the best expansions take that feedback and say you know what we've add addess this and we've revised this

element or we've brought in new cards or put in a board overlay or something to fix that element they are the best expansions an expansion when the game is released you know or before it's even play tested fully do very rarely work sorry don't sorry they very rarely work to get it right they just they're too much too soon they haven't had the full play testing they haven't been you know fully played to see oh yeah does has really improved the game a lot and most people are not going to use these modules until God knows when down the line anyway and this is a complex game that chances are you're not going to play with the same group of people all the time you know I mean if you do then fine you can try out a few of these but if you're teaching new players most of the stuff I wouldn't even want to touch with a barge pole because it's just adding more complication to them when you don't need to and having lots of little modules dotted around the insert and various places just make setup and pack away more of a chore cuz you got to separate out all the individual bits so these expansions effectively are a five out of 10 you know overall I gave it a five for nightmares a five for free associations they exist some of them I've got little neat bits you could use the pets module to make life life a little bit easier you could certainly use the mirror clients I think the mirror clients are good if you think the reputation track is not good enough and these objectives add a nice little cool element to the map thing you know these are bits in the base game that people have commented are slightly weaker than other aspects so these expansions help to make the weaker elements better don't

just try to pile stuff on top of everything you know in order to make it sell you know you can have a really nice cake and it's got loads of layers it's got CH you know it's got cream and sprinkles and you know lovely moist cake whatever and it's like perfect the way it is and then somebody comes along and just goes what if I shove like Smarties on it and yeah you chocolate Trunks and brownie bits and you know whipped cream all over the top and let's just shove all this other stuff on to before you know it this cake is ruined or made worse because you've just piled on everything in the kitchen sink onto it when it was already a nice cake to eat it's a weird analogy but maybe I'm just a bit peckish but yeah five out of 10 for these expansions they exist there's some bits in it but they are wholly not needed they are definitely not essential and I don't recommend that you go out of your way to pay stupid amounts of money to get them you know for just a tiny little bits extra but if you've already got the Allin pledge and you've already got this stuff and you're thinking well which bits should I focus on I've already told you which ones they are so that's it for on this episode of the broken meele if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek don't forget to check out the actual review for unconscious mind why am I pointing over there it's in the distance but yeah for the actual base game that I've reviewed a big long review so uh I think I have comprehensively covered this game now much to the request of other people and obviously check out the rest of my Essen content let me know your thoughts do any of these modules sound good to you have you had different experiences with these modules than I have I'd certainly be interested to know so until next time take care and remember regard less of whether you are Banning any cards from your game because they are

far too scary seriously people can we stop putting spiders in games most common phobia and all that it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved