Pitch Perfect: The Ultimate Guide to Pitching Your Board Game Prototype to Publishers
Transcript
hi I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming vlog and today I wanted to talk about pitching your board game prototype to publishers from all around the world I've done this hundreds and hundreds of times usually at the essence spiel convention but also UK games Expo Nuremberg Toy Fair land and Toy Fair maybe some other places but those are the main places that I've done my pitching my first pitch was I think in 2013 I would imagine that the UK games Expo I remember pitching to look out Spieler and the game was not taken up but the game wasn't ready or anything like that but I had no idea of that I thought my game was wonderful and I went into it completely sort of fresh-faced and nervous and and and the the the publisher always sort of guided me through the process he was extremely kinda gave me lots of tips about how to sort of how to pitch and this sort of thing and I think actually that's a mistake that a lot of people make is that they they go into those initial pitches so sort of excited and nervous to meet the publishers and so grateful for the opportunity that I think sometimes that means they sell themself a little bit short you need to remember that this is a business interaction this is not just an extension of your hobby if you are pitching a game to somebody the intention is that they are going to take that game and make some money from it and have contractual arrangements with you whereby you receive royalty payments and advance payments and so on
it's a business meeting and as such you should be going in there as a professional now that doesn't mean lying and making out that you're something that you're not absolutely not go in there and tell them the truth that this is the first time you've ever pitched that this is your first board game design but I don't think you should be gushing with your praise and gratitude you know this should be a meeting of equals who treat each other with respect and equally I don't wanna be talked down to by a publisher either so I think going in there with some confidence and recognizing that a publisher has an awful lot to gain from meeting a designer with a quality game you know they've got a lot to gain from you just as much as you have from them so so yeah go in there confidently tell the truth tell them who you are you know I I increasingly I will mention games that I've had published I tend to have a business card with me I'll have cell sheets with me with images of the other games that I've created and and often the publisher will say oh yes I know your game Doodle Rutter I know your game pick Koko those are usually the ones that they pick out and it does sort of help to be able to give somebody an idea of where you currently stand in the industry but I think it's fine if the answer is this is my first game design okay but I'm a really big fan of your range of games okay that's that there's no problem with that just be honest about it you should research you should know the line of games that are produced by the publisher that you're approaching
go on their website even if it's in a different language you can still see the games that they've created go on the BoardGameGeek website see the games they've made through the years you need to think about what you want from the process but also what does the publisher one from the process and they may be different things if you want your game out there in exactly the form that you currently have it with the artwork that you currently have the name you currently have the theme you currently have no changes to the to the rules then a publisher is probably not the correct way to go okay self-publishing go on crowdfunding systems Kickstarter something like that do it yourself if you want a publisher involved then they're taking all of the risk all of the financial risks they're putting in most of the effort and they want the game to fit their line to fit their range so that it it compliments their other games well they've got to think about the whole picture not just your game I think it's useful to approach publishers in advance I if I'm at a convention I'll go even if I don't have meetings with publishers I'll go and I'll talk to different publishers and save them what sort of stuff are you looking for what are you looking at what are you working on over the next year are you interested in meeting freelance designers or do you design in-house or do you design your own stuff you know get a feel for who these publishers are what they want and then next year you can hit them with a focused pitch based on what they've told you they're looking for when I contact publishers before a convention it's you usually four to six weeks maybe I might even go a little bit you know to two to three weeks before I don't go much more
than six weeks before because often if I do that I don't get a response they're not really in convention mode if I don't get a response I don't know whether it's because they weren't interested in the game or whether it's just that they weren't interested in a meeting right now so I never know whether to chase or not you can get plenty of meetings four to six weeks before the the convention starts so I send them an email I put a very brief description couple of sentences that's it about my game I'll put in a short video I'm talking a two three minute video even if it's a complex game I keep that video to two or three minutes I don't try and describe how to play the game I show the components and I talk through the hook the key thing that makes my game interesting and we'll come back to the hook in a moment it is helpful if you've got some sort of online presence or following if you've got a blog if you're a reviewer if you you know if you contribute a lot on the BoardGameGeek website you know for me I've had this YouTube channel although it's a fairly low-key YouTube channel it doesn't get that many viewers or subscribers but it does go back date back to like 2012 so a lot of publishers have watched my videos over the years because I've reviewed a lot of their games talked about a lot of their games so publishers often know me when I first meet them and that's really really useful it does help you to get a foot in the door if you've already got some sort of presence in the industry when I go into that pitch meeting I I start off by I want to be friendly
I will ask them how they are how they're finding the convention I don't want to get too much into small talk because usually you've only got twenty or thirty minutes sometimes the publisher might ask you you know have you seen any games that you've particularly enjoyed anything particular to look at so they might make small talk with you but again I'd keep it relatively brief because you don't want to waste time in that meeting albeit you do want to make a human connection if you're gonna show multiple games in that meeting then I think it's worth mentioning that up front at the very beginning and saying these are the games that I have which ones would you like to look at I'll often have a cell sheet with me an a4 sheet which just shows the basic you know an image of the game a little bit about the the gameplay and I'm guessing they're largely going off the image when I show those to them because they'll say well they'll lay them out nicely let's have a look at this one you know because they can see it's covered in dice well they can see this one's a party game or whatever you know so they'll pick largely based on the images I think but really what you want to describe to them when you're talking through these are this you know four or five different things I've got to show you what you're trying to tell them is what's the hook okay not how to play the game but what is the hook what is the one thing that makes this game special okay with pick Coco my game the hook was it's a trick-taking game where you can't see your own cards okay with thrown my hook was it's a trick-taking game but you don't have cards you have dice they're pretty strong hooks right they make that
game stand out as being something fairly unique I'm aware of one other trick taking game where you use dice I'm aware of one other as I think unpublished trick-taking game where you can't see your own cards both come after my games and so when I was pitching those games they were pretty unique concepts I think thrown was a little bit too unique because it never found a market and I think that was probably because people are looking for stuff that's relatively familiar okay they don't there there's thousands of games out there they consumers a lost okay there amongst the mix they want to find something that is very similar to what they've played before so you've got to tell them why this is a special product that's gonna stand out amongst this other stuff but not scare people away so what makes your game a great product why is it gonna do amazing things for this publisher if it's just like everything else even if it's got some clever little you know gameplay twists but basically it looks and feels very much like every other game then your chances are relatively low of any sort of success some publishers will be willing to kind of stretch their remit you know look outside of the sort of things that they would normally do and when I was making this video I thinking about this video I approached a few publishers that I I have contact with and an ass they're sort of views on designer publisher relationships cuz I'm gonna make another video on that broader sort of topic of relationships habiib are cat from hell batik who make games
like this misty and Bandido and hippo and omerta he came back to me and said he doesn't mind people pitching something that might stretch his line but he wants that person to tell him why he should be interested why it might be beneficial for hell batik to do that okay and I suspect if you showed him something that was wildly outside what he'll batik normally do then the answer would probably be no other publishers Jamie Stegman for example from Stone mire games who make wingspan and Jamie stigma has very strict criteria about what sort of games he would be interested in publishing for stone mine he loves all sorts of games you can see from his videos how enthusiastic he is about you know thousands of different games but that doesn't mean stone Maya would produce them because they have to fulfill very specific criteria that you can find on his website so I suspect you could irritate certain publishers if you approach them and you hadn't done the proper research you hadn't looked at their website their submission guidelines so do that work upfront and make sure you're not wasting anyone's time so in that pitch where is this pitch happening is the first thing okay so at conventions often you will be pitching on the table in that convention hall with thousands of consumers all around you thousands of of people looking to buy games I've often had people coming up and standing and staring at me while I'm pitching which can be quite distracting I've had instances where the
publisher sisters had to go and deal with a customer in the middle of my pitch again quite distracting other publishers perhaps slightly bigger customers and slightly bigger convention so at essence spiel for example you'll often go off into behind a closed door into a little sort of hut which is immediately next to the stall you know and you're surrounded by stock so you've got very little space just a small table you certainly can't get all the components out you're going to get out a few pieces and put them on the table and you've still got all the background noise from that convey some of the bigger publishers again you might get taken off into a conference room which is slightly separate from the convention hall and that's a very sort of comfortable place to be pitching but could be quite intimidating because it all feels very professional and formal at that point other publishers will take you off down a little alley and you'll find a a little corridor somewhere in the convention hall and sit on the floor outside the toilets or on the steps and try and set up and play your game there so you've got to be adaptable in these situations as I said I would start with a bit of small talk work out which games they want to see and then I'm gonna go in with the hook and then start trying to pitch to them now when I'm pitching do not spend too much time on the theme okay when people come to our play test group which meets weekly often new designers will come along and we asked them about their game in their setting up and they could spend 20 30 minutes telling us about the theme alone you know they've got so much background lore and and they created this world and they want to tell you about it and it's irrelevant to me as a play tester and
it's irrelevant to the publisher when you're pitching it to them so it's enough to say this is a fantasy world this is a sci-fi world where we're playing a game about building a castle whatever it is very very brief on the theme ok actually very brief on the gameplay as well you don't want to go into great detail about how the game works and and and you know every little mechanism that's in there just stick to the key information this is for two to four players it takes this long to play it's for this age group it's similar to these other games show them a sample turn ok this is what you might be doing on your turn these are the sort of decisions that you make in the game you'll have some of the pieces out on the table where not all of them and I will actually stack the deck of cards I'll make sure that if I'm dealing out a hand of cards there getting some interesting cards to look at ok I don't want to give them just a random set and then find that they just accidentally ended up with the most boring hand of cards you could get in the game I want to give them an example of how the game is when it's at its best ok stacking the deck is one thing I don't script my conversation ok I've seen this advice online quite a lot that you should really prepare your pitch and practice and practice and practice work out what you're gonna say and I disagree I think a pitch is as much if not more about making a personal connection with the other person even more so than it is about selling the concept of your game because that game
will come and go but a good relationship with that publisher can carry on for years and years and they'll meet you time and again and you might have multiple games in the future with that publisher so you need to get to know them and that means if you're sticking to a script and you're just on send then you're not building that relationship you need to be on receive you need to be listening to the publisher you need to be asking questions and responding to the information they give you use active listening when they when you ask them a question repeat the answer back to them okay if they tell you what they want for the next two years and say okay so I've understood what you want is this this this and this is there a timescale on that you know how soon do you need to see it next few months or I'll show you it next year at this same convention you know or get excited about that sound fantastic yeah I'd love to see a party game by your company or well whatever you know get involved with that conversation I think that's more important than your pre-prepared script you need to be adaptable you need to to go where the conversation is taking you you need to be flexible and you need to be willing to take rejection you will get a lot of rejection in this in this this world of pitching I used to be an actor okay so I used to work in the theater and I was very used to travelling long distances to go for an audition I'd spend a lot of money getting on a train sit there for hours to get there I'd have 10 minutes audition and they'd say thank you very much we'll be in
touch then I'd never hear from them again or I'd get a rejection and it was pretty devastating you know I'd do a play and there'd be a review that would come out and it would praise some of the actors and then it would pick me out as being the worst thing in the play or it or it might pick me out as being the best thing in the play but I never knew what I was going to see when I picked up those reviews and you had to develop a really thick skin and it's exactly the same in this industry you will get rejections you will get told no over and over and over again and beyond that and publishers speak in hyperbole publishers are excited about their products they they they will tell you their product is the most amazing thing the industry has ever seen okay they're used to talking in those sort of terms and so when you show them a prototype some publishers will do the same with you I have had publishers tell me that my game I remember Percoco showing it to people that was an interesting journey because it was so such an odd sort of game for people to see I remember a publisher telling me it was the most exciting twist on trick-taking he had seen in years and and they produce a lot of trick-taking games this company and then he didn't go on to publish the game after the events we've had got too excited about that it would have been very disappointing I had another publisher who told me that nobody would ever publish Pico Coe because the card holders were were too expensive too unwieldy they meant the box was too big it couldn't possibly be published and and again you know such hyperbole it couldn't ever happen and yet it did pick Coco was released brain
games did a wonderful job with it the card holders were the selling point of that game and yes they did make things difficult in some ways and the game didn't set in the world like it wasn't the you know the most exciting new trick-taking the world has ever seen like that other publisher told me but it did pretty well thank you very much so you've got to take on board what they tell you and say thank you and have a little chuckle to yourself and then move on and just learn the lessons as they come do you leave a prototype with the publisher I think in principle you should be thinking of leaving prototypes with publishers wherever possible aside from anything else you want them to test that game as soon as possible while it's still fresh in their mind publishers will often tell you oh you can give us a print and play file if you like and actually if you do give prints and play files my suspicion is it just slows the whole process down and your game may never get played I actually that's unfair because I do know some publishers where they specifically want print and play files and they come back to me very quickly and tell me that they they've played the game and they like to or they did like it so it is worth talking to the publisher and trying to get a feel for that but I'm always skeptical when a publisher says they're willing to do a print and play file because I've often had the situation where they've said that I've sent the print and play files and then I've never heard anything back and you just left wondering did they even make it did they even play it or did I fall the first hurdle that they didn't even bother to construct the game because they're so busy and they weren't that excited about it so I try and hand over a physical prototype wherever possible but some publishers don't want
them because they've only got so much room in their luggage and things like this so you got to be open to that I take let's say I had 12 meetings for a game at a convention I would probably take about six or seven prototypes for that because I know that some of the companies are going to say to me you can send me one later or I'm gonna have a word with my colleagues and then I'll get back to you you know this sort of stuff so yeah I'll take about enough for about 50% and then if more people want it than that then I'll say them I'll get it sent out to you straight away in the post after the convention of course we're moving towards digital play testing because of this lockdown kovat world digital play testing possibly even digital games and I think digital pitching and providing prototypes via things like tabletop simulator and stuff like that is likely to be part of the future picture of pitching this I talked a lot about the hyperbole there and the fact that people get very excited about your games and that you might take it with a pinch of salt the clues that people are genuinely interested in your game is when you start to see signs that they're kind of positioning it within their lineup okay this is where I think I get I get genuinely excited is when the publisher is saying to me things like this would fit really well in our range wouldn't it because we could put it in the same size box as this I remember with halvah TKE talking to Haddie and Haddie and when I was showing him my game that's coming up with hell
batik later in the year and how do you think that could go in a box like a murder and murders their big game this year so it could be the next one in the line he's saying this the initial pitch and you're thinking you know you're getting quite that that's when it's a bit like when you're trying to sell a house I've heard estate agents talk about selling houses and the people are looking around talking about where their furniture would go and and what color they would paint the walls and the estate agent now knows that this is somebody who's already picturing themselves living in this house and they know that that's a really positive sign that they might make a sale so those are the sort of clues that I'm looking out for I've had publishers say to me you know this game this could be the dice game version of our really popular card game or perhaps this could be the card game version of our really popular board game with a few tweaks and of course that gets me excited and I'm very I'm very open and adaptable I'm quite happy for them to say let's change the theme you know I remember a publisher saying you know we've got this particular license that we want you know how would you feel if we put this license onto your game well obviously I would feel great about that I I'm not attached to the game in its current form with the artwork even the rules the name none of that is set in stone for me I'm happy for the publisher to use their judgment on that as long as they keep me in the loop and we're going to move on in the next video to talking about the longer-term sort of publisher designer relationship okay so what do you do
after this pitch after these conventions I follow up pretty much immediately within a couple of days I'll send an email saying thank you very much for meeting with me thank you for your time it was great to meet you and then I'll leave it for at least three months okay that's probably around the time where I might start thinking about chasing people up and saying have you had a chance to play if not no worries but just wondered if you had any feedback yet by three months if somebody's genuinely excited about the game then often you'll have had some sort of Inklings some emails asking you some questions about the game or even an offer of publication but for other companies it can take an awful lot longer to get a final decision so that three months sort of check check in with the publisher can sometimes just give a little bit more information where they'll say well actually we're just going into our stage of selection or whatever and you'll hear from us in the next month or two and and you know and it also keeps you in mind and helps to build that relationship but don't pressure don't keep on writing to people and don't get angry word spreads quickly in this industry you don't want to beat make yourself a difficult person to deal with because publishers will talk to each other and that can make your life difficult so I think that's about all that I have to tell you about pitching if you enjoyed it please watch some my other videos as I say I've got a video coming up on publisher designer relationships but I've got loads of other videos about game design and and just games in general actually so what's
my channel Adams board game Wales on Twitter I'm at board game Wales and on board game he come out in 78 thank you very much watching all the best