John D Clair on Design, Mistborn, Stormlight and beyond - TCbH Interviews
Transcript
hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Herald my chance talk with creative Gamers and game creators and I am thrilled because today I am bringing on to the show the prolific the professional the recently at platypus con John D CLA welcome to the cardboard held good to see you after what like two weeks since you were up here in Alaska yeah it was a great time up there that was fun was that your first time in Alaska I had been to um Anchorage with my wife for our honeymoon uh we got an RV out of Anchorage and we went down the Kenai Peninsula and then up to Denali and that was very lovely uh Juno and we also did get over we got over into the Prince William sound for a little bit which was the most similar to the the look and feel of Juno but um yeah Juno was cool yeah yeah and that's nice that you got to do that big tour up there I'm originally from the Anchorage area so I'm very familiar with it I miss the birch trees a lot but here in Juno is kind of what I think of what I think of like a prototypical fantasy land with like big expansive Waters and giant Timber and that kind of stuff which I'm not just talking up my city and my state I'm bringing that up because when I think of you I think of very similar things because my introduction to John declair was Mystic Veil that was when I was like oh wait what's going on here who's this guy what's going on AG is
giving me cards where I'm like using you know slotting mechanisms what's up with this so like was that your big break or was that just when you appeared on my radar yeah Mystic bille is more or less if you want to call it a big break that would be if if you want to say I had a big break at any point it would be Mystic it well you could rewind it a little bit it would be like um you know I I I can credit AEG and particularly John zins are over there for um having a lot of uh or seeing something in me and having a lot of faith in my design um ability going forward because when I showed them um the card crafting system initially or I showed John szer um the owner of AG the originally the card crafting system he he was like boy we want to be in on this business right um uh and we want to do a lot more projects with you in the future um so that sort of a lot of doors um and subsequent years of working with AEG a lot um and I continue working with them a lot um for a while I was essentially exclusive with them uh I'm no longer with uh exclusive with them but I've got I still got um you know expansions for the games I've done with them in the works and then I think three new um unannounced projects uh with them still yeah you got a lot of irons in the fire I mean that that just from getting to spend some time with you up here at platypus con you know we were checking out some of
the newer stuff like mbor and I've played some the one you're not allowed to talk about oh yeah yeah yeah exactly I got to play some prototypes and everything but like it it occurred to me that you are very prolific you have a lot of varied uh game types that you try to uh work within and you seem to work with different themes and genres do you ever find that you're both having to one up that card crafting system but also kind of work around it so that way you don't get just known as the guy who has like card crafting gimmicks um you know I uh it's occurred to me to to uh that there's some Advantage uh to making sure my brand isn't just the card crafting guy right right um that said my uh inspiration for game design comes from all over the place any different realm of card games dice games board games whatever happens to inspire me if that's what I'm excited to work on it's what I'll work on and that has fortunately I guess varied from things where card crafting makes sense to things where card crafting doesn't make sense so um sort of I've naturally not just done that but the card crafting um um system has enough design space that still feels untapped
by the broader uh uh the broader game design community that often when I do have cards in a game I'm like does it make sense to put card crafting here as um not so much a a thing that a brand the brand that I do but just it's it remains a space of untapped design space largely um that I've spent a lot of time thinking about um and uh and continuing to do when it makes sense with the ideas that I'm excited about working on well for the audience I can't talk about the game that I'm about to kind of talk about but John John did mention at the con he's like oh yeah I got this prototype where I think it is a a real fresh take on some deck building ideas and some card crafting ideas and I was like okay you know like I I'll see your novel Approach at deck building and car crafting but come on man I'm a game reviewer I've seen it all uh completely blew me away and I was like this is completely unlike anything else I've played so you've convinced me that there is a lot more space to be explored if you're approaching it from that kind of creative Zone but I I took us ahead you know like I I got to the point where you're making games but talk to me about your inspiration like what's your background with tabletop games in general and like when did you start fiddling around with either prototypes
or variants or like what got you you know flowing in this direction yeah I the my origin story is probably both similar and different to a lot of other designers the similar part is I was a I was a nerdy kid I liked games I played games with my friends growing up um the different part probably for many is I was homeschooled which um I give a lot of credit for my uh creative in um uh experience as a child growing up to the way I was raised we had a it was very just creative free form um my mom my mom a great thing I get from my mom that or I get I give her credit for is uh anytime I wanted something she would always basically ask well first let's see if we can make it right so when growing up when my friends were all acquiring Pokémon cards and I was like that looks fun that looks cool I didn't even bother asking if they could get me um Pokemon cards I was just like you know what I'm going to try to make I'm going to try to make my own card game um and at the time I'd made other games but I hadn't done anything along those lines um and that turned into sort of my first game that was Playa fun as a kid so anyway that's the origin story um going for who who were you playing that with were you like showing that to friends or siblings or your mom it was a game called Monster cards um and okay yeah very creatively
named I as I recall I was like I think I'm going to I'm just going to call it Monster cards until I come up with a better name and then that one just stuck um I was like nine at the time right um uh so it was called Monster cards and I would just handdraw with color pencils and stuff pictures of monsters and it was stats and it was this very simple dice rolling monsters fighting game um and I showed it with a number of friends and some friends enjoyed it and they make they would make their own cards um I remember this little Community uh kids theater thing that we were doing and my sister was into the was into the theater stuff and a bunch of friends were and they were trying to talk me into being in this in this play with the other kids uh and I would bring my Monster cards to all the rehearsals and I was like I don't really want to be in the play but all these kids here want to like we can play Monster cards together were you even at that age were you thinking about like I don't know an ecosystem a balance because like surely there's the Instinct at 9 years old to be like well if I'm just make the cards I can make the best ever card but then within a game or two you have to realize well if I make a gamebreaking card then it's not fun for anyone so like what were those early experiences and lessons that you were having while you know playing around with iterative design um yeah I I um the balance was terrible um right of course fortunately it was one of those sort of Wahoo Chuck
dice games where you're like the balance can be terrible and it doesn't mean it's not fun um uh but uh quickly after making cards it was apparent that like well some cards are just better than others and then you you'd make some as a kid you'd be like you'd make some like I want this guy to be really cool and then you make them um and then uh have to sort of pair it back and I had this really convoluted system of like um if the if the attack was really strong the monster would do damage to itself um uh which didn't work half the time people forgot that rule anyway um yeah so later on when I got a little older I did some co-design efforts with some other friends uh and that was um some of my best friends and that was an interesting Endeavor where we would sort of go back and forth on um different rules and talk about the balance with each other and change it um and this is sort of going into the teenage years there um and uh some one of the challenges of course there is like if I have a we were sort of making like a ccg Style game um if I have a particular uh preference of like I want to make a deck that's really cool like this well like I'm also making up the cards for my deck um and they're making up the cards for their deck and like well now maybe maybe that power that's in that your deck is based around is a little too strong right it's like no maybe the one you're making is too strong right um it was fun growing up making that stuff though we had a we had a really creative Community my friends are
all very creative smart kids um uh who were into games and it was great was there ever any notion that you would be making games professionally um I uh I always sort of took very practical approach um uh I got a I went to college for economics with a business uh a business emphasis um I sort of Saw Game design as something that I would love to do nights and weekends and hopefully it would make money um but you know the goal was first to just do this thing I enjoy uh right and uh the second goal which which I always did keep in sort of in the Target was try to make money doing it but not with the plan to like you know replace a practical job practical salary job or something right um so I got the Practical degree I got the practical job out of college and I did indeed nights and weekends design board games um and it was pretty aggressive about trying to pitch them that was the goal it wasn't just for fun um and then uh you know the the so-called break we talked about earlier with AEG sort of uh found some momentum there started actually making money money comparable to what I was making in my salary job and then uh I remember at one point well I switched to parttime in my salary job and then at one point maybe a year after getting married I was having a conversation with my wife at a local place near our house
and I was just like what if I just quit what if I just quit yeah like you know I I think like we've been I've been at that point I've been making royalties for uh probably four years uh and they had they had now gotten up to you know maybe 80% of what my salary was on a sort of reliable basis right royalties are never actually predictable um in a way a salary is right and I you know we were like yeah let's let's try it let's do it was there ever any moment where you were going to be exclusive like an in-house designer or at that point I got to imagine you have this business degree you have an economics degree you know you're you're maybe thinking about well instead of being an employee for someone I could just be a designer as a business a freelancer um uh so I I actually tried to get a job in the toy industry and Andor game industry for a while I thought you know I could it would be interesting and useful to use um sort of my business background degree um being like a brand manager for uh aliance of toys or or a game line um and in La there's there's Mattel there's Spin Master there's a number of toy companies here and I had I had no luck I don't know what it was I was bad at job interviews or whatever I got I got down the process on a whole
bunch of jobs and never got a single offer I did to be fair to be fair to myself I graduated in 2010 when the job market was absolutely awful so the fact that I had a a reasonably good job at all was helpful for those first few years um but yeah I had no luck I got real close on a bunch of jobs uh in the toy industry and no luck and um I even I even applied to a a game design job at Fantasy Flight um and they flew me out for an interview I went all the way out to Minnesota to do an interview with them um uh and and this is back Fantasy Flight this is an as North America this is Fantasy Flight games Christian T Peterson yeah yeah um yeah so I mean that was my thought originally was like if I want to work in toys and games I'll try to do something practical like um be a be an employee at a company yeah um you know in retrospect it's almost a blessing that I or not almost it's absolutely feels like you know really good fortune good luck whatever that I actually didn't get any of those jobs because freelance is is much I can't imagine having gotten an employee position that I would enjoy more than being an independent game designer now right well what year did you go full professional where you had that conversation what if I quit my job like what year is that 2018 okay so 2018 you have a couple years Head Start
before Mystic B came out in 2016 so and um you know like you have so many designs under your belt at this point I mean you have um like and I'm talking about 2025 here I iconic designs you got uh kubos you got Rolling Heights you got space base like space base is everywhere everyone at platypus comom was playing space base and wanting you to sign their copies left and right you had people lining up for that um so you have these kind of like foundational Evergreen games um by the time that you're at 2018 and now for the next couple of years how do you structure your time like I I don't even know what a game designer's day looks like especially when you seem like such a business focused practically minded person you wake up in the morning and you go well I guess I'm working on game designs today uh yeah it's just it's exactly like that every day uh I mean I have so I have four kids so my uh my day is primarily first first and foremost I should say structured around what I have to do as a dad um and then uh uh to the extent possible on a day I will take out chunks of time to get to to do work um and work work is mostly
game design work um some of it is actually game design and some of it is the communication and business side um so like uh a week like this week um uh Monday was mostly a work day uh which means wake up have breakfast with the kids and then I've got a I've got a I'm fortunate enough to have a I've got like a separate back office from our house so I can sort I can say I'm going to work um you know uh and then actually like leave the house and walk into the backyard and go into the back office um where theoretically the kids aren't supposed to come bother me um that doesn't always work out but uh and then you know and then I'll work for whatever portion of the day that is at some point usually uh my wife who's who's managing all four kids that are five and under at this point um you know may ask for help hey can you come watch them while I take a little nap or something like that right um and then uh at some point I'll help out with dinner later in the day and that's what like a typical day is um you know I'll this time of year here I'm helping coach little league and stuff like that with my kids um and then often and then you know at least probably at least four nights a week after the kids go to bed I'm back up in my office until midnight working on stuff um has we becoming a dad has that uh changed any perspective on the games that you make at all I mean
have you become interested in making kids games at all or you know just the process of see small humans learn and the ways in which they gather information impacted you know anything about the way you approach this creative business um uh not not dramatically yet uh my eldest is five though and he's you know just at the point where he's starting to read he's um you know when you teach him the rules of a game he really understands them right uh right and uh so he and he's he's asking to play games a lot now too right so uh as he gets older and then the the follow the the girls that follow him right my uh my next oldest is four now um you know as they as they learn to read and they learn to play they learn to be they're more interested in games I suspect my um they will they will pull my inspir my inspiration comes from wherever and then I'll follow you know when I have an when I'm inspired to have an idea and I have time to work on it um I will follow the idea that sounds interesting to me and sounds like it has there's a business case for it right like it could it's it's a viable product as well um and I suspect as I play more and more games with my kids and my eldest Jackson he's like asking to like can I design gra games with you Dad I'm like yes well we can and we started working on one game but um I suspect that will pull me in a direction that for games that um are
particularly uh readily enjoyable for young kids Monster cards League going on in your house well we do we actually started making a game called uh that was Loosely based on my Monster Cards game called seventh Siders and Jackson and I were making cards together for it amazing yeah yeah so it's it's starting um none of the games that I've got on the schedule currently I would credit to my uh being a dad for having um Des inspired them but there are games I have on the shelf that are beginning to be worked on that are sort of the beginnings of I suspect what'll be a lot of child inspired games parenting inspired games I I can't believe that we're looking down the barrel at Mystic Vil being 10 years old right you know that is seeming like a short amount of time you know in my memory from when I first played Mystic Bale to being here but you know here we are it's 2025 are there things that you look back on on some of your early published designs where you're like oh man the the professional that I've grown into now would not make that mistake in design or you know that you've honed your craft like do you feel like you are getting better and better as you go yes I'm I think I'm a much better designer than I was 10 years ago yeah um
and what do you use for evidence of that uh so uh well there's there's two ways you could think about it right one is um am I better at getting a a good idea to uh into a good game or am I better at identifying what a good idea is to begin with right and doing that um I think I always I always reasonably good at identifying what a good idea is uh and then turning it into a a a decent game um uh what I've always struggled with as a designer is turning a decent game into a great game for uh for a more casual audience um so uh for me one of one of my design sort of uh North Stars when I'm making a game is that I have to want to play it and I want to not it I don't want to get tired of playing it right so if if I'm finding myself on the 20th play test of a game being like I'm really sick of this game right um you know this game had 15 good plays in it for me and I'm done that's usually a sign that I'm like okay I need to I I I I want to change this or work on something else right I don't this game's not doing it for me um so one of the challenges with me is um in that respect is an easy way to add DE to a game is to
add complexity right that's sort of the easy way to say like well if you're getting tired of the game let's make it a little let's make the challenge a little higher let's make it a little bit more involved let's let's add this other mechanism that um or more complex cards or something right um and the right answer from a design standpoint uh often if you want to appeal to a wide audience is um is not to add complexity uh sometimes that means means that the game you're working on it just isn't isn't going to be that type of game that will be a casual game that never loses its luster for people or particularly for me um so uh uh I think what I've gotten better at is knowing when I'm working on a game that isn't going to get there that I should change it earlier in the process rather than later so rather than taking a design that is a good good idea to a decent spot and then hammering away on it till it gets to a place where I'm like this is a game I'll play forever but now it's kind of gotten comp more complicated for the regular audience right I will if I get it to that decent point and I not seeing a path forward where it stays a more casual friendly game or a more the target audience I want um I'm quicker to just drop it or move to something else right how soon in the process do you start sh games to uh Publishers at like pitch meetings and
that kind of stuff I mean you're an established name people know that you have delivered products that sell but you know like if you if you're working on so many different projects at once I got to imagine that you're showing it before it's in a completely finished hey this is ready to publish as soon as you get some artwork on this stage there's probably a lot of development that still needs to happen yeah it depends on what kind of what what the the kind of game is so you know obviously if I'm making it if a publisher comes to me and says we have uh we have the misbourne we have an opportunity to make a misbourne game uh John would you like to make that and I'm like yes I want to make that um that's a different sort of timeline than if like I had an idea and I wanted to try see if it turned into a good game and then it seemed decent so I'm going to work on it for a while right um it's a very different sort of timeline um if it's if it's so in that second scenario which I think is what you're asking about um uh it it also depends on the type of game um and and also just some games just come together quickly right if that initial you know there's like a pairing of like the uh the initial concept that is like this is an idea worth working on and then what game should it be in um so often my inspir often my inspiration for games isn't um doesn't begin with like
the overall game it begins with the hook that's usually where my inspiration starts as opposed to like I want to make this overall kind of game how do I find a hook for it it's like here's a hook what overall game does that make sense in right and sometimes those two things come together quick and it's like oh boom there it is right um and sometimes they don't uh so uh the pace depends and it kind of like if the game is what it needs to be for me is the game needs to be at a point where I am enjoying it I am seeing that like this game is not getting boring for me um I'm seeing Play testers enjoy it um but it doesn't have to be at a point where I'm like this game's great it's done there's there's I'm I can move away from it in order to pitch it what it needs to be is like it there's a there's a the game design has reached a fork in the road where a Publisher's input and what direction they would want to take it um uh I'm is now is now important and it doesn't mean I can't choose to take it that path myself um but by choosing one way or the other it all of a sudden a whole bunch of Publishers May no longer be interested whereas if I stop at a certain point along that path and Pitch it then it some doors remain open right so um there's like a point of diminishing returns in a game design process depending on the game where where you're like okay uh I can refine this further down a particular um
theme path or something like that right um but by doing so I'm spending a bunch of time that I may pitch it to a publisher and they'll either say well we liked this part right uh but but we might want to change this or that right and then I'm like well why it shouldn't have worked on all those changes to begin with right so if like if I'm finding if I'm finding that I'm getting to a point where I want the Publishers input that's where I might be like okay it might be time to show this idea to some Publishers um how much latitude do you have in like what changes happen to a game I guess it it really depends on what publisher you're working with and every contract's got to be different but um I guess what I'm getting at is you know like you make a game with some concept in mind and then you bring it to a public and they go well we like about 60% of this game and we'd be willing to go a direction on this um and if that 40% you felt was really important to that game design are you from the business-minded uh perspective going yeah well I guess you know it's the Publishers game I'm making them a game it's their game at this point if they accept this or would you consider walking away and go I would risk not having this published but try to find the publisher who I think is
going to kind of maintain the Artistic integrity you know how precious are you about this and how much Freedom as a as a freelancer do you have in trying to shop around your ideas yeah I think if if I felt a publisher was going to make changes that for me would make the game not a not a good game um like I've got I've got 60% of a good idea right and I'm looking for a publisher who's going to help me take that 40% the rest of the way there or something like that right and 60% is a bad marker it's more like 85% often right and then that last 50% is a lot of work but but it's but it's important um but if I feel like the publisher if I'm like you know I could use a a publisher and developer to take it the rest of the way uh if for some reason I think a publisher isn't going to do a good job on it even if they'll or a you know even if they'll sell a handful of copies a good number of copies I I probably wouldn't pursue that that's not a scenario I felt I've been been into often um uh most of my experience most of my publish games at this point are still with AEG um most of my currently signed to be released games are no longer with AEG at this point uh but I've been fortunate not to be in a position where I felt like a publisher um sees a game wants a game makes an offer on a game but is also like signaling that they have a
different vision of the product than what I would want it for um I I think I'm less I'm a lot less precious than um some other creative types might be about my ideas um like like I said I I a lot of original ideas begin for me with the hook and I'm less worried about the game that goes around the hook as long as the hook is um is you know being front and center it's it's the thing that's there that's making the game what it is right um yeah it it's a it's a it's I've been fortunate again not to have to um butt heads too much with with Publishers and ideas we disagree with uh probably one of my earlier designs actually um was where I had the most uh frustration or disappointment with a publisher um that was that was a game downfall um my second game I ever published took a long time to come out and they made some development choices that I was frustrated with um but I think I was I was uh or I was on to other games at that point by the time that game ever came out so it didn't um didn't matter and I think you learn lessons from that and I think even if you've had mostly congenial relationships with Publishers from this point forward you still learn about how to advocate for the things that you think you want to
see so I think having that happen early in the career uh can also be viewed as a a learning opportunity you know yeah It's tricky to know um how much to push back right cuz you want um uh you want to if you have a very strong opinion about a particular aspect of a game design um you you want to give the the developers at the publisher the latitude to to test their ideas you certainly don't want to be the type of designer who's like you know you hear the developer idea and you're like that sucks right you know what are you doing um well let's talk about something that I'm very passionate about I mean I'm passionate about games in general uh but uh I got to play born with you up here it's out now uh by brotherwise games uh and uh it's awesome this is your second game with them as a publisher right you had Empire's end and then now Mporn um do you have any other irons in the fire with them right now that are announced that you can talk about here we have an unannounced but they've told me it's not secret uh Stormlight Archive uh epic war game um live in the Sanders dream over there so you uh got to uh ride the the Sanderson and lightning here with mbor uh this isn't the first mbor game that's
come out and it's certainly not the first cosmere tabletop game in general uh but misbourne the deck building game had a lot of Buzz coming at the tail end of 2024 uh and um I got to admit when I first heard about it and I read just kind of like a basic synopsis I had a lot of trepidation from some of the deck building games that came out maybe 5 to 10 years ago where it was just like here's DC Super Heroes and you just have punching as a resource and you just kind of build up and on paper Miss borne kind of has that Vibe like it it it just feels like okay okay so you have a some purchasing power you get some cards and then you're going to play them and it's just going to be a slapped on theme I was actually shocked that as a mbor fan there were a lot of subtle things that you did to integrate the tone uh and like thematic Resonance of the series into the game design itself and not just the illustrations or names of characters and those things so I guess my first question is uh were you already a a fan of misbourne or did this project come to you and uh you became aware of it through that and what was your approach
to adapting a pre-existing IP into this game yeah so the first question um I was full read up on The Stormlight Archive at the time okay and uh was in the middle of the mistborn series uh when uh when brother wise asked me if I would consider doing the mbor game um or be available for it uh because we had actually previously talked The Stormlight Archive game was earlier on in our conversation uh and they and I had basically come to an agreement on uh creating a Stormlight Archive game um and some point in that conversation they had mentioned that they also wanted to make make a Mis born deck building game and was The Stormlight game a deck building game or or is it something different it's The Stormlight game we're working on is in the vein of like War of the Ring Star Wars rebellion it's a one V one 1 V1 2v2 um dudes minis awesome war game yeah um so we'd been talking about that and they had they had mentioned the concept of making a mbor deck building game but they were going to do it internally they said and I was like well if you ever do want a designer let me know I would love to make I would love to have a swing at that um and then it was like six months later that they messaged me and they I think they they I remember ask they asked um we're not we're John we're not finding time to make this internally and
uh would you would are you still interested in making it would you rather do the misbourne game instead of The Stormlight Archive game uh and I was like actually both would be would be preferable okay okay yeah they're like well we'll get back we'll we'll get back to you on that uh and then then they were like okay fine go ahead take a swing at the Mporn game um so then my Approach for making that game and this would the misbourne game was the second uh or I guess is the second IP based board game that I've made the last Kingdom game based on the Netflix show was the first one um for the Mporn game the uh the the design CH goal was to make a deck building game that was um uh accessible enough that fans of the books who were not Bard Gamers would uh not be um overwhelmed by it right that they would they would be able to get into it and they they could enjoy the game um but not but also that it wouldn't be uh that it would have the depth to attract board gamers who don't necessarily know uh or yet like and enjoy the books um so those were sort of the two main goals right so it had to not be too complicated but it also had to not just be like a it had to not be a slapped on theme um to just sort of
appease book fans with like art and stuff right it had to be a real a real game um with the depth uh with the depth of the uh of of a game strategy that a gamer might enjoy but also um not overwhelming for just book fans uh and whenever I so my Approach for an IP game right I'm I'm beginning the design process not with a hook I'm beginning with a uh with a theme essentially um but I still sort of approach the uh with misor I was still sort of approaching it from the from the thought of like what what makes what hook makes the most sense here um it was Hook's the wrong word right what I wanted was we the other aspect of the design challenge was like the goal of the design is to feel like M born's fighting not not to like you know have a game set in the misbourne universe that is you know about politics or whatever right that was that was um sort of what the prior game uh by Kevin Wilson was about it was called I think it was called um oh Jesus house War I think yeah it was house War yeah and it was a very politics game to be fair I've heard Brandon Sanderson say that like uh Miss born was his attempt at making my fair lady but with superpowers and I thought that was a pretty apt description um so you know like I I think he he does have a a strong affection for that
politicking Palace Intrigue type of stuff but oh yeah that's all over the you know we want the meat of you know B and keler and the Lord ruler and you know like everyone going Toe to Toe so this game was supposed to be yeah Mis borns fighting um so the challenge with that design uh if you if you're familiar with the books is is sort of like how do you there are eight different metals that the Mis borns use to do various magical powers and we could either we could abstract that right and just basically say well the medals will show up in terms of like art and card names right but we'll just make it generic deck board deck building money to buy Cards and attack to do damage or whatever right um or we could be like you know what we are going to have eight different resources you have to manage in this simple accessible game um right uh which is what shocked me because there were eight individual Resources with their own tags in front of every player and you could use them in different ways and my instinct was like wait this was supposed to be like some simple easy deck building game how's this going to work and then as soon as we were like two times around the table I was like how did he manage to make it feel so smooth and simple in spite of having eight unique resources yeah yeah so that was the challenge and um uh the where I where I
finally I actually just let the idea ruminate in my brain for like 2 weeks before I even started working on the on the design um or started prototyping anything and the and the the idea I had that finally sort of clicked into place before I started making the game was to to make all of the resources not like tokens that you take out of a resource pool or like slider tracks for how much of each metal type you have but just simply to have it like it's either on or it's off you either have the resource or you don't have the resource right like it's either that you the metal is either it's on or off and that's it and and then it's like obviously then it's just coins because like if you're familiar with the mbor series like coins are like a big thing in this mbor universe right um it's like oh great okay so it's thematic because there's coins and it solves the eight different Metals problem um yeah and that was and then from there there was other design changes of course along the way but um that hook alone I was like that is uh that's a great hook and if that really fits the misbourne world we can make those medals sort of speak to the different category the different Magics that people can do and while people are playing the game they're using the language and vocabulary of the world like I'm burning this metal but then I'm going to flare this like all of that just puts you right there if you're familiar with the books right um uh and because I thought that was so compelling and so sort of spoton the theme um it didn't my uh my designer ego was somewhat satiated with the need with
with my typical need to uh not make a derivative game um uh and keep as much of the game as possible away from being derivative of like overused mechanisms um and you know the Star Realms Ascension chars of infinity Star Wars deck building game right style of deck builder um is pretty ubiquitous at this point right um and misbourne is derivative of those designs right uh and I and I was okay with that in the end because I thought that metal system was compelling was so compelling and meaningfully different and also very misbourne right that the rest of the game could be like okay we can lean into known mechanisms that totally work we don't need to go off the rails and try other try other stuff um because we've got this core element that in and of itself is kind of being the hook was there always the Dual Victory conditions in the game I mean for those who haven't played the game you can either win by dropping all other players life to zero or you can win by completing some objectives that are kind of a a different tug of war uh and there's incentive to doing either of those and both of them can put pressure on opponents allow for Meaningful decisions risk assessment um keeping that pressure up so that way you know you get people with a guard down uh and the the combat
system to me is very reminiscent of say King of Tokyo which also has a um competing either get to 20 points or kill everyone else if you are the target you're dealing damage to everyone else at the table um but you can also give the target away in certain circumstances uh and anyone who doesn't have the target is only dealing damage to that King of the Hill type of character um so that it it always had Mission and combat as two different sort of primary Victory condition resources but in the original design there was only one way to win I should say that the uh the handoff design the version that I had created and then and then handed off to the development team at brotherwise there was only one way to win it was missions uh and combat was effectively a way to stop opponents from succeeding at their Miss missions and by S by stopping other opponents by like preventing opponents from making Mission progress you gained Mission progress yourself so combat ended up being sort of this interaction on other people's missions to stop them and push them back from succeeding at their missions while they're trying to stop you and it was a it was it was more of a tug-of-war thing uh whereas now the mission tracks and the combat are a bit more separated right obviously the person who's doing well on Mission becomes more of a target for combat damage um and damage is still
still and always was very relevant for dealing with opponent's allies cards in play they don't have a sort of a busted Ally engine um but uh I really actually like that system I thought it was working I thought it was working well uh it fell into the space if we we rewind our conversation back to the way in which I've uh struggled as a designer it fell into that space where for me it was working um like uh I I understood this the depth of it and the strategy and I was enjoying it and um uh brotherwise found that a lot of play testers were finding it unintuitive um uh and this is this is one of those moments where like you know I disagree with them uh and I have to decide like you know do I do I put up my fists and make a fight of it um or do I actually just let them let them try their idea and see if their idea is actually at least as good as mine um and it turns out their idea was at least as good as mine right it was and arguably better right um uh it was certainly simpler it was more intuitive to just say you know what let's make missions its own Victory condition let's let combat be a different Victory condition um and let's make sure that the card balance of the game makes those things um appropriately balanced right um uh so I I let I let them I wasn't I didn't make a fight of it I was like yeah okay you guys see what you can do with it um and you know it's they they're the publisher they get to make decision and in the end I think they did a really good job with it I think it totally
works um it had the it had two potential risks factors with that approach though right one was you have to make a card pool like I said that actually there's there's more risk in the card pool being imbalanced and favoring one or the other right um uh so we so it's it's more important that you get that part of the balancing right um and I think the current dynamic in the game is that new players often win with mission because they're focused on their own thing and they're trying to figure out the game system and then once players become more heads up cuz they're more comfortable with the card system and they start looking at other players then the combat sort of evens out so I've actually seen experienced players win by combat at least as M just about as much as Mission and new players where the whole tables at new tend to win by Mission more so I actually I think that's fine I think that works well um the second problem that crops up when you give a combat Victory condition um is something that many of these games all face which is what I what I sort of call the attack targeting problem of like I have five damage points to deal to whoever I want to right and then sometimes there's just just there's like a meaningful strategic regions to Target one player versus another but a lot of the time it's just like kind of arbitrary right you know I guess I'll I guess I'll Target you jack because you know you have the most life or you have the least life or or maybe it's funny or you attack me on your a little bit
better and you don't want some strangers feelings right exactly um and uh I've never liked that in a game right I have no I have no objection with it with fighting games I like fighting games I don't mind games where like he's winning attack him I what I want is there to be a strategic reason to to do to attack someone as opposed to like you have attack damage you better use it against somebody so pick someone right like that's a I like I Want U the game to give players a better hook for that or just to make that go away if if there is no meaningful strategic hook there right um so in the in the development process um I was I was like okay guys we're we've I I'm happy I like what you've done with the missions and the combat um but I don't like that this problem is now back in the game because it wasn't in the game in my version right um uh and it that's when I sort of suggested uh the uh Richard Garfield sort of solve to it from King of Tokyo I was like you know it works great in King of Tokyo um uh and I'd been I'd been actually uh Richard and I were co-designing a game together um and we' been talk we've been talking about this we've been talking about this problem together um and uh I had been complimenting them on how great how great I thought that uh system was in King of Tokyo for solving that problem um so it was sort of top of mind for me and I was like maybe we can do something that's like similar to that but fits in the context of
mbor um and uh uh and we tried it and we're like oh yeah this this pretty much works we had it's not exactly the same as in King of Tokyo of course right um uh most importantly the person who takes damage can give the target to anyone they want as opposed to only the person who targeted them um uh but it I think it it basically solved the problem right in a way that I that in multiplayer I think really helps obviously it's irrelevant in two players with in a two-player game or in the co-op version of the game but at three and four players it makes misbourne I think it makes misbourne stand out from um uh games in a s in the similar space uh in a way that you know Star Realms is only a two-player game uh so is so is the Star Wars deck building game um and if you added a fourth player or a third player would it would have that problem problem right um like I think shards of infinity is one of my favorite type of games in that genre but but it once you had a third player it's annoying right like um so I was really happy with that solution now do you only design games that you win because you skunked Michael Dunmore from asade day North America and me while playing misbourne you're just like no pity on the new guys at the table you're like let's let's take out some rat here I uh I I'm often good at the games I design I I lost my first game of cubitos at
platypus conon wow I lost what I lost another one of my gam was it space Bas I lost another one of my games there too um I'm I'm just giving you just giving you some crap here uh so on Miss no no if I'm bad at a game it definitely means it needs to be redesigned no yeah well that might even be a good that might be a good is something to that you know like like if your brain works in a specific way that you lock into an idea then it's probably something that you're intrinsically you know like you feel it you see through the Matrix you know you'd be naturally better at yes and no though right like if if I feel like I can play a game that I'm working on really well uh and I if the if the right choice starts becoming obvious to me in my in my games right that's not a good sign right that then now the game's not fun anymore like the game that I design needs to present me with questions that I don't know the right answer to right and I need to try to figure out the answer because if even if I like if I've designed the game and I'm playing it and like well you know I know what the cards are I know what the right choice is here the game's not good anymore right um so so actually you know um I want the game if I'm bad at a game that actually may be a good sign some times um depends on the type of game right and as long as you're not showing Jack Eddie and Michael Dunsmore in Alaska um on on misbourne um how much
were you involved in the actual integration of the story as opposed to the theme and what I mean by that is um like were you involved in how much of the world you could show and at what stage in the world uh for people who aren't familiar with sanderson's work uh there's often some really bombastic rug pulling twists at various points in the stories and even within one book if you showed a character one particular way as opposed to a different way that's revealing you know a major twist so I I got to imagine that at least for Miss born you probably were only allowed to present things from like the early half of the final Empire you know before things really get cooking um and H how much did you have to restrict yourself in that regard yeah the the first book the final Empire in the mbor series was sort of a soft constraint um uh I had a few of the characters that show up in later books in my first prototype um there was I think I had eight different Heroes you could play um and the ones that show up later ended up being being sort of set aside for expansion stuff um uh and we and uh it was and the the content of the first of the Mis born base game was
mostly spoiler-free uh I mean if you want to really dig into like the artwork and stuff you'll be like oh what is that I don't know what that is that's right right but um mostly spoiler-free there's not there's not main characters that show up later in the story or like reveals or anything in there mostly based on the first book um and a lot of that art directing and the naming of the cards um uh has to be credited to the brotherwise team and their work uh Johnny O'Neal one of the two brothers um is I think one of the best art directors in the business um uh you know not to take any credit away from the artists themselves of course uh but Johnny has a way of just like pairing what pairing the graphic design like what he's getting from the graphic designers with the way the Art's coming in with the fonts like it just looks so good right and um he's just got a way of doing that and and he's also a really he's also very knowledgeable about the lore he's a big cosm fan as well so he's he's pairing all of this stuff with like this character this scene from the book should be depicted on this card and this should be the name of the card and it goes the best with this card Effect right so like all of that was the stuff um him and and the people working with him did uh and I it did a great job of it I think Brandon Sanderson is a noted Magic the Gathering player did you get to play this game with him I did we went out to um his place in Salt Lake City uh probably four months into the
process so I had uh I had shown brother wise my version of it to get there sort of sign off on like okay what you've got going is something that we want to move forward with um and then I worked on it for a couple more months I went back and forth with them I think it was probably two months after that maybe three months after that we went out to Salt Lake and got Brandon sign off sign off on it so I actually got I sat down with Brandon I taught him the game him and Chris O'Neal played it together played a two-player game while I taught um and uh then he got a chance to offer his feedback and uh uh he really liked it uh gave the sign off on it so then we uh we went back and then I think I worked on it for a couple more weeks before basically giving a handoff version to the de Dev team at brother who uh did a whole bunch of uh good work from that point on the biggest change they make like like I mentioned up before was to the missions um mission system and you dropped this bomb I and I I realize that you really can't go into it too much but is this Stormlight thing is this a reality is this you know something that is just a possibility at this point or is it actually cooking oh it's cooking it's going yeah there's um uh uh barring unwanted events uh it will come to pass that's amazing as a ginormous kaledin storm bless Stormlight
Archive fan you know like uh my wife and I just both finished uh wind and Truth we are you know like dedicated Uber nerds when it comes to this uh have gone through the series multiple times and that ain't no small series um I'm very excited about uh a Stormlight adaptation uh and especially to have it be like that big sprawling epic type of game like rebellion and War of the Ring it is unlim the the the current design is not constrained to the first book or anything like that which as you know from the book there wouldn't be a lot to to go off of in the first there'd be a lot missing it would be a lot of Despair and just kind of looking over chasms going should I jump um so it's it's the whole five books series it's based on um uh first the the the first Arc Five series that were're the books that are written um is all the characters and stuff that the game will touch on there's a reasonable chance that the final product will be something like books one through four uh with some of the stuff that shows up in Books five and maybe the half latter half of books for uh is like an expansion stuff um it's coming they they made the minis before so we're g so the um the minis that they've made before will will probably many of them will show up in the board game along with some probably some new ones um yeah it's going to be
it's going to be cool yeah now I could talk to you about so many different things and I love having this access to you know kind of like this practical business mind approach to professional game design um but in the interest of maybe just our part one of this conversation concluding because you know it's uh it's after kids bedtime but uh I imagine you got some game design to get to here I do I got I got Mis borne expansion stuff right back on that table that I'm working on oh man you bringing in got go I got I'm working on the solo mode for the expansion Solo Cup and I got to go run some personal play test I'm going to go play play test myself tonight afterwards so I love it I love it um let's end with uh aspirations like where do you want to go from here you've done uh mediumsized games you've done really Innovative systems that feel like they're brand new things that people haven't seen before uh you're now apparently working with Richard Garfield you're working on a big epic sprawling game uh at least one big epic sprawling game are there things in the the game Space that you haven't touched on or at least you haven't published yet that you are really eager to try I have one big b i mean I've got a bunch of ideas that I'm excited to get to eventually um I have one big bucket
list design item that uh I'm waiting for a publisher to um be ready to jump in with me on and that's a card crafting collectible card game um oh yeah okay that that would be that would be complex but I I can see some ideas there I can see some ideas there so I mean there's there's so many there's so many interesting things to like talk about on that we don't have to go into it that much but like um The Challenge right one of the challenges with so first of all the the card the collectible Card Market is super saturated right um and it's it's like resaturated recently um uh and you got to stand out in some way right right okay so so so card crafting is like a gimmick that lets you stand out right but like it's not just a gimmick it's a re like if you do it right it's a it's a real thing that can impact either the game play or in a really interesting way the meta of the game if you allow players not just to build their deck of cards but to actually build the cards in their deck of cards right so like if I've got character you know hero man a right but I can pair him with like equipment that attaches to him in my deck that no one else can do like so my version of that guy is different than yours right and all of that presents a lot of interesting options and also potentially balancing challenges but maybe if it's if the systems were right it doesn't it's not actually that much harder another challenge with it is like how do you produce the cards right we're
we're requiring players to play the game with sleeves well it's a collectible card game everyone plays their game with sleeves anyway right like like you know anyway there's all these interesting challenges and I've I've done some good thinking about it I've got I've already got um I've got a couple drafted up versions of the games it's just wa it's waiting for a publisher to say you know what let's uh let's go for it um and it could be like an lcg Style game or a ccg Style game but anyway that's um that is the big item on my bucket list um uh well I mean Monster cards can make a return and it your lcg ccg collectible card game card crafting game there you go uh I've got a lot of uh a lot of ideas in the in the hopper that I don't have time to work on currently um uh uh so I'll mention I'll mention one of them in game design and then one other creative thing I want to do um so the game design one is uh I want to make a so mazes when I was a kid before I ever started designing games I love drawing mazes they've always been a thing there's always been a thing I've uh enjoyed drawing um and doing um are your kids getting into mazes yet like you're 5-year-old are you you showing him the Maes and yeah just the other day we were coming back from a hike uh and I was like I got to work on I got to work on you know I got to go to work when I get home Jackson today so you know what do you think you'll do when we get home and
he's like I want to draw a maze um and then of course he was like I want to draw a maze with you you Dad I'm like I have to work I I've gotten that from my son quite a bit um uh so the idea is a like full adventure maze book where it's all one maze uh and there's uh and there's like encounters throughout it it's like this whole narrative Adventure through a maze it's a it would be like a solo super gamified almost like it's like a novel meets a giant maze meets a game uh and this this would be an artistic Endeavor for me also because I would probably want to draw The Mazes and write the story and obviously make the rules for it right um this feels like this is this is may be more of a retirement project but you know we'll see you know I I bet there is some intersection there with like um you know like puzzle Tales like what Rita or La is doing with um uh post curious or you know some of the unlock games or maybe some like Grand bass uh novels and stuff there there's got to be some intersection for that kind of cryptoid secret message uh Zone as well as mazes untap potential for sure waiting for the John D Clair signature and then the final creative
thing I want to do which uh if um uh if I get to a point where I have the time to work on it is I've got some I've got multiple novel ideas for novels books um that uh one day I'd like to I used to do a lot of writing when I was young it was one of when I when I graduated college I was like you know in my mind the two things I wanted to do to make money right I mean real job and then like nights and weekends I want to make games I want to write books um and the games thing worked uh and the the book thing never ever got off the ground right and I want to get back to that some point how much do you get to imbue your own theme onto games I mean obviously you're adapting IPS uh with the last Kingdom with you know misbourne uh but if you're if you're pitching an idea do you pitch the Thematic world as well like I don't know is Mystic Veil your your concept to have these Druids and magic people uh you know like forming this world out of the card crafting system um yeah yeah I mean the the themes uh often the theme is something that I had some input on um Mystic veil's theme is very nebula it's you know Druids making making happy nature right um I don't know there's some ferocious
stuff in there that does not seem like happy nature well actually so like the base game of Mystic veil was a bit closer to my vision of it um and then the expansions drifted it away into like more like magic the Gathering but like the green like just the green color yeah um uh so we're working this is no this isn't secret but also it's unannounced um we're making a uh we're not calling it a second edition of mist of veil and it's not I think there's a good reason not to call it a second edition of Mystic Veil but for anyone who's played Mystic Veil you'd be like oh this feels a lot like this is like Mystic Veil but like you know um 2.0 2.0 yeah um clearly a sequel to it so we're making that and I've been much more involved in um sort of trying to craft the uh the art style and the vision of it uh on that one and then another game we're making is a sort of a sister game to um dead reckoning and dead reckoning is example of a game where a lot of the particularly Saga expansions are were actually my a lot of my writing and World building was in those stories and the characters you meet and stuff um and we're making another game where like the world is actually really deep um and I created a whole world document for it um to share and like where the magic comes from and the you know stuff like that um that game is uh called grit and it's this one's cool uh this game has a this game
has a 8 foot roll out map what this is like Battle Masters when I was a kid rolling out the like shower curtain it's like a it's like dead reckoning it's like a yoy engine engine builder card crafting game um where you travel around the world and buy upgrades and do adventures and stuff um and it's this 8ot rollout map and so I was thinking like how do you do a really thematically and artistically cool like centerpiece for a game that's a modular fantasy map right so like a lot of these fantasy Maps like you know uh Rune Wars or whatever right it's like put the hex's out and you're like each hex has pretty art on it but the whole thing is this sort of like compiled hex thing it doesn't look like a real map right uhuh so my idea was like well okay just make a huge map right of the world and then in any given game you play a chunk of it so we made this so so I I actually made the I made the whole artart for it's not the final art but it's it's good enough art for a nice prototype for this 8ot by like whatever two and A2 feet roll out map uh and in any bananas and in any given game you roll like the corners in and you play like uh just like a three-foot section of it and then like a different game you can like roll it this way and play that three-foot section of it so essentially have this modular the game has a modular map experience
because you play a different chunk of this world and they all have very different topography um but the whole map if you roll it it's all one consistent world map right um anyway that that's an example of where I'm doing a lot of World building and stuff for that game well when the novelization comes out I'm sure you'll get first crack at it you know yeah that's right well John it has been an absolute pleasure it was wonderful meeting you at the convention uh and this followup was something that I felt needed to happen and I was so thrilled that you uh agreed to come on and I'm looking forward to having this conversation again with you in the future when you're on the precipice when you're on the tour for The Stormlight Archive game coming out and uh we can you know really dive into the nuts and bolts of that um I've been following your career since uh I first uh uh played uh Mystic Veil and it shows no sign of uh slowing down so thanks for all you do for the community thanks for coming to Alaska and thanks for coming on the show