Skip to main content
Loading video...

Antike II Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:49

hey everyone today i'm taking a look at antique two which is a board game designed by mack gertz and published by rio grande games this one takes 90 to 120 minutes to play and accommodates three to six players so this is a euro strategy resource management war game hybrid and that focuses on the rondelle mechanism which matt gertz is most known for but before i get started on my review of antique two i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and actually the place where i picked up and tk2 from and if you use my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order okay so the main board for antique two will look like this at least one of the two maps will look like this where this side is a bit more europe-centric and but on the reverse side of the board we do you do have an alternative map which is more focused on the eastern part of the world and on this map you can see it's all divided up into these different regions and within these regions at least most of them you have these cities and these cities are going to produce different resources so you have three different types of resources in this game you've got iron you've got gold and you have marble and each of those resources are going to have their own uses at the start of the game each player is going to have their own kind of starting region so you can see here the yellow player is more italy based and where they're going to start with rome and the surrounding regions whereas the blue plate up here is going to start more in these kind of germanic regions up here at the top of the board

you have the scoring track and the objective of the game is to reach a certain amount of points depending on the player count so if we were to be playing a six player game the first person to reach seven points will be the winner uh in a five player game it will be eight points in a four player game it will be nine points and in a three player game it will be 10 points on the top right hand side of the board here you're gonna have the action rondelle and which is the main mechanism of the game as is the case with a lot of matt gertz games where as you'd expect with ronda games you're gonna start initially any way you want but from then on you can move one to three spaces around the rondelle to take the corresponding action however you can discard resources to travel further and we'll touch up on what all those different actions mean a little bit later there's also going to be a display of these objective cards which are the way we're going to acquire points throughout the game and say for example in order to collect this um navigator card i need to have control of seven different c areas um on the map and if i have that i've completed by the end of my turn i can claim one of these cards and then move up my points tracker to show how well i'm doing um some of the other cards here we have the um this general card here which means that every time i destroy a temple i'll claim this card and there's going to be some presets temples kind of just as neutral players on the board but also as the game develops you as players are going to be building temples because it's a very useful thing to do and you also got

this king card here where for every five cities you claim you can take one of these cards and if you ever say have five cities but you lose one to another player and fall back to four you actually do keep control of these cards but for every kind of five increment you get you can collect another one so at 5 10 15 and 20 cities you have under your control you'll get another one of these cards and the same applies to the citizen cards here where you're going to get points for every three temples you control and there's also these no um no wall cards here or no how cards i should say um these scholar cards where for every piece of knowledge that you gain as in these upgrades at the bottom you will gain one of those cards if you are the first person to do it and additionally if you get know all the different knowledges then you can get this pliny the elder card which will give you a bonus point each player's personal pieces are going to look a bit like this where you have ships you have soldiers you have these city markers to show the regions that you control and you have these little um knowledge tokens as well so for each knowledge you get you can end up putting one of these tokens on there just to show that you know that it can use that ability i mean you're also going to have the different resources so you've again you put your marble you've got your your iron you've got your gold and you also have coins which are a wild resource um and you've also got the neutral temples and things that you can build throughout the game okay so in this game you're not going to have a preset amount of rounds or anything like that you're going to keep on taking turns in order until somebody has reached that point's objective so let's talk about how the players turns

are broken down because they are broken down into three very simple phases the first of which is to select your action on the rondelle again the first time you can place it anywhere but from then on you'll be limited to one to three spaces but for every resource you discard you can go another spot around the rondelle now let's talk about what the different spaces actually do so you have these three spots here which work in exactly the same way but correspond to a different resource so you have the marble one here the iron one and the gold one and when you take one of those actions let's just say i'm the yellow player and i took this marble action here you're gonna have a look at the corresponding amount of cities you have of that type so at the start of the game this is going to be pretty easy because you only ever have one of each so in this case i've got one city that's marble there's corrales here so therefore i will take one marble from the supply however you also always get a coin the science action spot here allows you to buy upgrades for your little civilization and when you do that you're going to have to spend a certain amount of gold now the first time anybody buys a specific type of science upgrade you're going to have to pay the higher figure here on the left-hand side of the slash um but when you do that not only are you going to gain access to this ability and we'll talk about what they are very shortly but you'll also gain one of these knowledge cards which are going to be a point at the end of the game so again they're very useful to get in there early um so let's talk about what they actually do so you've got these two spots here which allow you to freely trade um resources for other resources and to start with

it's going to be on a two to one ratio so let's just say i had a you know two iron and i really needed a gold i could trade in those two iron for that gold and if you want to upgrade further you can go down to the next one like this and do it on a three to two ratio but you do need to do it in that order so you can't just go straight to here you have to go here and then here but you can see here on the right hand side i mean once somebody's unlocked this ability for the first time everybody else is going to get access to it at a much more affordable rate this one here basically increases your yield by another resource so let's just say i you know when i took that um marble action earlier i got one marble and a coin this would allow me to get two marbles and a coin but again if once i've done that one i can slide down to this one here by paying that extra cost and get an extra yield of two so much makes you much more efficient and to get resources much quicker uh these two spots here increase your defenses so if people want to start attacking your cities um they're gonna have to basically spend another troop or an extra two troops and we'll talk about how combat works shortly and these two spots here are very simple and working pretty much the identical same way which makes your troops and boats much more maneuverable because normally um as a movement point you can only ever move one spot like this from border to border but say i had this upgrade i could actually move a troop with two spaces so we just talked about how movement works that's what these two spots um correspond to and you've also got the temple action here and when you land on that you can spend five marble to build

temples and you know you can do that as many times as you want and when you build temples you have to build them in places where you already have um cities so let's just say i wanted to build a temple um in roma here now the reason you build temp want to build temples is not only because there is an objective card corresponding to temples where for every three temples you control you will get a card which is another point but they'll also increase your output when producing um different goods so you can see here that my um my temple is now on the gold region that means that when i play payout gold now i won't only get the one resource for um having a city in that region but because i got a temple i would actually get three resources and the final action which we haven't talked about yet is the militia action and when you do that you are going to spend an amount of iron um and you're gonna spend two iron for every troop you want to spawn on the board however you could only ever um spawn troops where you have um locations already so i could say spend two to um put a troop there in that obviously idea because i want to have a boat there so let's say i spent two to put a boat here i spent two to put a troop here and i spent another two to put a troop here as well and you can see here i haven't put two in the same region because you can actually only spawn one troop per place where you have a city but if you have a temple you can spawn up to three and once you've taken your main rondelle action you're going to have the ability to build as many

cities as you want as long as you have presence there so let's just say in my previous turn i actually moved these troops here i maybe moved one up here if i had one of each resource as in a steel a marble and a gold i can establish a new city in that region so by spreading that resource i could maybe put one of my control markers in um circus here and maybe even another one if i have the resources to do so in ancona and once you've taken your rondelle action you've established any cities you want to establish or you can afford to establish then you're going to check how many objectives you have complete at this moment or if you've completed any new ones and claim the cards accordingly so combat actually couldn't be much more simple banning and tk um essentially the troops will cancel each other out so let's just say um the blue had a troop here they spent a movement point and they ventured into a region with another player they would just count each other out like so and kill each other now something that is important to say is that as long as players agree they do not actually have to fight so you could say you know what i'm happy for the blue to cross through me here and let's just um let's spare our lives and not fight at all but as soon as one player wants to fight then it will be happening and that is when you'll start cancel cancelling each other out so let's talk about how um claiming cities from other players works so let's just say that the um the blue player had managed to have this city here like this um and the yellow player was saying on the bordering region like this and as their movement they ventured in to this city with the aim of trying to claim the city from the blue player

now when they do that as normal the troops are going to cancel each other out like so so they'll kill each other for one to one to one but also the cities count as a strength one um just like the troops do so right now these would capture each other out like so um and when there's a tie the attacking player will win that tie and therefore claim the city for themselves and um make that under their control however earlier in the game as long as you have fewer than two points you automatically have another string so in that example um because the blue hadn't had any points yet they would actually need another strength or the yellow wouldn't even need another strength in order to conquer that um additionally by um buying certain upgrades here these defensive upgrades you can make your cities just passively much more difficult to breach by other players now if you wanted to invade a region containing a temple it's going to be even more costly for that attacking player because any region with a temple is going to have a base defense of three so this one right here at the moment has a strength or defense value of three and plus one for this troop for a total of four and they have fewer than two points therefore it'll be a defensive defensive value of five meaning that that blue player would have to move in at least five troops into that region in order to conquer it for their own and when they do that they don't actually take control of the temple they actually destroy it meaning they'd have to build a new one themselves if they wanted to however they would take control of that city themselves and as a reward for

spending so much effort to destroy that temple you'll gain one of these um one of these general cards here you can also see that some of these sea regions have this little boat icon on now if you ever have one of your pieces on one of those areas then that actually counts as a strength of two um concerning these c's sailed cards so you can see here this one needs seven c cells and however if you um have again one market in there that's gonna count towards two of those seven okay so let's get into the review of and tk2 and i want to start with how the gameplay works and just the mechanisms um used here because i'm always impressed about how matt gertz manages to just use very complex involved and thinking games but condenses it down into such a digestible and manageable system by utilizing the rondelle and antique is just another perfect example of gertz pulling that off to such a high standard because essentially every one of these actions in their own right could not be more simple you know three of them are pretty much identical as in producing resources um two of them are just move and you know movement couldn't be more easy just move borders to border and then the other three are just you know equally as a simple you know make troops um get knowledge as in buy a new upgrade or make temples so the fact that that's all you're doing in this game however the decision space is rich is just so so impressive to me i also love how players need to kind of conquer the rondelle and how to use each spot to the maximum benefit because you

need to know when to bypass certain actions because doing things at certain times might not as be efficient as if you wait and hold on and you know go past it this time but maybe land on it next turn when you have more resources to spend because i love it how you know if you end up on the military action you can take that minus reactions as many times as you want you know if i had 10 iron that means i could build five troops which is gonna be much more efficient than if i just you know do it once and then just stop here um and i don't have the cities to actually spawn those troops in in the first place so i love how everything ties hand in hand here you know you need the marble because you want the marble to be the temple the temples but then you want the temples on certain spots because it's going to increase your yield of the other resources and allow you to spawn more troops then you want of course you want the troops because you want to move and you want to move because you want to get more cities so every single thing goes hand in hand with each other i think it was a really smart decision not to add the building action into the rondelle you know you take your rondelle action and then you get to build in as many cities as you want anyway just as a passive action so it makes the game tick along at a much faster pace and it feels like you can get a lot done a lot quicker rather than rather than having to wait to go all the way around the rondelle one more time i think this game strikes a wonderful bounce between being you know that more war game feeling to the economic side of things because you know you can't really go for any approach you want to you know if you want to go into that more economic feel then you need to really build up a network of resources and each of those resources are equally important

you know you want the marble because the marble's going to allow you to build the temples and temples are not only great because they give you points but they also increase your output you want the iron because it's going to give you more troops to protect your regions in the first place after you start venturing into other regions and getting the uh you know establishing cities there but of course you want the gold because the gold gives you access to all these wonderful upgrades and although these upgrades um i suppose compared to a lot of other games might sound pretty um you know pretty subtle and not overly you know game breaking but because the rules out here is so simple just being able to move an extra border with a each troop on your on your movement turns is massive it gives you so much more flexibility than if you do not have that or even like of course i'm increasing your defenses meaning that you can maybe start renting your troops elsewhere and can leave your cities unmanned because they can pretty much handle themselves and even within taking that militaristic or economic approach to the game there are other things you can do within those kind of categories as well because you know if you want to go for a kind of area majority style um approach to the gameplay by controlling the seas you can do that and just try to start you know building a massive fleet and controlling all the key regions here and try to farm points that way um again you can go for that real big smash and grab you know if you're falling behind things might get desperate and you just need to go on the warpath and start smashing people's temples if you can the fact that you start with pretty much nothing in this game but can end up with a massive empire feel satisfying i mean you start with just cities and no troops at all but as the game goes on you can

start to see how far you ventured off and where you've established new cities and you know get more and more resources that you can produce it feels like you've achieved a lot by the end of the game which i think it was a very wise design choice for the um battles to go in favor of the attacking player um if there is a tie you know like if it's a one-on-one tie here the city will go to that attacking player and although it's going to cost a troop which might be something you need to factor in because troops you know they're not the cheapest and it does take quite a bit of time to move them around the map but the fact that you can spend it in order to gain something rather than having to build up a huge force a big military just to take one city i think that could have brought the game to a bit of a halt whereas this one because the attackers go or the yeah the wars do go in favor of the attacker it does feel like that incentive does slightly weigh in the favor of that attacker to make things a bit more spicy and to kind of put the players on the edge of their seats because you need to have your wits about you to decide where are these attacks coming from where do i need to build my defenses and what kind of contingencies can i put in place if somebody comes in and snatches some of my best regions you are looking at around a two-hour time frame to play this game which to be honest i think is completely fair and justified especially considering that the terms are so lightning fast there's very little down time you know you're not waiting for your turn to come around and just getting bored and frustrated when you're not involved in any conflicts um you know this one you are always engaged and to be honest when i've played it i've not felt for a second that the game has dragged on too long and yeah i've enjoyed the whole process i also feel the game scales pretty well because the amount of points are

adjusted depending on that player count so you know if you're playing a six player game you're not gonna have to wait until somebody gets ten points because that's going to be just too long but you are only getting to seven points which makes a big um difference and i think the feeling of the game does change quite a lot because if you are playing with say three players and you are going to be exploring more and you're not going to be standing on each other's toes as much and i suppose your forces are going to be a bit more diluted um around the board but if you are playing say a six player game or a five player game i'm just gonna be a lot more contested and probably gonna be a bit more conflict heavy um because there's just not the grit land there um available to grab but considering it does scale from three to six i think it does a good job of catering to all those player counts i think the game is pretty much perfectly produced um everything looks great i mean i love the look of this map it looks fantastic um traditional euro pieces as in the boats and the meeples and all the colors are well differentiated um you can clearly see what all the different cities are and even the iconography of the different technologies is absolutely spot on i suppose the only minor minor pain is the fact that the rondelle is right in the top corner there meaning that if you're sat on the other side of the table um you have to lean all the way across in order to um in order to move your player piece so that's a little bit inconvenient and it might have been a good idea to have a separate rondelle um you know taken out of the main board um an additional minor nitpick is that as the game develops um of course you're gonna be claiming more and more cities and sometimes it can be a bit tedious having to calculate each time how much

of a resource you are producing so i thought it would have been a nice touch if each person had their own little player board which could track how many roofs they're producing so at a glance they can say you know what i've got seven marble cities therefore i'm producing seven marble so that'll be a lot nicer rather than having to calculate each time because it is so dynamic and things are constantly changing okay so let's get in some final thoughts on antique two and this is a game that does exactly what it says on the tin it is a perfect hybrid um that seamlessly mixes a euro economic game with a war game and the fact that it does it in such a streamlined and simple package is quite remarkable as you'd expect with matt gertz using that rondelle system to the highest degree possible making a game of this depth teachable in 10 minutes is just quite fantastic um i do think that you know you are going to either be on board with the zero-sum nature of the um of the combat and things like that some people are gonna want that wild card in terms of the dice rolling and things so you know bear that in mind um and despite me having kind of no objective criticisms of the game i think it just works so well and there's nothing i would really change about it this is still one of those games that i would need to be in the right mood to play and to be honest my mood is leaning towards this kind of thing more and more than it was say a year or two ago when i'm a bit more kind of um receptive of being a bit more in players faces and being a bit more conflict driven but i do love the fact that you have this option of maybe building a military force just to repel people and

then focusing on other things and getting your points economically rather than you know trying to squash and crush your opponents but i do like the fact that you can kind of zigzag on that you know if things aren't going so well you can maybe start building up a force and going to conquer the world instead and trying to catch up by destroying other people's temples and for all those reasons this is no doubt going to earn a chairman's accommodation now i suppose the main question is here where does this rank compared to the other mac gertz games and other kind of more conflict euro games that i have in my collection so matt gertz generally is one of my favorite designers ever you know two of his games are ranked extremely high and we're going to start with the upper restaurants here so concordia definitely his kind of magnum opus i suppose and that one is ranking as high as number five at the time of this recording and let's be honest this game isn't quite up to that level navigator another one that i rank slightly lower than concordia but i still love it again more a more passive euro with a lot less conflict involved that one i rank at number 15. um alternatively i had hamburgum which i think was a kind of a less refined version of navigator but it still had a lot of qualities now where i've placed antique at the moment is between hamburgum and navigator so really impressive debut really especially considering it is so conflict driven or has the potential for this much conflict really impressed by this one probably not going to hit the table that often but when it does i know i'm going to enjoy it so that is antique two

by mac gertz

Progress saved