Skip to main content
Loading video...

Homeworld Fleet Command Preview: Undaunted In Space

Transcript 25:55

hi everyone I'm tally this is Faro and we are bored of it and today we're going to be previewing Homeworld Fleet command so this is a game that's based on the video game series Homeworld which came out in the 90s onwards it's for two to four players but we've saved primarily it's for two players really because in a similar way to games like Star Wars rebellion if you play with four players you are just kind of dividing down the responsibilities um that you would have in a two-player game so primarily two-player gameplay wise we have got some dice checking card management it's a two-player head-to-head tactical battle where you're going to be trying to complete objectives and maybe take out your opponents in space mechanically is different but we kind of get vibes of undaunted so we've been calling it undaunted in space yeah that's kind of a pithy way to describe it um so Homeworld was very popular video game series I believe the original was Game of the Year in 1999 and this takes that translates it to a board game and you're kind of playing through ever through scenarios of ever increasing difficult difficulty so first scenario very basic you just have some Fighters teaches his basic mechanics and buy scenario five you have hundreds of gameplay elements thrown in tactical elements and these scenarios are based off some of the things that

happen in the story of Homeworld so if you're a fan of the video game you're going to get some of that flavor for sure and as professional reviewer I decided to buy the game and play it um so I can I can confirm but also if you've never even heard of Homeworld which we hadn't before we took this on it is pretty fun I mean if you if you do like these head-to-head Battlers then it's it's for you basically so we're going to give you a brief overview just kind of go over the Baseline rules and then we'll discuss what we think of it

you'll begin playing Homeworld by picking a scenario and the game comes with 10 kind of pre-made ones and then some instructions on how to design your own and I definitely think this is going to be something that you know there'll be a community online on Board Game Geek and people will be creating their own scenarios and you can look up so I think there's going to be quite a wealth of content available but as I kind of said in the intro there's 10 scenarios I think based on different aspects of the video games or scenarios or missions and you're going to work through them and the first one's very basic and then the first kind of five add more and more and more rules and then after the fifth one you're kind of ready to play and you know they have all kinds of different stuff going on there's different goals and the core of how you win is you get medals for doing certain tasks and whoever has the most medals at the end of the game wins and the game can end if someone gets all medals possible which usually means that the other player cannot get some of their medals yeah or complete some of their tasks or the the round tracker goes to zero basically and there's different stuff like sometimes you know I think the first mission one of us had to kind of get next to the other person's planet and then fly back home and the other person had to stop them from doing that yeah um because they're always asymmetric yeah very excited yeah and you know then this one here in front

of us just played tally had to capture my space station which is hidden behind the Minefield and I had to defend it and how did that go not great no you played people iterated the kind of you guys it lasted like three rounds you've got a very lucky role in one of them to be fair oh yeah that was quite funny yeah I got like and then every one of my dice was a hit uh so so you set up your scenario right and then how you play is the first thing you're gonna do is both players will roll for initiative and it should say that you know there's two factions in this so one's kushan and the other's taigan um and yeah so the red and blue basically yeah and they kind of have uh unique ship managers but not really unique ships um so you're going to roll for initiative so you both roll and you can discard kind of your command cards which is a card you play to take actions to boost that number and whoever rolls the most gets to go first and the other gets a Valor token which is like this little token you can spend to re-roll like an entire roll of dice but then it goes to the other player yep and you really you roll for initiative every round yeah every round so yeah so the round structure is roll for initiative and then you'll take turns playing these command cards like I play one tally plays one I play one target plays one and you kind of have your you know

scenario give you the ships you have and your uh faction card and maybe some abilities and leaders and these will tell you how many of these command cards you can draw and how many you can play which are different numbers and when you play one you activate a kind of unit and a unit is a group of ships so you can kind of see here there's three ships in this unit there's six ships in this one and they all kind of act as one basically it's just about you know if you get three hits against you you lose three ships so you activate one unit for that card and then you take an action with it and then it goes back and forth and then obviously you're kind of trying to attack people or capture things or um and yeah I mean that's basically it at the end of the round you can discard down if you want and then you'll draw back up and you'll kind of keep going until someone wins yeah and I think we'll just we can call that the brief overview and we can kind of get deeper into gameplay as we dissect so let's go to the dissection okay so now we'll just talk a little bit about our highlights from the game what do we like and maybe things that we didn't like didn't like or didn't work so well um for me I really like how you can be very strategic in the way that you approach each scenario or like battle or wherever it is um I think it's very fun to sit back at the end of the game and say hmm yeah shouldn't have been so

um offensive or defensive or I should have played it like this so you've got a lot of options in terms of the strategy of that how you play yeah you really do is a game that you finish it and you dissect how you played and what you did and you're like oh I should have done that I made a mistake there and it's it's quite fun in that way to do that definitely and even going into each scenario you can think about okay where everything is what's my objective should I play offensive or defensive or try to I don't know split my units to send my opponent in One Direction or whatever it might be so you can really strategize and make a plan as if it was like a real space battle I would say yeah exactly um so in this particular scenario that we just played I was thinking at the beginning this is my Mothership and uh should I just try to send some units to the Minefield to blow it up so that I can get my bigger units like through or should I just move everyone together and kind of take it step by step uh should I try and knock your Fighters out so that you're just like not in my way the entire time and yeah you can really yeah yeah yeah but it's difficult because um you can only activate each unit once in a round so once you've used them you have to wait until the next round to use them you can't just keep activating them and keep moving the same one but that's a really fun challenge so that's like puzzle for sure yeah exactly a highlight for me is the puzzle of when to activate each unit um trying to

anticipate what your opponent's going to do and acting accordingly so should I use move and act like attack uh you here right at the beginning of the scenario to get your units down or actually I did want to move something else further back but then I'm leaving my other thing open uh for you to maybe attack me so really like fun to strategize and a fun puzzle to try and figure out of what you activate and when um I think the card action command system is really smooth as well very simple you have an amount of cards some have more detailed actions on them so you use like the front of it but if you just want to do a basic action you just yeah move attack basic right exactly but these cards are really an interesting system because they're kind of random and you shuffle them and it's like you say they have access so it could be the card it will be like I don't know um like weapons to full available titles yeah and it'll be like move and then attack like with a kind of bonus attack strength yeah and so you get to do both of those by playing that card and there'll be other ones uh like more for you Fighters where you know it'll be like I think it will be like like drive by or something hit and run away and you'll get to like fly in attack and then you fly away a bit so by when they activate next turn they can't get you they have to move to get you and in

particular one of the funner cards you can get are these interrupt cards yeah which are both really fun and incredibly annoying if they're played against you where you interrupt what the other person's doing so if they move to attack you before they like interrupt and now I attack and you get to attack them first which if it's like fighter on fighter you could reduce them by half so suddenly they're only rolling three dice instead of the six they thought they were yeah and then they're gonna roll less hits or for instance in this game that we just played you did a really annoying thing where I had a card where I could move attack and then run away yeah but you did an interrupt move and run away yeah rendering the rest of my card where I could attack and like move again completely pointless um so that is a fun little mechanism that some cards are like for your main action and others are these interrupt cards and you also have interrupt and interrupt card so that's quite funny really funny when you're like I attacked you and then it's like canceled interrupt and then you're like ah I can interrupt you interrupt interrupt so yeah that's fun but I find it very very um obviously the cards which have more detail on them and have more complex actions I would say they're in the minority so on the whole everything is very simple it's just you know move attack and it's more the complexity or the interest comes from how you play them like we said and when yeah and I just think the cards like like you said they have names on them there's one called pincer movement it has it adds to the you know the thematics of being like the

commander um and figuring out how to play the battle Yeah I think it is it's really fun system and it's nice as well as like the scenario itself is a puzzle and how to go about about it playing these cards like the good thing is that they're basically all really interesting yeah so it's like which you play to which units and how and that's like another puzzle and it's just and you know our words you can always do a basic action if they're useless so I think it's it's a nice element but definitely what I will say kind of who this is for so we've said in the intro uh you know it gives a feel of kind of undaunted in space so it's a lot more tactical so this is for someone that you know you like to play a head-to-head but you like micro management right you like yeah really like the minutia having a big impact on how you play because there's a lot of basically like many mechanisms right yes like we've basically just talked about moving and attacking but you can board other ships which is like a special attack and you compare different values you can RAM chips which is another type of attack with different values the way that your ships are facing so you have to be really careful when you move them and orientate them properly yeah it has an effect because sometimes your defensive fire which you can do you can't fire behind you so if someone gets

in behind you then they kind of safe from you defend attacking them uh and there's always you know some have more armor on the front so if you're hitting them directly on they're more protected and there's a lot of these little things that I think it creates a real wealth of gameplay but it is a little bit fiddly but I I definitely think this is like people will really like this right yeah it's not a simple case of do an attack like you said yes yeah a lot of different things and all of your abilities on your cards so you have to be kind of comfortable with reading them all and then knowing what is available um I also think I personally quite like the battle system great with dogs in the trash she's using this time where she knows that we can't go and stop her yeah because we're mid filming to do this anyway uh I I quite like the battle system it is Dice chucking um but I think it's nice and simple it's just a five and a six is a success and the rest are not and there's a few things you can do to kind of re-roll but I find it doesn't interrupt the pace or anything like that it's quite seamless in that way because you are just throwing dice the opponent maybe can stop you or re-roll some of your successes okay and then it's kind of like over and right and it just hits yeah I really like that back and forth

where usually it's you like and you get to roll a lot of dice usually at least at the beginning of like when you're involving ships because as you lose them you obviously roll less but you're like oh I'm rolling seven Dice and you Chuck them all and then it's like oh I get to re-roll two and then Tally's like well I get to re-roll one and then it's quite like fun and back and forth and dramatic and then you have like the valid token where you can re-roll them and it's just quite fun and like bombastic and yeah uh engaging exactly I guess maybe just to say if you know if you're really bothered by luck maybe you wouldn't enjoy the battle system because I I think there's little that you can do at least in the like first scenarios that we've played um you can re-roll certain units will give you abilities to do these kinds of things but there's nothing that's really in your control where you can uh I don't know buy different cards I'm just thinking of other games where you can choose what what abilities that you have which might allow you to manipulate the dice that doesn't really exist here right I think well yeah you can't manipulate the dice no but I think in the later ones you can kind of because in the first couple you're given the units you have and you can't manipulate that so if you get that roll that's that whereas in I think the later ones you it's kind of like more like a like a real real-time strategy game where you can like Harvest resources and build chips like in the kind of final missions

yeah so then you can kind of choose build yeah what you want but yeah you're right you can't manipulate yeah I just yeah and it's a good point because there's well I don't think we had a problem with it at all and but I think that it's a real you could say like weird thing because this is so tactical that mispositioning your ships can really like do you over and you can lose right because there's a real cagey thing of you you usually want to move towards something but if you move and then they can activate and they can just come and hit you and blow like half your chips away so it's like kind of cagey like that but also there's obviously luck so it's very tactical but obviously but anyway it's not I mean it's just a system right I think it's fine but um we're not bothered by but it's just something to be generally though yeah so I don't know I think we've covered like mostly what we like about it so should we just talk about some of our issues now if there's anything else you want to nope say so one thing we really want to make clear before we start this is this is a prototype I mean complete prototype like the rule book we have is basically a draft that they printed out right so you kind of take everything with a pinch of salt because there's a long way to go before this game comes out and the gameplay is very sound right I think we both agree like we've obviously been talking about it quite passionately is fun we've enjoyed it um but I think how I would describe it is this is a good game that's a bit

fiddly but it could easily be I think a great game with mostly quality of life improvements yeah right there's a real quality of life improvements I would personally like to see and I talked to the the publisher about this and they were quite you know honest and like you know we don't want to say that we will or won't do something because there's a long way to go and things will change so we don't want to promise anything but we're they're going to take the comments on board which I thought was fair so I think the biggest issue is you might have noticed in the setup that it was maybe one of the longest setups we've ever had and a big part of that is and these are the quality lightings so the most annoying thing let's let's get that straight out you have these tokens here and so you know this has C D and it represents C and D over here which is fine as a system right yeah and you know you flip them over when you use them to show you've activated them however the symbology is to be quite Frank atrocious I mean when you've started referring to things as can you pass me the umbrella and the tampon it's it is it kind of breaking the immersion there right because they're just like little blobs and squiggles that don't mean anything and they're just not very distinct from each other no this is my comment it's very hard to tell the difference and just to make this clear this is like undaunted right where you you know you have Rifleman a and you have like Ralph

Monet there and then you know so you know what you're activating is that but the issue is you can hopefully see and I'll do some b-roll of all these tokens and I think there's about three different shapes each that aren't easy to distinguish and that's a huge amount of time added to setup because you're like rifling through about 40 different tokens looking for things that are very similar similar yeah yeah and we've passed each other the wrong ones yeah I mean like to be frank I'm daunting fig this out by just having you know right from an A on it I don't know why they couldn't just have Fighters a or you know I know some of them are like different classes you could say yeah I think well because the tokens Can represent different uh types of ships they can't really write that but I don't know why yeah they just don't do like small a frigate a or something like write it on there so you can read it or work on the symbology but yeah yeah that's our biggest issue because it really adds to the time and in a similar thing we would love to see a split of the rule book into different booklets for each player because at the moment everything's in one rulebook and when you're setting up a scenario it means that only one person can set it up at a time even though there's kind of two sides of the battle like if me and tally had her own scenario book we could just set up our half and be done in half the

time but as it is like I have to look at the cards I need I have to find the tokens I have to find out and you know it's kind of hard to reference on here where it's set up because you have to kind of like count from the urge and it's not like a number in a lettering system yeah and it just because we have to do it individually like one at a time it takes a lot longer yeah I had to stand around and wait for you to be done yeah with with your side before I could set up my half of the scenario and then you you kind of also because you're playing asymmetric scenarios and it's all in one rule book it's kind of like it's harder because you need to learn new rules for the first couple of games but only one person can read it and you've got to keep passing the rule book and I think if you just had your own scenario books to tell you what rules to read yeah and how to set up your half the scenario and your objectives the information that is relevant yeah the quality of life would be like vastly improved I just think I think they should have one rule book with like every game mechanism in it and then a scenario over a work which tells you how to set up and what new rules to refer to for that mission yeah uh and I think that'll be a huge Improvement yeah but I guess for us the gameplay outshines yeah it's right this is what I'm saying good game a little bit too fiddly kind of setting up and stuff but with some just quality of life improvements I think it could be like slick and fast and really a great game uh and I guess the last thing we

would like to see is so you have the command cards and you kind of put them in from the beginning but the way it works it's a bit like George's line where you get slowly introduced to the mechanisms per yeah scenario but it it because all the command cards have all of the mechanics and also the ships have all the mechanics printed on them there's not a clear delineation of what is for this scenario what's for scenario seven you know and it gets really confusing when you like do I need to know this or should I be ignoring it and in particular there are uh command cards that have special abilities that kind of don't get introduced they're just like command contact do this one thing yeah and you know it's like evasive you get to kind of reroll someone thing it's never in the rules it's just on these command cards but you don't know if you're supposed to be including it or not so if they could just have kind of like scenario like a list of what command cards to include in What scenario and what to ignore and what not it's just a bit messy at the moment right and it leads to a lot of confusion as you're trying to learn because you don't know what to ignore and not ignore definitely yeah I kept having to say to you but my unit can do this yeah and then you just like don't worry about it for now don't worry about it exactly but then like I said we learned that these command cards have stuff that you you can I guess include at any time because it's not oh you learn this now yeah but

anyway so like you said very important that this is a prototype and these are quality of life things right I mean the gameplay is great yeah um really enjoy it had some fun tense battles yeah wooden change I think the scenario design is excellent it feels different every time yeah it's really well done and the asymmetry and the fact you can sign your own it really uh adds a lot of replayability I think you do get the feel in later missions of a real-time RTS where you harvest minerals and you build your own troops up so I think should we go to final thoughts yes with that yeah okay so final thoughts this game overall is a recommendation from us we think it is worth the investment the gameplay is really really solid we've had a really fantastic time playing it but as we mentioned we would maybe like to just see some quality of life improvements um some tweaks but not to gameplay though that's the thing yeah facilitating the game yeah and we don't think they are bad enough negative enough to oh no for sure not you know not worth want to look at the game yeah exactly if you if you love like you know playing undaunted or kind of two-player head-to-head War Games tactical games then this is I think a Surefire back yeah um and I'm like we we for sure want a final copy like I really this is a prototype that I

think one of the the biggest compliments you can give if you have a prototype and you know you're going to get the final game is to keep still playing the Prototype while you wait for yeah yeah that's true and you know we don't do that for so many games right yeah and this is definitely going to be one that I want to keep playing all the scenarios till we get the final one absolutely so yep thanks for watching this video and if you're not subscribed to our Channel already and we really love it if you do that means a lot to us please feel free to ask us any questions about Homeworld Fleet command we'll be more than happy to answer them in the comments down below yeah 100 thanks for watching bye

Progress saved