Tea Garden - Board Game Review - Abstracted To A Tea
Transcript
hi everyone I'm Lor and this is the brok me a show where I Raven rant about board games with MIM more the latter this is a game that has certainly been high on my please Luke can you review this as quickly as possible pile because as much as I wasn't necessarily aware of this one much before ESS I kind of saw the cover and thought Oh this could be quite cool everybody wanted me to try this one out well it was harder than it seemed to get a copy of this at essm because they only did pre-orders that was it you could only do pre-orders for this otherwise you didn't get the game I had to go back to the publisher about five or six times constantly sort of checking right if You released all the pre-orders are you now selling to the public yet and at the very last like minute on Sunday when they just started issuing them to the public I was able to grab a cup so I can actually review this so why was I desperate to review it well the name on The Box Thomas ho I no idea if I'm pronouncing that right but the the idea is is that this designer has done something very ballsy this Essen come out with three games at Essen different Publishers different levels of complexity supposedly and different themes and all sorts that's quite a dangerous move for a publisher sorry for a designer to do but hey I'm certainly down to see some new faces and you know some New Kids on the Block and see what's what and you've already seen my review of setti Where I Was gushing a lot about that one essentially the equivalent of a high N Low 10 score for me well okay this is number two of three so so can we continue along the same trend of gushing or is this one not
quite up to that standard Tea Gardens is essentially a hybrid of deck building and hand management as well as Resource Management you are building your tea garden starting from one Province across the map in order to produce better quality leaves and these leaves will start off fresh which are green but you can ferment them to be brown and the idea is is that in the maintenance phase green leaves decrease in quality brown leaves increase in quality but the turn sequence is essentially taking a main action a secondary action and any number of free actions in any order you like and the Crux of how you do this mechanic is done with these cards so here's a selection of starter cards for a typical player and essentially these cards are comprised of several elements they will have a strength value on the top a little red number they may have a picture of a teapot on them they may have a picture of a secondary action icon on them and they may have other benefits like fermented leaves and points and stuff like that for the more powerful cards but essentially players will start off with four and when you want to do an action via your player board you will play as many cards as you like from your hand face up underneath each slot effectively starting with the first slot second slot third slot and fourth slot um as you take turns and the total of the strength values determines the strength for the action but the card that is face up on top dictates any other bonuses you might get what secondary action you may or may not be doing or what teapots are available for a particular action so what sort of things can you do well you can build the Tea Gardens you just build them across the map more of them produce more leaves
in certain provinces will produce better quality ones your board effectively tracks all the quality leaves on there you can also sell to Caravans which are essentially a card that turns up um throughout the game there's three in each around and you can sell any quality leaves to these and they will give you various points and rewards they're kind of like a you know if I've got loads of lesser quality leaves I can just dump them on the Caravans and they'll be happy and then afterwards you can decide whether you want to buy some really cool new cards so these cards come in different tiers they progress throughout the game and basically these are here to bolster up your deck your deck has basically got little rubbish starter cards these ones that you can buy which require certain quality tea leaves will will give you more actions more bonuses more teapots but crucially they will be higher strength values the teapots on these cards are essentially a requirement to buy these you need to have teapots showing amongst all your face up cards so that when you buy a new card you match the teapots and that's the the main three main actions you'll do you can ferment leaves and do extra Harvest as well but those are the three main ones you'll do and they're all explained briefly on the little reference guide flip it over you get the secondary actions and the free actions free actions are just simple things like leveling up tracks and you know using various scroll tiles but the secondary actions stem from one of three main things you have the River track which goes on the center of the board follow it down get bonuses get points at the end you have the University track which is like a little Rond Del thing here you basically move to the different quadrants pick a bonus and as you move
around and around and around you score more points but the one that's a little different is the cup connections where you've got these different cup tiles if you've ever played Pulsar 2849 there's a similar mechanic with a transmitter in there you are essentially collecting these tiles from the different provinces and putting them together to make color connections if you do score more points at the end but either way even if you can't make a color connection you will still put a little bonus token in between the two cups and basically you can take these off as a free action to trigger the effect on the cup so that's kind of the Crux of what you're doing each player gets four turns Max in a round you do three of them for free it costs to do the fourth one once everybody passes you then do the maintenance of collecting tea leaves from your Gardens and decreasing and increasing quality as I mentioned and then you proceed to the next round after five rounds you ignore the last maintenance phase total up the victory points from endgame scoring cards such as the emperor cards which are these like scoring cards that you can get during the game which are pretty powerful as well as where you've ended up on the river and University track and such and of course the one with the most of course tea Garden's Aesthetics are pretty nice here I mean it's lots of old pastel colors everywhere it certainly looks nice on the table it's not a particularly big board so you can actually fit this on a reasonably small table space although you do need space underneath your board for the cards that you're playing but for the most part it tends to keep to a reasonable size table and of course you need cards laid out below the board for the ones that you can buy so you know it doesn't it's not a huge table hog but it still has some
presence the rules themselves a little text Heavy I found you know the book could have used maybe a few more pictorial examples here and there but for the most part it's decent and you know I actually did didn't find that there was a lot of ambiguity in here things made sense a couple of weird spelling and grammatical errors now and again though so maybe on a reprint they'll correct those but nothing that made it you know impossible to play there was just one in particular that was a little bit weird where I'm trying to think here we go yeah um if a player removes a card from the draw deck they must Shuffle it afterwards full stop discard pile and create a new draw deck okay that's a little bit of a weird reading in there but you know one that I've asked on BGG but aside from that you know the rule book was generally quite fine really where the game shines most is the deck building part of this you start off with an 11 card starter deck mostly or rubbish but as you go through the game you're buying these different cards and you're going to need to buy some regardless of whether you're focusing or not cuz they're worth points and they are much better cards but the idea is is that when you buy a new card it goes straight to your hand so you can use it literally from then on within the same round turn two I buy myself a really cool card turn three I then play said card I'm allowed to and there's a lot of ways in this game to trash cards from your deck this probably got the most ways to do it you be you could actually be in a position where you get rid of every single starter card you began the game with if you do enough trashing of cards so there's certainly a lot of tweaking that you can do although that does bring in a little bit of a flaw because I would have maybe
preferred if it wasn't deck building in this instance because there are some times when you need to critically do secondary actions especially if you're trying to get to the end and get the most points but in deck building game the nature of Randomness is that you might just draw cards and not get what you like you could have eight cards in your deck most of which are really good cards and of the actions that you want you then draw four more all the time at the end of a round and you get nothing but rubbish well what can you do you've got to go out of your way to try and draw more cards but you only have four turns in a round and if you're having to go out of your way to do that other people are naturally doing better than you as a result now that wouldn't be so bad if the game was nice and short but it's short up to a point it says 90 minutes on the box and it just does it as a flat figure and it's only two to four players there's no solo mode I don't like it when games just put a flat figure on the box because that's always complete garbage you know the the game will be 90 minutes at one player count but what about the other player counts you know you need to put a range you need to be more sort of like give a broad spectrum and for this honestly it's about 30 minutes a player you are talking about just over an hour if you played this with too you're talking 90 minutes if you play it with free and that's assuming people go at a reasonable Pace cuz there is a decent amount of AP that can arise from this but four players oh my word this game can drag on quite a bit you're talking two hours plus the teach and the game just isn't like complex enough to Warrant that much time in the game you know there are 2hour games I can play
where there's a lot more going on a lot more to think about here you're not really doing a huge amount of thought processing I mean most of your thinking is which cards will I play and which icon will I have at the top of which if you're playing this game you are essentially spamming the same secondary action throughout the whole game so it's kind of self-evident what you're going to leave up when you play this with two it's fine when you play this with three it's just about right when you play this with four though this game is a 90-minute max type of game I just don't think two hours plus the teach warrants it because the game does drag a lot in rounds four and five you start off in rounds one and two playing not a huge amount you know there's not much going on you've only got so many leaves and cards to do anything with so the round one and two tend to be quick it quickly snowballs though in round three that takes a bit longer and rounds four and five take a really long time because everybody's doing four actions a turn at that um four turns every round at that point and the turns take longer because you've got more stuff to spend more bonuses are being triggered off and so it's a a much more longer FR process you know it's like you know speedy speedy speed as it just slows down to a CO and especially in a four player game with the downtime between turns that you've got very little to plan for because most of the time people aren't going to interfere too much with what you do aside from buying a card that you like otherwise everything is pretty much non- interactive another problem with the game because the only bit of interaction in this game really honestly is somebody
might take the card you wanted whether it's an emperor card or one of the main cards that's it you don't interfere with each other on this track there's no like first person to get to the top gets the bonus and everyone else loses on the emperor track there is no real sense of area control even on this map I mean this map has got limited spaces in some provinces but in a fre player game you'll be able to go pretty much where you like except for a couple of the final provinces in a four player game you'll probably split and Go in different directions you know like around the bottom around the top of this map and again you probably won't hit each other because there's just not there there there's too much space and the map doesn't scale with players in fact the whole game doesn't scale with players literally there's no player scaling you don't like put less cards in oh no sorry there is a little player scaling you have some player you you have a slightly different number of Caravan cards in the deck and out of the five tiers of cards you put in so many for players that's literally it that is literally just so there's enough cards in the game but other than that the other players might as well not even be sitting at the the table and you can't play this solo so really this game just feels like a two-player game rather than a three and four player game you know I can't see myself ever really wanting to play this with four because for two hours plus a teach I can think of other games that give me a bit more to think about on my turn and more to do than this one even though this one is decent enough at two and three you know three I think is the absolute Max in terms of
the secondary actions as well they're kind of a little generic in how they work the cup connections is probably the most interesting of the lot yeah it makes no fmatic sense why you're you know putting colors together and honestly the theme in this game is kind of non-existent really apart from the whole way that leaves um go up and down in quality you could replace this theme with just about anything that would still work but putting these together and getting bonuses and sometimes repopulating them can lead to some fun jiggery pokery like juny combos with these but the River track and this University track are pretty boring because they're the same thing really each of the fre secondary actions tends to cap at somewhere around the 20 to 30 point mark depending on how far you get but the river and the University track are the same thing they're just a track the river you start here end up here get bonuses along the way University track you go around in circles and get bonuses along the way the only thing that is slightly different is that one of them is a bit better at getting leaves and fermenting and the other one is better at getting scroll tiles and various other little bonuses but that that's literally the only difference between them if if one maxes out the river they'll get 25 points on the River track if somebody maxes out the University track they'll get somewhere in the region of 25 to points if someone gets all seven cup connections you know and maxes out that scoring that's about 25 odd points or something I forget the exact number so the differential between the three tracks is almost sort of non-existent really but that's the bulk of your of your scoring at the end those
secondary actions and the emperor cards I cannot stress enough how much the emperor cards are so critical you can get three of them in the game they can score you something like you know 16 18 points a piece if you Max them out and it's not that difficult to Max them out really so if you try to ignore Emperor cards you will just flat out lose so each game you're basically just deciding which secondary action to spam and what emperor cards hopefully turn up although you don't see them all in every game so you might have one here that gives you points for you know you get three points for every tea guard in you build oh that could be 18 points I've built all my Tea Gardens this game and the card never appears you know you might focus on I've got secondary cards that give me the ship action all the time and the scoring card for that never turns up so again there's a random element as to what you're able to score for and there's only three out on display at any one time so it's difficult to plan ahead for what Ember card is going to come out and that just seems again something that can Scupper you when it's not your fault much like the deck building part here you cannot ignore it you need at least two if not all three Emperor cards to stand a chance of coming first and it just the game kind of gets a little syy like each game plays out the same you'll build most of your Tea Gardens by the end and they'll produce leaves you'll pick a secondary action move along the track get some member cards job done no game really feels that different even if I'm going for a different strategy I don't really feel like I'm playing a
very different game and with three or four of you all the stuff's going to be done you're going to see everything there's not that many cards in each tier of here and they're basically just the equivalent of how many teapots do they have do they have a secondary action what's their strength value and you can sell some leaves in the late game that's kind of it and once you're done it takes a forever to score because this track only goes up to 50 and you have to do the 50 plus 100 plus 150 thing and it's just gets annoying when you go all right I've scored a little bit all right there we go and the game ends right so now I got to add 47 I on that puts me there right now I got to add 36 right that puts me back round to there and it's like could the track go to 100 that would have been easier so yeah there's some decent stuff I like the card system is cool it looks beautiful the rules are generally quite smooth a few ambiguities with the way it's worded but otherwise fine you know could be a little bit less text heavy but and for two to three players it's a decent length and pretty smooth it just drags its heels a bit in round four and five particularly with four players I don't recommend this game with for hell even recommending it with free is kind of a lot to say because frankly there's just no player interaction but the card system is fun there is a decent amount to plan for the round and it is fun doing the whole Resource Management with the leaves so the game is decent but not blowing my mind I give it a six out of 10 overall it's above average it's not enough for me to say everybody's going to go out and buy this you know I think the replay value is a little bit questionable you
know with what is here especially when most of it is just leveling up tracks and the fact that there's no interaction really with players means that there's just not much reason to play with more players and as much as it looks great and has a cool little card system action it is frustrating when it just you know luck of the draw just happens to screw you over in a game where you know it's critical to do as many of the secondary actions as possible as well as get the emperor cards so there's you know a few niggles that get in the way of making this like one that I can you know whole heart give seals to but I still think it's decent I think it's going to have its fans but uh certainly not the best game I've played all year you know by shot and i' certainly preferred setti a lot more you know but I still think this is decent but just not blowing my mind so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on board game G that goes live on the page don't forget to check out the rest of my content check out the other review I did for this designer setti it's a little bit more gushing than this one and there's of course more games to come bes sides including the other game by this designer Galileo Galilee which I'll will be uh hoping to get done at some point during November and of course let me know your thoughts do you really love Tea Garden do you agree or disagree with the comments I've made what are your thoughts or would like to know and discuss them with you so take care and remember regardless of whether you prefer a cup of Daring or some Earl Gray personally um I'd just rather have a cam mile to be honest it's still only a game so bye for now