Underwater cities extra time
Transcript
kia ora koutou and welcome to underwater cities extra time the extra time videos exist because i can't cover everything i want to say about a game in three minutes the three-minute format is really cool but it has its weaknesses and for this video i really want to talk about why underwater cities is a gold medal game for me what sets us apart from a bunch of other games i've played this year and why i seriously think it's going to stay in my collection for a dirty long time simply put underwater cities is one of the best games i've played this year and potentially one of the best games i've ever played now why does it tickle me so much let's dig in find out one of the reasons underwater cities works for me is because it's a bit like games i already enjoy a lot so yeah i consider it an absolutely fantastic game but i also like things like terraforming mars and guy project games that involve engine building and a lot of moving parts and well science fiction themes as well underwater cities in this regard almost feels like a game that's pandering to me in my particular interests i like long games i like games with lots of decisions and i'm a sucker for a sci-fi theme and underwater cities does all that just like gaia project and just like terraforming bars one of the things i love about all those games is you start off with a blank slate a board like this which is full of possibilities and the decisions you make shape what turns up on the board so after all of those decisions you go from having a blank slate like this to a nice fully finished city like this this big underwater complex it's yours and yours alone
and how you got here is a result of a bunch of different decisions that you made and that brings me to one of the deceptively clever things about underwater cities each turn you're really only making one decision and that decision is which one of the three cards in your hand are you going to play now of course you don't always have to get the placement bonus as well as the card bonus but really you absolutely want to and at this time i've got one of each color which gives me a lot of options but you're never ever going to have one of each color and the perfect combination each and every time you go to play a card and that's really the standout thing about underwater cities is matching these cards against the available actions if you've got the absolute perfect combination of things you want to do it works out perfectly for you but that's never the case there's always going to be spaces blocked up that you can't use you're also going to have cards in your hand that you really want to play but you don't want to take the matching color action at that time this is a game that's absolutely ruinous for people who are stuck on one path and absolutely have to take the action they want to take and the trick there really is that you only have 30 actions per game so if you are matching the right action card to the right location you're essentially getting double actions now they might not be the double actions you want but you have to be able to pivot change and adapt and take maybe the third best option or the fourth best option in order to come back and get your number one option in the later round and that i think is the fundamental core of why underwater
cities is a great game in some ways a game is easy if you can always take the action you want to take there are a lot of games that force you to make non-optimal decisions and get the best outcomes out of them and it's not just worker placement games there's games like war of the ring where you have a set of action dice and you have to make the best use of the action dice you've rolled for that round some people derive this as luck saying things like i would have won if i've got the right cards i just didn't have the right things to match up the fact is you have to adapt to what's in your hand and good players will adapt poor players will blame the luck of the draw and this happens in pretty much any game where there's not an abstract people blame luck well in underwater cities you might construe what you get in your hand as luck but the game is about maximizing what you've got it's not about drawing the perfect hand absolutely every time for what you need immediately it's being able to see six turns ahead and go okay that might be the best action for now but this action actually helps me out later in the game a lot more so finally why is underwater city so compelling to me and i think it's the stuff i've just described the fact that you cannot take the action you want to take each and every time you play that you have to make the best of a bad situation continuously they have to make plays that will pay off in six eight nine rounds time that you have to suck it up and do a bad move because you know it will allow you to do a good move later it's that pressure that comes with the game to make good decisions in bad circumstances or to make the least bad decision at that time and few games actually put that kind of pressure on
you in some ways this is better than terraforming mars in that regard in terraforming mars you can build a sprawling tableau of dozens of different cars with chaining effects and you can have your own sort of mini-game going on that's totally distinct from what anyone else is doing underwater cities never gives you that freedom it's always limited in the number of actions and that pressure that constant pressure throughout the game to do as well as you can with those limited actions is what sets underwater cities apart from most games so there's a whole bunch of other things i could have talked about such as the different building types you can get and the different resources and how they all interconnect or the different types of cards and whether it's worth getting action cards or permanent cards or scoring cards but i honestly don't know enough about the game yet after six plays to really tell you exactly what's the best out of all of that there is so much to dig into inside underwater cities i think i have a rough idea of how to generally play a good game but i'm really far away from coming close to solving this as a game and that for me is really reassuring there are an awful lot of games where i play two or three times i'm like yep i know how to get a really optimal score every single time with this game like that underwater cities i'm still really discovering and frankly that's really refreshing for me and if you enjoyed this video subscribe to the channel hit the notification button and come support us on patreon
you