Memoir '44: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey welcome back to fat never enters and this time we're doing a no run-through review of memoir 44 by Days of Wonder in my more 40 for you and a note player it's a two-player game can play up to four by that's one of those things where it's really a two-player game you go through a bunch of scenarios depicting battles that actually happened in real life with you know very very clear winners and you recreate these in in a board game you know strategy type setting it's kind of like a what-if scenario and I the reason why that it's an this is a no run-through review instead of an actual run through is because I did not like this game at all like like I don't hate it I don't think it would make my top like if I did a top 10 games I hate again I don't think it would make it make the list it might be an honorable mention and this is a difficult one for me to give one because I only hear good things about this so whenever I first played it I played just the the you know the tutorial the very first scenario with another friend and we played it and it just did not click for us at all like we were just very one we were just we were bored with it and we were pissed off the entire game and then it had an obvious
winner and so we were like okay this this is obviously a shitty game well I was like okay you know maybe it was just the tutorial that cuz it could just be oh here's just the mechanics of the game yeah the real weed isn't like the advanced or the further scenarios so we did a few of those same same exact feelings like nothing nothing really changed about it and okay so here's so so a lot of people praised this game they think it's extremely somatic they think that it's extremely tactical and strategic that you feel like you actually were in in the battle you feel like that oh my god this is exactly how it happened yes okay uh so with that with that let's let's just take the theme and and the battles that happen and all that and whenever you're recreating those scenarios it's like it's almost like what's the point kind of so if in a certain battle that the Nazis won the battle and it's like if you want to say that's the mattock then it's almost like what's the point of playing it because the Nazis are gonna win and it's no longer that what-if scenario or like Oh what if this happened in the battle it's like oh whether if that did to happen and the results are still the same it was just done a different way to me that didn't make a whole lot of sense I it's like if it's so grounded in theme just read the history that comes in the in
the in the in the book in the scenario but can be like oh okay then that was pretty cool and then put it back up there's no reason to actually play it play the scenario whenever you're looking at your opponent and you're like hun the Nazis won oh it's because they have you know ten times as many people as I do interesting and I'm gonna lose so it's almost like one person is sitting there like what's the point if you want to sit there and say well it's a weather scenario the Nazis could have lost that's that's fine or the Allied could have lost either one that's it's perfectly fine I will actually dismiss my argument on that one because a game like War of the Ring for example is one where it's of what if kind of game yeah except it's hard for the heroes to win but they they can like and I feel like it's done a little bit better in War of the Ring to where like yes okay what if you know all these people broke apart and they helped allies and then they help through fight and every for it and I did all that that's more of a what-if scenario because it's one that's fictional like it didn't actually happen this one all the stuff actually did happen so you're playing a scenario or there's actual historical context behind it which is cool like that's that's the thing it's really really cool to recreate these battle and actually set it up and be like ah man yeah this is this is kind of intense and and seeing the outcome even though it's kind of weighed in the favor of the victor of the actual battle but that's
fine what if they allied beat the Nazis in this particular battle at that that's cool okay so let's go on to the things that I really really really dislike about this game and it's I want to say originally it was a mindset thing and that's why we played it again because the first game I was like I was so kind of caught off guard I thought I knew like this element and I'll get to it in a sec but I thought maybe this element didn't really expect it to actually be so heavily involved so whenever my second game I played I was like totally like ready for it and my feelings were still the same and that is this game is luck it is absolutely lucky the entire game and and yeah and it wouldn't be so bad yes so every combat and never almost everything you do almost is revolved around dice and that's fine because in games and more games dice happen they can go your favor one one game and you'll love the game they'll go against you the other and and you'll hate it it's just it's one of those things and that's okay because even if you're watching me play where I'm playing I'm pissed off because the dice suck at the after the game I will be fine but during the game why would I be happy if things are just as your you're not smarter than me you're not more strategic than I am if you just got lucky like better dice rolls that's not like that's just not how anything works so in a game that supposed to be so strategic when everything you do is like huh okay I
have ten ten times as many people as you huh I missed every single attack cool my strategy is perfect I'm doing everything right and uh but that sucks that you get everything you need and I get it don't get any that's not it's not like I had to out thank you or you had L thank me and it's like oh my god and expect you to do that [ __ ] I didn't plan for that so that's why you're winning now it yeah look at all these hits I'm getting oh they all died yep I win no but but fine dice happen let's dis let's also dismiss that one what really bugs me really bugs me about this game is that there is one deck of cards that you and the other person share and there's really powerful cards in here and these cards are what bring you to play the game it's a very card driven game hand management which I do like I like the hand management but it's how the board is broken up into three sectors you know left middle right and these cards that you draw I'll tell you who you can order it's like or they're two units from the left flank it's like okay so you pick those and then you order those and then some and then they vary it's one deck that you that you share so the entire game you not only are you getting it's luck based on the dice it's luck based on the card you draw as well if you really need to order your right unit you better pray to [ __ ] God that you get the cards to do that and that bugs me so
much like if the dice were there I'd be like ok yeah that sucks but if you had action points or you had you know action points to spend and like moving units costs like more or you had just standard actions that you all can do and you get and that would be perfectly fine I would actually keep this game but the fact that everything you do is revolved around dice and a deck of cards and hope that you get what you need and not only that some dirt it's true throughout this deck which is not it's not divided up evenly it's just one deck these shuffle and then hope you get what you want straight in are you know very powerful cards that you could never get your opponent could just draw all of them and and then like you're just getting a Tecton you just have your shitty regular movement and attack and hope that you have the right because this is the second game I played I lost because all he had to do is I kill a unit of tanks and I couldn't move him so he was getting all the right cards to move his people up and attack I couldn't do anything about it that's not strategic that's not the mannequin anyway because your orders are you not some like dumbass that's like oh the love sudden weight more important there's nothing happening over there still gonna focus on the left side that's that doesn't make any sense me and I the person who was like oh this game is amazing that I've been talking to he was like well it's all about hand management okay fair enough yes if you technically know that the
deck can screw you you'll hold on the cards that you may need later okay except like it's kind of like those in games whenever there's like a certain power your date like you have like take pandemic for example you have an event card that you're like okay we can use this right now and it'll help us right now but there could be a time where it's way more important you can't predict that you can't you can hope and be lucky that oh I think I'll be held on to this card but that's not that's that's luck and that's hoping and I don't like that so like it's kind of like okay if I had I had moved the right unit multiple times it's just I couldn't do it whenever I needed to because I needed to move them earlier in the game the fact that the hand management part is completely mute in my opinion it's just you better hope you get the dice you need and you better hope you get the cards you need and more importantly you're going to get the cards you need so you can then roll the dice you need and get the results you need to win the game so no no it's just it's too skewed in what was portrayed as a very somatic and and strategic game when all reality you and the other person are sitting there and rolling dice and hoping that you you win I just I could not do it it was it was not for me in any way which is a shame because I have a bunch of expansions for this luckily someone wants that way more than I do and the fix that I've heard to this game is oh
just buy another base copy so spend 40 50 bucks for a second deck of cards so I'm not going to do that because I'm not spending 50 bucks for a goddamn deck of cards and even then that doesn't the problem because yes now it's okay the results are still the same now you have your deck of cards okay yay and your opponent has their deck of cards same deck of cards shuffled completely different so it doesn't matter that oh hey I got the draw from drawn from the same deck I'm not getting what I want you are it's the exact same he could have his own deck of cards that he's getting everything he wants why I'm getting this still it's insane it's the same and I don't like that I don't like that whenever I play a card that's like an airborne strike and I pick some people I roll dice I'm italic you lawyer people because I didn't feel like I did anything to deserve that and I just I like strategy games to have a sense of meaning of strategy and like actual thinking to them and like okay if I do this you might do that and I want to come with like if this was more tactical like that or I'm thinking okay if I move my people he can come down here that means I can flank them and oh and I'll catch him off guard it was it just there was none of that there was just I I moved up and rolled dice and missed and you just killed them because I moved them up there's really nothing to it and it's a shame because I've heard a lot of good things about this game and hence why I bought it and I was like oh this is right up my alley it's not it's it's not at all not even a
little bit like it looks cool whenever you're setting up the board all the terrain tiles and all the RV you're like this is good oh yeah looking at it seems like it's gonna be a lot of fun like you're gonna be like oh my god I have [ __ ] on the tanks I'm gonna kick your ass it doesn't even it doesn't feel that way at all because you can have you know a unit of four tanks move up next to one guy like one you because the number of people doesn't determine the number of dice you roll if they're always a unit so the little infantry people will always roll the certain amount of dice regard they start with three I believe all right now for in an area and if you had one guy in that hex its they still roll the same around the dice so that doesn't make sense either and it's just like I could roll up for [ __ ] tanks next to him attack him miss okay find the mattock hid okay and he comes in rolls three dice for some reason still it's like one person is just as strong and blow up a tank it's like that that doesn't like it because the grenade results are wilds and they hit everything or they roll a flag and make your guys retreat it's like really the one infantry guy made my Legion of Tanks retreat okay oh and now you get to keep advancing and Eiling it to move them so you're just gonna pick them off because you're getting the results it's like no this was not for me
at all I have no interest in ever playing this again and I have no interest in playing any of the expansions hence why I'm getting rid of all of it uh if I had to rank this out of 10 obviously ten being perfect five average and one being complete [ __ ] it's not a one because I see the potential that's the thing is when the games I give low ratings are games that I would rather see every copy burned at a game burning that I'm organizing for some religion that I've now created on hating on hating games that's not a bad idea I can probably make a lot of money that way anyway uh so it's not a one I huh for my personal taste I'd probably give it a four I think it's below average I really did not like this game for what it was and it could be completely how it was described to me and portrayed to me and unfortunately that that goes a long way in board games so I did not enjoy it the person I played with also did not enjoy it I'm not just making like make it something he really didn't like it I forced him to play the second game because he did not like the first one the first one was you had to the the allied units had like had to actually come up in advance on a bridge and you had to get like you have to get like four unit kills so if you kill everyone then a hex you take one of them places
and then usually a certain number of those to have you win so he had to on me we need to get to four and I finally got to two because he was the Nazis behind sandbags which reduced dice and all that but if they move the sandbags go away for some reason they just disappear or obliterate I don't know how I won was I just happen to you know move I to kills he had two pills and I moved my unit onto a bridge and if you had your people on the bridge that counted of this too so I won that way and it was just so anticlimactic it was just I'll so you just move on the bridge and win yep that was it I want so haha you suck like yeah I know you can have prevented that I mean you kind of quit just kept his people there but I mean that's that's not the point so I'm probably gonna give it a 4 out of 10 not for me at all but I've been proven wrong before and who knows maybe years years later someone will be like yes it's right again and I'll love it I don't know I doubt it I highly doubt it but that's memoir 44 let me know what you think of this game in the comments below and we can have a nice friendly discussion or debate on this game friendly apparently but other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you want to support us you can go ahead and click that link
to go to my patreon account if you have any suggestions you can go ahead and click the link in the show notes below the goal of my board game geek list other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of data is for you