Scythe Digital Edition comes to Mobile. What's different? Is it worth it? - The Mill
Transcript
hello and welcome to the middle i am your host dusty crane and this week i thought we would talk about those big drops last week into the apple app store and android market respectively that's right i'm talking about scythe digital edition it made its worldwide debut in the app store last week i want to start by doing some side-by-side comparisons because there are some questions that i see come up repeatedly and i figured that was as good a place to start as any the two questions that i've seen most often are does it have the expansion material and do they share a common online lobby the first questions answer unfortunately is no the steam pc version has invaders from afar which enables the seven player games and brings albion and tagawa into the board but the ifa factions are absent from side digital mobile hopefully that'll uh come along here soon the second question though brings terrific news i wasn't terrible it brings terrific news it appears that all copies of the game share the same lobby so i'm gonna go ahead and pop into the lobby here and check on the devices i have in front of me steam ipad and iphone i think that bodes really well for finding a game online even when you're on the go if you don't want your elo score to suffer though don't start any online games on a spotty connection or that you aren't certain you'll have time to finish with that out of the way let's poke into some of the nooks and crannies both versions share some very good common features like a tutorial as you would expect the first this first area though actually demonstrates
something that i found interesting about the mobile version and the steam version and that's with its space constraints i do like some of the decisions they made with the menus in the mobile version the tutorials menu is noticeably prettier on mobile i like these art in the menus it's nothing to base a purchase on certainly but it's a nice touch i also love the inclusion of the paint shop i love being able to change the appearance of my characters mechs and workers both versions allow you to paint some of them none of them are all of them steam just has a couple more factions to work with i'm hopeful that ifa comes soon to mobile and it's not a device concession and by that i mean that as my day digital wasn't thinking if we include these factions then we're going to limit our audience to this so we'll just keep them out moving along to the album we see encounter cards factory cards objectives and mats that are unlocked as you accomplish certain feats in the game if i had one gripe for these cool unlockables though it's that you can't go back and see what actually unlocked them mobile's also missing a mats option but i guess that's kind of understandable given the potential real estate and who knows maybe it'll arrive later so the options have a few differences but map colors identical as is language one option on pc that i'd like to see make its way to mobile is the power popularity of triumph tracks that are on the map it's nice having the familiar tracks visible on the map rules will bring up a game pdf on all versions and login settings is where you'll provide your credential if you already have an asmode digital title and you'll you'll need as with a digital id to play online anyway let's go ahead and
get into the game here you see we have much of the same options just mobilizing broken into two different screens same undo options same options for promo cards and the game will also prevent you and your opponents from getting a banned mac combo if you so choose mobile tops out at five players while the pc version permits seven thanks to the invaders from afar expansion let's go ahead and kick off a two-player game versus crimea and look at some of the differences where they really matter in game all right now look at this here this splash screen again demonstrates an instance where i think i like the mobile screen over the full steam version i think the font and presentation just looks cleaner on mobile it's just a nicer overall appearance
all right let's go ahead and get into the game now the animation is identical and the load time was too the only difference that immediately stood out was the essence of the tracks and the fact that olga is facing a slightly different direction um but again same time same animation so that's cool um let's go and take a look at the both of the uis and by that i mean user interface if you don't speak the that design language um in steam my default view of stars and resources is actually smaller than the mobile version but it can be expanded to show us even more information not just for ourselves but for our opponents and we can also find this in mobile we just can't hang it out on the screen like we can in the steam version in mobile to find this information we have to hit that burger icon in the top left hand corner or long press on the faction icon over the end turn button steam version has the objectives tiles right on the screen too and mobile has it clicked behind the on-screen icon or accessible by the burger icon in fact most of the information you see on screen of the pc version can be found behind that burger icon and it's actually a cleaner experience that i find myself kind of liking maybe even a little bit more the turn details are hidden away and maybe it's just the poor way i play scythe but i don't necessarily feel that i'm missing having it sort of hidden away the way it is the exception to everything being visible from that burger icon menu is our combat card values the only way to access those is the combat card button that's just below that burger button so i guess that was a decision that they made um
now let's go ahead and take a look at the buttons that we're actually using to take our turns the buttons on mobile are obviously far more optimized for a smaller screen but the layout of the button for whatever reason sort of takes me just an extra moment to kind of get what's going on in the case of the mat itself good luck finding out what matt you're using if you happen to forget at least in the full-blown version aside you can find it by clicking on your faction icon i guess i sort of digress there as i mentioned it takes just an extra moment to look at the mobile ui and go oh if i produce one village or more it'll still be free to produce but if i produce two i'll lower power the faded icons are light on the mobile ui and the pc ui keeps the color language of the regular game aside whereas you have a red cost and a green gain which you also see in the full version of side digital i think they could have used a red box inside of the green box already there to kind of continue that design language throughout it's also not very intuitive that the upgrades possible are indicated by a second row indicator in that button the top rows the non-negotiable cost in engineering here an upgrade is always going to cost to oil but it doesn't have to cost three and building a structure is three wood out of the gate but can be brought down to one and you'll get three coins for your effort too there's just a good deal of information being presented in that button that doesn't strike me as the most effective way to go about presenting it but like everything once you're familiar with the design language it becomes second nature and the mystery is gone since this isn't a stonemeyer title itself i'm free to share a review and since asmoday digital didn't provide
me with my copy of side digital you can be sure there's no bias besides the fact that i really do love scythe personally this gives me everything i could possibly want out of a side port the bots actually give me a challenge i haven't played enough to know exactly what they're going to do and if i want to be humble that isn't difficult to find a game online as you may have noticed just by hanging out in the lobby for a moment in some cases they literally come to you i can see a situation where this might fall flat for you though first if you're a player of high skill these bots are not going to challenge you you could probably give them banned faction combos and you'd still sweep the floor and if you're not the type of player to play an online game this is going to be one more reminder of your scythe supremacy and so short of just enjoying the ebb and flow of a game you might as well spend those hard earned dollars elsewhere for me though i just love the decision tree of scythe just going through the motions of a game sort of lets me slip into a zen place and sort of forget about the world around me for a bit and for that alone i'd pay that asking price i'm hopeful that invaders from afar comes to the mobile game soon and i hope that win gambit isn't far behind while i'd love to see the rise of fenris come to side digital i think i'd like to see atoma show up first the higher levels of atoma are also beatable by high-end players but the more variety out of our ai would be a welcome addition of the game and it seems like the modular board would also be an easy addition but maybe the bot ai isn't that adaptable yet in any case a full-blown release of rise of fenris would have me
happily handing over the cost of the application again and while i understand i may be in the minority there it just seems like too big of an addition to expect to pay invaders from afar dollars all in all though i'm super pleased with my purchase and if you're still on the fence i hope the video was enough to help you make your decision if you have any questions feel free to drop them in the comments below and i'll get to them just as soon as i can that's all i have for you this week thank you so much for watching and as always take care of yourselves and each other bye