Skip to main content
Loading video...

Seeland Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 52:36

hey there welcome back to Friendly ties today we are talking about a very old game we're going to talk about sealant so I'm joined by my friends Jonathan and Nick hello hello and yeah so ceiling guys let's uh let's talk about it when did this one come out I just said very old so I hope I was just thinking as I said that I was like oh man is it old I think he's old it's got to be it's got to be at least seven years old 2010. I like the idea that something being seven years old is very old yeah it's actually 12 years old like 2010 is not that long ago 12 years old that feels like an eternity some people would say that's ancient for board game well so 2010 you know it's interesting to think about like what other things happened around then you know Dominion came out in 2009 to you know put a pit on that same with pandemic so you know this is about as old as Dominion and pandemic to to put it into perspective so yeah this is a game by uh Wolfgang Kramer and Gunter Burkhart and I had never heard of this until a few months ago when Anastasia you're like hey have you played C land before and I was like what had you heard of it Nick no no nothing but this this also isn't like my style of game usually the like borderline abstracty Euros is not not

generally my wheelhouse yeah yeah which we're definitely going to talk about because this is this I'm gonna put this out there I think it's pretty safe to say this is more of a John and Anastasia game than it is a Nick game yeah it'll be it'll be interesting conversation so yeah this is like a 45 to 60 Minute Thai Lane game um I guess in the Netherlands or something like that where we're all you know putting down windmills and uh harvesting cabbage I guess and uh really getting in each other's faces it's in the sea land it's right in the title right yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah is that what we're harvesting are they cabbage I think it's cabbages roses and some yellow flower I don't know flowers Netherlands I have to assume a tulip right yeah you're probably right yeah I think that is the case yeah it's so funny because sealant is one of those games that so I'm I'm a really big Kramer and kiesling fan and so are you John yeah but this is a game that I have had on my shelf for in shrink for like seven or eight years yeah I actually want to give a quick shout out to an old board game friend of mine um his name is Mike riesley he's actually he's on another podcast called 5x5 and it was through him he actually is we played games on Buddhism and I I don't even play on there anymore because I switched over I play on Yukata much more but we used to play Concordia on there and that was that was like when I

was really fostering my love of Concordia and he suggested he like came across this played it I think at a games day or something and was like you know this is like a really lovely little game and he was like you should check it out sometime and based on that I like I think I saw it on Amazon for like 15 or something I was like I gotta buy that like yeah that's you know the thing I do anyways and then it just sat and it sat and I like never pulled it off the shelf and I was so convinced I was gonna sell this game that I like I just kept saying I'm getting rid of that I'm getting rid of that I'm never gonna play it whatever whatever and then I took it I I watched a video before I got rid of it which I didn't do because I watched this video and I was like oh this is kind of like intriguing and then I sat on my shelf for another four years until I convinced John one day I was like John I gotta get this game like I gotta do I'm like on this mission to play every game yeah you came to my house we didn't even know the rules we learned it together we played a two-player game and I think within 15 minutes we were laughing at how Cutthroat it absolutely was that's right we had left our spouse's significant others in the other room talking we're like we're just gonna go play like this year out for a minute guys and then they're like yeah that looks boring and we're like okay and yeah and then we had Like a Knife Fight yeah so the main concept here is that you put Mills down onto this hex grid like it's a tile Lane game and when you put a mill tile down you put your own

little Mill token on it and then once that Mill tile is completely surrounded by other tiles you score it and you just get points for the the tiles on the mill and the the vegetable or vegetation tiles that are around it like you know cabbage and whatnot but the trick is on the return you're either either putting a mill down or you're putting these vegetation tiles down and it's a big shared space so it's very possible that I could put you know roses down next to one of my Mills that's next to Nick's Mill and now Nick and I are both going to score those Roses as long as our individual Mills actually score um so that's like the friendly way to do it because there's actually a lot of like shared incentives in this game which is I think part of the reason why I'm I'm falling for it um but you could also be mean and plunk a mill down next to somebody else's Mill because you never score for other people's Mills so you can really get in each other's faces either putting bad vegetation tiles down or just straight up zero point scoring Mills to get in other people's way as you're trying to grab points and stop them from it I think this is a really good example though of a game that both sounds cool and there's a lot going on and we're obviously going to talk about it a lot lot but is there a lot going on that's exactly my point and yet and yet I came off that first play with John so high on it and I was like Nick we gotta play this game I made a TTS mod I was like Nick let's play it and I played it with Nick and he was decidedly yeah and I was like oh okay

that's solid I don't have any I don't have any beef with it I actually think that that the game is very honest like it I think it it's like a pretty straightforward package um I think the how you run your turn is is nice the um it's a it's like rondelle you like choose this thing but like there are very very clearly like strictly better things like as Jonathan you score everything and there's just a bunch of numbers and like bigger numbers make bigger boom booms like you know it's it's very clear you know generally what you want yeah and then there's like a couple extra considerations there like there's the colors and like whether you're setting up or cashing in right if you're doing like the windmills or if you're um doing the field so it does that really nicely with like just a really small package but I don't I don't I would argue that there is not a lot going on and that's actually what's good about the game that's the very it's very clean yeah this is not a Euro with like multiple paths to Victory like in this game you put Mills down and then you get points for those Mills and then whoever does that the best hypothetically wins and yet somehow when John and I played together this way so Anastasia and I've played this I think four times two players and then uh just the two of us and you played with Nick two players and then we just like an hour ago played a three-player game which is the first time that any of us have played a non two-player game and uh this interesting thing happened where our three-player game took an hour and pretty much everyone how long it's

supposed to it's a 45 to 60 minutes but pretty much every game every two player game the Anastasia and I played have taken two hours two very fun hours that were like have wrapped attention and having a great time and swearing at each other but it's I think it's part of the reason I really wanted to try this with more people before we chatted about it because it seems like there's maybe a couple different games in the Box depending on who you're playing with and maybe how many people are at the table I think a lot of these abstracts and sealant is absolutely no exception have that Dynamic of two player is just very very different from three or four player because of the the zero-sum nature of games right where it's like you're scoring points and if I place my windmill next to you that's minus points for you which is essentially plus points for me but if I'm playing that way in a three-player game when I'm and I'm like you know making Anastasia's windmill worse then John's just gonna come out ahead and so that that Dynamic of like getting at each other um is less appealing in a multiplayer version of this game yeah I was thinking about that when we were playing because very early on in this play we just played just now John had the lead right so when we first started like John said there's a shared incentive element but you all start around this like kind of central place in the board and you know John and Nick Place their first two windmills like right next to each other and I placed on the other side technically you and Nick placed on opposite sides and I got all up into Nick's business yeah yeah

for most of the game Sorry that's the game yeah yeah so that is technically what happened so John being the aggressive player uh got up in Nick's business and then they were just kind of like Cutthroat at each other over on one no John was Cut Throat at me okay so Nick let's just okay let's read retail this okay so Nick was kind of mind his business John just kept coming in there and messing up his Fields well I do think there's something with that the turn order here right because we were playing where it's like Anastasia then me then John right and so John has the opportunity to act after me every single time right whereas I'm kind of left with wooded Anastasia decide to do and because I'm not so good at this game um and I haven't I've only played it the one time prior I didn't like think about a lot of the times when you would do sneaky stuff like I'm gonna move a space and then I'm gonna take another turn and move two spaces and I was like what that's not at all where I thought anything was gonna be yeah um and so I couldn't I couldn't like anticipate in that kind of way whereas John always knew exactly where I was at at the end of my turn yeah that is true that is true that does make sense and then I was on the so I was on the other side of this area and so I'm just kind of building out on one side of the board by myself and then and then you know John is is basically taking all of Nick's work reaping all of the rewards and then coming out as the as the leader

in this game very early on and um and then stayed the leader through the whole game which actually was a little bit of a of a bummer I'm not gonna lie from the three-player game um that that you had such a lead and that you never really that happened almost never really came back and that hasn't necessarily been um my experience playing this two-player maybe one out of those two player games that happened but like for the most part it's been much more time I think John and I have tied this game literally the first time we played was literally a tie we were laughing about it I don't recall how the tie goes but I'm not sure if it's friendly but we thought it was hilarious and this is the thing we typed 200. 228 Points each just like are you freaking kidding me and I think it's come down to like one point or something like it's come it's come down very some very very close games but anyways to go back to that idea that like kind of you have a leader in the three-player game and then it's a different dynamic because I could think that's a little King maker like suddenly I want to like take John down so then suddenly I was doing things that were good for me but they're hurting Nick and I'm like oh man I feel bad like I'm I want to be gone down you know what I mean like is it is it yes you're still doing that but it I can see that it changes that chest like quality of a duel you know of the of the the you know just two people going back and forth and kind of being able to anticipate so much more of what each other is going to do yeah it really brought to mind Carcassonne to me

um the first few times I played Carcassonne I thought it was fine you know it's a Thailand game putting things down you could be you know kind of cutthroat getting each other's way and whatnot and then I played two-player carcasson a few times and I absolutely fell in love with the game and it's still one of my favorite game games specifically at two players and I think there's a lot of parallels they're both Thailand games they're both games where you can get a bunch of points based off of the efforts of your opponents and uh they're both games where if you have three players it's kind of possible to to not be able to punch the right person at the right time whereas in the two-player game there's only one other person and you're always going after them they also both have the I put my thing out in this game it's a windmill instead of a meatball and then when it scores I recollect it so there's kind of that limitation of how many uh anticipatory scorings you can set up uh then then the other way I will say I think that's a little bit more interesting in carcassone I feel like there's something about the like economy of the going in and going out whereas like in Sealand it only came up the one time in this game with you John where you were at a cap of windmills and it got in your way yeah and I I wish that tension was a little bit tighter but maybe I'm just too eager to cash in things that are on the board and that's just a misplay on my part I think we felt that in some other plays of it there's been the tension of like I really need a windmill and I'm too Diversified or I have none on the board this is actually the first game that

I've played of it and like John pointed out I think this is my sixth game of it this is the first time that I didn't have any windmills on the board and needed to take vegetation tiles which when you don't have any windmills they do nothing for you right so I felt like I took a couple of wasted turns because I didn't have enough but there is there is a fun Dynamic of that that I that does hearken to Carson it's funny that up until this moment I never actually made that comparison funnily enough there is a there's a lot of carcassani elements in here yeah which is interesting I mean jumping off of the carcasson comparison I would really like to talk about the rondelle uh because so far we've been talking about the you know the knife fight on this hex board and whatnot putting towels down now like Knife Fight is that like just a terminology we're gonna use it's like I guess podcasting around well I mean I guess to a certain extent that feels that way you know on the hex grid because you so often get in like physically into each other's spaces like you get points by putting vegetation next to your Mill and I could just put my own Mill next to your Mill like like could not be closer and I just deny you points like you're not gonna score points from the spot and it just feels like a proximity to the uh the interaction that happens I just I guess it was hilarious to me is that I hate games that are aggressive I like actively dislike so John just not true

attack people I think that I don't like them yes John claims to be Nick actually I think enjoys fairly aggressive tactical games and yet this is this is I guess this is my style of aggression yeah yeah anyways you were making a point John and I took you off of it no no that's fine so in Carcassonne every turn you draw a tile randomly and then you have to put it down on the board and there could be a lot of awesome decisions from that um but it's a random tile draw and you do the best that you can with it but in Sealand there is this rondelle and it has nine different spots for tiles and the tiles are either vegetation or Mills like we've been saying and there's one other spot that we don't really need to go into and there is this communal Pawn that just wanders clockwise around a circle that has all these tiles on it and on your turn you move the pawn one to I think five spaces forward depending on something else I'll talk about in a second but you have options like you're not randomly pulling a tile and trying to see what the best thing to do is you could you generally have a whole bunch of these things that you can pick and this is kind of hard to describe in a podcast format but the number of spaces you can move forward is dictated by how many spaces you've moved compared to your opponents there's this double rondelle the second rondelle essentially where the more you move the Camino Pawn means the more you move your own pawn and you can only move within a certain amount of distance from your opponents that's a long way of saying let's say I

keep moving like two or three times on my turn and it keeps moving once soon I will run out of Runway essentially Nick is holding this leash back and suddenly on all of my turns I can only move to the next tile it's a functionally carcassone I'm randomly drawing a tile where I see what the tile is but I don't have control and that's because Nick is is being really stingy with his his usage of this movement ability and the moment Nick actually starts using it that will give me some you know leash again to be able to go forward you know and I I you mentioned earlier on like is there actually a lot going on to this game and I don't want to overstate that there is a lot but I do think there are couple of considerations in this play that we just did Nick you you spent the first half of the game barely moving to the point where I literally was like are you Nick are you playing a mini game yeah because that's going to make this miserable I had like almost no flexibility once around you can kind of you're forced to pay points to gain that flexibility but it was an extra consideration like do you jump forward a whole bunch to get that tile because if your opponents move slowly then you know this really good turn could turn into some pretty lackluster turns in the future because you don't have flexibility yeah I mean part of the reason that I created the leash as the two of you called it um which I thought was funny that is because you were making stronger plays than I was but paying for them yeah and so then by sort of like slow boating it forces you to have no

choices on your turn and so by being able to kind of like constrict what you can do hopefully is my opportunity to catch up but by restricting what you do I'm restricting what I do so you always have to be making that choice of I'm gonna take a mediocre turn because then I can see it will be a really bad turn for you and uh this was the game you know the two of you talked about how it was like looser and faster when you played at three players than two players and I felt like I was one of the slower players this game as we've talked about before that's not commonly the case uh when we're playing and I think it was because I was in that position like I was in the position of power to like kind of stop the two of you from having options but then was it worth it for me to do that versus like what would happen if I gave you some power or no power no leeway so you can get into that situation and then what was interesting too is when I at one point kind of said okay well I can't keep doing this that I need to go do this other plan then that power shifts and then John was in charge of it yeah I started slow building it and maybe that's why this game felt so much quicker because the first half of the game Anastasia and I had very few choices on our turn yeah because Nick was was denying them actively which you know is is an interesting interaction I mean I think that that's I think it was tactically brilliant on Nick's part I mean I can sit here it's part of kind of the the way this game can go and I think you know if you play this game you have to be prepared that it does have some sharp edges in that sense where you can be like like oh Nick that's gonna make

this game miserable and it's like but it it's not about it being miserable I mean Nick was playing really smart like he was that was his way of exerting control and it was my choice to use all the you know spend all the coins go to the front and then recognize that my options are severely limited you know it gives you can't just place anywhere on the board you're you can only place next to Mills that you have and that's why I was talking earlier about how this is the first game that I was playing where I just I had nowhere to place things if I had nowhere to move and you know I I do think that that in some cases you know in addition to the idea that you know John you had a little bit of a runaway leader thing happen in this game and I do think it is possible and I'm kind of making a small assumption here because I think I think it's possible that in the three player player game or four player game and at times and maybe even in the two player game we've had that happen a little bit that you can probably find yourself in situations for multiple turns where based on choices you've made you might not have anything you can do and that that can be difficult but because the map is so shared it over time I feel like it you know as you said Nick for as much as you were holding us back in a way you're also holding yourself back like at some point you either had to go and take what you needed or you too were just going to continue to take bad tiles I mean it's a rondelle it's a random rundown there is a really interesting tug here of choices

of what do you take what do you do and then how does that affect your opponents and I think that piece of it makes this game more complex than just a simple tile layer to me and I actually think that that I agree with you somewhat Nick that Carcassonne is a little bit more interesting in its own right because of the puzzle that you're playing out different ways to earn points but this one is just to me it's it's the same level interesting it's just different it's just kind of two different mini games kind of played together um I don't know if that's how you guys feel yeah I mean there's no pattern matching in Sea land you just have to place a mill next to something else or a vegetation tile next to one of your Mills and you have a ton of flexibility with where you can actually go so the game's just asking you where do you want to go yeah I think what's interesting let's ask this question like which game do you think is harder to master sea land or carcasson my instinct would be Carcassonne is harder to master yeah I I think Mastery yeah I think I would agree with you on carcasson I think the big difference between sea land and cargo zone is that in Sea land the pieces that you're putting out there like you said you recall them but you can always recall them if you complete them but in Carcassonne there is this uh this moment where you have to put workers down forever you know the farmers you put them face down and you are permanently removing it from your collection and the moment you know deciding the moment when

to do that and where to do that I think is probably you know it's a consideration that you don't necessarily have uh in the sea land where it's just all about trying to cash out as many points from these things as you can if there's any of your pieces on the board at the end of the game in Sealand it's worth either zero or potentially negative points to you I don't know guys I mean yeah I guess but I I think I'm inclined to disagree slightly I mean I feel like they're about equal weight they're about the same teach yeah Sealand is does feel more abstract and there's a lot more math than sealant I mean that was a comment I was going to make anyways there is a lot of math like you are constantly counting out you want to just like get your get your math reps in addition you want you want to practice your Edition two plus seven plus six plus five plus five plus two plus three go I was like actually thinking I was like this would be like a great game like I don't have kids but like I'm like I could see like playing with this kid this is kids like a great educational game let's just do a lot of math together yeah because so and depending on it's pretty easy to to look at what's going on so you're kind of always doing that math to get a sense of what you're gonna score and there's a couple other layers to the game they haven't really talked about but but you know you're making choices based on how many points you have and are you going to score this this Governor that needs you to have a certain threshold of points and if you don't you get negative points so there's like all of these kind of layers going

on and I guess that to me is what makes think I think that sealing would be harder to master because reading the board and knowing where to go I guess I don't know in Kyrgyzstan you just like you pick up a tile and you place it down I just I there's a there's something beautiful in Zen and I actually I love carcassan I'm happy to play it anytime it comes out but I I feel like this one takes more thought to me personally this is super interesting point actually made me think about something with the both of them right so they there's this whole concept of input versus output Randomness and this doesn't have that in the same way I mean Carcassonne does when you draw a tile and this does in terms of like putting the tiles but what you do is at the beginning of your turn you choose you know which of the next things you want and then you place that and the placement is very simple right it's the windmill or the farm um and in carcassone it's you get this thing and now you need to decide where to place it and what the mode of your meeple is going to be are you gonna go robber or farmer or night and so yeah it's almost like I see what you're saying Anastasia and it made me like realize that there's certain there's like an inversion of where the decision point is for the player yeah right it's not just what tile do you take but is it worth the movement cost to you like there have been many times playing this game where I'm like oh wow that five of cabbage would be be amazing for me right now but if I do that then I'll go to the end of the leash and if Anastasia

doesn't move on her next turn and looking at the next tile she probably won't then after turn after that I'm gonna take that you know one of roses that does nothing for me so you know maybe I hold back or that kind of thing like yeah you're right there's instead of drawing a random tile like Carcassonne there's that decision space but then the decision space of where you go is maybe simpler because there isn't any restrictions that being said there's a lot of looking at a map with a sea of colors and numbers and trying to find the diamond in the rough you know every time you take a mill at least for my perspective I I'm like okay this is a four power Mill that seems great okay look at the board where where's the best spot and you know maybe there is a best spot sometimes there's kind of a coin flip um and actually that that leads me to something that I do think we should talk about you know input Randomness versus output Randomness because there is some output Randomness in this game um you know sure there's the rondelle that fills up behind the person you can wait see a couple turns ahead but out on the main board at the beginning of the game you randomly put a whole bunch of these Island tiles face down on specific spots and you flip them up when you build one of your Mills next to them and those Island tiles are generally good I would say um they're gonna be either vegetation like you know a three of roses or a two of cabbage something like that or they could be a little house and the houses have a zero on them which sounds terrible because you know that's plus zero points but the houses also come with a coin and on your turn you can spend up to one coin to take another turn and I know we mentioned this briefly earlier on like the possibility

of double turns and I think that's another fascinating decision space of the game is is when you spend those coins for the double turn but but going back to the output Randomness you know when you put these Mills down oftentimes you're putting it down next to one or two of these islands and you flip them over and you don't know what you're gonna get it could be a six of roses which would be amazing but if it is then it comes with that Governor Pawn that Anastasia briefly mentioned and if you don't score high enough with that Governor then you actually lose points but if you do score high enough you get points so it's like a double-edged sword and I know in the games that we've played I frequently find myself like a moth drawn to the flame of flipping over more tiles because I just I want to see what's underneath them because you know there's no bad hit generally uh yeah you don't keep saying there's no bad hit the number of times I've flipped over a governor that is then like the worst bill ever yeah I like there is no bad but you need to be able to to deal with what comes right like you know the governor wants to come check out your mail like it actually reminds me a little bit of they like to do that this is like a Kramer and Keely thing have you guys ever played since you see either of you no no it's not really the same concept but I've just immediately reminded of it maybe because of the gardens and stuff but it there's a similar element of like this person is Gonna Come review what you're doing right come like judge you they just enjoy that supervisory concept yeah I think so I hope I'm thinking I hope I'm hearkening to it correctly but if I remember correctly yeah anyways so yeah like you have that that Randomness that

you don't know until you commit to putting the tile down but honestly I found it fun like I said I find myself drawn to it I know Anastasia if you ever have a chance to put a mill down and flip three of these islands you you genuinely can't say no I know I did I said no today I said no tonight John literally was like uh you're not gonna be able to resist and I was like I have to I have to because I I have actually found in playing this game that I love flipping over tiles I also love kind of reading the map and finding spots where I can throw a mill down and just get like 15 points or something like a fantastic Mill scores you 40 points right that would be like that's amazing that's like the best meal ever yeah yeah a a good a decent Mill you know it gets you 25 to 35 you know and um actually that's a solid metal but anyways yeah I love finding those spots out of context this is just the most ridiculous decent yeah this is a hard game to explain this is definitely if there was ever one it's funny it's so light and yet this is the game where I'm like if there was ever one to go watch a playthrough I think part of the reason that it's hard to explain is because there isn't it doesn't have uh anything except for abstract components right it's like put these things down and score some points and we're like saying like a Mill and field but it's like put down the scoring thing and then put down the things around them yes and then make

the colors okay and then you can score the thing you know it really is pretty much right there at being an abstract game yeah it very much is but you know the these Governors added an additional layer of thought because on that rondelle as the rondelle moves the amount of points the governor wants to see from your fully enclosed Mill which really just means put a bunch of flower tiles around your Mill and then score it when it is encircled uh so that it fluctuates and so that changes you're like oh I got to close this one because the governor wants low points and I don't want to get the negative points so there's there's just like kind of all of these layers going on and you know there's also then flip the board over and play with a completely unhidden board if you want to which John and I did do once yeah yeah all the all the islands quote unquote are are flipped over so you know at the very beginning of the game where all the extra coins are to give you those bonus earns and where all the governors are and yeah we played that last week and I genuinely did not know if I would like it or not going in like I was super curious to try the uh I guess strategic variant you know because there's there's no output Randomness at all and while I did enjoy that game I think I went away from it missing the excitement the like the the what do I get yeah like you know the slot machine Like You Know What's it gonna be I really hope it's red yeah do you do you think you'd like that

Nick or do you like the the sort of hidden I mean I love exploring things so I I definitely missed the exciting details yeah I think for particularly for game of this weight um it's it's fun to do that first of all right like exactly the two you're saying but then the other thing too is I think that if it's on the other side it just lends itself more towards like if I go here then you can go there that opens up for you to like take this spot but I want the extra action space and like more moments of like I won't go here so you can't go here which I think is unfun and and because it's it's random it's like well I'll go here and you can like hit two islands but I don't know maybe they're good maybe they're bad I'm just gonna do what's best for me like you know there's there's less of that like oh I I've I'm such a dummy because it's on board that it's such a good spot for you to go there um I think I'd prefer the randomness I know in in our game near the end of that two-player game on the quote-unquote Strategic side I took a turn to take all of the last coins on the board I did a double turn spending a coin I already had to make sure I grabbed the last coin so that I would for sure have a one more coin that Anastasia did going into the end game and considering you can spend a coin to take another turn that could be just enormous at the right moment especially when you're getting close to the end of the game and you know what that never would have happened on the regular side but on the Strategic side I could see where those coins were and I specifically ran out to grab them them before she could take them yeah it's kind of amazing to me that in 2010 with

very prolific like skilled designers take another turn is a mechanic in a game and I think it works in Sea land because your turn you know generally the action you're gonna take is pretty tight so if I take a double turn like usually it's like okay I've planned my turn to take a double turn and it's not gonna add that much extra like space in there but that's like like take it take an extra turn or lose a turn is like feels really old school very unpopular very old school yeah I think I don't even think about that that's so funny like I'm like I'm like of course you do like I'm like it it seems to work so well here but I think that's the part of that is because you can save it up and cash it in and I really like that that you're kind of positioning it is this the turn is this the turn I don't know I don't know because a lot of what you do with a double turn not only to get yourself out of some of those sticky situations we've already talked about but the ability to like grab a Mill and then grab another tile and like extend out and do a flip or like speaking of the Strategic side in the game I played with John on the on that the side where nothing is hidden there were a lot of opportunities to because nothing is hidden you can spread out on the map a lot more quickly the idea of sealing being that you kind of all start in the center and then you can only add tiles to the sort of discovered area to look at the kind of area that's on the board just kind of continues to expand out into the sides and in the game where everything was face up

I was like oh well I can actually just put a towel here and then that adds this to the discovered area and then I can jump to the other side of it and then I can put a towel here and then I can open up this and like it just it expanded and unfolded in a way I didn't expect and that was the part that to me that was really intriguing it was very different at least in terms of adding variety I still think I would play the the hidden one that would be my choice but you know if we continue to play this you know uh fairly often I would probably mix it up you know sometimes and it's nice to have the choice it's just the other side of the board yeah yeah do you see yourself playing this fairly often you know that's a really good question when when John and I played it that first time I immediately made a TTS mod for it so we could play it more and that was during a time which is still the case where I was on this very old game I'm putting this in air quotes old game kick which is like you know like as you said what 12 years old is not that old but I was feeling myself very drawn which I still am to this idea like kind of looking backwards and board gaming right like so looking for those hidden gems looking for the games and around the same time we played helles which you could watch a playthrough of that on John's Channel we played um spectaculum also a playthrough of that on John's Channel and and Sealand was one of those games and I just was having the best time with these guys when we finish that first game like

it really sung that first time yeah and you know even though it took two hours we had it was just it was fabulous and and every play that we've had since has had a very similar feel and it just it fits a nice space you know you know we we play a lot of games you know where we're just sort of like grab an hour and we do it and and and it's it's nice for like the end of the night where it's like hey you know what it's 9 30. you want to play a game for an hour like or two hours it fits that space well when you want to think you want something that's just not gonna all those games do that's not gonna take a ton of brain power and a ton of load up but having said that I do think that it doesn't have I I had to be reminded of the shine like I'd sort of like I put it the other night I was like John you want to play a game here's like six games I threw out and I threw it on there and it I told John I was like that's the one I want to play the least and it's the one he picked and I just it's just because it had kind of lost the shine for me I was like I was like do I really want to do that math do I remember all the intricacies or the role there are not that many rules just to be clear but there's some things to consider and it doesn't you don't look at it and think oh like what am I you know I think I'd probably pick Hellas over it I think hella's for me has been the game the The Hidden Gem of the Year for me uh but I but now that we've like like brought it back up and like I mean seriously last week we played it three times in seven days yeah that's that's quite a lot we played it

back to back last week you know two days in a row and once it's in your brain like that was so easy I was like I was like yeah you wanna play that again let's do it you know I so yeah I don't really see this one going away like I part of it too is Johnny keeps winning it's so freaking annoying to lose this game and I yeah it's like I think I won on the tiebreaker or we friendly tied on that one but we've had some really close games but yeah we played this for the first time a couple times like you said like six eight months ago something like that and then last week you you really wanted to play Carnegie I know you did and it was like literally it was 10 30 at night and I just did not have the brain to dig into like a deep strategy game where the things I'm focusing on and like the the paths I'm going down in the beginning lead to the middle only to the end I just wanted to look kind of at my feet and maybe a few feet ahead of me you know tactically and just make a bunch of decisions and that's part of the reason why I think I like Thailand so much it was the the brain space that I really wanted that night and also like moving forward this really is just my wheelhouse I'm much more of a 60 Minute Euro gamer than I am uh uh a 120 minute Euro gamer even though again we've somehow managed to play this in two hours uh repeatedly but it's a brain space that works really well for me so I I also have a copy I got this one after uh playing Anastasia's copy because I I really fell for it so much um I will say that playing it three players versus all those two player games I do wonder about the different player counts because I've genuinely loved this game like loved it at two

players and the three player game was fine but it did feel a little looser and a little less serious in a way and I think it's because you just have to play a little bit more tactical because there's two other the people that can mess things up and you don't know how those things are going to collide I I think you know the two player version of this game is like a 9 out of ten you know maybe even 10 out of 10. I've been loving this one at two players the three player game is is maybe more like seven and I know I don't know what a four player game would be like I wouldn't say no to it but it's it's interesting how different they are but I think I would give the same exact numbers to Carcassonne for those different Americans one thing that we were talking about earlier we were just joking about the math that you have to do that's like third grade math but you have to do a lot of it yeah and I was thinking about actually playing this game with with you know kids like I could see actually like I like wish that this game existed when I was a kid because I know I was a gamer kid right my parents were Gamers and so we definitely could have put this on the table I could have been like you know totally solid at the game um and enjoyed it but then as you kind of like are developing your gaming skills you're just seeing Oh it's not even just I'm not just maximizing my points I'm trying to decide like where down the line do I want to go or like how do I want to set this up so I can have kind of a better turn in the future or stop them from having a good turn right now and so the fact that it can you can play it totally respectively by just being like I'm gonna make the big numbers go boom um and do what seems best like right now

in the immediate moment or you can graduate to I'm gonna think a couple steps ahead I think is a cool aspect of this game that on repeated plays you know people could really develop their gaming skills through it which I think is is not all games have that and this one I think does yeah yeah it's a really interesting point and you know when you think about a lot of I don't mean to group them together because this is just Kramer and who's the co-designer on this one John Gunter Burkhart what else has he done I don't know his uh a bunch of things um uh Maori is the first one that jumps out to me that I genuinely really like Maori ULM is a euro game from like five or six years ago that I thought was fine but Maori is a super cool Thailand game um where you have this kind of kind of a rondelle around a grid of of squares and you're building out Islands I think you'd really dig it it's got some Vikings Vibes to it well I was actually going to go straight to Vikings funny you should say and I you know it's funny because I kind of loop Kramer and kiesling together even though they don't always design together clearly they didn't Design This one together yeah and I've always kind of gone back and wondered like over time I've been like do I like more am I more of a Kramer girl am I more of a kieslinger sounds like some business in 1920s New York yeah

sells meats or something like that 100 um but you know Vikings I've talked about a number of times I gotta get you guys to play Vikings more we I would I would love I'm down I love tiling I just that they're games and again grouping here but the games uh that they've had a hand in generally for me have been some of my favorite light I don't even call them light because they're so there's all they're exactly where you're talking about Nick they're like the rules Like rules light simpler tile layers often depends on the game but there's there's always like some kind of math component but there's like these layers and you could play the simple version or you can play the not simple version and I actually recently you know John and I were on like a konitzia kick a couple months ago too kind of right after we played this and similarly I do just kind of appreciate these older Euros for that for that kind of layered you can it's they're easy to get into you can totally enjoy your first game you could be younger and play it and get it and then develop more skills but even as an older gamer you know I feel like I can develop with a game like this where the more I play it the easier it is for me to read the board the easier it is for me to do it the more I can see the layers Vikings I always go back to because for me that was probably the first first board game I played because I played it so much I

played it so many times on Yukata and I you know we talked you know when we were talking about Nick you know training quote unquote for the world board gaming championships like I felt like I trained in that game like I just I wanted to get good I wanted to understand it and now I play that game completely differently than I would then I played it you know when I first started and I I love that it's such a simple game can do that and I feel that that's sort of what's Happening Here with Celine like I think John has gotten very good at this game it's very annoying because we played at the same number of times and I am still kind of waiting to see you know talked about Mastery I'm still I'm still waiting to see what I'm missing because I am not clicking my my choices are not being as smart as John's and I find that both like frustrating and exciting because that's a challenge I kind of want to you know a puzzle I want to figure out I mean part of the reason why I was all up in Nick's business in this play that we just did is because that's what I'm used to you know we played all these two player games and just you know trying to get these incremental advantages in a you know one versus one type setting I just kind of used to playing Close Quarters sea land and like I could totally see some people just kind of doing their own thing you know Nick goes to the West Anastasia goes kind of North and I kind of go east and we all kind of build our own thing and we're like oh that was fine you know but like I could see some groups playing this not Cutthroat at all you know much in the same way some people play nice carcassone and they don't you know try to force other people's castles into

unbuildable orientations and whatnot uh just you know one person to the next it sounds like John plays like evil carcasson I'm like I'm not like having some question marks here about I mean it's it's interesting John how you you made a good point that by going off into the Into the Wilderness by myself if you will I did I had to do all the work by myself yeah there was no shares basically going on yeah but I want to before we wrap this up I want to go back to something that Nick you know games like this they just you know all that we just talked about this sort of represents you know um the kanitzias that I've been playing with John and Hellas and spectacular and Sealand and we have kind of talked about this these aren't really these really aren't your jam so much I mean you enjoy them you'll play them with us but I don't think you you get quite excited like we do yeah but is that a question or just yeah that was it was a question it would it would why yeah why yeah I think I think one of the things that I really enjoy about playing new games is like deconstructing new systems and figuring out like how this and that interacts with each other and interlocks with each other and a lot of these games they're not interested in doing that right like sea land is interested in getting you into playing the game ASAP there's not a lot to like unlock their um you can you know develop your Mastery over time by playing it and understanding like the Dynamics but like I'm not a big chess player I'm not a big go player you know like I don't I don't tend to to go for

that style of of interaction and you know I think one thing you mentioned earlier about me liking aggressive games I actually don't think that's true but the thing is that I like for a game to be very honest for what it is and so um like a game like Kemet which is a very aggressive game I really like because it basically just it just rewards you for attacking and there are other avenues that you could go in that game but like mostly gets geared towards you're supposed to be attacking in this game and so you don't end up taking it one way or another and I like uh Sealand for its its elegance and its smoothness but am I playing this game to score points am I playing this game to stuff you from scoring points um and then what does that look like when I'm playing it I think the identity of it as like two and four players is is very different and so they just they don't they don't just like compel me uh I guess in the way that uh that a bunch of other games usually frontier games are going to yeah I mean coming back to Carcassonne I know Nick you and I played a two-player game of Carcassonne a handful of months ago on board game arena and I I feel like you walked away from it with the same exact thing where I was just like oh man that was so great it was so tight and you were just like that was fine and yeah I guess it's an interesting difference in in uh in preference it's I guess you just enjoy more systems yeah I do usually like more systems yeah we got a few more things

going on which I think makes sense I mean I don't think this comes as any surprise but I think you know Nick you growing up playing board games in the way that you did I think you can take apart you know a game much faster than I can you know oftentimes I feel like when we come to especi some of these heavier games I feel like when we get to them it's like you immediately see a through path through them and I'm like okay I'm over here drowning like in this like Pond like um that I found my way into and you're like oh here's the castle and I found the dragon I'll say also that it's not it's not just about heaviness which certainly is like kind of where I incline like when I think about like playing games with my family like we got really into playing like the mind and the game which you can argue you think those are games or activities and I want to get into that discussion I love them I have no problem I'm a big fan right but there's there's no depth or intricacy to those games but you know we played a ton of that and the crew also like you know the crew is it's a cooperative ticking game like we played a crap ton of that and it's not you know very deep there's a lot of interlocking mechanisms in those games either yeah but there's there's something very but they're like the mind for instance is like very honest about what it is right I'm here to like fling cards and then yell and frustration when we didn't get on the same page no I think it's interesting because it's I wonder is it at Cape May which is arguably a lighter

game and you were like yeah I think you we both even enjoyed it more on the first play even than John did because it was like it just had I was really into the theme but I also liked the layers there and I think that was similar to what even though it was a light game yeah I do really love when a game has a personality I mean outside of board gaming my my primary hobby is like playing dungeons the dragons so like things with like stories and components and that like do do really do something for me that I like so when when a game has I mean when a game has a theme that like speaks well to the mechanics that's amazing but even just if the game has has just like an interesting dressing and it feels like it's going for that um yeah sea land doesn't try it's like it's about to send windmills that is kind of what I met with the luster a little bit that's a really good point yeah it's interesting so I guess I think that's going to wrap up everything we we have to say on Sealand it's uh it's fun to bring an older game on here there's a couple of others that you know once even wounds we've mentioned that I think we'll try to talk some old games when we when we all feel so inclined it's uh it's nice to kind of Look Backwards not the least of which because that's kind of where my tastes have been but I guess with the Essen coming up and all the cons we're going to be getting all the new releases coming out soon here hypothetically but yeah I'm really glad we talked about this one too I'm still really digging it in particular at two players it's it's definitely my current jam and uh you know playing it

three times in a week definitely says something I'm looking forward to playing it more I'm sure it'll get back burner relatively soon but hopefully a year from now we'll we'll bust it out again uh reread the rules and be like oh yeah that's right I remember why I like this game do you know John before all of this you were like I never replay games like up until like two years ago I feel like like you played games like like twice and now now we got you playing games like 10 times in a week I have you to blame for that and uh and thank you anyways uh thank you all for hanging out with us yeah if you have any thoughts about this game if you know about it if you've played it or if you you know are totally confused about it then uh please go to the YouTube version of this episode you can find a link to it in the description and write us some comments we really appreciate it and yeah catch you next time Brown Brown

Progress saved