Isle of Cats Duel: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over the Isisle of Cats Duel. This is the two-player version of Isisle of Cats, which I was going to do a re-review for uh the base game of Isisle of Cats cuz it had been, you know, quite some time since I had played it. But that video that I have on YouTube uh is the it actually has my old cat that passed away um in it. I think I tried to get her to sit in the box and I just can't bring myself to redo it. So, this is kind of a pseudo Isisle of Cats re-review as well as talking about Isle of Cats Duel. Um, because I had recently replayed, well, I played Emberleaf. I I have a discussion on Emberleaf, which is this designer's newest game, and I I just did not care for it. Uh, but someone commented and they're like, "Giving Isle or giving this a five or whatever. gave it an aisle of cats uh a 10 is is some certainly like a take or something. I don't remember exactly what it was, but they they were they seem to be shocked that I really liked Aisle of Cats. So, after replaying it, you know, to see if it really was a 10. Spoiler, it's not, but it's still a really good game. I would probably give Isle of Cats an eight or a nine. it hits all the, you know, the buttons for me for a polyomino style game. I think the polyomino aspect is great. The the uh drafting element is
great. Um, and just the fact that it was able to merge both of those and do something that I mean with the modularity that is in the version that I have, it's fantastic. So, not a 10, but it certainly uh is is high up there. So then I see Isisle of Cats Duel and I'm like, "Oh, awesome. It's a two-player only version of Isisle of Cats." And funny enough, I've never played at regular Isisle of Cats at two. I've only ever played it at three or four. So, I was thinking that this would be a perfect a perfect game for to to capture that aisle of cats feel. It' be quicker to get to the table. Um, and I am so disappointed to say that I don't really care for this version. The dual craze that is happening where people are designing larger player count games specifically for two and obviously they use the duel because of Seven Wonders Duel. I mean, you have Splender Duel, you have uh I think Azul Duel is uh is out there and then obviously Seven Wonders Duel. So, there's a ton Oh, Flamecraft Duel. Uh, there's there's a ton of these games that are coming out as a two-player, and for most of the like most of them tend to miss for me, but there are ones that come out of the base game that I don't enjoy, but the two-player version I really like. Splender Duel is a great
example. So, I was really hoping that this version was going to come out and make me, oh, hey, I love the multiplayer game, but now I also love the two-player game. And for some reason this one just does not hit. And the I think the biggest reason is because you are missing the draft element. And I did not realize that in the base game of Isisle of Cats that that was such an integral part of the overall game because you think oh polyominos that's the crux of the game. that's how you score and get your points, which is true and that is in here. But the fact of the matter is that the drafting element is is so important because that's going to determine, you know, how many cats you can get, where you can go, how many uh how fast you can go, and your scoring, special abilities, things like that. And you just don't necessarily have that same feeling here. Because in this game, you have your cats, you know, if you if you're familiar with aisle of cats. You have the the polyomino pieces and the shape for them, and you have the boat there, and it's double-sided, and you don't have to play the same side. So, there are I mean, there are only two boats to use, but you you have it in terms of aesthetic, it looks just like I love cats. But the biggest diff difference is is you now have the central board. And this board is bro I mean it's double-sided as well but I cannot tell if it's different in
any way but you have this board and you have these uh hexag not hexagonal but these these u 3x4 spaces that this is where these are where the cats go and these spots here are where the cards go. And on your turn, you have this uh Oshax Oshacks. You have this Oshax mele that you move around to whatever it moves through, lands on, or started its turn on, you get to pick one thing from that. And you always have to move the cat twice. And you would think, oh, there's some spatial awareness element to where you want to go and where you're going to leave it for your opponent to get. Okay, that would be true if you and you always have to move it twice, but you could literally just move it once because every single spot almost connects to everything around it. So, you could just hop if you really want one of the tiles, one of the cats that are adjacent to where it's currently at. And you might be like, "Dang it, I have to move it twice." Well, you can. You could just move it left once and then right back cuz you follow the footprints and that just lets you get there. So the spatial movement of the Oshacks just isn't interesting in any way. So with that being the crux of how you get your cats and there's no there's no like speed on
who okay which cat do I want to get first? Um, there's no cost for getting the cats either. In the in the base game of Isisle of Cats, you are trying to get a bunch of fish. You get a you get an influx of fish and then you spend them to keep as many cards as you want to pay for. So, after the draft, it's like you're looking at your hand and you're like, "Ooh, I have 20 fish. I have 12 fish worth of cards. Do I want to pay for all these and only be left with eight fish?" because then when you go and grab your cats eat this the left side and right side of the board, it costs three or five fish. So that's important because you could have five crates to get five cats, but if you can't pay for them, then it doesn't matter. Here there's no cost. Uh they do something a little bit interesting with the fish in that they are now special abilities. So you could spend a fish to move the thing in extra space. You could spend two fish to have it jump anywhere. You can spend two to take any treasure that goes onto your boat and then you can spend three fish to choose an extra thing. So whenever it moves, you know, two spaces, you could take a cat and take a card. So I don't hate that. I don't hate the fish element. Really, just what it boils down to is the fact that I felt the choices weren't ever interesting. It felt like I didn't have to take into consideration really anything because I everything was laid out for me. I could see exactly
what the cards were. I could get to them relatively easily. And I also felt like and I don't know this for sure. It it could be true, could be not, but it felt like it was also insanely easy to fill out your boat. And then regular Isle of Cats, that was that was a chore. At least in my games, it was it was difficult to completely fill it out. And in this, it just wasn't. So, it it is of cats, but I feel like it's just watered down version. I can't I can't really imagine choosing this over regular Isisle of Cats except for the fact that this is easier to set up. the Now, to be fair, the base aisle of cats has this wonky ass deck system where you are throwing in certain modules or certain uh decks of cards into the main the base uh game set. And while that adds for variety, it's just really poorly explained in the setup.
And I know this because I recently played it. So, I had to keep reshuffleling cuz I was like, what do I add to this? and it was like, "Oh, missing this deck. Oh, missing this deck." So, then I had to reshuffle all of it. So, yeah, the Polyomino system is the exact same. You have your cats that you that you will eventually grab and you will place them into your uh into your boat. You will I mean the the cards are the same in in the sense that the gold ones, hey, take two treasures. The blue ones are a scoring thing for you. two points for every blue or purple cat on your boat, whichever you have fewer of. The purple ones are also instance, but there's that that's it. Like there's a bunch it's it's a majority of blue and it's just this tiny deck. So, you also don't really have any variety, which I guess you're not really expecting in a in a tiny box like this. But yeah, I mean the polyomin if that's what you love about um about Isisle of Cats, then you're going to you're probably going to really like it here. I just I feel like it's just missing a significant portion which is that drafting element.
And maybe Isle of Cats and I haven't played base aisle of cats at 2. Maybe it's awful. Maybe the drafting element in a Isisle of Cats 2 sucks and this actually supersedes that, but I would much rather just not play this and find a third person to play Aisle of Cats with because it's just that that drafting really is is a huge huge part of the game and it works so well for base Isle of Cats. Now, I will say one thing. They did keep the cute little Target in the in the lid cuz in the other one it was like a cat box. Hence why I tried to get my cat to lay in it and she was just like, "What are you doing? I don't want to be in this." And then she left left my life cuz she died.
No, I'm It's been a while. But uh this one is a training box where it says, "If you have a kitten, you should place it here while playing Isle of Cats," which is cute. Um, so if you're like me and you love the base game, but you can't ever table it for some reason and you're wanting to try this as a two-player game, uh, maybe I don't know. I feel like this might be one might be a hot take. I feel like some people might really like this, but I just found the movement to be uninteresting. Uh, and the polyomino aspect to be too easy and the lack of drafting just not just just making it just way too kind of go through the motions is how I was feeling. And that's it. That's my thoughts on Isle of Cats Duel. Not replacing the base game and and not not super awesome. So, on a scale of one to 10, I mean, it's serviceable. I'm probably just gonna give it a five. I think it's I think it's an average game.
I It's It's a huge step down from his other games. Uh not other game, his other game, which is the base game of what what it is uh implementing. But yeah, that's it. That's my thoughts on Isle of Cats Duel. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.