Skip to main content
Loading video...

Horrified: Ravenloft - Review

Transcript 13:00

Welcome to Allies or Enemies. I'm Jess.

And I am Sean and today we are talking about Horrified: Dungeons & Dragons Ravenloft and our copy was provided but the thoughts are all our own.

This is the latest game in the Horrified series and it has the same general gameplay as the other Horrifieds where you're playing cooperatively, you're collecting up items, you're trying to get villagers to their safe spaces and importantly you're trying to defeat the monsters. But this one comes with a bunch of new monsters and some new mechanics. So we're going to be talking about those right now.

So let's start with the stars of the show and that is the monsters and I will say there are some misprints on a couple of these and we are going to come to those and clarify how you're supposed to play them and everything else. But also I do want to talk about the positive things and one of the positive things are I think these are the nicest looking monster boards that they've had so far.

Yeah, they're nice and thick and the backs make them look like books. So they're quite fancy compared to the other ones. The other interesting thing with these monsters is they all require dice rolls to defeat them. So the previous like Dungeons & Dragons themed Horrified used the dice in different ways but this is specifically like a big dice roll to try and defeat the monster.

Yeah, and I do like that. It's kind of like a little skill check thing at the end of each little quest and that it does feel Dungeons & Dragons-y. But let's talk about him. So the first one, probably the scariest looking one, is the Carrionette. This is terrifying and with this guy you've got to take objects to where he is. You've got to drop all those objects into his backpack, I think. And then once you've filled up that backpack and all of those are going to take a dice roll, then you've got to do your big dice roll and defeat him.

This is probably one of the easier, more straightforward monsters. It's like it makes sense what you have to do, but you just require like a lot of items and a lot of specific items. For Baba Lasagna, you've got to get this gem out of a maze, and to do that, you've got to go to Baba Lasagna's location and discard items to be able to flip the tokens on the monster mat, and then like roll and discard items to be able to move the gem all the way out before you can finally defeat her.

Yeah, and she's also got an interesting thing where her special exclamation mark power picks up villagers as she moves, which kind of makes sense cuz Baba Lasagna is based on Baba Yaga, and Baba Yaga like tricks people into her house like the famous fairy tale character. And so this kind of does that again. It is fairly simple, and then again it is using a bunch of items and a bunch of die rolls. Then the next one, and this is the one that's probably the most kind of contentious, is the Gulf Fire's tree, or Gulf Fire's tree. I'm not sure how to say that, but what this is, it's a big tree, and the tree itself is just going to stay in one location the whole time, but it's got these three twig blights. And so in the rule book it says that these three twig twig blights are all going to have different color symbols, and when that activates, whenever the Gulf Fire's tree activates, you're going to move the one that matches the symbol on the card, but they don't actually have symbols. So they reconned it to say move whichever one you want, which is actually how the exclamation mark works.

We tried that, and didn't love doing that. So what we ended up doing was actually taking out three of the stands from the other Dungeons and Dragons cuz they have the right color stands, putting them on those, and then moving them like the rule book says. It works way better. So I would really suggest doing that. Beyond that, the thing that you're doing with this is it's got a whole bunch of tokens on that mat. And when you go to it's when you go to the trees location, you can get rid of an item and then you can flip over as many as you want. But, anytime you get two that match, you've got to flip everything you flipped back over and mix them back up. So, this is a little bit of a push your luck game.

Yeah, and you always want to push it, but it's pretty risky. The final monster is Strahd, and this is the big boss. And has a bunch of different steps that you need to do and a second board that you add to the map. What you need to do is you first have to go to Madame Eva's tent and figure out the location of these special items that then go out onto the map. You then have to go and collect all of those items. Then you've got to bring them into the castle, into the like the special rooms, drop those items off, then you got to destroy Strahd's heart, which requires a dice roll, then he appears in that location, and then you get the chance to try and destroy him.

There's a lot of bits you've got to do cuz it's kind of a fetch quest, kind of another fetch quest, and then a bunch of fighting and you can use items for those fights. You can use items, actually we didn't say this, but for all these fights to help kind of beef up whatever it is you're trying to roll. So, that is also a little bit of push your luck because sometimes you want to be a little bit cheap with those because you need so many items and Strahd uses a lot of items and a lot of turns.

I I like Strahd and I think it makes sense in terms of that D&D world where you do have these mini quests of needing to get these very specific items and carry them around and then eventually defeat like the big monster. And I found that these monsters are really well balanced. Every time we've played, it's come down to I think like the final turn.

Yeah, I think we've played four games, we've only won one and everything has been the final like big dice roll. Actually no, we've won two and two, but both of the times we won right after I was like, "Oh, wait, I messed up. I should have had these." So it did not feel like a good win. Part of that messing up as well is that Strahd's map says that you need 20 to defeat him. The rule book says that you need 15. Apparently the rule book is correct and it's too bad that there's that mix-up, but just remember you need 15 not 20 as we first thought. So that was one of our wins is then we look, "Oh, only 15." And it didn't feel like as good of a win. So just know that you need 15.

And I like that Strahd's second monster board sits so nicely above Castle Ravenloft. And speaking of the map, let's talk about that now.

This is kind of it feels a bit like a back-to-basics map. Like it's got just a things are kind of connected how it makes sense to me. It's got a bunch of little dead ends. I think just enough dead ends. It's got some circuitous routes you have to take, but it's not taking kind of the big swings that I think we saw in the last couple of maps.

Yeah, I would agree. I also like the artwork. I think it looks good. And I think if you know the world, you'll probably connect with the locations that are there. I do think that the font for the locations is really hard to read, but I like that they included numbers on the locations. That makes it a lot easier to put the items out.

Yeah, it's kind of a pluses and minuses cuz I agree with you. The the numbers are great, but they are only on the items and I kind of wish they were also on the villager cards. That would have been really helpful. But those are small things. Overall, I agree. I think I think it looks I think it looks nice and I think if you've played the D&D storyline, you're probably going to go, "Oh, this place, this place, this place." But it's a little bit lost on us.

So it comes with five new heroes and like the previous D&D horrified, you do have an option of rolling a die and based on the result doing a specific hero action. And I like that because sometimes you're in a position where you don't have another action you want to do, so it's nice to have that. I also like the art. It has like a stained glass style to like the windows and everything. And what's new for this version is the dark gift power that each of the heroes have.

That dark gift is interesting. So what it is is you can, if you want at any point in your turn, flip over. But once you flip, that's it. You're stuck there forever. And then you get a little extra power boost, but you also mostly get a negative. So you get something like you can protect a villager at one point, but from now on the monsters are always going to target villagers. So usually they're really bad the thing that's going to happen. You're going to get hit at the end of every turn or you're going to lose an item at the end of every turn or something. So you generally don't want to use these till right near the end of the game. These are kind of for like Hail Mary's. But the other thing that they're for is the one card in the deck that makes whoever's turn it is flip that over. If you've already got it flipped, you actually lose it. You gain a terror, not you lose a terror. You get more scared. But if you don't have it flipped over, you have to flip it over and then you have to deal with that. I like that part of it.

Yeah, absolutely. As you say, it's more near the end when you're like, "Okay, we've only got a few turns left. We just need that like final little push to make it to the end." And that might do it. So I like that you're not reliant just on a card telling you to flip, that you always have the choice of when to flip.

And then just to wrap up with all of the other stuff. So there's a whole bunch of villagers. This does something that has been in a couple of the other games where the picture on the villager is not the same as the picture on the card. It drives me nuts. One of them has a different color dress. I'm never going to find that person. And some of them have a last name added or don't have a last name. I just a little more consistency with those, but they look cool. Then also the power cards. And this is some of the coolest art that has been in any of the games. I really like the artwork.

I do like that one of the card powers is adds a plus four to your dice roll. So, it's nice to save that for some of the monster fights. Uh a few other things is I really like the molds of the monsters. I think they look really cool. I think each of them do as well.

Yeah, yeah. I think the carrionette is super creepy. I really like the Baba Lasaga house. It reminds me of the one Miyazaki film that Baba Yaga is in or a Baba Yaga-esque character. Another negative, I feel like I'm just being the negative guy here, but is the bag in this. So, they went from the cloth bag in the first one to the like weird bag, but I actually really grew to enjoy the weird bag. No problem. But this is just a straight-up cardboard kind of container. And you can't store the items in it when you put it in the box. It's not a giant thing. These are kind of nitpicks, but it still is a little bit of a nitpick. But overall, I would say that the art is generally really nice in this one.

So, we've played all of the Horrified games. And anytime we play a new Horrified, the question always is, well, where does this fit compared to the rest? For me, I'd say this is probably in the middle. I really like the monsters. They have a really neat look. And I think that just mechanically, they work well and aren't too complicated. And I really like that it all comes down to like a big dice roll at the end. It feels very D&D.

Yeah, I really do like that. It's what I think of when I think of D&D. And so, I like that that is in there. I do like those monsters. I do wish that there wasn't the mix-up with the tree. I definitely think put those colored bases on. Use it as it is in the rules. It just works so much better. But generally overall agree with you. I think this is kind of right in the middle. I'd probably put this above the last two, but certainly not as high as Universal or Greek monsters. And part of that is just that I I like those themes a little bit better. I know those monsters a little bit better. And part of it is that this one just has a few like little graphical things or just little mistakes that are holding it back. I don't think most of the kind of tiny typos are going to make that much of an impact on your playing other than those two monster mats which which do.

Yeah, and and I do like that they have continued to make it usable with the other games in the series, in particular the more recent ones that use the colored symbols. And so you can continue to mix and match. And I think Strahd as a two-part boss works really well to do the questing and then the final fight at the end.

And that is it. That is Horrified: Dungeons and Dragons Ravenloft. Have you played this game? What do you think? And what is your favorite Horrified?

Thank you so much for watching. As usual, please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.

Progress saved