The Broken Meeple Show - The Spice Doesn't Flow - Episode 35
Transcript
you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's luke hector best known for the broken meeple youtube channel and i'm an everyday gamer just like you and i'll be talking about reviews top 10s and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as i have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everyone oh my my camera's out a little bit there thanks for joining me on another podcast episode this is going to be a shorter one than usual for a few reasons firstly i'm a little bit exhausted mainly because i was a convention this weekend which was stopped short so it you know it wasn't as long as i thought but obviously it still knackers you after a couple of days but i'll get on to that in a bit more detail as to why it was cut short i'm also prepping the house and all sorts of stuff and myself for my gastroscopy procedure on tuesday this is sunday the first third of october as i record this and so in a couple of days i gotta go in for a gastroscopy uh procedure which is nothing major it's just a routine check but basically it's when they stick the camera down your throat to check your digestive tract uh and your throat basically and the idea is is that hopefully that will give the specialist some kind of idea as to why hopefully my system keeps giving me acid reflux issues worse than it ever has done
before i mean i've already kind of figured it out it's called stress it's called the stress of work plus the stress of the blog now but you know maybe there's something else down there or maybe it was just a case of right well now you've gone and checked my system can you now put me on some pills to reduce my acid level down or something you know just something like that but i gotta have that done on tuesday which means i've had to you know self-isolate today i got a self-isolate tomorrow and then on tuesday my parents have got to take me to the actual hospital i've got to be in there for about half a day probably because they can't guarantee when i'll actually be seen i gotta be sedated which is basically the equivalent of having a roofie which is not something i fancy the idea of but then again the idea of having a tube down my throat is not exactly much better either but i say i'm going to be out of action for tuesday and possibly even for a part of wednesday according to my boss who also had similar issues so you know it's uh something i gotta look forward to i guess i know of course i'm prepping for essen which is gonna be the following week so i'll be going there from tuesday all the way to sunday so that's a big trip i got a plan for and yeah just basically a lot is happening right now oh yeah and the top 100 did i mention that you know i've got to record the next segment of the top 100 today as well as the descent review i need to get that done and i probably have a blitz compilation review to do at some point for some games or maybe just a singular one because i know i've got a settlement over there which i'll give you some basic thoughts on uh soon this episode and i think there's one or two other things i need to
review oh yes of course i need to get played um circadian's uh first order of circadian's world order chaos order i think it was called new games being shipped to me from uh garfield games for any thanks to that and emperor s4 have sent me copies of uh hanimakoji with the expansions so little tiny expansions that you can throw into the game it's like oh i'm interested to try those as well as their new two-player game geisha's road which is basically based off the same system so cannot wait to try that one especially especially if it's taking hanumakoji and adding bits to it that i'm excited for so yeah quite a lot happening so main way this is going to be a shorter episode is that there's just going to be no topic of the day so we'll i'll talk about well how i've been as i'm doing now some games i've played a fairly extensive look at june which is a game i played over the weekend i've got a shout out for a channel that i discovered recently that i'd like to do and of course some other games that i've played and i'll mention what why the kong got cut short but oh and a couple bits of news so you know standard stuff but just no topic of the day to take up the next half hour of the show you know so this will be a shorter one but to make up for that the next episode even though it's going to be delayed a couple of days because i won't be able to be recording on the sunday because i'll still be coming home from germany i will be doing a podcast episode to basically just talk about nothing but my experience at essen so yeah that will be a special episode it will be a bit later than normal sunday that i put them out so bear with me but it will hopefully be worth the wait
so that's just to make up for the short episode today but yeah generally channel pretty good the subs are climbing things are good the compilation review was uh taken well i was a bit afraid about that because the problem is compilation reviews don't always sit well with publishers and it's very difficult to do compilation reviews on bgg because you can only put one video you can only put a video up once so i have to choose where it goes on board game geek and i can't put it under all the other games which is a bit of a pain unless i try and do a split of all of them and kind of piecemeal it onto boardgamegeek but then it just looks amateurish so that's the problem with them but it's getting some views so it's doing okay and as i say it allows me to catch up with games so it's not that all my blitz reviews are going to be done in the compilation style it's just when i get overrun they'll appear so it's just a case of as and when really but the top 100 is still continuing 60 to 51 was last week 70 to 61 was a couple of weeks ago and 50 to 41 i released on september 30th so only a few days ago i need to record 40 to 31 today so i can get editing that like i say slowly but surely we're getting there to the very top so the views are still good for it thank you very much for tuning in to those and also if you want to check out a live collaboration i did yes i will be bringing those back because i just was very busy but i mean i'm staggered by the paul grogan one we did i cannot believe how well that started nearly 15 000 views that is insane for a
video on my channel that is ridiculous for a live stream on my channel especially one that was two hours and 40 minutes it was a huge one but i mean i can only put it down to paul grogan has to be you know i would have probably got a thousand if i was just there but you know paul's there and it pulls me in another thirteen thousand views i think but uh you know love the guy i'll see him at essen he's got a gathering on the thursday evening i'll be going to uh around the fitzpatrick i think it is a fitzpatrick pub in essen so i'll be like that and i gotta drive him home that'd be interesting but uh well not to devon thankfully but at least to uh back to the britain so you know hopefully he's a good passenger in a car but yeah that was a really good fun list i can't wait for us to do more but the main one i did recently was uh top 10 games at warren app assistants from mackenzie franklin from side game co llc you know you want to know the watch mojo of board gaming it's basically him because he puts out so many top 10 lists it's ridiculous i mean i wish i could put out that many but that was a good fun stream to do it was his idea two hours on as i say none of them live streams are going to be short they're all going to be long but yeah i'm trying to get these done uh i want to bring in some people like you know the nerd shelves and board game perspective and a few other people like that back to the table you know um boardroom gamer and billy and diana would be certainly up for it but i think the next one i do will probably be chairman of the board uh chairman of the board uh does some stuff along with mackenzie franklin actually and i have seen some of his stuff mackenzie recommended him as well and let me see
if i can chairman of the board let's see if i can show on screen but basically he does his own youtube channel so two i mean all right we're getting two shout outs today i guess but he does his own uh channel 2.37 k subscribers and various reviews uh various games ranked a few top 10 lists you know kind of what you expect to see on the you know on youtube but he's a very nice guy and he wants to do a top 10 list with me on the collaboration live stream so we'll do something like that don't know the topic just yet although he's got a couple of interesting ideas one of them was games that aged well which in fact let me put it to you guys what do you want me to do actually um games are aged well which is where we need to look at games at least over 15 years old and see if they stand the test of time yeah that's usually useful for something i mean in fact when i was doing the uh shelf by shelf one that was something i used to talk about uh but with this one it's kind of like hmm well how would you say it's aged well for me i would have to be very strict and say it was kind of like not just a game that i play now it's gotta be a game that hasn't been reiterated now so for example cosmic encounter came out in the 70s right and you still play it today so you'd think that's age 12 right it has been reprinted and re-implemented and redone about five or six times though and i have the fantasy flight version i wouldn't dream of playing the 70s version so i don't say that's aged well but for
example uh pillars of the earth pillars of europe uh somewhere over there i think is a very good euro game very good light euro game has a mechanic that hasn't been replicated which is crime of crime frankly but that hasn't been reimplemented being reprinted for stock but it hasn't been changed you know bar maybe minor tweaks i'm not even sure if anything's been tweaked in it but that game has stayed as it was since it was first created and i would still happily play it now and it's still on my shelf that's an example of a game that's aged well and you know maybe it's a case that has had well in some cases expansions would apply but in pillars of the earth case no so that's one we're thinking of doing uh the other idea he had was a versatile games which is kind of a case of saying that if your game can cater for multiple player accounts multiple types of gamer like you know light gamers heavy gamers and has a like a sort of multitude of mechanics that kind of thing you know is it versatile in that way i'm a little bit hesitant about that one because i'm curious as to how you would really describe something as versatile not to mention what games could actually be described as versatile i mean are there that many games that a light gamer as well as a heavy gamer would play hard to say but it's a possibility that one i just think will be a bit more tricky but what do you think let me know in the comments where do you want to see games at age 12 or versatile games it's probably going to be one of those two i need to go back to him with an answer as to which one we'll do um but yeah i'd like to see what you would like to see
as well uh so with that said and done let's move on relatively quickly to the actual shout out i was doing this uh um episode you know not to say that i didn't want to shout out chairman of the board as well but uh this was the channel that i was talking about earlier games made easy this is from a lovely lady called i believe they're pronounced lavinia i hope that's uh uh correct and their cat peter i mean peter just basically appears in the like bit there so if you're looking at the youtube version of this podcast then you can see cute peter little white kitty cat oh he's so cute little kitty cat i love my i love cats but as you well know but games means living here now this is a tutorial channel so there's no reviews there's no top tens it is basically learn how to play and the reason i bring this one up is because when i was figuring out how to play june before i went to play it uh this channel was the one that i went to first i just basically typed and learned how to play june looked for a small creator because you know me i like to check out the small creators first and this one came up and there's several game ones on june there there's also brass birmingham seven wonders five tribes uh blood rage merchants and marauders various catans and there's plenty more besides although i think it is a relatively new channel so there's not like years and well i don't know actually nope my mistake uh oh no oh there we go so it's been around for about a year uh so 3 700 subscribers is not bad for a
year and there you go there's a azul carcassonne patrol on house on the hill ticketed ride more katan seven wonders duel terraforming mars wingspan terra mystica oh dixit loads of water deep tapestry scoundrels of skullport uh splendor viticulture endemics um i think that's a special that's normal pandemic uh what else we got and then there's a welcome to games made easy so you know going up in the world here but it's she's very nice she's very clear you know i was able to learn the rules for june and that from this so i can tell you firsthand that the channel works but here's the unique selling point here because you might think well it's just another tutorial channel and it's like well come on i mean so's watch it played you know there are other tutorial channels out there you know support small creators but the interesting one with this is that you might have noticed that one of them is written in spanish that's because lavinia actually specifically does two versions of every video she does she does one of how to play in the english and one in spanish so we've got learn how to play seven wonders better and faster and then we've got combo jugas evan wonders seven mara villas measurement why am i even trying to read spanish i can't speak spanish but you get what i mean basically if you are a spanish speaker and english is not your first language then you can check out this channel games made easy and get certain tutorials done in spanish and to be fair some people would like me to be able to do multiple languages sadly i can barely speak english let alone any other language i was i was decent german
at gcse but jesus he was a long long time ago god i feel old and yeah i would certainly say give this channel a look she's very nice peter the cat is adorable when he's on screen and you know these videos are good they're covering a wide range of games you know light medium and heavy and you know very friendly and i like that unique selling point of being able to do videos in spanish as well as english i think not a lot of people can do that but if they can i encourage them to try it really so uh by all means give her a look support small creators for games made easy right so uh quickly before i go into what i played i mentioned about my con getting stuck short well this time of year and i think in march as well uh there is a convention in southampton there's a local con you just go there and play games not high turnout it's just nice and local called i feel ashamed to say this shake battle and roll it used to be called stab con because it was related to another convention it was called stab con south it was related to another convention called stamkone which i think was further up north or something it despite the fact that had no relation to it i don't know it's weird the naming with it and they decided to change their name and they made it shape battle and roll i think it's a god awful name but that's just me but who cares about the name of a convention and the good thing is that you go there and you have fun playing games which we do and because it's in southampton which is only up the road for me i can see a lot of my friends there and we basically get to play a lot of long games june included in fact two of the games i'm talking about on this
episode are games i played over this com but it got cut short and at no fault of the organizers the organizers did a great job and they cared about the people that were there and they cancelled the con along with the hotel basically to get people out to safety safety what do you mean by safe uh well um this is what i mean by safe yeah basically if you can't see this on screen because you're listening to this basically the place practically flooded and i mean flooded this is a shot of essentially one of many corridors that was just dripping water from the ceiling this is showing water dripping from all the electric lights into canisters are like pretty much overflowing the toilets had a water coming through the ceiling with towels underneath there was other corridors where you know you could tell that the thing was sagging it stunk of mildew and mold that the hotel was basically disintegrating around us and i know that we've had a lot of rain in the uk lately but it's not like we haven't had rain before so clearly this has been some ongoing issue with the construction of the building for a leak to have occurred in this in intensity well the corridor you're looking at here it was either this corridor or another corridor collapsed 10 minutes after this video was taken so it was definitely somebody had a video with 10 minutes after and i know that timing is right and not to be there i saw the aftermath of it but yeah roofs
collapsed internally inside the building so the convention had to be canceled because it was basically leaking everywhere where the convention was don't worry no games were harmed in the making of this convention and you know board game extras were able to get their stock out that bring them by was unharmed you know nobody lost anything due to the water damage but man it was crazy absolutely crazy i've never seen a leak that bad it was just like you might as well the building might as well had no roof you know the rain outside was torrential some of the heaviest rainfall we've had in the world but wow something was going on at that hilton hotel for uh it was the hilton doubletree doubletree hotel at hilton near southampton i think it was and oh blabby yeah i mean would you be i feel sorry for anybody who came specifically for this convention and had to you know make other plans or go to yeah well i mean bored in the city put up people free of charge for those who had to leave this convention which was very nice of them but cool bloody could you imagine coming down and having to leave early because of this i mean it's not like the convention in the hotel can prepare for acts of god effectively but this was some crazy league i've never seen anything quite so bad like that in my life but yeah it got cut short so the reason i'm not at the convention today is because it got cancelled so hang around with some mates we finished playing june in the hotel room on the bed and that's joking here six of us in the little hotel room on the bed finishing the last round and a half of dune and then we sat in the lobby they got some tables out for a few of us to hang
around and play some games we stayed till about midnight i went home went to sleep and i figured well i get today to do what i like and i've basically as i say i've been trying to catch up so you know the house is cleaned got me food supplies for this week when i'm not going to be able to go out you know preparation for the parents gastroscopy and all that so i'm trying to get my stuff together really and that includes recording this as well as the other videos and going to the gym and cooking myself dinner and playing stellaris later yeah you can tell i've got a bit of a full life i really wish i had like a an intern to do half my editing or something but i digress so yeah that's just a weird story with that one uh so let's move on to some let's go into some news then i don't want to finish the podcast on news i'm doing everything in a bit of a jumbled up order this time so uh keeping it fresh i'm sorry i didn't talk about this last week um the last podcast because i cannot believe i forgot about this when i was doing the fantasy flight in flight report for uh all the stuff they were doing like the lcgs and other expansions i forgot to talk about probably the biggest expansion on the list which was star wars outer rim unfinished business finally there's wretched game is getting a stupid expansion it's been on my shelf unplayed for a while because the lack of variety in those decks is hurting it you know it has fallen down my top 100 for that reason and it's in danger of falling off but with this expansion it could come back into a nice stable position so hopefully this will get done soon i mean it's uh what's it quoting on board game
geek 2022 yeah 2022 who knows when in 2022 i'll bet you it's probably halfway through the year at least but then they've released next to no details on it we don't know what it's adding we don't know if it's uh themed around anything like mandalorian or anything or if it's just more cards it's a big box by the looks of it so i hope it's going to include a lot more cards and they better i don't mean just a few cards per deck no you better be tripling the size of those decks you know put some effort in but yeah finally unfinished business which seems a little bit on the nose if you catch my drift i feel that they maybe should have thought twice about that name unless they're deliberately insulting themselves but uh yeah that just seems a little too on the nose there unfinished business but hey it's coming by na lee and then the second bit of news which i only just found out about yesterday actually which is something i'm i'm excited for but i'm a little bit uh i'm gonna hold my feelings back because this might not be my type of game i play but i play a game on a pc called deep rock galactic i have sunk colossal amount of arrows into it triple digit hours several hundred into this game deep rock galactic it is a great fun pc uh team-based co-op where you as dwarfs and the mining corporation dive into these asteroids with procedurally generated levels to mine minerals and shoot up a ton of spiders that are in there coming at you now yes i'm around the phobic but these spiders look very
different from a typical spider they look quite cartoony in some areas and it's like yeah they're not particularly uh threatening well they're threatening but they're not like scary spiders except for one the shrieker or whatever it's called the uh it's it's one of these it's like a giant spider daddy long legs thing or something that screeches comes out of the dark with his arms like outstretched and basically grabs you and lifts you up and basically drops you from great heights it's scary when you hear the shriek it is absolute bedwetting heart attack inducing when you turn around and it's in your face i was like where is it it comes out it's like ah i have had heart attacks are plenty from it but fantastic game i still play it to this day it's only on in-game content but basically every week a new deep new elite deep dive comes out and i play the elite deep dive i put it down pick it up again it's one of those that i'm very good at if i don't mind saying so myself i think i'm pretty good at the game but it allows me to basically just pick up and play a good fun cooperative shooter so the fact that he's getting a board game is whoa okay a one to four player co-op board game based on the deep rock galactic universe so you know it's shadowed as to what's here but i'm guessing there's going to be like big chunky miniatures i mean this is going to be on kickstarter so you know it's going to have miniatures but you're going to have miniatures for the dwarfs there's four classes you can have all the different spider miniatures so maybe those will freak me out a bit more on the aratophobic front than normal but oh cool yes i am very interested in this
now will it be good i don't know i mean ips get used a lot and they don't always turn out for the better but the thing that does make me feel a little bit better about this is essentially back in november 2020 i received an email from our good friends at mood publishing about collaborating on the board game project and i quickly replied yes it got even better when we convinced our friend and professional board game designer um olay steines i think is how it's pronounced to join in now if you don't know that name i'm not surprised because he only has several board games under his net belt and i don't know how many of them are well known but one of them is well known because it's champions of midgard yes he did champions of mid guy one of the top 100 games at the moment and very popular with a lot of players so if that designer is working on this game this could be pretty good fun hopefully not too complicated than that in fact what else has he done actually i'm very curious so here we go computer game designer by day board game designer by knight and that explains how he's uh uh linked to the deep rock galactic crew so what do we did he did champions of midgard oh he did priest precinct interesting uh spurs are telling you west we've got here more champions of medicare champions in the middle chinese guard go with everything's about champions midgard into the fire uh mean pools and monsters uh lots of priest precinct spurs are telling the old west okay so not that
many games to his name because most of these are just expansions of the same game and i never played police precincts so we'll see uh he also had some um ideas for the pandemic on the brink expansion so most of the time though he does video games so things like kane and lynch total overdose and game glow and stuff and lots of uh educational games so i'm going to hold my expectations back a bit but the idea of one of my favorite shoot em ups becoming a board game is still something i'm uh quite excited about so i will definitely be interested to find out more on this as it goes through the motions right let's talk about games i've played i'm just going to talk about three two very briefly and one in a bit more detail firstly settlement i don't want to talk about this one in too much detail because i'm actually doing a review on this one but basically this is done by oh blimey i got i'm really butchering names today i do apologize like i said i can barely speak my own language but settlement is a new game from him and i games and if you don't know those two names well this is the same man who did mysterium uh detective club and mysterium park and stuff was like oh hello a couple of my favorite party games and the company is also i think reprinted i think they reprinted no they didn't reprint uh small islands that's lucky duck games um but let's say they did detective club and a couple of others so you know this is an up and coming publisher and designer
well settlement is basically a very lightweight engine builder euro game so you are well funny enough building a settlement and it's very well produced gotta give it credit it's probably overproduced for what it is but essentially it's a very bog standard euro game you are collecting resources to build little city buildings that get you to do various things you can explore regions which is basically just flip a tile and see what it gives you it might give you a monster that you can go and kill off you have recruit heroes which are basically victory points you know it's a and you use meeples as a resource it's pretty generic with the exception of some artifact tiles that you pick from at the sort of start of each round and as players pass they put them back and you can take another one so it's almost like the bonus tiles you get in terra mystica and gaia project but it's well produced it is super simple the rules are dead easy to learn the rule book is just fine it's very well produced in fact over reduced i would say and it looks very pretty in that on the board as you can see from some of these pictures my issue with it though is that as good as those aspects are it doesn't have a huge amount of depth this is definitely a lightweight game and granted maybe we do need a lightweight game in this genre of building a little settlement get resources and trade them in for stuff you know we don't most of the times these tend to be fraught games with a ton of rules and too much complexity this does not have that problem i mean this is dirt simple the artifacts i wish were a bit more interesting but the idea
that you can have different artifacts each round which give you bonuses at different things is quite interesting the solo mode is in this is basically the multiplayer game except with a one minor tweak and that is another flaw of the game it is 100 multiplayer solitaire other than the taking of the artifact tiles what do you do so you are basically playing a mini little engine builder game yourself so having four players is pointless you know in fact having any players at all is pointless because the solo game is such a minor tweak of the multiplayer rules why would you have multiplayer it makes no sense yeah there's not enough there's no interaction in this game so it's it's got a lot of pluses but i'm worried that in six months time this is not going to be talked about a lot because there's just not a lot of depth to it i mean you collect the resources you put them on stuff and you trade the resources in the heroes and get points in the end i mean it's mainly just which artifact you fancy in which buildings you get so it's got some variety it's got some you know half decent choices but it is meant to be a lightweight game so i can't be too hard on it maybe i'm just getting off lightweight games i do think that medium weight games are my sweet spot but yeah there's certainly room for this in the market you know a lightweight game of this nature i'm just worried that it's kind of kind of slipped by nobody's really going to talk about it although rado talks about it pretty uh you know in high positivity although he does put a lot of emphasis on how much he loves
those artifacts in fact i think he puts a bit too much emphasis on those artifactels frankly it's like okay they're nice but i don't think you should be going kid in the candy store google gaga over the things i don't know it's i'll say different strokes different folks but you know it's got some pluses it's got some minuses i'll give you the proper review soon ready uh moving on to xcom the board game uh this was on my top 100 i mentioned it hadn't been played for a while well thankfully a good friend of mine put that to rest as we played a couple of games on friday night as part of the shape battle and roll convention and i just wanted to say it's as enjoyable as i remember it yes this is a wonderfully thematic uh cooperative game it's got a lot of dice rolling and luck in it yes okay but it's such it's such a good one to have like you're on the back foot of these aliens are coming down to invade earth and you've got to deal with the ufos in space around the continents you've got to go on missions with your soldiers you've got to defend the base from getting attacked you've got to stop all the continents from panicking so you've got your income each round to buy more stuff it's oh it's such a good cool game and when you've got four of you working together of which we had one new player and three of us that were more familiar um although i did need to go back i think we had a tutorial just to get us back up on scratch with the rules and then once we cleared that one pretty easily we went right let's go on to a decent hard difficulty and we just won it like just won it but it oh it feels good i think i played the scientist both times uh the new guy played the commander so thankfully he was the only accountant in
the group no sorry the only non-accountant in the group was the commander that's different but he did the right with the budgeting he never messed up once so you know fair play to him but i like being the scientist because you get to do all these card shenanigans with using the workshop to discard them for one-shot uses using other cards to flip them back onto your deck deciding well what do i want to research how many scientists you know can i get some salvage from the from the squad leader great when shall i use it when should i burn through cards in my hand if these are texts i don't want to build what should i build first given on the situation i like being the scientist even though it's like i say it's it it's kind of well all the jobs are a crutch holder i mean if the scientist doesn't get you cool stuff you're going to lose but if the mission leader doesn't succeed in the missions you're going to lose if the commander doesn't solve the choose the right crises or get the budget right you won't have any money and you'll lose and if the central officer doesn't defend the space your app will go all up the spout and you'll lose so it's it's one of those deals but yeah we had good fun it was good to get back into the theme of this you know yes there's a lot of dice rolling but i just it really captures the x-com game so well even though it has to be slightly abstracted on the basis that this is more about the planning side like the global mission screen side of x-com as opposed to the actual uh going into the missions and shooting up agents which i know some people wanted and didn't get from this but i don't care i enjoyed this one and i've got the expansion in my copy although we didn't use an expansion in this case
yeah the exalt one evolution i think it was called but yeah i like this game really good fun nice to get back into the shoes of this one and it makes me want to play it again with the expansion in it soon so uh you know with new players or should i just play it solo we'll see but yeah this was good fun and i seem to be a very good scientist not just because my die roles were quite lucky but because i'm very good at building the right stuff you've gotta know what to build you can't just build everything you gotta build specific stuff get that alien construction one up and running fast don't underestimate alien alloys are using the workshop a lot certainly do not underestimate archangel armor oh man allowing the chiefs allowing the uh squad leader just to use spare soldiers to give you salvage oh that is really nice you know you cannot underestimate some of this stuff but yeah great fun really captures the theme i don't know if it sells much these days but it's worth picking up because it is one of the first few games i think that really delved into apps being a part of a game and trust me this is still a great app to this day ready okay let's wrap up the episode with a talk about june not the best rating there three might bump up to a four yeah uh i know nothing about the dune universe june is alien to me at this point the only thing i have got is snippets from playing dune imperium and what friends have told me i know the names of some of the factions i know a little bit about how each one
works i know there's big sand worms i know that spices everything and that's about it yeah i really don't know a lot about dude i'm really banking on the new movie which i think comes out in the uk 22nd of october so i'll watch it when i get back from essen um i'll try and watch it on the day it comes out you know if i can uh to clue me in as to what on earth's going on in the june universe because i haven't read the books and i never will so it's kind of like yeah i'm going into this one with next to no thematic knowledge now that hurts a little bit but it wasn't a killer just based on that however the problems i have with this game and it's not to say that this is all bad there are some positives i played this with friends we had great you know great company always have fun playing with friends even if the game is bad i would have hated this game if i was playing it with unknowns i will never play this game with randoms it's not going to happen i also kind of shot myself in the foot by playing probably the most complicated uh faction in the entire lot which was the benny jesuit or that ben jessup i think that's how you pronounce it basically the sisterhood the avoid sisterhood and uh yeah they weren't the style that i was thinking they were gonna be i wish i'd picked something like harkonnen or the fremen maybe or perhaps a spacing guild because that could have been quite fun but you know certainly the bendy desert was not great for me now this is a big technically a six player game because nobody wants to play it with less than six players where you're fighting over
it's dudes on the map you're fighting over various territories trying to collect the spices income bidding on cards which have like various like weapons and defenses in them and other special effects and it's a very political style game so you are having discussions with players in secret you are you know making alliances you're breaking alliances there you know you can win as a shared victory but that's only if you're an alliance so there's definitely a lot of negotiation a lot of planning in this one and that's all good it certainly does capture the theme of june well even though i don't have much knowledge of it it certainly is fraught with a lot of that negotiation and party political stuff so if that's your thing you're going to get something from here but here are some issues and so in the end let's carry on some good points um it does have some good story highlights in it i mean uh we blew up the shield wall in great fashion um the last gun shield combo which basically nukes an entire area we nuked free of the strongholds with that i got to we called it the ruffle bang which was unexpected the first time i saw it and hilarious when it was done two more times and two other strongholds and when i got to do it as well which was funny but i'm not sure i agree with that rule being in there but as i say we'll uh touch on that in a minute uh you've got all the different factions that play very differently not gonna lie about that so that's all well and good but here's some problems i have with this game firstly this game is too long
wow this game took us like what six seven hours plus or something to play this is huge uh for length and granted i know you could probably shave off a bit of time if you weren't first-time players and stuff like that but you know we learned a bit of the rules in advance we just had to get a you know a kind of a an update in a way but man though this game does not need to be six to seven hours long it's way too long and i don't like it when games go on stupid lengths of time you know when they don't need to so that was a bit of a put off especially as the ben jesuit that i basically just had to sit there and do nothing for about half the game because the whole point of them is that you just slowly drip in as other people ship to the world and you have no money you can't buy anything you don't have any money to ship people onto the planet other means so you're poor you also apparently i got this rule wrong the entire game you're supposed to spend money to put people into battle so all this stuff that cost you money and i can't afford any of it so i can't do half the stuff in this game and i'm just supposed to wait there and play the long game oh wow am i playing a long game six hours am i playing a long game here that is not a good way to design a faction to make them so like underpowered in so many ways until the very end now i almost won but that was a fluke in itself i just happened to be in the locations where things went complete like chaotic massive fights happened and then i got to say i've
still got a few people on the planet right i'm going to try and go for the win and i almost won but too many forces to fight against i mean the the ben jesuit just cannot hold a fight people say oh they've got the best leaders they're all level five even that yeah other people have high level leaders as well but they also have more troops and some of them can boost their troops so i don't care how good your leader is your troops are still going to overwhelm you so i really had a problem with the faction in general and granted that's on me should have picked an asia faction but then frankly i didn't know what faction was either because i didn't know what any other factions were you know give me a break i'm gonna down the rest of this coffee because it's cold right but you know that was one problem uh so really long oh god the prediction thing i hate this stupid prediction thing one of the apparent advantages of ben jesuit is that you get to predict who will win on what turn and if that happens you win instead i'm sorry what this is a 10 round game there are six of you and you have to somehow predict which person can win on what term and somehow orchestrate this that's insane i'm sorry but especially when some of them say like i mean this one in the picture here says emperor turn three how i was playing this game i do not know how anybody is supposed to win this on turn one two and three there's like i'm sorry if you're predicting that you are mad absolute mad
so you probably want to go for a high turn and i went for harkonnen on turn seven three turns in harkonnen gets laz gun nuclear explosion on one of his things and takes out most of his troops well there goes my prediction so that's already done i'm not going to win this game we got another five hours left are we okay then wow really it just knocked him at the game and knocked me out of the game pretty much on that one well from a prediction standpoint stupid mechanics stupid stupid mechanic so what else is negative well it's got huge bouts of swinginess did i mention the last gun combo that basically just obliterates a stronghold just because somebody shoots a gun into a shield seriously why do they even exist in this universe i mean if you have two things and when put together can cause nuclear explosions shouldn't you like decommission one of them stat it doesn't make any sense but maybe the movie will explain more but then there's also the shield wall somebody was able to put like the weather machine on destroyed the shield wall and then suddenly the storm wiped out two strongholds in a butt of an instant and you just can't prep for it you can't defend against it there's a the worm thing that pops up every now and again so spice appears in various locations but when you draw from the deck if the worm comes out and goes on a specific discard pile it moves to that location and eats up everybody there i had six troops in one location i was doing okay went and grabbed some spice next turn worm comes out eats all my troops and i can do nothing about it so you have to play russian roulette with a
deck of cards to say when i go and get spice i'm going to try and collect it and hope that i just don't get randomly eaten on the next turn oh yeah the amount of random swinniness that this game has for a six hour plus game is beyond ridiculous if this sort of thing happened in a 90 minute game i wouldn't be too fast because 90 minutes you're done and it would create some haha moments i'm not going when my entire force on the board gets eaten by a worm by random chance you can't defend against it it just happens that is not good game design that is crap game design i am sorry i'm not giving that one any passes yeah and there's other examples like i say the last gun shield combo as soon as somebody puts a single dude in your place you know you're about to get nuclear explosion can you defend against it only if you are the ben gesserate and you know it's coming you know you can say right you can't play your last gun it's a weird voice ability they have which is a decent ability but that's probably the only good thing about the ben jesuit so it's all right so most factions can't even defend against it i mean in the start of the game it just like literally the emperor just appeared and went boom you're all dead and then later on in the game my tradies had all their stuff in one stronghold and then suddenly you're dead you can't defend against it have fun stupid design stupid stupid stupid so
and let's say people got knocked out so like the last couple of turns two players the freeman and the harkonnen could do nothing they had no way to win the game they were effectively knocked out they weren't in an alliance with anybody who understand the chance of winning so what did they get to do nothing if they try to go after anyone they king make so it's got bad king making issues it's got pseudo knockout problems it's got bounce of random swinniness it's got way unbalanced factions i think i mean some of these factions are much easier to play with than others i'm not saying that the ben gessera cannot be won with you know some people have done it but to play them and the tradies you've got to do some weird stuff to get them to work whereas someone like the emperor and the spacing guild pretty much just sits there collects money from everybody doing other bits of the game so they never have to go out and get spice never because they can just simply sit there and go bro you buying cards money money money money i'll spend it on doing stuff spacing guild oh you're shipping to the planet money money money money money i'll do stuff ben jessera you get two every round how do i get more money go get spice okay i'll get my one dude over there oh well somebody else is coming around you wanna fight with your one dude you're gonna flip it to an advisor i guess i'll flip it to an advisor then it's it's stupid stupid stupid stupid so i'm wrecking on this game a lot and frankly i think it deserves it but i know there's a bunch of dune fans who are going to have me like a head on a head on a pike for saying this stuff you
know i'm still interested in the dune law i want to watch the movie the movie looks fun although it is stuck in the desert it's going to look pretty muted and bland in terms of its color palette so i am worried that it's going to be an ugly film despite maybe being a fun film but i'm worried it's also not going to teach me anything about the law because it's either going to pile on an exposition or it's going to make assumptions that everybody who watches the film has read the book it's like no i'm coming into this as a complete noob i demand that the movie tell me what's going on explain what these factions are all about and while this universe works so hopefully you know and i was interested in learning more in this game i was asking my friends who had read a couple of them had read the books or reading the books a couple of them had watched the old films two people who taught us this game you know bless their hearts they love this game they they think it's amazing and you know they were teaching me snippets about the dune law great i was interested and it's not that i didn't have any enjoyment i was with good company i always enjoy fun company with mates there were some stories in this game like the destruction of the shield wall and a couple of the last gun things that were funny you know they were funny and they happened although to be fair it's funny when it happens to someone else not necessarily to you so there is that problem but i just i just don't think that this is a good well-designed game i think this is dated it's been reimplemented in this nice looking new version by galeforce9 so credit to them but i think the rules being kept mostly the same i don't know
how much changed from the really old version but i just think that it's dated the mechanics are something that i am not surprised existed in a game made in like what was it like 1970s or something i mean with it tell me it's probably going to tell me this is a 2000 summit game because of the re-implementation yeah 2019 but it reimplemented dune which was originally made in 1979 yeah um and i don't know how much changed but this is clearly a game that was made in 1979 not to say that there's nothing good about it you know i do think that that negotiation stuff is fun but it drags the game out to six hours because everybody's making alliances and going off and talking with each other in private and that's like you could spend like half an hour on one nexus phase while people discuss plans it's like can we get on with the game i mean i'm not in an alliance here i'm sitting here with nothing to use waiting for people to hurry up and do their um their plans it's just i don't know but it's clearly dated so i wasn't a fan i i'm giving it i've given it a 3 out of 10. maybe i could make it a 4 out of 10 i mean using their scale it's bad likely won't play this again i do think the game is bad i probably am not going to play this again you could convince me maybe to play it with friends only and that's assuming i choose a better faction but also i can be told that it's not gonna take six hours i mean it says 120 minutes
here no way is this 120 minutes and who's playing this with two players anyway people play this with six players you will not get a six player game done in 120 minutes it is physically impossible stop lying on the backs in fact 3.95 doesn't even sound like the right complexity rating for this either because i mean it's complex in the sense that the rules are convoluted as hell and you've got so many exceptions to the rule depending on what faction's going on it is a little bit of a smorgasbord of rules faq issues you know we had to constantly stop the game for faq members i'm not even convinced we played every single one of them right and i got the rule wrong about paying for people because i didn't realize you had to pay for people putting in combat i didn't hear the rule when it was being explained and other people have got exceptions to that rule so i never saw anybody physically pay for people so i thought it never occurred to me that it was in the game i don't know like i say i got enough problems with this i don't want to ramble on too long i am more interested in two versions of june firstly portal that are doing the house stories game the one based on the detective series they're doing one on the dune universe based on the new movie and that that i'm interested in because that sounds like a good fun storytelling adventure game with the dune universe definitely up for that but i'm more interested in what gale force 9 are doing later this year now i don't know if it's on on board game geek yet because it hasn't been made but let me type in june and see what comes up june imperium uh june imperium
vice harvest dune house secrets that's the portal what here we go this is the one i'm interested in well and how secrets but here we go doing a game of conquest and diplomacy 2021 is coming out later this year in fact and this is from gale force nine so this is essentially another you know doom game but it's obviously going to use the new universe and that and it says i think it says reimplements doom yep so this is going to be another re-implementation of that dune game but here we go it says fast-paced streamlined version of the classic doom game so this one caps at four players has a variant that works well with two 20 to 60 minutes i'll be the judge of whether this can be played in 20 to 60 minutes thank you very much but i'm totally down for a shorter version of this game i'm probably gonna be gonna be more two hours but two hours is perfectly fine with me right and uh here we go so this takes uh there we go dude builds on 40 years of development refinement and evolution the original classic game same dna same flavor all that lot with new game board design more spice new streamlined rules and a new market deck from which you can purchase game advantages a brand new two-player mode that opens up new gaming opportunities as well as making the game more accessible for casual gamers you can it caps it for players you can do atreides harkonnen fremen and imperium okay so you lose the spacing guild and you lose the ben gesserat well i'm not exactly going to lose any uh sleep over losing the ben jesuit put it that way but ship your forces to doom get spice seize control of strongholds destroy your enemies and where's it go
multiple phases uh spice phase and all that lot sand worm attacks uh here we go four battle cars can purchase market cards shipping and movement you take turns adding forces to the board uh each pair of faction has specific powers in that a game plays three to five rounds not ten um starting on round three the game can under the knockout player occupies three strongholds uh if no one at the end of round five has it and the player with the most spice wins and so this is building on the dune game but it's going to be shorter and more action-packed and it looks gorgeous you know the boards there you know i like that board i like the cards i think this one is going to be a good well produced fun looking game will it be as good as the original dune i bet you this one is going to get hated beyond belief by the dune fans you know i think they're fans of the original dune are going to go ape over this and say that this is a travesty that this has even been put into production whereas i'm gonna look at this game and go okay didn't have the best of experiences with the big version of june will this one with modern board game design streamlining and you know some thought about those stupid bouts of randomness and things like that improve the game for me we shall see hopefully and also being tied into the movie might mean i'll be able to get connected with it in a more thematic nature as well so we shall see how that goes but i am interested to see how this one turns out i don't expect to be playing
the other dune one any time soon wow that was a bit of a rant i apologize if you are a june fan and you think i've hated on your favorite game here but uh as i say different strokes for different folks and wow i've already gone under 50 minutes okay so this isn't that short an episode but uh yeah that is my first impressions of a mega game basically a 67 hour game is a mega game for me so that's essentially what i'm classing june as i don't care what it says on the bgg list but yeah so no major topic just me talking about games and weird conventions and stuff i'm doing but i better cut this episode now and get on with other things you know time is running out for the day and obviously i got stuff to do and things to record so uh that's it for me i will probably see some of your essen if you do see me essen say hi shake my hand give me a hug i'm totally down for hugs you know whatever the mass stuff happens you know the precautions not having to be if you want to hug me you can hug me all right because i will hug back uh but yeah say hi let me know you know let me know what you think of the channel let me know how you're getting on essen what game you found give me some recommendations you know have you tried this game at this hall because it's a big place i'm gonna miss stuff so by all means come and say hi i'll be on the portal booth helping them out for saturday the rest of the convention i'll be dotted around the place but thursday and friday will probably be the best times you can get me um if you're going to paul grogan's fitzpatrick meetup i will see you on the thursday evening so by all means uh come and say hi well i'll probably say hi to all of you there and yeah i'm excited for essen but not
as excited for the uh tube down the throat thing man my throat has been acting up as i've been doing this podcast because the more i do this talking the more the acid refluxes kick in and i suppose the coffee was not helping but oh well like i say needs master i need to get through that day so without further ado let's sign off take care let me know in the comments what you think remember to leave a like and comment on the video it means the world to me to know you appreciate the content don't forget the channel is unofficially sponsored by zatu.cod.uk and of course remember as always no matter how much i could rant about certain games whether i love them or hate them it's still at the end of the day only again take care bye for now love you all i'll see you soon