Let's Talk about Vantage - A Discussion with Jamey Stegmaier
Transcript
Hey everybody, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well. And if you're not, I hope you are soon. And hey, today I'm super excited to talk with Jamie Stagmire from Stonemire Games. Uh Jamie, how's it going?
It's going great. I I am really excited, especially I've watched your channel for so long. I'm excited to just talk to you face to face for a little while about about games. So, thanks for this chance to to chat with you.
Yeah, this is super cool. Um I I read a lot of the things you write, you know, your kind of blogs and stuff about the gaming industry and all of that. So, um I have a history of of kind of knowing about uh your games. And in my video for my review for Vantage, and Vantage is the game we're going to talk about today, I did kind of frame that in me not typically being a huge fan of the kinds of games you make. You know, I say it's not that the games are bad, they're just not usually my style. And so I was really surprised because I had, you know, your the advantage was completely off of my radar. And so I was really surprised when you contacted me and that you were designing an adventure game, which an adventure game is the kind of game that I like. So why why an adventure game? What what's your history with adventure games? Have you you've always wanted to make one? Um why why yeah just why an adventure game?
Well, yeah, there's I guess a couple different ways that we could look at that. One is that I even though my company and me as a designer, we mostly publish like mediumweight Euro games. Yep.
Managing resources and economies and things like that. I I've been doing this for about 12 years now and I I like new challenges. Like I don't want to design the same game over and over again. I don't want to design the same type of game over and over again. So when uh Zelda Breath of the Wild came out around seven, eight years ago, um not, you know, not a tabletop game, but it it started to really inspire me to do something a little bit different with a game uh with exploring this adventure format. So that was the inspiration and just I I like the idea of trying things that I haven't tried before and adventure was a was a genre that I hadn't explored very much of.
That's interesting because there's something on my channel I talk about a lot especially in the the kind of the history of tabletop adventure games. How um there's this kind of back and forth relationship between tabletop tabletop games and video games.
Yeah. And you know, throughout the years, one seems to influence the other a little bit more and it kind of switches. So I I think we're seeing a lot of younger designers who are coming into this space who are influenced by video games whereas before it was a kind of video games influencing RPGs and then RPG. So yeah, that's really interesting. So, so Breath of the Wild kind of sparked this this curiosity in you or this desire in you to kind of translate that kind of world into a tabletop setting.
Yeah, there were two things in particular about it. One was I guess one thing that is almost inherent to a lot of video games, which is the first person perspective, which wasn't new to Zelda Breath of the Wild, but it is a big part of it, like using that using your field of vision to decide what's important to you and what you want to go check out or look at,
right? Seeing something in the horizon. I want to go to that temple, so I'm gonna head in that direction.
Exactly. Yeah, that was a big part of it. And the other part was just the freedom of movement that if you saw that temple in the distance, you could go there or you could get distracted along the way or you could turn around and go a completely different direction.
Um, I was I I I really like that sense of freedom. And even going deeper in that sense of freedom, as you know from Play Advantage, now you could spend a whole game on just a few locations and just not necessarily do a lot of things on those locations because they're generally limited to only one action per location. Yeah.
But you could go they're like little rabbit holes that you can go down. There actions on your character. There are actions on the cards that you acquire.
And so you could
similar to Zelda Breath of the Wild, you could spend you could spend a whole session of that just like cutting down trees and maybe building a house if you wanted to. and that could be your your hour of of the evening playing that game. I wanted to kind of capture that advantage as well.
Oh yeah, I feel that completely. Um I often say I have something like over a thousand hours in Skyrim, but I've never I've never beaten the game.
Yeah.
You know, because I just get I just that's that's not even really what I'm concerned with in a game like that.
I just want to explore a world
right now. How do you um So you have so much experience with tabletop adventure games. Um, one of the things that I found tough to capture is in a video game like Skyrim, you can sit down for uh an maybe an hour, however long you normally play video games, let's say an hour, and you can decide maybe what's important to you for that hour and you can accomplish it. And that's that's the whole experience for that hour. But that isn't like you said, that isn't winning the game,
right?
That is your own intrinsic motivation for that hour. Have you found games that capture that? because that was really I think difficult for me to capture that advantage which is a single session game. It is not a campaign game.
Yeah. Have you found games that do that well?
I think that's why I do actually prefer non-c campaign style games. Yeah. is because they are single session
and I often find that games like that and I'm looking at uh earlier games you know kind of more I think you would say you know almost vintage tabletop
adventure games things like Runebound or Talisman or Arkham Horror
you can kind of do that in a way you know I often don't play games to win because I'm not very good at games and that might be why I don't typically like the the typically the kind of games that that that you create cuz I'm not good at them, right? So, it's a little frustrating and my friends are really good at them so they'll always just completely trounce me.
The one time I played Scythe, I got I got trounced by every other person at the table. I was and I was like still stuck with my mech
and I couldn't cross I couldn't cross the river, you know? I was just I was like, "Oh man, okay, I'm not doing very good at this game."
So, creating my own kinds of goals is something that I really like. And that's one of the reasons why I like house ruling uh games so much. And it's also one of the reasons why I've
gravitated um closer maybe to that kind of free form sandbox solo RPG style play.
Yeah. and Vantage kind of scratches that itch a little bit. And I know that you have encouraged I I just recently saw a thread on BGG where people were talking about the win condition and you kind of jumped in and were explaining a little bit about your desire to have people create their own endgame goals, their own kind of things to trigger the endgame. And um maybe talk a little bit about that cuz I'm curious about was that part of the design process from the beginning was to have that kind of freedom.
The freedom the element of freedom was definitely there from the beginning. I wasn't always sure how to apply it to the game.
Um in my opinion there's there's a delicate balance in a game like this uh and especially for Vantage between uh the type of player who wants an extrinsic motivation. They want the game to tell them go do this uh go do this big picture thing or do the go do this short-term thing advantage that would be either like accomplishing the group's mission versus maybe if you find a quest along the way going trying to pursue that little quest or side quest um versus people who want the freedom to uh have intrinsic motivation. So oftent times when I play Vantage, I'm I'm a more intrinsically motivated player and when I play if like the first few cards that I get are are animals, then I might just be excited about uh making those they usually when you get an animal advantage, they're a wild animal and you can make them you can uh work with them a little bit and make them a loyal animal. I like that. I I like just saying, "Okay, this is important to me now because I have these animals."
That's a random example, but I wanted to in in the in in the spirit of freedom, I wanted to cater to both of those types of players. And that carries over to like a a passage in the rule book that says that a victory in Vantage can be you deciding that something is important to you and you accomplishing that thing while you play Vantage, which I think is a little maybe that's very odd for any of the games that I've made in the past and probably somewhat odd for tabletop games in general.
Yeah, I think so. So, uh, there's a there's an older, uh, game, not too old, maybe 10 10 years old, called Myth, and it's kind of a tabletop skirmish game, but it was very much made like that, and they had a very hard time conveying that to the players. Players went into that game thinking that this was a typical kind of tabletop adventure game where you had a goal, but the goal was really up to the players, and a lot of tabletop players really struggled with that in mind. and had a hard time think what what am I doing like what like where what's my direction? Well, it's completely up to you. If you want to go and just fight some monsters or go and uh disable some traps, uh you can kind of do what you want to do. Um have you ever played Vantage in a play test environment where you have just played without even drawing a main quest where you're just a complete sandbox kind of experience?
I I have I during setup I've always gained the mission card, but there I would say in almost most games of advantage that I play I almost completely forget that card is there. I
I I like that it's there in case I'm ever really looking for guidance in the game. But almost right away on that when I crash land in a game of advantage, we uh I at least me I I am I am focused on other things. Um, I'm focused on like what I want to do in that moment. That was a big part of Vantage. I I wanted a player to feel like that they could choose what was important to them and that they actually had those options in play because in a lot of games like this, I feel like they're geared around combat. And I know there are a lot of players who play for the combat. Totally understand that.
But I I genuinely wanted like a number of other viable options that you could choose other than
looking at someone who looks different than you and immediately trying to kill them.
Yeah.
Um, Yeah. Yeah. I I'm I don't like combat in most games, which is kind of weird because like 90% of the games I own are all about beating stuff over the head, right? So, combat is almost almost never a thing that I I am excited about in a game. It's kind of something I put up with to have the adventure. And uh that's one of the things that really struck me about Vantage is the variety of things that you can do.
Yeah.
That aren't just direct conflict.
You know, you have different things, different mysteries you can discover. You have the whole flora and fauna system,
which was really interesting. I'm very curious about how you came up with all of that like the the the bestiary the the all of the all of the the the the flora you know there seems to be kind of a thriving kind of ecosystem and different uh biospheres and stuff in advantage. What what was the process of just kind of conceptualizing that that world like? Yeah, this was probably my favorite part about creating Vantage because I was working with three different artists. Um, uh, Valentina, Saurin, and Amelon.
Um,
and they I I brought them in starting with Valentina and then adding the other two. Uh, so I guess normally when I have a project like when I made Worms, I found an artist for Worms. I said, "I need 180 dragons. Can you illustrate them?" The artist said, "Yes." So they they illustrated those dragons. Um, and even they have a lot of freedom. I'm not telling them like I need this blue dragon with like big fangs. Like they're they're they have a lot of creativity, a creative space to explore. But with Vantage, there was even more than that because I was like here's a world. I had this rough idea for this world.
Um, create some locations that look cool for it. That's how we started out. Just create some stuff that looks cool and mysterious. And then once uh art the artist started to uh conceptualize these different locations that looked cool, then we started kind of iterating off the things that seemed really fun and mysterious or interesting. So we kind of populated this world one location at a time and then we'd come upon a a concept like you mentioned the the the fauna or the flora and we'd get kind of together we get excited about that idea and then populate the whole world with that type of thing. So there was kind of layer upon layer until we had this full planet created uh over I don't know the illustration process took around six of the eight years to to work on together with this artist. Yeah.
Wow.
Yeah. Because you've been working on this game for for eight years. That's has it just been kind of on like a back burner status just kind of bubbling away
kind of. Yeah. like it for the last eight well this year has been different because it's been in production but for the for the seven plus years seven to eight years that I worked on it pretty much like any free time that I had where I wasn't running still games or working on another game I was I was working on Vantage making trying to make some incremental progress uh as you've seen it's a pretty big world and so for me to make an addition to it or make a change could sometimes take weeks or months to add it across the entire to like populate the entire world with with that addition.
Yeah,
we talked Yeah.
No, go ahead.
I was going to mention like on every location there are six different types of actions that you can choose, but originally there were only like two or three. And for me that ended up even though I knew there were six different types of actions, the six different skills. And so eventually I was I I just realized I wanted all six to be on pretty much every location.
Every card. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah,
that was a massive change that took probably about a year to go from two to three all the way up to six per location.
Yeah, there's a lot of interconnected pieces in games like this where yeah,
you're looking at cards and then you're kind of uh looking up corresponding entries and and a story book. And a lot of times I find games like that, they kind of they, you know, if you have just one or two typos or things can be wrong, it can really derail a game.
I haven't found anything like that in Vantage yet. Uh I haven't checked the FAQ, so I don't know if people have, but um
yeah, so when you make a change, you have to make a change in the book, you have to make a change to a card. Um, what kind of process did you use to just keep all of that in in in check? I mean, what I I'm really curious about how all of that came to be, like just like the the the the inner workings of of keeping everything. Did you have a bunch of post-it notes or or huge spreadsheets or something?
A little bit of both. A little bit of everything. Yeah, I have many many I do my best brainstorming with paper and pencil. So I had many post-it notes and paper pencil brainstorming. Um but eventually all that ended up going into in design where I had
uh essentially like the location spread out on a big world map but the files it was actually ended up being like six of those files because the files were so big with these huge they were so huge. Yeah. And on each of the locations um at first so I had like this world map of locations and on each location I had overlaid on top of it I had the text for that location because I found it pretty helpful to like I wanted even though the the actions that you're taking on the location are unique to that location sometimes they are related to adjacent locations too especially the look action might take the look action you might notice something
you look to the north or east or south and you have to keep in mind it's uh Like I used to back in the early 80s I got into basic programming and that's like kind of like where I stopped computer programming because I I hated it so much. But um writing little text adventure games in basic like Zor and you had to keep this uh matrix of locations and how they were related to each other so that the computer would know, okay, I'm moving north. Well, what's now to the south?
Right. Right. Yeah. You have to I think I think it it helped me to visualize that had that visual and the text combined in one. But it also meant that eventually I had to take all that text and copy and paste it and sometimes rewrite it over to a big Google sheet, a big spreadsheet.
Yeah.
Um and I'm glad I did in that order though because if it had been on the spreadsheet from the beginning, I think I would have missed a lot of a lot more of those little interconnected elements between the locations. But eventually I did have to go on this spreadsheet that was shared with some of the play testers and editors and developers and uh that was when we were kind of continually making little changes to the spreadsheet to or the text on the spreadsheet to improve it to make it clear to catch mistakes. Yeah.
Now do you have a full kind of map image of all of the cards in their corresponding locations of that world?
I do. I do. Yeah. It's Yeah, it's a pretty cool image. Um, I don't know how deep I can zoom in on it, but I can zoom in fairly deep onto it. And I used a lot like I had this world I have I have a world grid that I use for a lot of different things largely to make sure that when we had something like the fauna, the fauna of the world that that it wasn't all clumped together in one place. Like it might be in a jungle, there might be a little bit more than other places, but I wanted to be spread out around the world so that if you're on one side of the world and you discover a unique fauna that you can talk to me about it and I can I can maybe find something like that or some other fauna in the area that I am. So trying to make sure that things are spaced out. I use this this grid for that.
Do I don't know. Does the world wrap around? Is it actually a globe? Oh, it is. Okay, cool.
Yeah, you can walk completely. You could spend your entire game probably just walking completely around the planet. I don't know if you'd quite get there.
Yeah,
but you could get back to exactly where you started.
Oh, that's awesome. Yeah, I did. I I was wondering about that. Um I know some people uh I think at least a couple comments on the uh YouTube video that I did, they mentioned that it reminds them of uh No Man's Sky. Have you spent any time with uh with No Man's Sky at all?
I it uh I haven't played it, but I am aware of it. I've watched some videos about it. it. I ended up not thinking about it too much because I think it's um it my understanding is that it's uh what's the word? Procedurally generated.
Procedural. Yes. It's all procedural. Yeah.
Yeah. Whereas Vantage is I guess it it isn't. You know, everything's in a specific place. But yeah, I can see the comparison that you can't you have these complete planets that are fully alive and living. Yeah. Have you played it much?
Yeah, I played a little bit. It's one of those games that I I like the idea of a lot more than I actually enjoy playing the game
because there's a lot of survival um mechanisms and I'm not typically into survival mechanisms and I was pleasantly surprised to find that Vantage doesn't really focus on that kind of thing. Um, I know that you do mention that like Seventh Continent and Seventh Citadel were kind of touchston that you were thinking of
and um,
Seventh Continent, the first one I bounced off of because of those
survival mechanisms,
whereas Seventh Citadel kind of put those off to the side. You can still have some of those, but they're not nearly as important
and it's more focused on that journey. Did you ever think about having, you know, you you on Vantage you you crash and you have to first repair your suit or find food or how come or if you didn't, how come you decided to like not do any kind of survival mechanisms?
Yeah, that's a good question. Um, and I think the one video game that I thought about a little bit with that is Subnotica. Yeah. which starts out, you know, feeling a little bit like a survival game, but pretty quickly it's more about exploration than survival. Um, at least my experience was with it was. But I for me, I I had a very similar experience with Seventh Continent where I uh I enjoyed a lot of it. I enjoyed the openness of it. I enjoyed that the game asked me to use my eyes to look at the the Artem locations to find different things and make decisions,
but I the grind of the survival wasn't fun for me. Like I that I bounced off it bounced off that aspect of the game, too. And we played a cooperative well, it is cooperative game, so we ended up probably cheating a little bit just to avoid that type of thing. Well, there's a there's like a rule in the game where you can save your game to reset the hunting zones, but it always just felt like it was punishing me as the player because all it meant was I was having to spend time
putting stuff away.
Right. Right. Exactly. Yeah.
It's like, well, why do you have this this this mechanism that's just punishing me in my physical space,
right,
with like taking away my time of actually playing the game,
right? I for that reason others I I wanted to avoid that type of uh what I perceived as a negative friction to the game. There are great survival games including that one and games like Robinson Cruso where people go into it wanting to have a tough survival experience. I was not looking to give players that for Vantage and so like thematically each each character has an augmented suit, a body suit that is helping to keep them alive and they also have implants that help them talk to other players and things like that. So they're these are far future humans that are able to survive for at least a limited amount of time on a planet without having to worry too much about finding food or water, things like that.
Yeah, you just mentioned something an interesting term, negative friction,
and I think that's a really interesting way to look at game design is I often talk about there's those things I call them roadblocks, but I think negative negative friction is a is a really good term there. And often times I will find that design has a negative friction or it has that roadblock
and the designer instead of coming up with rules to circumvent that you know they or they they do that instead of going back and just removing that negative friction which would cause a new rule. Right?
So Vantage is a pretty simple game at its core. I mean, it's a very simple game. You can practically learn it while you're setting up the game. I mean, it's it flows really, really easily. So, were there other kinds of negative frictions, other things that you saw that maybe uh you didn't like in adventure games or these style of games that you Okay, so how do we circumvent those? How do we not introduce those things so we don't have to come up with a rule
to make it a game? the well the number one thing there are lots of little things like like that and some some big ones but the number one big one was that uh when I first sat down to really play Vantage and because I've been I I spent so much time working on building this world populating it with different actions
but I kind of saved the actual action system until I had enough populated that I could actually play the game um and the first time I played the game the action system that I had in place was a system where you could fail fail an action. They were skill tests instead of actions essentially. And almost immediately I was like, wait, this is not working. Like I just decided that it was important to me to try to pickpocket this this creature who's walking by me and I failed at it. And now what did I just do on my turn? Like I I just didn't I didn't do anything because I tried to do something and I failed.
Yep.
And so right away I realized I need to I need to make this a little bit more like the game one deck dungeon. When you take an action, you succeed, but depending on how difficult that action was and how good I was at it, I might lose some time, health, or morale as a result of it. So, switching that in reverse and just having this a kind of constant fail or succeed forward instead of not having progress or having negative progress, that ended up being something I realized rather quickly and I'm glad I did because I could have wasted a lot of design time on that if I hadn't realized it.
Yeah. I think that also kind of simplifies things because if you just completely reject the idea of of failing a skill test in a narrative game, then you as the writer, as the designer, you don't even have to worry about writing what happens when a character fails. So, I mean, that could like double the amount of of text in the game because you have to not only come up with the
the the text for this succeeding on an action, but you also have to come up with, well, what happens when you fail,
right? Yeah. You're and there's enough text in the game already. Even though the passages are short, it's it's a lot of text. So, uh yeah, that's that's a great logistical reason why I didn't want to do that either.
Yeah. Yeah. As far as the text goes, um, you know, I typically one of the things that that I like or dislike about modern adventure games. I think there's kind of that distinction between modern. When I when I talk about Vantage, it's very much in that modern school. There's some games that you mentioned like Lands of Galier and even some of the Jerry Hawthorne's new and Sleeping Gods and some of the new Pla Hat, you know, they're great. Freelancer and Wandering Galaxies. You know, I put this in in in that school, but um there's this trend that I'm sure you're aware of, especially in campaign games, to have these giant story books that are
500 plus pages long.
I'm sure you've seen Madara. Madar is always the example I use of what I would say not to do because
you you you spend
many many minutes at the table just reading
and you're reading about what your characters are doing and you're not actually doing the stuff
and I've never really felt that advantage because the
it's the the the narrative is told with brevity like every every entry is
is short. I think like the longest entry is maybe a short paragraph.
Yeah.
But that must have been pretty challenging to keep the narrative in check.
That was Well, it I guess it was in a way a little bit of a challenge, but it was a priority for me not not to have those long paragraphs of text. I appreciate that some of those games exist for when I'm in the mood for that. Like I love Have you played Legacy of Dragon Halt by any chance?
Yes. No, I I really like Legacy of Dragon Hole, but
yeah,
I kind of I I think I approach that
from a different angle where I look at Legacy of Dragon Hole more as a game book.
Yes. Yeah.
And I Legacy of Dragon Halt, man. I God, I wish Fantasy Flight would have would have taken that system and actually done something with it.
Yeah.
Because what a great I mean, it's like maybe one of the best game books I've I've ever I've ever played. It's fantastic. It is really good and it's one that I even recommend to people when they go on like a road trip because you you don't need a surface or a board. You can you just have someone reading from it out loud and everyone else is saying let's do this or let's do this. Really clever game. Um and Sleeping Gods also long passages of text, but what uh I think Ryan did something really clever in the sequel to it. I don't know if it's in the first one where he gave you the option to just read a little bit of text um for instead of the long passage. And I really like that because sometimes I'm in the mood to read that long text. sometimes I just wanted to read the short text. So that was definitely a big part of Vantage and I had until you just said it that way. I hadn't really thought about or I hadn't said it out loud, but a huge part of the reason that I did it is that I didn't want the story book to tell the players what they were doing. I wanted the players to do what they were doing. Um and that is that oftentimes exactly what you said like I'll be reading those story books and see feeling suddenly like like I'm detached from my own story because it's telling me what I'm doing instead of me actually just doing it. I like that. I'm really glad you said that. I need to bring that up more often. Okay.
Yeah. I mean, I I don't watch cutscenes in video games. Like, I I just it it it takes me out of the game. And I often find that in video games when there's a cutscene, my character in the cutscene is way cooler than my character in the game. Like, they're doing things. They're like stabbing buildings with swords and scaling the building and jumping in the air and landing on a mech and like why can't I do that in the game? Why is that uh why is that part of a why am I just watching it? And I do feel like that in in in a lot of modern narrative games where there's a there's a there's a disconnect between my character in the story that I'm reading and my character on the table, what I'm actually doing. Right.
Right. Right.
And a game for me should be me in charge of like what I'm doing. With that in mind, I'm curious about this about your experience with Vantage and other games like it. Um, I wanted the characters in Vantage to be different from one another. I didn't want them to feel like you're doing like they're exact exactly the same person. Um, and so they kind of have subtle differences on the surface.
Yeah.
Where each one is has a specialty with one type of skill. So, I wanted them to be different, but I didn't want them to be so different that uh that players felt like they had to only do what that character specialized in. You know, there's I feel like there's a balance there. Did you feel like it struck that balance? Well, did you wish they were more asymmetric? And do you have any other games like that where where like what balance do you like between those two elements in games? I like I like my characters in a game like this that presents me with pre-generated characters.
Yeah.
To feel more like blank slates.
Okay.
Where I can project myself into them
and take them down a path that I want.
So I felt like that advantage. However, I also with, you know, each character I think has I I haven't explored. I mean, there's so there's so much to this game that I still haven't fully explored. Like, I don't know how extensive the skill system is. So, for those of you who haven't played it, yeah, the characters each can take an action where they can master one of their starting skills. And that was a huge surprise to me cuz I didn't think you were going to put anything like that in this game. Like, oh wow, there's like a whole whole skill system that you can level up your skills and stuff. So, I don't know. Do those skills branch off? Um, are there are there other skills that each character can learn? And also, each character can also kind of equip their their custom weapon or their custom piece of gear,
and that also kind of differentiates the characters from each other.
Um, again, I don't know. I haven't really discovered any other pieces of gear that were specifically kind of made with one character in mind over another. Um, do we have the maybe go into a little bit more detail about the gear system and the skill system and how that might
touch upon characters?
This is actually Yeah, this is my solution to this thing. Going back to that idea of freedom, giving players the freedom to stick with a more generic character or if they discover it, they can go deeper and have more specialized characters. Um, and we are we're talking about some mild spoilers here. If anyone wants to
Okay,
just be aware of that. Um, I'm curious if you just if you found it, but uh you're right that one of the ways you can do it is that each character has a unique gear that they can equip. Each character also has a buy action on their character uh where they can they can buy things that are not necessarily geared towards that character, but the stuff that I can buy on on the red character are different things.
Wow. I don't think I don't think I realize that. That's awesome.
Those are all different. And then the deepest way I think that you can differenti differentiate the characters is by uh you mentioned the uh if you take the master action and you get the experience card and then you complete the experience card.
I think that leads you right away to your survival character. There might be some other thing.
That's right. Yeah. The character can can become kind of a just a little different version, a little more kind of custom version of that same character.
Exactly. Yeah. And there's also another version of your character that you can get. Have you seen that one?
No. Okay.
And there's there's so much in this game, man. I just like,
you know, I I've played five times now and I I I I don't even think I have I feel like I haven't even scratched the surface on what this game has to offer. And I often talk about a thing in adventure games where I like the the illusion of discovery. And I call it an illusion because you're dealing with a finite number of cards. a finite set of materials in a tabletop game, right? So, of course, that discovery is an infinite, but
some games are better than others at creating that illusion of anything anything can happen and that type of variety. And like I I really felt that from Vantage because
yeah, like I said, there are I tell people, man, there's just so much that I don't even know about. So, I'm super excited to to uh get more into it. But um so with that variety, with all of the things that uh this game has to offer, I know that you said, you know, there's not going to be an expansion like this is this is a oneandone. That's another thing I like. So many games these days I feel are just kind of bloated
and especially on crowdfunding. You pay $500 and you get 30 boxes and it's like what the heck am I going to do with this stuff? So, is
yeah,
I know there's not going to be an expansion, but is that is the world of Vantage is that something that you want to return to in a different kind of uh style or different type of of game? Is it a is it a is it a closed world now? What's your what's your feelings on that?
Yeah, I I I approached it with the closed world mindset.
Okay, cool. I I think if I wanted it to be like these many games that have, you know, the game and then 10 different expansions, then I would have just picked like a few slices of the world and published them as the game and essentially given the world borders in that way and added added other biomes as we went. But instead, I just I really just wanted a a full planet. And so for it to be a full planet, everything's interconnected. Um I don't know if you've gone deeper into the planet yet, but there have you gone underground? You have gone under. Okay.
Uh I've gone under underwater and
underwater. Okay.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Under water. You can go underground. Yeah.
Yeah. And I was like, "Wow, there's like a whole underwater world." I think that that kind of reminded me of uh the sequel to Breath of the Wild, Tears of the Kingdom, how there was like a whole
another huge map under under the main map. And it's like, "Wow, okay. So, here here's a whole another place I I can explore." I was very excited to see that when they announced that sequel, but I I had I had already put that in Vantage and so that was one thing that I was kind of hoping wouldn't be. Although the underwater part isn't really in Breath of the Wild. I don't think there's much underwater.
No, I don't. Yeah, I don't think you can even I don't know if can you even go I don't think you can even Can you swim underwater in Breath of the Wild?
Not deep. I think you just Yeah.
Um so yeah, it is definitely like a fully Vantage is a fully it's I consider I it is a complete game. Like I'm not planning to add more to it. I think the only thing I'm maybe someday if I want to return to the adventure game format, I I do really like the action system advantage. I like the way it turned out and so I could see maybe me using that system or something similar to it in another game.
But uh
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you have this kind of basic framework
that you could develop other adventure games with. Kind of like the Plaid Hat, the Crossroads system that they really honed to a great great place with that their their app that they're using, which is the same app that I think uh Lands of Galier
uh uses.
And um
so that brings up this topic.
No app. No app. I know that's a it's a
somewhat um controversial subject. Personally, I like apps in games. I think they're great tools, especially for adventure games. Some people,
if the game has an app, they will not even consider playing it. Even
if I say this is like the best lands of Galier was my game of the year when it came out.
Yeah.
And I would tell people, guys, this is an amazing adventure game. You will have so much. And like, nope, has an app. Not going to play it. Like, all right. But uh but yeah, so so no app. And uh talk a little bit about that. Like why was that an early decision? Was that a was that a decision because you uh are not into apps or like what went with that?
Um I I generally prefer to turn off screens when I play tabletop games. But I really do say the word generally because I love Lands of Gazir.
Yeah. That was mentioned as one of your as one of your inspirations. Yeah.
Yeah. it it's it's a really really well done app that makes the game smoother than I think it would be if it if it used story books instead. Um part of my my thinking advantage is that I I I separated the story books. I guess I'll say it this way. When I play Do you play Role Player Adventures? Do you play that you play that?
Yeah, I I like that game that that's a really interesting game that is I think it it approaches this this kind of ideal game that I look for and that's um effortlessly easy. Yes.
Where you can just play the game. That's where V advantage. You can just play the game. You don't have to It's not taxing, right?
Yes.
Yeah.
I I think not taxing is a great way to put it. Like it's it's uh it is a campaign game. So there is that level of commitment to it. But
I the game makes it really easy to play the game and part of that are the way the story books are executed where it just it any any rule that you need to know is in the passage of text that you're reading. Um, but my my thing that I would do in roleplayer adventures is that and that I do in storybook games sometimes is that I'll read the other options while I'm reading. So I might say, "Okay, I want to choose if it gives me three different options. I might choose one, but then I I my eyes might drift to the other options and maybe regret not choosing one of them." Or sometimes I might cheat a little bit and change my mind in a cooperative game. And so I wanted to avoid that advantage. by having the different story books. I that was how I tried to avoid it without having an app because an app can conceal that information from the player.
Right?
That said, I a lot of people have have asked if we might consider releasing a uh a storybook app for Vantage and we do we are set up to do it rather quickly if we decide that we want to do it. But I kind of wanted people to have their first experience with Vantage with the story books to give that a try to see if that's a good format for them. And then in a few months I'll send out an email to the Stillmire or to the Vantage newsletter to say, "Hey, after playing it this way, do you still want this?" And if you still do, we can we can certainly do that. It wouldn't be hard for us to do.
Nice. Now, no, there is I I saw something. I haven't looked into it very deeply, but I saw something that there is some kind of web access. it. Yeah. Is that still in place or was that an idea that you had that that you jettisoned?
Some kind of thing kind of like Dark Souls where you can leave notes for other players or you can leave clues for other players or something.
Yeah, this was um
uh Elden Ring. This was inspired by Elden R.
Okay. Elder. Okay. And this is uh so there there is one little thing in the game where you you can if you want to go online very briefly to a a web app that we have but it isn't necessarily you don't need you don't need this to do the game and like you said you've played the game a couple times you never even saw it.
Yeah. Somebody was mentioning it on BG and I was like I I've played the game five times and I didn't even know this existed. So if you're worried about a techn technological portion of this game you can just completely ignore it.
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. I think it's like maybe 20 actions out of the 7,000 actions in the game. They're related to the uh Do you want to know? Do you want me to tell you the where to look for it
or do you I will tell you where? Yeah, it's in there somewhere. And Okay. And that the app you you're sent if you want to to go to a little website where
Oh, so Oh, so
if I discover that it's actually in the in the board game somewhere.
Oh, yeah. Yeah. It's in like in the passage of text that you're reading. and it'll say, "Hey, if you want to go to this link and you can you can look at the thing that we have there and there's another
something." Yeah, I had again something I had no idea. So, more more surprises to discover. And so, when you go to that app, you have some additional actions and do those somehow
uh
not quite actions. It's it's uh it's essentially really the thing from Elden Ring where you can leave little essentially messages like pre limited messages to other players around the world. Like in the in our real world,
you can leave a little message for someone else to find and
like kind of hint to them that maybe they should go north after this and and take a overpower action. That type of thing.
Yeah.
Wow, that's super cool. Yeah, I had no idea. That that's really neat. Now, um I want to I want to talk briefly about the name Vantage and
how that really does correspond to kind of the whole idea of the game of of of seeing
things and everything is from your character's point of view and how that relates to this game being solo versus co-op. Um, I know I have seen some people, well, can I play um multi-handed solo? Can I play as two characters? And you discourage that because that kind of defeats the whole point of this game being called Vantage. However, there also are some people who are saying, well, if these characters are in these technological suits, how come they can't see uh what other players are are seeing? they don't have video communications or they don't have a way to to convey images. They don't have a an a phone they can pull out. So, so how did you what are some of the the things that you thought about when you were designing that part?
Uh yes, it's it's a big for me it was a it was like the foundational element of the of the game. um that uh so we're talking about these games like uh Breath of the Wild, which is a game that you play by yourself. There are there isn't anyone else that you're playing with. And so I wanted to translate that that concept of looking at the world from a first-person perspective to a multiplayer format. And um so I kind of just built it from the ground up around this idea that that you can see your own location, but no one else can. And there are several reasons that this became important to the game's design in my opinion. Part of it is just related to the theme. That's a big part of it that you can't see what I see. I I think it's a valid idea that in a futuristic world, we could send images just as easy as we could send audio. Um, and there are some items you can get in the game that let you see other players locations, but not by default. Um, but part of it too is just to really encourage communication to get players to talk about what they see rather than just showing each other. And I a lot of that inspiration came from the game Time Stories. Have you played much Time Stories or
I did I did play Time Stories. Um, that's another game that I liked the idea of more than the actual game. like uh I thought the
the whole concept was really interesting and how you're kind of plugging in these modules to have a new adventure.
Um for me it was a little too on rails. Yeah,
it felt a little mist like where if you don't know the solution to a puzzle then
tough, you know, and I'm not very, you know, I hit a lot of roadblocks in that game just cuz like my brain doesn't work with those kinds of puzzles and so I was like, well, I guess I can't progress now.
The thing that I I I had a similar experience where fortunately I leaned on some friends who could figure out that kind of stuff. But the part that I really liked about Time Stories was that you would enter a new location and then you would divide up right away cuz you weren't like all going to look at one thing. You were right. Like we'd walk into a room and I would walk over to that corner and look at it really closely and I would look at an illustration unique to that corner that you couldn't see because you're on the other side of the room or the other side of the house, wherever we are.
Um, and I really like that. I like that idea that I got to see something that you didn't see, but I got to talk to you about it. I got to share what I saw about it. And sometimes that meant that I would miss something in the art because I think we all see the world in different ways. We look at art in different ways. And so just that idea of perspective and communication and avoiding a little bit an alpha player because not all players have perfect information about the game. You could decide to share however much you want. Um
that all just all those things added up to the reason that I
really encourage players to not play double-handed and to not show their location. Oh, and one other thing we talked about Seventh Continent. My one other thing that I happened to me when I was playing Seventh Continent is because the art is important in that game, but it's on a small little card.
I would find that whenever we'd reveal a new new location, instead of putting it in its slot on the table right away, you would pass it around the table. We'd all look at it and when I'm looking at it really closely, you can't look at it.
That to me was a bit of an impediment to the game. I I like that the art was there, but it
it slowed down the game instead of speeding it up. So, I wanted to avoid that advantage.
Yeah, that's interesting because everybody would take their time to look at the card, right?
And advantage, you're only ever looking at one card, which I think is fantastic. I really did like that how I didn't have to build a map.
Yes. Yeah.
You know, it's because I play on a pretty small table
and that's another thing that a lot of modern adventure games aren't designed for.
They're sprawling. Yeah. so big and I don't even have room on my my dining room table for some games. And so being able to play Vantage on a pretty small table. I mean, you could you could almost play this game on a coffee table.
I mean, you know, if you just if you had the books in a in in the box sitting down or sitting on the floor or something. Um, yeah, one thing one thing I was expecting and I didn't see, maybe you can tell me why this wasn't in the game, but was a
a narrative reason why this isn't a campaign game. And the thing that I was thinking of, I don't know if you played the video game Outer Wilds.
I I've tried to play it, but I couldn't get past the tutorial because I'm not good at video games, but uh I know about it all about it. Yeah.
Yeah. So, you you you play the same things over and over again, and
Yeah. It's a time loop that you're stuck in and your player's knowledge of what's going on is the only thing that
right
determines how good you do in the game. And so I was expecting because I knew this was not a campaign game, I was expecting something at the end of a scenario, at the end of a mission that would reset my character. Like, oh, you fall into some kind of wormhole and you you you wake up again on your ship. And so you kind of have to it's a Groundhog Day situation.
Yeah.
These characters are constantly reliving the same thing. But that there's nothing like that in the game.
Did you ever think of a a reason why this is not a campaign or was it just is it just because of your background of just making normal tabletop games that you don't have to think about campaigns? I think that is I think that is the reason in the end like you're right when you play Vida culture there's no thematic reason that you play viticulture and then you start over from scratch that's
yeah why is my why is my my vineyard like starting at square one again
exactly it's just
how games like that work
but it is I would say one of the the
one of the things I only have a few like tiny little regrets about the game a few are like a few typos things like that but that is probably one of them looking back cuz a few people have asked that question and there's really no thematic reason why I couldn't have said that and you're right that it would have been a nice end cap to some of the missions to to complete it in that way. And then I do play with time travel in the game. And I I and the reason I'm kicking myself about it because I love a time loop and time travel fiction. And so I do play with it in other areas of the game, but that would have been a very a nice and easy way to thematically explain to players who are used to this type of game being a campaign game explain why it's not a campaign game,
but to still have the theme re reasoning behind it. So I think that explanation makes sense. I might make that just the unofficial explanation for it. the end of Yeah. So, some some narrative era.
Yeah. Yeah.
I I was also curious uh real quick about have you ever played a game advantage where you start with your beginning equipment and a skill where you kind of start with an an advantage and to maybe have a a ground up or or have you have you ever experiment experimented with different ways to start the game in a kind of sandbox mode? I guess that would just kind of take place of some of those initial actions. You know, a player would have a little bit of a leg up when they're just starting.
So, there is a way the game lets you do it, but it's very specific. Like, it's a thing, it's a thing to find.
Um, and it isn't possible in every game. It's it's possible in certain missions to do something very early that gives you that. But by overall, I I can see why you're asking about it. Um, it would accelerate, I think, the beginning of the game a little bit and probably decrease the playing time a little bit. Um,
the game already plays really pretty quickly. I mean, especially for a solo player, I think most people
can get through an endame in about an hour, hour and a half, I think. Yeah.
Yeah. For solo and one to two players, maybe even three, you could get done, you can get done in an hour plus. It does slow down a bit. you're still involved in each other's turn, so I don't feel like there's that much downtime, but it does just take longer at higher player counts because many of the missions scale based on the number of players. Um, and the game gets a little bit easier at higher player counts, too. Like there's less
less tension to like to lose the or to to end the game and potentially lose the game.
More ways for the other players to help mitigate some of that bad luck or not bad luck, but uh mitigate those those resource losses.
Yes. Yeah, exactly. Now, what's funny is I want to convey this story to you. Um, I played the game once with a group uh with a couple buddies and at the end of the game, one of the one of the guys I was playing with, I had just met him. He came over with with a friend
and he said he really liked the game, but at the beginning of the game, he felt a little aimless because the um he didn't have the enough information to where he could make a a good choice. he thought and for me that's not a detriment because I just like exploring but for him he likes to have that kind of perfect information about what exactly am I doing and why and um I asked him do what types of uh co-op games do you normally like and he said I like I really like kind of tightly constructed um uh asymmetric co-ops and I was like oh so you probably like Spirit Island quite a bit goes well yeah I work on the game
oh really I I had no idea. I was like, "Oh, okay. Well, that makes perfect sense." But over over the over the time that we played the game and his character started getting built up and he kind of learned about the world, he started to enjoy those decisions more. So that's why I was kind of asking about
a way to start the game where you maybe have a little bit more in mind of like what you're supposed to be doing
that that for that type of gamer who doesn't want to waste a turn. It's like, well, if I would have known that, I wouldn't have done that. But for me, that's a positive because I try to picture it as my character,
right?
Just crash landed on the ship and I don't know what the heck's going on, you know?
Right.
I thought that I thought that was funny mentioning Spirit Island because that seems to be kind of like the ultimate and he's like, "Yeah, I worked on it." Like, oh,
I do I I have a quick response and I have a question to bounce back at you about about that. But the the quick response is I I did I tried to build in little nudges, but I didn't want to fully steer a player to do anything because the game is built around this idea of freedom. So like the nudge would be if you have the character that's good at moving, you might you might move like early on when you don't know what to do, you might do that. And also with a mission, you know, the mission, did you ever take any of the actions that are printed on the mission?
Yes. And that was really cool because and I'm not sure, so don't tell me, but I'm not sure if each one is kind of like the same, but in some of the actions I took, I did notice that the missions can alter. Uh you can kind of uh make them a little easier or a little more difficult. So yeah, that was that was super cool. That was neat to discover.
And that was something that wasn't originally in the game. That was something that came directly from play testing because some play testers, this is where I found that some play, even though I wasn't focusing on the mission, some play testers would really focus on the mission or would really lean on that for guidance.
Yeah.
And the missions at least like as the card is printed, they aren't vague, but they don't tell you like go to place A to pick up this thing and then go over here. Like that's pretty wide open because you might crash anywhere on the planet and have to accomplish the mission. And so I built those actions into the mission to both speed up the game, which I wish I made a little bit more obvious in the rules that you could do that to speed up the game. Um, uh, but also just to give you some guidance as to what to do.
Yeah. Yeah.
Um, but the question I wanted to throw back at you at is in a lot of the games that you play, these adventure games, there is, especially the the cooperative versions, there is uh an AI that you need to control at some point. Sometimes a quick and easy AI turn, sometimes it's more involved.
I didn't want that advantage at I didn't I wanted players to solely focus on what you were doing, not what an AI that was doing. Um I'm curious about your thoughts about that in in general like are there AIs that you don't mind running or some where they get so cumbersome where you do mind it or
Yeah,
100%. U and that's one of the reasons why I like apps uh because um one of my favorite games is Mansions of Madness second edition. Yeah. Right.
Yeah. the first edition. I did not like that game at all because the person who was it wasn't fully co-op, but the person who was controlling the game, you know, you can make a simple mistake of getting two cards swapped at the beginning of setup and completely derail the game.
And so the app in Mansions of Madness handles all of that stuff in the background for for for the players. I I typically like games that have as little upkeep in between turns as possible.
Yeah.
You don't have, you know, if there is an AI phase, if there is a game fights back phase,
right?
I don't want to have to, okay, I need to move this on this track, this on this track. If if if this track is at seven, move this creature over. You know, I mean, it's like Arkham Horror, right? Arkham Horror can be an AI nightmare during those during those I love the game,
but
to be honest, I don't think I've ever played that game 100% correctly
because there's just there's just so so many little tracks to keep up and it can get really cumbersome. And I think Lands of Galier, uh, Role Player Adventures, um, Sleeping Gods and and Vantage kind of
take all of that away. Yeah,
there's really not much you have to do to keep track of what's going on except for what you were doing on your turn,
right?
Yeah, that was that was that was great.
I was curious to hear your thoughts on that. And it I I think the the downside from the design perspective a little bit is that it makes it you need to use different tools as a designer, I think, to to make anything that you encounter feel unique or different from anything else that you encounter. I think that's more difficult. Like Sleeping Gods does it with like the bosses that you fight. They they are different but they are following the same rule set,
right?
Which was a clever way to do it. And you don't you're not really running much from the bosses. Maybe a little bit but not much.
I think that's the sacrifice that you make. And some people do like they want they like to play these boss uh boss fighting games where the whole game is about fighting a unique asymmetric boss.
Yeah,
that isn't my style of game, but I I get that that is what some people are going for. Now, there are some bosses, some boss creatures in Vantage, I think. I think I've come across one like a a Leviathan.
Yes.
And are they kind of
does each I don't I I mean, are there different bosses in like different biomes? Is it is it that kind of thing? Are these these big creatures? And I think
yeah,
you know,
I typically spoil games for myself because I like to see what I'm working towards. And I did notice some cards that seem to combine into a big creature. I don't know what that is, but um I thought that was cool because that just something that I I again this game this game surprised me because it has all of the things that I look for in an adventure game and and very little of the things I dislike. And the reason why it surprised me was because it was coming from Stonemer Games where I thought you would be focusing not on the things that I really enjoyed. So, it was it was, you know, it was a like just like I said, like having weapons and having skills and having bosses. These are all these are all staples of the adventure game genre, but I think you do things quite differently and um and and and did them well. So, yeah, congrats on that. It's it's it's an amazing game.
I really appreciate that. Yeah, I think I think I had time as an asset. like it was kind of a luxury to have that amount of time to work on a game and to learn a lot along the way by playing other adventure games by playing some of the digital games we talked about, but a lot of also just watching YouTube videos about people talking about them. And I think that's when I got into your channel. And when I got into uh the One-stop Co-op shop, their channel, their their podcast,
it was just like a I love the research side of it. And that I think that ended up hopefully being an asset for the game to have that time to spend researching and learning and playing.
Yeah. Awesome. Well, hey, uh thanks Jamie for taking the time to talk to the dungeon dive today. I really enjoyed it.
So, all right guys. Well, hope you enjoyed this uh conversation with Jamie all about Vantage and we'll talk to you later. Bye-bye.