Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest Review
Transcript
hi everyone tally and farrell here from board of it and we also have mr sven here with us today and we're going to be reviewing libitalia winds of gail crest which was kindly provided to us to review by the publisher stonemeyer games winds of galcrest is an updated version of the much beloved but sadly out of print libertalia which was first released in 2012. now we never played libertalia so we went into this with completely fresh eyes yep so in short libtonia wins the gale crest is a pirate game for 1-6 players where each day you're going to send one of your crew members to an island to gather treasure but the twist is is that every crew member in your deck is unique they have a special ability and they have a specific number and the way that these interact with the loot and other players means that by the time it's your turn to take the treasure anything could have happened first thing you're going to do is decide which side of the board to use because depending which side of the board you use will change what the loot tokens do when you gain them next you're going to set out a number of loop tokens equal to the number of players on each of the first four days on the voyage track lastly one player will shuffle their
deck and draw six cards they'll then tell all the other players what cards they've drawn and all the other players will find these cards in their deck so everyone starts with the same randomized six cards each day the players will secretly pick a crew member to send to the island and all the players will reveal at the same time your decision will likely be based on what treasure is available what rank of characters you have in your hand and your character's abilities this is because once the characters are on the island they get ranked from lowest to highest with reputation breaking ties then from lowest to highest the characters daytime abilities are activated if they have any and then once we get to the end of the line the player that has the highest rank then gets to choose their treasure first and then so on back down the line and at the point of picking treasure any dusk abilities are also activated any surviving crew members are then sent back to the ship and then night time abilities will also be triggered the stem repeats four times at which point any anchor abilities will then activate then each player records how much treasure they have in their treasure chest then everything repeats again from the point of drawing six new characters except each voyage lasts one day longer than the previous one and there are three voyages in total the winner unsurprisingly is the player that has the most treasure allied doubloons in their treasure chest at the end of the three voyages jumping straight in a few of the things that we really enjoyed about livitalia
are the amount of interactiveness and the mayhem the game provides while still having a low rules overhead this is the kind of game where one turn you're going to be groaning because somebody savoured you and now you don't get to take any loot and the next turn you're going to be laughing righteously because you did something clever and you stole loot out from under the nose of someone else who was sure they had it it's pure chaotic fun and pure chaotic fun that you can set up teach and be playing in under 10 minutes which i think is pretty admirable and a lot of the fun actually comes from the fact that it's almost impossible to predict the cascade of interactions between the character actions the card numbers and the loot tokens that are available so almost every turn you're treated to a dramatic reveal and a surprising twist on what you thought would happen libitalia also has a great arc because as the game goes on it gets more asymmetric and therefore more zany we really love the design where you keep the cards that you didn't play in your hand between voyages so it means that the players start off with exactly the same hand on day one voyage one but then end up with something unique by voyage 3. it's also super interesting to see how different players will work with the same cards that everyone has been given do you go for the super obvious choice of when to play a specific card or do you hold that card back for a later round and surprise your other players with a
sharp tactical move because they've played that card long ago and they've forgotten all about it and this is a bit of a theme running through the game in that you'll be playing mind games with the other players all of the time that player is likely gonna play that card so i should play this card or no i can't play this card now because they still have it in their hand and if they play it two it's gonna cancel mine out it's where the game design of libertalia really shines because the simple rule of highest ranked character gets to pick their treasure first will almost certainly be turned on its head by the interesting actions available for the lower ranked characters so you never really know where you stand or what you're going to get however this aspect might grate on some because often you can feel like you have very little control over your situation because of how chaotic the game is and sometimes you might just wonder if playing a random card you might just be just as well off libitalia is a good game but it's not a perfect game because of the randomness of the cards and how they interact with each other or the loot tokens on the board there's a tendency to occasionally have dud or by the numbers turns what we mean by this is either it can be exceedingly obvious which cards to play when or which card to play first or you'll have a handful of cards that just don't really do much at that current moment they don't really help with what loot tokens are available or the game state
so you have a few turns where kind of nothing happens which is obviously not very fun in the game as zany as this however this is a quick moving game so although you do have these moments occasionally they don't last forever they move along quite quickly sometimes the game change will the game stay will change and allow you to start playing them and worse comes to worse you'll soon be drawing six new characters to mess around with speaking of player count we're really happy to report that it works really well at all player counts it's actually really surprising how engaging it is at two players considering what type of game it is it turns a zany almost party-esque style game into something that's actually quite a tight tense tactical head-to-head battle that said our sweet spot is four this is because it captures the essence of what libertaria is without overstaying is welcome whereas we did find at five and six it tended to drag just a little bit however if you have a group that's super familiar with the game this will of course fade away so what are the differences between the two versions essentially if you own the original there's really not much need to grab this updated version it adds a new reputation track to break ties and 10 new crew members but aside from that it's basically just the same game with a new lick of paint and a few tweaks think of it as a remastering rather than a sequel as the loot tokens and 30 original crew members are mostly here
and pretty much do the exact same things it's worth noting that the art in this version though has been a bit divisive so the original had was very pirate themed uh so much so that it really looked like a board game adaption of the pirates of the caribbean right whereas they've gone in a completely different direction here it's very colorful and fantasy style and all of the crew members are anthropomorphic animals for the most part but what you can't fault is the quality of the components you know there's excellent card quality excellent storage solution and the bakelite s tiles loot tokens they're a real joy to touch and fight over so final thoughts if you're in the market for a light-hearted silly board game it also provides plenty of engagement and laughter and you could do worse than libertalia wins of galcrest it's never going to be our favorite game of all time but it's certainly going to be one that we pull out when we play with family or perhaps friends who answer into board games and definitely on those beer and pretzels type of nights and i feel like happy to admit that it's really grown to me the more we've played i wasn't really convinced maybe the first time or two we played but we've had some really silly games of this and it's just growing on me to kind of maybe fill that space of a warm-up game or a kind of late night closing down game what i will say is that if you have the original
libitalia you probably don't need to get this unless you're some sort of completionist so that was our review of the battalion winds of gail crest we hope it was helpful uh feel free to ask us any questions and it would mean a lot if you could subscribe and us and the dogs will see you next time say goodbye thanks stenson