Rebirth Review, Game of the Year 2024 Contender - No Questions Asked, No Doubt About it.
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and this is our review of reper no spoilers but this might be one game of the year is it already oh come on you you need to keep it for later might be keep it for later guys uh like it hit the Subscribe button find out why and find out why uh in in 30 seconds after the do
thats it's a Vibe for you B all we need what to be what be G GI for you and me what what here what you play see rebirth is a new tile laying game by RNE ketsia where you're going to be rebuilding the lands of Scotland and Ireland through the power of tile laying on your turn it's pretty straightforward you're going to take a tile from your bag and place it on the board and you're going to place it in the matching space in this case energy versus energy and you're going to score a point Not only would I get a point I can also put a castle out because I've placed my tile adjacent to a castle on a future turn if I place a matching tile see energy next to an existing matching tile I'll score a number of points equal to the group that I've created in this case I'll get another two points but watch out what if another player comes by and starts placing their tiles nearby as well well at the moment absolutely nothing but once they've created more adjacent tiles than I have they kick my castle off and they place their Castle on and they'll be scoring points at the end of the game instead of me further to that if I place
a tile next to one of these Cathedrals like these yellow spaces here I get to mark it and get one of these fantastic objective cards watch all ask me to go and do something by the end of the game if I can do that that's going to be a bunch of bonus points that I will score at the very very end we're going to keep going until we run out of tiles and it's the person with the most point at the end that's the winner and if you want a more strategic crunchier version of this game rebirth has another map on the back which has slightly more rules for those that want a slightly more advanced game all right when you spoil it already this F ready you really like this game it's great I really like this game it's a great game so that's that's it thank you for see you we'll see you soon byebye let's dig into why though right that what game so this is uh as we saw in the little overview a t Lane game it's a rhia design it is reminiscent of some of his other stuff that he's done before like ha or t frees or through the desert that sort of thing but way more accessible than that it is and it's so much fun you say accessible yeah and I'd say distilled yeah it's Mr roia Dr sorry doctor uh all this a lot of his very wellknown games distilled into this yeah uh because you
got yes the to placement game that that you got here you got the cut rting bits where you need very interactive with the with the others um there is a strategy there especially on the on the island map cuz again this game comes with the on the same board you got the Scotland side you got the island side where the where the Scotland one is the more accessible more tactical um but probably it's the one that you want to to introduce people to the game yes but then if you want something a little bit more meaty you go on the island side that is where it levels up and it's magnificent and it's a it's a two very different games depending on the map because okay the Scotland one the mechanics is very much the same there is one different mechanics with the um um with the cathedral uh but this one everybody's got secret objective that you can pick up while the other ones you will have open objectives where everybody fights for them and that is uh it's such it's so so good um Matt what I really like about the mechanisms of this game and as we saw in the overview the principle of it is really simple you have a tile which you've already drawn from your last round you look at it for a little while and then you decide what can I do that's going to get me the most amount of things yeah that's it and then I'll place it if it's a house tile like this one well that tells me it has to go in a house space one of the villages one of the settlements okay
okay what could I do I could put it here I could get me two points straight away fantastic but then if I put it here it would get me maybe not any points but it would get me a castle here and actually also it would get me a cathedral here which means I can get a card here and potentially oh maybe I've already done that for Five Points at the end of the game so there's some really great decision making all done through one tile one single tile that's it and um yeah that that makes the game um very Snappy of the incredibly Snappy the start at the end it's when when you got less decision that is when the let's option that's when the games can go a little bit like oh wow okay I really need to plan now what is going to happen but I love the interactivity with the other players my gosh this area control with the castle a me justful and the way it's it's seamless sort of stays out of the way like for example in this scenario here Matt has control of this Castle because he's got one of his tiles there but if I come along with one of my tiles okay that's a tie nothing happens but if I come along with the second one I I kick him F off and you take control of that and that's my castle now but I can try then in further F the um turns to add another tire TI another and then he kicks it back and now it's surrounded and that's locked down for the rest of the game and if you think about this mechanisms with four players when everybody's trying to fight for that
castle that is really really good again there is always the uncertainty of what you're going to pick up from the from the back and again just um to be precise this bag in this Edition is the kickstarter deluxe edition that includes these bags um while I think the retail version will not have the bag but um you just have the tile face down on your on your table and just flip the one that you want to take um this makes your life much easier it's nice too uh and it's a very nice component but um this we're talking about this is the the kickstarter deluxe version what also like about this game when you are placing your tiles is everything is scored as you go right so you place a tile place if I place the tile by itself it would be a point I place another tile of the same type next to it two points place a third one three points so it escalates it's encouraging you to create these big groups clusters of the same CL of time and encourage the other player to cut you off yeah so that's it CU if I seen Wayne started getting three points now four points now Five Points six points and next turn I need to do something and you need to cut them down so you probably don't want to um you're not going to get much coring putting a tile to block Wayne but it's going to stop him from getting even more points that means that I'm still gaining still gaining in the end yeah ideally you work it in such a way where you can block someone off while also growing your
existing cluster somewhere or block someone off to allow you to create your own new cluster off of their sort of where you sto them it's really really cool just a really wonderful pleasing it design that is very simple and talking about the scoring so as we said on the Scotland map uh when you put your tiles on one of the um uh Cathedral you will draw one of the of the scoring things and you would need to try to do whatever the cards tell you at the end at the end of the game uh what kind of missions are this going to be like oh have the longest Coster line um or um control of a specific Cathedral or have the board next to England which is a really cool one yeah yeah yeah or different clusters several clusters have control in settlements is so it's all kind of that and then at the end of the game of course the tower will score you points as well these are Big at the end of the game each one of these castles that you still have on the board It's Five Points each yeah you get like 25 30 points sometimes by having your castles out it's huge huge swing what I was going to say earlier was about the um the mechanisms where you to pull out something from a back yes now it's not a roll of a die no but it's still got your your randomization of of the action that you can do uh now I can see um some people starting being frustrated when
you start pulling out the wrong tile one after the other however this game it gives you the option to always do something with the toes that that you got so um I saw I saw you people getting frustrated about like oh I really needed that oh I really needed that it's not coming out it's not coming out but you can could actually use the wrong tiles to go somewh always get something somewhere completely different on the map and do something different cuz again in this game you don't need to build a cluster from one single space you can go whatever you want yeah exactly you don't have to you don't constantly have to grow you can I'll go here and then the next turn I'll go over here and the next turn I'll go in this corner it might be if you don't have the right the right tile you can use that to block someone off exactly or do something else interesting so um I I saw a r a coule of like oh I don't like the the the random in Des it's not actually that random and on top of that it's one of three things right yeah is a is a power it's a farm or or or it's a house um and and that's very much you know that that's going to be one of those three and on top of that if you started getting all your houses out at the start of the game you know that you're not going to have it at the end so you need to start planning your games thinking about all right I'm leaving the house the house game out toward the end of the game concentrate on something else so um yeah random but not that random it's not
you're not rolling a D20 hoping to get a 20 if you are good at the game you will score more points than people that are not good at the game yes it's yes it's um it's very much it's very much dead there's not much of a random it's not like you win accidentally you win through playing well no no no and and then with touching that thing you an expert player will always have a lot of Advantage correct from uh from LS um but you don't have to play the game in the Cutthroat way if you want you can play this pretty chill if you really want to especially on this side of the map which actually I think is bit more relaxing and less intense than the other side because it's is the more tactical map so you are more just making a decision based on what you have at the time this game also has like an interesting Arc but you know how it says it sort of slows down I don't think it slows down at the end I think it slows down in the middle because it starts pretty quick and then as things start to fit up it it slows where you have these really interesting decisions to make and then at the end you're more limited so you go I I have this tile it has to go here I Have This Ti Do see what I mean I it's more of like a a bell curve I guess and it depends a lot as well on how the other players will play the game correct yeah uh cuz if you got the ones that likes to build their own little garden around in a in a single area um or you got the very aggressive one they're just like trying to cut everybody and and trying to go for the for the towers or just steal all the towers or yeah or or quickly rush to get objectives and then
work towards those there's a few different ways that you can play the game and I I really like it you can either just like you're saying Matt just focus on getting as many towers as possible and protecting them or you can rush out to all of the cathedral spaces get as many cards and work towards those or you can just do groups of tiles and score that way so and doing a blend of those is probably going to get you as many points as someone that focuses entirely on one way there's a few different ways to play and they're all satisfi and yeah and uh it's not like one way is going to make you win the game all the time cuz it's uh it's very you don't know what the other play to to um we touched about the difference between the two um the two map do we want to go a little bit more in depth why this is more tactical while the other one is more strategic yeah should we should we cut maybe yeah let's uh let's go to the other map let's do it and if you we're inel like magic we moved from Scotland to Ireland uh yeah now this map is the one that we said is a little bit more meteor but but in a in a different way not that the Scotland one is not it's just like this gives you a very different way of playing G feeling um same rules same rules is yeah but structured slightly differently yes so where in the Scotland map you'd be placing your Cathedrals and then getting these uh these Mission cards to complete by yourself in the Ireland map the missions are public as you can see here
uh down the line and they are done very differently because they are public it is a first come first served to get the maximum points for all these misss ex and all the seconds all the ones arriving after they will take some points but not less points not as many yeah not the big points and so that makes that really interesting because then suddenly the game slows down becomes much more strategic because you're thinking okay now what can I do with my tile that will get me towards as many of these together as possible while also trying to get castles while also trying to get close to these towers which will give me different bonuses which adds another wrinkle to the game yeah so the tower so the there no um Cathedral anymore we're moving to the to the towers each Tower will have a different powers there if you're close to that Tower you will get a bonus for example one of the tower will let you for your next turn get three tiles and decide which one you want to pick that is a massive massive uh another one that will let you play another tile straight after from the b super cool another one that if you're close to two of the the same you get points yeah bum bum like like there um some of this will let you put a a per two on one of the cards that means that if you're going to score that card you're going to get double the points just you you're going to get double the points that becomes public knowledge so if I then put my my my multiplier on one of these objectives
everyone else at the same knows that and so then you're put yeah yeah yeah um but it's very much and on on on top of that the bigger difference from the map itself is that on this map on the island one there's way open more open tiles that means that when when there is no either a farm or a or a power plant you can play you can put whatever you want between the two then makes your decision you you got more options absolutely this makes it wider it makes it uh more crunchy it means because it's so broad I where I put my tile is now a different Beast yes like this can go almost anywhere so then I going to look at these okay how can I get the most out of that as well it's and the open market it makes it this the of the two version this is the most interactive the most cat Troy because the on the Scotland one you got your secet objective you're going to play your game and at the end of the game is going to be like oh I did this and I did that and I did that well done me yeah on this one it's like oh when is going to go for that or when he's going I need to stop it I need to stop it or I see all the players like oh oh my God I need to score one of the scor yeah so so so this is more Cuts red this is the the one that you feel uh not having a catchup mechanisms you you'll feel it more yes uh because if you're behind you're behind yeah it's rough um but in in a
good I think rough yeah yeah in a very good way it's it's still it's a more competitive way of playing this game impressive way of playing this game a more more strategic more thinky way of playing this game so I think we all when we played this for the first time we went ooh now what do I do where's where's on the Scotland side it's like oh I've got my tile it's going to go here it's gonna go here boom it's going to go here this is a different beast and this is not an expansion this is not a Kickstarter this is the game so I just want to stress it out the two maps are the same the same in the same box that again we'll talk about production wise but keep in mind because it's what you're getting in this box is a lot of it's a lot yeah a lot of lovely game time it really really is Matt you did mention production and I think it's probably time we let's go let's talk about that so Matt let's throw it over to you uh because I mean I don't I almost don't need to say anything I think because this is such a beautiful looking game it really pops on the table and more to the point this is all in the Box yes uh so all the pieces are absolutely gorgeous let's start let's start artwork artwork is fantastic stunning uh all the colors readability everything looks absolutely great on the table you got a great table presence the map is is it's large and full of colors and um it's really really what I really like to do keep looking at the map CU
you will see little details little details and stuff and uh well we know a few of the guys that work on this on the artwork this and they did an absolute brilliant job it's beautiful I love this game how it looks and you got the between the irand and the and the Scotland they all change all the Minor Details that you want to go there and actually see it if you are from island or Scotland you will see your your cities around the map and how they are drawn everybody's all the cities are different so this is a full artwork and absolutely great I mean you can see the style this it's kind of like almost um mang not manga but you know like Japanese anim like yeah hyper realized it's wonderful it's so nice I really really like it and then component wise uh we need to talk about this these castles are great so the cast the um this piece is amazing apart from they look stunning TS to well well done to you know who Max call you out great piece uh they design the the single pieces um all the fact that all the cathedral stuck together with a different with a different colors and create this lovely tow um but what is it this made of of remind me rewood all of the pieces in this are rewood there's not a bit of plastic in this box it is
amazing thing yeah congratulations to what a fabulous thing this is what this is what we want to see um uh mighty bols took took a heat in terms of like costing and everything they could have easily do this with plastic and no one would have said much about it but since the team of the game been the rebirt of of of of Planet hurt and trying to to go more towards again that um ecological side and trying to yeah keep this prodction um and they they produce in Europe so so you can think about what costing and what more as well yeah pain must have been to to go to to get this PES and the production ends up being absolutely fantastic and what I really like about these cuz these castles could have been tiles yeah but what I love about this is it gives the the board State such a tremendous readability yeah right you see at a glance okay how many of you got out okay great and I can see that compared to the tiles which obviously on a different they're on different plane right the front of the floor if these were tiles as well it would also be a little bit more fiddly and I'd be trying to focus more wait is that a castle or is that a tile yeah really gives that great usability that user experience it really lifts that up it adds a great verticality to the board which I think is wonderful and the other things is uh the the actual tiles each player different colors and different shapes different shapes you can see so
they're all different each player will have the the the different cuts so again this things is very thoughtful uh not needed the color would have been enough cuz they're all very this pastel colors that really pop on the on the green of the of the maps uh but it's a great addition a um and again um I'm not sure what's the plan from mighty boards if you can buy the the bags in the future uh you could always get some can bags of Amazon uh if you really wanted to yeah exact just to put the all the it is nice to do that it's not nether the first time that we played uh rebirth we didn't had the bags back in ukg yeah back like seven months ago or or something or something like that and it did work absolutely fine as well abely F not necessary but yeah if you don't have the kickstarter version grab some canvas bags off Amazon or wherever your favorite one place you want to get them from and it will Elevate the experience a little bit and I think production wise we set it all 10 out of 10 for me yeah very well done guys absolutely Matt let's talk about who this game is for yes okay Wayne um who do you think this game is for and give me some Alternatives if I like this what I would like or if I like those games I would like rebird I think firstly um this I feel is either right at the top of the beginner category of gaming or is at the bottom of the intermediate we're going
to have to have a debate about that because the rules are so clean and it's like two pages of rules it's so simple but the game depth that you get out of it and we cover that in our final thoughts is a lot um so I think it's there it's there or thereabouts right begin begin to intermediate at the most if you like uh if you want something more complex definitely into intermediate to Advan you want probably want hang or yellow and yansi same so we're talking about unfortunately that's what it does it does it really really well really well that's kind all all through the desert is another one in that style where you're trying to do as much as you can with one thing that you place yeah I I will say one will be my my go-to if I want something similar a little bit more complex correct yeah I I would more rules more pieces more interaction more interaction it's more Agro in in a very amazing way W I recommend 100% one of the best game ever made yeah great game um if you want simp you got a classic which is kassan yes so which has a similar feeling where you're playing competitively placing tiles uh but is way more laidback in terms of its area control it has some when you when you're building the um the for the forts together castles together uh you're trying to get some area there but this is uh slightly more than that yeah you got some feeling from kakas but I will say since Kasson is a very well-known game so a lot of you might have played the game might have liked it but think
it's a little bit or it's well it's nice but it's a little bit too easy or too begin this is definitely your second step if you are on that you like that kind of stuff this is definitely where you should go if you like tile laying generally if you're used to tile laying on your own board and you want to get into s a more competitive tile laying game this is one 100% going to be for you absolutely I agree full on um yeah it it takes that whole uh normally when we think of T Ling we think of our let's suppose multiplayer soliter I take a tile from a market and it goes this is the other way around so we're T laying the other way around so we're taking from our own Supply and they're going on the central board in a competitive way and if that's something that's new to you you should very much have a look at this game what about you Matt who do you think this is for um I do agree 100% of what you just said um I do not agree on the complexity but we'll talk about it on our on our thought um but yeah for these are this is the game this is um this is what is for and uh and it's a really really good game so um even if you're not if you never play a TP placement game this is a game I would say like then try this one but if you never like a top placement game I would say like then play this one first I yeah absolutely um in terms of things like theme I mean this theme is completely innocuous I think the artwork is amazing and is really got a wonderful appeal I think the production is again Great Wide
appeal um the theme doesn't really come through in the game but it does come through into in the production the production is beautiful yeah but I feel like and and the fact of having all all it's all about rebuilding her after um a postapoc very pretty one yeah in um but it comes out with the fact that there is not a single piece of plastic in the in the game that they're using rewood and all that kind of stuff so yeah the team is not touched to the actual mechanic of the game but it's attached to the game in a different way and I still really like the this this this fact absolutely Matt should we go into our final thoughts yeah let's let's talk about let's cut to that and we'll talk about that how good the game is this this Weir good so Matt you mentioned that you were kind of on the fence as to whether you agreed where this complexity lies um because I I think it's quite weirdly enough it's quite a hard one to judge yeah um so you were talking about end of the beginner and starting of the intermid to me this is like bang on intermid just because exactly what we discussing between the two maps Okay so in the game you got two games that's true one that is um that one is told with the beginners that is the Scotland map what you got the um the the Island map that is toward the top in to mod not Advanced but can if if you play with with um with other players that are probably Bard Gamers he can be really
really crunchy crunchy so um that's why to me it makes it bang on on the intermet that's a sound argument and I think I'll take that for me that's good it's uh if you took the two maps and averaged it out yeah well both in the Box both exactly absolutely so it probably sits in intermediate but what about more final thoughts Matt on on rebirth as a product as a game we fell in love with this game um a while ago yeah we did um and after we played them uh the first times we talked about this a lot we couldn't wait to play it again and uh when we finally managed to to play it again we played a lot we played it a lot yeah uh and I see this being a game that we going to play and play and play it's a game that uh in the in the B stupid family we got three copies out of four and we bought every single copy yeah there no R you got these we B because we really like the product and it's right that uh people like Mighty Bard in this case should get uh their money for for for a fantastic product yeah absolutely this is um without doubt I think uh what definitely in my my top three games of the year for sure it's not even a question it's so so good there's so much I like about this game it's so satisfying to play it is easy to learn it has complexity where you want it it is deep you have the choice of style if
you want more tactical or more strategic you can teach it in five minutes or less two minutes and get playing minutes it is very table which I mean you can just oh what do you want to play we'll play rebirth 45 minutes boom we'll set it up in five minutes and we can get going yeah and you can play with Mom and you can play with your best friends and you can with a with with a bunch of people that never played a ball game or you can play with a bunch of people that plays a lot of ball games this is this is why is it makes it one of those um modern classic like Cascadia for example that great that is simple to learn simple to teach but at the same time always Del us even if you played it 100 times yeah I mean I mean we we played a lot of games Matt and um as soon as we sat down and played this the first time I took like there three or four turns in I was like yeah this like yes this is really good is it it's like yeah yes it is derivative of other ksia games fine but I don't care I think the way this is done is amazing yeah what's what's the problem with that I don't see why there is no problem with that exactly this is this is this is a a feature not a bug no it's as as I st at the start this to me is distilling what what is done in the last 20 years and giving us almost not not his final product sorry Sor do I know you got to brought out another 100 games I hope so accessible design but so
far very accessible design I feel that is all learned in the in the industry in the last 20 years and put it in this product and um I love it you love it I love it I love it we we this a strong recommendation for sure easy peasy yes uh should we say if this gets the Seal of Excellence or not we haven't discussed it no but let's do do it 3 2 1 you're getting two two for me get absolutely absolutely uh this game again we said it it's in your top three of the yeary it's very much easily my top three of the Year top if it's not top three top four um but again um which where it ends up you going to have to wait and see for we got some plans got some plans for that yeah but what a game rebirth is I absolutely love it well done Mighty boards so that was our review of rebirth by Mighty boards Matt what game fantastic uh I'm so glad that games like this exist that is that is my thing it's one of these games that I'm happy my life is is slightly better because games like this exist what do we always say on the channel what's our main concern we love games and we want to fun we fun we want to have fun and this is that game it is a fun experience uh it's a it's a wonderful wonderful game is a perfect game probably not does it need to be a perfect game no no it is to be
fun that's what it is we're not talking about um Competitive Gaming super heavy the level it's a fun game absolutely um amazingly produced with a stunning artwork and it plays great you got two maps what else do you want it's wonderful we we love this this game can't say it anymore but what do you think have you played rebirth if you haven't then we think you really should and let us know what you think in the comments below uh and if you liked this review you can also check out the rest of our stuff and you can hit the Subscribe button come that absolutely exactly it's it's a wonderful thing that Everyone likes yeah especially us and uh our life is going to be slightly better knowing there you following us because uh we love you all yeah absolutely like this video so the great algo God can be rebirthed a you as praise be to him and we will catch you again real soon me what what for you and me what what here what you some play and see