Finspan - Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about Fin span and this is the latest edition in the span series but this time we are going under the sea but are things much better down where it's wet well just wait and see and this was provided for review but the thoughts in this video are all our own finpan is a one to five player game designed by David Gordon and Michael oconnell let's start with how it plays you start the game with a player board that has a few pre-printed fish a couple of egg and fish tokens a couple of starter fish a few other fish cards and a bunch of divers ready to get into the water on your turn you place a diver either to play a fish card by paying its cost and then adding it to an appropriate space on your board gaining any when played bonus or you can go diving which means choosing one of the three dive site columns on your board and activating the benefits one by one as you travel into the deep this will gain you things like new cards cards from your discard eggs hatched fish or swimming which can help combine your fish to form schools players take turns placing divers into until all of them are spent and then you gain points
for round end goals take back your divers and do it all again after four rounds you add up points from game end Powers fish that you've played consumed fish eggs young fish and schools of fish and then add this to the points that you gained from the first three round and goals and then the greatest diver is named so the obvious question is how does this compare to the other two games in the series and this is I think the simplest most streamlined version of the game so this would be the simplest then wingspan then worm span as the most complex yeah I definitely agree with that this one really streamlines things because well one of the main things you're taking out the food you're taking out the card row you're just you're just making everything a little bit easier and there's really kind of six things maybe seven that you're ever doing in this game where you've got eggs you're hatching eggs you're swimming fish you're gaining cards you're playing cards uh sometimes you're eating fish with other fish and it's really easy to bring in new players yeah and that said there aren't a lot of things in the game but I it's still engaging because you have to manage those limited things in a really strategic way because you'll want to play as many fish as possible but a lot of fish cost cards so you're trying to set yourself up maybe where you're able to you know spend cards to play a fish that might gain you cards and then same thing with those eggs and those fish
resources because you can get a lot of points if you can swim your fish together to make a school but so many High Point cards require payment of a fish so you need to manage like how many eggs you have how many fish you have and when you're like replenishing them and Diving down those columns yeah the key here I think really is that card management well it's the card management and action management but a big part of it is the card management because so many of those fish cost other cards but then a lot of the fish bring cards back from your discard pile so you can kind of have a system where you're spending fish and then almost immediately getting those fish back if you're playing things right and same with the the eggs you've got to be thinking about I need to have eggs out in case things make these things hatch or sometimes the cards that you're playing are making eggs hatch but you need there to be eggs so that they can hatch so you do still have to think kind of one or two turns ahead but worms I felt like I had to think well well in advance and then wingspan was a little thinking in advance but wingspan has a lot more Randomness I think than this game and a lot more things that you're kind of you know you're hoping the right Bird's coming out of the deck you're hoping the right Foods coming out of the feeder so it's a little bit more kind of responding to the situation whereas this you've got a lot more control over what's going on yeah and it is interesting because you would have thought maybe that this one one would have more Randomness because there isn't a card drafting row so anytime you gain a card you're just taking it off of the
top of the deck but there isn't like that much difference between the Cards there there is in terms of like where they can be placed and what their cost is and there is a difference in like the value of the cards but the higher value ones are understandably just going to cost more resources and I feel like those goals for fin span specifically tie in to things that there isn't as M much difference as as there is in wingspan cuz in wingspan it will be like only 10% or less of the cards would have that trade whereas for here you know if it's who has the most small fish like onethird of the cards might be small fish so those discrepancies I think mean that you're still able to find those cards that you need yeah pretty much anything that you're doing is going to be at least onethird of the cards cuz you're going to put something in one of the three rows you're going to put it in one of the three depths you're going to play one of the three sizes it's going to I I don't think there's anything that is going to have worse odds than that and because the food or the things that you need to put it out it's really just those three things have eggs have fish have cards as long as you've got that you're going to be able to play basically whatever you've got coming out yeah I like that it's streamlined as well to try and encourage you to put fish in all of the columns because I think you really do need to have all three of those resources of the cards the eggs and the fish and if you have fish in those columns at the different depths you get to activate that action
more moving on to replayability one of the key things is there are a ton of different fish cards like over 120 fish cards so your odds of seeing the same ones at each game is going to be quite low also there are different goals so there are three rounds that you put a goal out and for each round there are three tiles that are double Ed so that means each round can have six possibilities yeah there's actually seven even because that board flips over and the other side of that has pre-printed ones that are kind of for your first game or for whoever's first game and so You' kind of got an option of seven different goals and those are quite different those do make a big difference um in general though I think the game play is going to be fairly similar because I've generally found myself you know you need to have all three of those resources you kind of need to put things in those three different col but all of that is kind of and it's really in the that fuzzy Zone where things get interesting because you can add a lot of when activated cards some games and then that can make a column really important and really get you a lot of stuff from that so there are there have been games where I've had slightly different strategies and just the different fish that you have coming out and kind of what you're spending on those is going to change things so I've had games where I'm gobbling up a lot of fish because I'm getting fish that just eat smaller fish which which is great because then you're not spending resources but that means I have less fish on my board and then that game's going to feel a little bit different so there definitely are things that change
it up yeah and the fish that you have available is going to be the biggest factor that is going to make it feel most different and they do have some interesting Powers so like one of them for example means all players can add an egg to every fish in a particular column for example and so for ones like that when it is all players you want to keep an eye on the other players cuz particularly at two players I might choose to play that when sea doesn't have any space for eggs for example and that would be a huge Advantage for me and not so much for you yeah and there are a few of those that feel almost like kind of little events that happen in the game like there's some fish that when I play this then I can play another one at a column and then maybe when I play that it helps me because I can add all those eggs or I can add all those all those fish or maybe I can even play another fish in another column so you can sometimes chain things you can feel a little bit clever paying attention to what are other people doing and what do they have and now how do I play things so they get the least amount and I get the most amount um all of that does come into it but that's kind of more player count so let's move on to player count so this game plays for one to five players and for the most part you are doing things on your own board so it's not going to feel hugely different at different counts it will take longer with more players but for finpan I think this this is the quickest turn turns out of the whole series so each person's turn I think on average is much shorter than in wingspan and and way shorter than in worm span yeah it is it's quite
a bit shorter I think the other thing that is going to change a little bit more in this is this one is kind of like sneakily a little bit more interactive and you wouldn't think so because there isn't the row of cards that you're drafting from which was kind of one of the core parts of interaction and worm span they also had that little board that you were kind of going around but here we counted them all up and it seemed like it's about one in every five cards affects all players and so all of the interaction is going to be positive interaction you can't mess with people so if that's what you're hoping to do it's just not going to happen here but a lot of those cards are when you play everyone gets something or every time you activate it everyone gets something now you do want to play those so other people don't get things that is kind of a core part of the game but you are going to get stuff from other players so if you've got that five player game you're still going to be getting stuff quite often on other people's turns yeah and with a five player game you're going to be less able to monitor when that would benefit the other players and so you might not be able to take advantage of that as much because you might only have like one egg and someone's like everyone gets to hatch the next person's like everyone gets to hatch like oh no I've run out of eggs whereas at two players you can pay close attention so try and see if you can activate those all players when you know specifically the other player may not be able to although you don't necessarily have a lot of control of that and the other thing is with the goals so in the other ones as well there is also kind of like a hierarchy of like first second third of how people have done here it is just everyone gets points for the different
goals but then whoever wins it gets three extra points and so that becomes kind of more of a race and in two players winning that really becomes important but it's always going to be kind of important and getting the most of something and getting the extra points is one of the ways to play you could just stick with like the side a where you everyone scores for how much they have without that addition but it is nice to have that competition and the extra points if you have more of something there is also a solo mode we haven't played it but it is from atoma Factory I think they're the best in the business it's solo modes I've played the solo modes for the other two games I really enjoy both I can't imagine that I don't enjoy this one but I haven't played it so I can't fully say that but I feel pretty confident so on to components and the first bit that I want to talk about also does impact player count and that is just how big those boards are so you it comes with these big player boards some of the biggest player boards I've seen in a game maybe the biggest player boards I've seen in a game and this in a lot of in a lot of tables is going to just be a maximum like three maybe four if you got a big table game if you're playing this with five players with those table boards you better have that table that like Bruce Wayne has in the fr first Batman that he first goes to to have dinner with that like comedically big table that's what you're going to need for this at five players yeah and I get why because it's all about boing
fish at different depths so it has to be like quite deep but it's just such an awkward shape of going like so high up so it is something definitely to be mindful of that said the boards like do look great and it's really neat cuz the backs of them if you line them all up make a map of the world and that's just like the back of the boards which is a nice touch yeah they they work great it's just when you're putting them out it's weird for as a board gamer I'm so used to games just being shaped differently and it has been a little bit tricky to get our heads around how to play this with two players you're not going to have a problem but when you've got more players it's just how are we all going to fit into this space um but they do their job really well so in terms of the other stuff we have the retail version and so the fish and the eggs are represented by cardboard tokens those work great they're double-sided with the fish on one side an egg on the other side the only thing and it's again very minor is that the fish is oppositely face to how it is printed on the board it drives me nuts and so that is a little bit frustrating there are like upgraded options of getting like nice rounded eggs and that kind of thing but we haven't felt like we've needed them the carboard tokens have done the trick they're really noticeable all the iconography throughout has been really clear yeah the iconography is really really clear which is important because this really feels like kind of the entry the entry level of the span games and I don't think new players are going to have any problem understanding what all the icons are and there's only like
seven eight icons in the whole game so it's not going to it's not going to trip anybody up the one other kind of small complaint I've got is just there's just a lot of white in this where the drawings on the cards are lovely but the background is just kind of really plain and I think maybe you need that because then it brings out the a bit more but it just feels like on the main board on those fish just a little bit Plain on the backgrounds maybe I want want to see a tiny bit more but this is such a small small thing because all the fish look terrific they well they look like fish if you like fish they look terrific yeah and there is a little bit of color on some of the cards because some of the fish cards have a bit of color for the column they need to go in and we found our first game we kind of missed that but then it hasn't been a problem since so once you know what to look for then it is quite obvious yeah and that I guess can be tricky I think I think that is going to be something that trips up a lot of people in their very first game is cuz you're not looking for it and it's only on however many cards it's on it's not on that many cards but I do like it and I understand why it exists in the game and I think it was a really nice way of showing it and it looks great once you put that fish onto the board and once you've seen it once you're just going to really notice oh wait this is green and I put it in a blue column and I can see on that line that it's broken up and I think I think generally if people have played this once twice they're not going to make that mistake again so for final thoughts I think really the key thing is where this fits
in the series so just to reiterate this feels like the most streamlined simplified version the easiest to teach people um but it's still interesting decisions of managing those limited number of resources that you're dealing with yeah if I was playing this if I was playing any span game with the new player I would pick this 100% of the time not even a little bit of a question this one by far the easiest one to teach moves super super fast um I do cuz I sometimes feel like wingspan really overstays it's welcome my personal preference is worm span is probably still my favorite because I think it takes out some of the stuff I didn't love about wingspan and it just a little bit of a more interesting system but this I really like as well this might be my second favorite because it's kind of like the flip side of that coin to worm span where worm span makes it a bit heavier makes it a bit thier adds some more little decisions while still smoothing it out this is even smoother but just super super fast and sometimes that's kind of what I want yeah I really like wings SP the original wingspan game I think I like it more than you and I've really enjoyed worm span I like the increased complexity but I think there is still very much a place for this game and I think you mentioned this earlier I think this is probably the one that we're we're going to play most just because it is the fastest to play at two players I think we can play it in like about 40 minutes it's quick but it's still interesting so even though I'm probably like you preferring like worms Span in terms of like the slightly thier
more interesting like combos that you can pull off I think fin span is likely going to be the game that we play more often and I I'm going to say I don't mind that there's a bunch of these span games as well it's like Ticket to Ride had how many different countries all of them just had this little different mechanic I was pretty happy to have three or four of those when I started my board game collection I'm pretty happy to have three different span games and if you want to put out a dinosaur one I'll be very happy to have four yeah and they all feel different enough and are bringing something different and that is it have you played finin span what did you think and what are your favorites of the span series how would you rank those also what other span game do you want to see thank you so much for watching please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game