Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arcs Review. Is It Really THAT Good?

Transcript 38:58

hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and this is our review of ARS you may have heard of this game it's been all over the Internet uh and if you haven't heard of this game then we hope to at least bring you some information on it that will give you an idea of if it's for you or not and that's what we do with our reviews uh and if you'd like to know what we think of the most hyped Game of the Year a lot of fun HP well hit the hype button sorry the Subscribe button hype button also accurate hit that button and uh get ready to go into hypers space with us yeah let's let's talk about all this hype H should we go let's go let's Get

Hype rolling dice feeling nice cboard dreams and game GS CL subscribe it's a Vibe for two B all we need what's it what it g news for you and me what you what you here's what you should play and see arks is a condensed Space Opera for two to four players that plays in up to 120 Minutes Des designed by Cole Worley and published by leader games ARX uses trick taking as its main action selection mechanism and if you're the lead player you're going to be leading a card and then performing the actions on it depending on the suit of the card for example this Administration card allows me to tax or repair or influence other players are going to be copying or pivoting to do a different type of action alternatively they may surpass by playing a higher value of the same suit of the lead card giving them the ability to go first next round and set the pace of the chapter other things that you can do with your cards could be to move around the map exerting your power or battling other players destroying their ships for the warlord ambition or potentially putting influence on the

court deck thus giving you amazing Powers potentially for the rest of the game unless someone comes in and raids you for those very cards after all of this battling and all of this jockeying for position and all of the declaring of Ambitions it's the person with the most power or victory points that will be the winner okay um let's start saying that the box that you can see here next to us is the blighted reach expansion box uh that was actually part of the Allin pledge when ARS came out uh but for this review we are talking about the core game the core game only yeah we played a lot the core game we haven't started the um the the expansion that is the campaign style a but um the good things is that the C box goes everything goes inside the the expansion box that's why is here and on top of that is a prettier box absolutely that's what we have right here yeah but yeah this is the premises of the video so is the review of the core game now let's start talking about the hype there was around this game and why it's been the top 10 hottest games for a while now yeah absolutely so uh leader games is a company uh which has Cole Worley as one of the what the key designer I guess for that company and he has designed games uh such as root which

is one of our favorite at present our favorite game ever um and also other amazing games like John company and I think he did Pat did o yeah did he's part of that design team at leader which makes um really critically well acclaimed interesting Avant guard designs yes which always aard is defin right which always brings something interesting and freshh to board gaming which is why when they come out with something new and something interesting there's always a lot of Buzz yeah uh and they normally do things in conjunction with uh Kyle thin who is the in-house artist who has this amazing art style and all of these things together I think lend itself to people getting very excited about these games people love Co Worley's designs uh and when he comes out with something yeah again do they love it or most of them love it most most of some of them don't really go along very well that's why I think there was the lot of B Bel this game cuz he one of those um both the designer uh leather games and the they do a lot of like what in the UK we will call a maride game so games that you you love them oh it's difficult to be in the gray area yeah it's quite a challenge to feel H I kind of like this yeah you with with with leader games designs cold world designs specifically it's it's very much love or hate I think and this one

spoiler it's nothing different yeah it is it's quite a and I think if you look at uh there are quite a few reviews of arcs at this point and lots of forum posts if you go on Board Game Geek there are tons of posts discussing this game all sorts of things about this game uh which we'll try and dig into a little bit of it um but we're just going to give you our our thoughts our unfiltered thoughts on on how we feel this game is uh and we will go from there Matt let's start mechanically around how this game works and we talked a little bit about it in the introduction but this is ostensibly an action selection game that uses trick taking as as the expression by which you select your actions exactly um so the when the first time that I heard about this game when he what it was like a couple of years ago now and uh it's like oh they're making a Space Opera with trick take and I was like what what uh and until I actually played it yeah I was still like how is this is going to work yeah um it does work it works it does work works great it works in um mechanically wise very very well yeah um kind of like infuriating frustrating sometimes uh I get really um frustrated game but um uh but it it does work plus on top of that let's put the uh the area control area majorities well

um the very simple mechanic for the for the battles yes um so again it does work I don't know how but it does work but they've done it really well yeah and it's it's fascinating right because there's a lot of things to think about with this trick taking element which is kind of like pseudo pseudo trick taking yes because you don't necessarily win a trick of cards what you really win is the chance to go first and lead the next hand right lead the next actions and that brings with it a bunch of benefits right if you lead you can typically dictate the flow of the play you can uh typically have more actions than anyone else um it gives you a lot of advantages if you can if you can lead the hand which will allow you to potentially also declare Ambitions which is the only way to score points score the points so again the cards um each cards will have a different um uh seed a different um action that you can do some of them will let you construct or repair some ship some of others will let you battle some of them will will let you put influences on the uh on the council that is actually the open the open market um some of them will will manage will let you tax the the planets that you got um and uh to get to get resources and use resources for for other things so it's it is crucial to start when you start to get the first position and drive the game yeah cuz this is where the comes

the frustration comes if you never manage to win a trick so to be the first player you're always going to be the second that you always going to have to hope that the other person the other player is going to play this or that seed um that's yeah that's where the the the a lot of the frustration around the game the game comes yeah because it's it's entirely on you as a person and how you feel about games whether it's a bug or a feature that most of the most of your hands will not necessarily benefit you right and I think most of the game you will be doing one action right most most of your most of your your actions will be one thing you'll be copying the lead card or as the game calls it pivoting to do something different but each time you are not surpassing I.E winning the trick trick you are doing one thing uh and it's like I said it's you'll either like that or you really won't like that and it'll be quite annoying um and like me have debated this a bunch I mean it is it is entirely in by design of the game it where it says here's your probably crap hand of cards uh deal with it it is yeah yeah it's uh how can you deal with it and it's it's a heavily tactical game I think we need to underline that it is it's a very very very tactical game there is almost no strategy for say like probably no strategy at all just because every turn you you're going to get given different cards and if you never win the

trick you cannot play exactly how you would have would have played those cards you always need yeah you're always on the kind of like on the back foot of what's going to happen and need to change yeah with whatever the other players are doing yeah I think the there is strategy but it's in a restrained scope so the scope of your strategy is in each chapter only yes so like you go here's what I have so my my tactical decisions are going to be by chapter by chapter and within this chapter I've got this what order do I play them in right because if I know I'm not going to lead I have a few strategic decisions but it's not like a grand strategy game where I'm going to look at the start maybe like brass Birmingham which I think of a very strategic game where at the start of it you can be like okay I want to start here my here's my hand and the whole era I'm going to try and plan that out and maybe execute it this certainly is it is the opposite absolutely um it is a fascinating design though it's bold I mean there's there's something to be said for absolutely aggressive and it is very aggressive yes you will have to fight and elbow your way for everything in this game in the galaxy to get to get every single point um again it's um it's not a forgiving game it's not forgiving you could be you could be the one especially like in games like a a three player count you could be the one in the middle of the other two and just getting beaten this

guy and just getting beaten and um there is not a real catch up mechanisms or anything like that so if you do something wrong at the start you might pay it for a long time might get stomped exactly um let's quickly dig into this again as well so we've talked a little about the trick taking mechanism but when you lead cards if you lead with a high suit you're probably going to also lead with the next there is a mitigation for that which is you can choose to play two cards and seize the initiative but it does mean you'll be playing one less round than anyone else so you discard two cards to get the first play in Mark but you pay a very pricey cost because you're going to have an entire turn less than other people and there are other mechanisms in the game to uh there are some of the cards that will let you play an extra turn at the end that means that potentially you could be the the only one playing two less turns than than the other player and every single action is absolutely fundamental in this game that means that even if you you lose one you could be in a very bad position at the next turn so yeah the catchup mechanism is there but it's pricey it is very pricey pay it yeah so we'll talk a little bit about these Ambitions because as we said this is the only way you score in this game and it's entirely driven by if you can lead so if you're the first player you've got the

first play marker and you play a card it will give you the chance to declare an ambition yeah depending on the value of the card each card will have its own ambition that it can be declared um and when you declare an ambition what you're saying publicly is everybody we're going to score this condition yeah so if I declare tyon I played a two and I say like at this point we're going to get these points if uh you have the highest amount of these resources yeah and then guess what that's going to trigger it's going to trigger a fight for resources pretty quickly that is everybody then try to get those scoring because um each each chapter you can um get up to three scoring points out conditions uh not always going to be all the three out cuz some player may decide that well I'm just gonna I'm just gonna so it's en yeah and it's entirely possible that someone declares Warlords twice for example and get point for it um and we'll talk about those because like I said we we did already say it's a bit of a spiky aggressive game if we do declare something like you know the Tycoon where we're looking for fuel and for building material resources you're not only you're going to be taxing your own buildings you have to fight for them you're going to be raiding people you're trying to be taking their stuff and the game fully encourages thator yeah yeah yeah absolutely and the same things goes with the warlord that is basically I need to destroy more things than everybody else so you are at that point going out to fight as all the other

player because that is one of the only way to get points so it's going to be a gigantic battle left and right uh no quarters and being really aggressive absolutely and this is one of the things in the game the game is absolutely Agro AG gr AG gr all the time there is uh yeah we haven't even touched on the cards yet which is which is the the court deck here which will be and the open market of the game which you're going to be putting influence on and these cards are also aggro yes I mean many of them are quite aggro they're like steal this from your opponent or uh take all of them all of the resources from the supply and you know you are the Cel and when they're scored they go back to you and yeah it sort of encourages that interaction where uh I always want something of yours and you're always going to want something of mine and I really like the um the council mechanisms and the the influence that you need to put so each basically each time that you can play an influence Point you're going to put one of your little men on that on that card but doesn't mean that that card is yours until you secure it but you need to have the most amount of little man on their card and I find it really interesting because then you fight even for the cards even for the cards in the open market so you kind of fighting for everything right you're fighting for the resources you're fighting uh to destroy ships yeah you're fighting to have control of different um areas you fight for yeah fight for space space you're fighting for space cu the the you can

build building around on on the the different planets but there are not that many spots yeah that means that if you really want to build something well you need to go there destroy what is in there and then build your thing absolutely and you fight for all of that and you're even fighting uh to get cards into your too um yeah it's entirely built around it and if you're not prepared for it it's going to come as a bit of a shock yes yes it's uh probably one of the more sagro game that I played in in ages do you want to talk about the the battle mechanism because I think something that I don't know how well underlined it is I think it's fabulous yeah the the combat in this game when you are doing space combat is pretty cool yeah so it's super simple each ship that you own and is in the in a fight will roll one yeah simple as that the uh the gimmick here is that you can choose between three different dyes the blue one the red ones or the orange one the blue one is literally a 50/50 is one shot or one miss you can't you can't go wrong with that yeah well I mean you can't go wrong and most of the time if if you like me you go wrong A lot of times but um the second eye the red one will have different faces some of them will have two hits that means that you can BL out one enemy ship in one go and the other one is started being like okay it's one sh one damage to to the opponent and one to yourself yeah some of them will let

all the ship in the other um from the other players shooting back at you yeah uh so we starting getting this is the risk reward dice so we started getting more risky uh the last one the very interesting one is going to be the orange one the most risky that is the only one that you can use to raise other people that means if I wants to steal something from Wayne it's not just a thing of going there and destroying his ship doesn't work like that you need to roll a certain you need to roll keys on the raid dice yeah on the raid Dice and those keys will then um you can check on the top of the of the boards there are number of keys so you need to have those number of keys to sto to steal these or that resource that the other players will have on his board or steal their card because the court cards also have keys on them so you you you you did thought you have to put men to get the cards on the from the from the C into your board and then someone can come and roll a couple of th and right back from however we need to say that the orange one is the most difficult to use because it's like it's very risky you might blow yourself up pretty pretty much um uh very easily pretty easily but it's again it's a very cool simple mechanism is and uh is is it's a chance mitigation because you can always be like all right I got four ships you just set one I do not need to roll the red dice so you can

I rolled it so I really like it it makes it less random um it's it's quite of like similar not the say similar feeling to um a simple combat is in in ti4 for example but way more mitigated from the choose that you can make it's more of a it's a contemporary take on that it is yes absolutely yeah it's a super I think it's a great great design it's absolutely fantastic it's probably one of the more the things I like the most of the game is this combat system and how they make it feel modern yeah and um and natural right the other player doesn't make any decisions just all done pretty simply so um M there anything else mechanically you want to talk about before we for the rest as we said uh there is all this like um area control where you need to have more ships in this or that system to control that system and making sure that you can tax that system or if you want to build more ship in that system you need to have the control of that system otherwise they come in and play damage and they don't really that's not what you really want um there is a piece of movement and um um and control but again the movement as well of the shipes is dictated by the cards if no one's moving it's very difficult to start moving from one place to the other um there are few things some space ports will let you shoot yourself catapults yourself on from the

to the other side of the map ideally but otherwise you moving one space at a time and if you're buttoning on the other side of the Galaxy well it's you're not going to get there in time get there certainly not by the end of the chapter that's for sure okay m so let's talk about the production and again we are going to focus this on the base game of ARS which for clarity will not include things like these holders yeah which are all from the blighted reach expansion box specifically provided to hold all of these components in the base game uh so it's a bit of a weird mismatch there so just something to note you will just be getting this stuff in the box but purely on the things that are in the Box I me such as the board and all the pieces and all the dice and the tokens Etc and all the cards I mean it's pretty good I mean it's it's fine it's all cardboard and wood which for me I know you don't like it but I no no no no in this in this case works very very well um it's very if you play root is basically very much root and it's a very good production uh the artwork again it's another Mite thing yeah you could really like it cuz I like I do love the the artwork in rout yeah um I feel slightly less on this one but that's probably that's probably me I just like the idea in roots of the cut anymore that want to wage water and burn things uh while this I felt um a little bit less um what is it that you feel a

little bit less about I think it's it's less characterized by um character that's fair uh but again the character on the cards is Fant yeah it's it those are really nice um we haven't touched about the potential um asymmetry in the game before um we're not going to go intoo many details right now but there are some cards that will let you add some a symmetry a symmetry there's and that comes in the base game as well you have leaders and law at least some of them and again that adds a symmetry um in terms of the card card production it's all F it's all good quality stuff there's really nothing to complain about I love the artwork on the cards I think it's really interesting when you read what the card does and when you see the actual illustration I think it's fantastic car Farin is is really freaking good at making those sorts of things come alive yeah yeah and uh but yeah for the rest you definitely pay the right price for a very good product I can't I can't say anything else to be honest absolutely um yeah I mean what else is there to say there was a lot of complaints I think during the campaign that these weren't screen printed but I think the argument was well they're tipped over half the sign yeah was ex like it would be an additional production cost and therefore an additional cost for the consumer uh to that much yeah I'll be honest it doesn't need it I mean I I like it as readable as possible the game did come with an option on the kick started to have uh plastic ships and I'm very glad I didn't get them because there's been some complaints that they way to the wooden one is it apparently the plastic ones

tip over very easily accidentally and that's not what you want in this game because it's crucial it's crucial that you know the board state by having them either upright or not um so I think the the production is perfectly adequate for something that it's all just cardboard wood with I think an excellent art design um and what Matt thinks is is okay yeah the the black on the board could not be for everybody yeah cuz it it makes it like very dark and slightly less readable especially because the colors are kind of a little bit more tuned down and yeah I mean some of the symbols on the board are also quite small and with the colors being quite Blended um it is hard to read which ones are what I I think that it will be my only comment about the the overall production but for the rest yeah it's uh pretty good yep all right Wayne um now this is going to be a very interesting part who is this game for or actually was he not for that's a great question I think if you are a fan of Space Opera games like Twilight Imperium um or Eclipse second Dawn but you want something a condensed in a condensed storm factor I think in two hours instead of nine yeah I I think this does achieve that in two hours the not necessarily everything but the feeling of it you are very right cuz see uh I keep saying it every time we

play I get the same level of um anxiety and frustration and joy when something goes goes good that a game like Twilight brings me yeah but um this one he condens in a couple of hours it does that feeling and I think that's quite important to note right because it's yes it's not going to have all of those spraing things like all of the politics but that's condensed down to the chat around the table because all the scoring is public you be going oh we need to stop that guy over there I need to steal that that's your negotiation in the game oh I need to steal this or you need to put influence over here you need you need to make Alliance especially if you see one of the player is very far ahead in points the other players needs to needs cuz otherwise it will keep it will keep winning um and that's brings me to the to the point where where this game is not for yes is um if you don't like very Agro game um this is this is not for you um if you don't like um it's not Randomness cuz the cards again you can you can uh you can mitigate whatever but if you get really upset not being able to do exactly what you want to do some this is not a g for you you got to if you don't like it that that you have to go into this game with the expectation right I I feel like I enjoyed this game much more when I went in thinking right everything could

possibly go wrong yeah and just kind of go along for the ride because all of your best L plans could probably just go to hell so you you need to kind of just let the game kind of happen I yeah I totally agree I don't know how I won the first time that we play and never happen again said because at that point I was very much like I don't know what if this does and I'll try this or I'll try that and I was very much more playing uh Daren at the moment when I I found out the other games I was more like okay this car that this so if I can get oh I was trying to plan too much and then B me back yeah I think that's an entirely Fair criticism I'm sure some people might may or may not disagree but I think it's a fair criticism that the game will just kind of happen in a way yes where you have you deal with what you've got and then the game will play out and that is a feature I think of the design yeah one one last things I would like to add is um if you are going into this game for the first time and you're playing with some veterans players some ones that already play like 20 30 times and they know the cards you're not going to be in for um for a pleasant ride um but it's one of those games that requires you to play and every all the players to pick more or less on the same not not that everybody needs to have out tons of hours in the game but the more

leveled is the knowledge of the game between the players the more the more enjoyable at least familiarity with the CT deck because this is the thing that swings the power of the game it's not possible to have that level of knowledge in your first game you will get crushed yeah especially because there are a Caple of cards that together can make some Combos and can make some quite powerful combos uh again there are not tons of those cards but if you know which one you need to pick you know which one you need to steal from another player or or some so um that what I would say is by same things very much like in TI first time that you play smashed you're got to get smashed but um is what it is yeah is what it is um should we talk about some uh Alternatives is this game is for if you like if you like rud yes it's very much is for you yeah I think so if you liked rot this is uh Carl Worley expressing that design principle in another way you still have public scoring yes you still have the feeling of trying to slap down the person that might be getting too far ahead right you still have that kind of scheming where root is more strategic this is more tactical where root um is sort of less card driven more sort of player board driven this is more card driven it gives you these two different expressions in how Co early designs games but they're both really aggro so

both incredibly Agro I I think and and if yeah again if you play rout and you're going into arcs you you will have kind of think you'll be like ah I I kind of get it you see where the designer is going and where he's coming from so you you you will have those things um another games that you will if as we said it we nominate it like well we talked about it like million times already uh if you're a ti4 fan and you want a distilled version of it go for it you it's a different game but you will get all the rage that you get away a you can getting CLE hours all the joy like made more intense cuz it's a shorter time frame you don't get to spread out over six to eight hours H likewise uh if you're a fan of arcs and you're enjoying it and you've never played Twilight Imperium 4 I thoroughly recommend you go and find a group and find a group and yes absolutely because you'll find that slightly stretched out experience with an emphasis on the political okay Matt it's time for the final thoughts on a very hyped very debated game um and we've had endless chats and we had too many talks about too many talks about arcs about how we feel about ARs and it's indicative I think of the design principles right it's not necessarily a bad thing that it is a provocative design no um as as I say like to you multiple time I really

wanted to not like the game it's SM rebellious streak but no you know it's it just like one of those things where like too much hype on something um yeah I got that yeah you like Punk kid mentality uh but the game is really good it gets me frustrated and uh very like every time that we play yeah and um every time while we're playing it's like not going to play this anymore and then as soon as we finish I'm like oh next time when we play do this this this um and and even say like yeah we set it up now to shoot the this video and I was like uh maybe we'll have a game later yeah right um so it it is it is really my mind and and I can't still make completely my my head on it because the question is are we going to be this hype are we going to like it this much in the year time yeah I don't know well something like rude if you asked me like here ago say like yes and today you ask me do you want to play Ruth absolutely yes but that is a general things as well because that is the asymmetry different games but that is what my question mark at the moment is in six month times is this game's going to see the table a lot or not maybe maybe not it's hard I mean I think and

we discussed this briefly that this game has a very high ceiling and I think that's a good thing because I think leaving each game thinking about what you could do differently is indicative of quite special design principle when you're thinking ah dang I could have done this oh I didn't know about that card and how it combined with this card and uh actually I could have copied here instead of pivoted um it's it's quite clever uh and when I say quite clever actually mean it's it's really really clever really clever it makes me want to play it more um I 100% recognize that there are facets of this game that people will just hate they will just absolutely hate everything about those facets you got the randomness of the cards yeah uh you can Meade but it's still you've got the ruthless nature of it you have fully AG yeah you have the fully aggro Vibe of the game uh and for some people that is just a pure no yeah it is stressful it's not a relaxing game not in for a relaxing time no it's it's a it's a roller coaster um but I think all of those things are are by Design and I do really enjoy it Matt but the thing that gets me about this game is I can't go there is not a guarantee that I'm going to have a great time when I play this game sometimes when I play this game I mean look it's just games right don't make don't Tak me serious just playing games but sometimes I'm like ah I spent you know three hours playing that and I set up and I'm like I just feel a bit deflated over it and I'd rather let's let's play River of gold

and have nice relax game and uh just everyone call forever home I think we play Forever home because re homesome doggies and feel happy and everyone everyone's happy but it's important sometimes to feel uncomfortable and I think a game that pushes that tension and that stress also lends itself to Great Moments of exhilaration and excitement and amazement and oh my god did that happen and storytelling and when you can talk about the game for the next week ah do you remember when Matt did this and blew the thing away and won with the last points at the end you're like ah you can only get that through games designed like this like this no absolutely absolutely and again we now are used to what leather games does every time they got something out and this is no no exception this is a fantastic game um so saying that Wayne would you recommend this game generally as a should we say is an expert game 100% this is in the expert level and I think that I 100% recommend this game and that I think you I do recommend it as well so it's a heavy recommendation from both stupid uh we debated quite a lot now if this game should get the Seal of Excellence or not and we decided that we're going to play the blight reach expansion that is the the mini campaign mode and uh and then

we'll talk about that and we revisit at moment it's going to be a heavy recommendation in the expert category um and the reason why we are sort of deferring it till after the blighted reach is because the I think the blighted reach was the original vision for the game for the game yeah so where base arcs was sort of pulled out as an extrapolation from the the bigger game yes I think originally it was called Big arcs and small arcs during the design Diaries so we very much need to play Big arcs MH and see how that makes us feel y uh and takes us on a roller coaster and then we will revisit but at the moment it is 100% recommended in the expert category okay Wayne this was a beefy one but it's it's not possible to no it's the this game yeah is um there is a lot to talk about it there is a lot the the hype around the game is Justified cuz he um um is such an in um Innovative and interesting game that yeah of course is there is a lot to talk cuz it's not a copy of of something else it's not similar or same same of something some other games this is its own things um as the the Le games guys that normally they're used us to and I think it's important to note that probably shouldn't believe all of the no massive hype about this is the greatest thing of all time greatest game in the I will be

very yeah that's why was one of the reason why didn't want to like the game but on the same side M you probably shouldn't listen to everyone saying this is terrible and a bad game cuz it's not um this is neither of those things this is nether the the the both things we you can spring a little bit more to the left or to the right if it's like best game of the year or a very good game but not that all that OD it it's fine and we still talking about games guys so did you have fun with playing ARS sometimes not is an amazing game yeah absolutely so with all that said what do you think please let us know oh my gosh I am waiting for the comments yeah I want to see all the comments I want to see all the rage down there um because um yeah I know that this is gonna split a lot of you guys because he it split us so yeah it's been an interesting uh conversation and an interesting experience playing this over the last few weeks but I'm dying to to know what you think in the comments below uh and if you like this video you know what to do hit the like button and of course hit the Subscribe button the most Agro hit it aggro pow po just raided all of your cards red D subscribe button absolutely shoot us out the sky with that subscribe button uh check out the rest of the content and Matt we're going to catch them again real soon C what what you should play see

Progress saved