Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm looking at a game that really kind of took me by surprise called between two castles of Mad King Ludwig and the reason that took me by surprise is because it is a game that is a kind of combination of two very distinct intellectual properties from two very individual companies one being stole my games of he made games up to size and a wingspan and then you've got bezier games who made but you know but the castles are my keynote vague and games like one night ultimate wealth and that idea of these two companies companies coming together to make this game is very very intriguing the first game that is based on the castles of mad can live big is a truly excellent game one of my favorites i've reviewed on the channel so check that one out think very very highly of that game and the second one is between two cities now that is a game that really intrigued me because it's a game that you have to assess or it's a drafting game where you're trying to build your own city in fact you you are building two cities and you're building their cities in combination with each of your neighbors and the worst of your two cities is going to be the one that is your end game score that's an idea that very very intrigued me very interested in playing it but it seemed a little bit too light for me and i just didn't ever kind of pulled the trigger on buying it so the fact that this this game was kind of reimplemented as a theme that I really love and trust you know it was a definite buy for me so I did it I'm gonna show you how it plays and I'm going to come back and give my final thoughts on between two castles of Mad King Ludwig okay so set up here for a three-player game now as you can see I've got these
three different throne rooms and these rooms are going to be shared between two of each of the players so if a player was sat here he would share this castle with Miss player and this castle with this player and in the same this player would share this castle with this player and this castle with this player and this play would share this one with this one and that one with that one so each player has kind of a vested interest in two castles and each plate is going to be given nine of these room tiles to start with and they're going to pick two of them and then they're going to basically choose everybody's going to do that and once they've chosen both both of their tiles they're going to take their there tiles and pass them to the left ready for the next player to take in the next round and then basically everybody's going to reveal their two rooms together and they're going to choose where they place each of these tiles in relation to their castles so one tile is going to have to go in each Castle so as we can see this throne room here which is kind of your starting point it kind of represents the ground at level of your castle so anything below it will be will be kind of underground and above it will be over ground so as you can see this one here really requires corridor rooms and food rooms and this symbology hitter's you're gonna get two points for every corridor room or food room that is above this tile now I've just picked these tiles randomly so these aren't going to score me any points this one
here again this one gets two points but every lounge room or whatever they call a living room and corridor to the left and right of it because as you can see the symbology here is the white tile is the catarrhalis that this one is and then the ones you're placing are going to be either of these black tiles so just sold slower I've drawn two tiles that don't actually score any points but if I had had placed one on one or both of these types of room you're going to get at least two point on you're going to get two points for one this side and two points on this side but at the same time everybody's doing the same thing so once you've got your two towers you're really going to try and negotiate with each of the players to your sides and try and choose what's best to score as many points as possible okay so I've zoomed forward a bit here and give an example of after the first round so once everybody's placed their eighth tile of each stack they're going to discard the the last tile out of the nine you start with and that's going to kind of conclude the first round but I'm going to give you example of how the game actually scores and how you accrue points so as you can see these Cordell rooms also explained earlier it's kind of score two points per every lounge room and corridor room to the left or right over so I've done that so that's going to get to four points this room here is going to score by scoring one point but every picture-frame room that's surrounding it so as you can see here sommore doesn't have one this one doesn't have one that one does have one so that's gonna score me one point this one here it's gonna score one point for every connected Garden room so that's
kind of basically going to be anything that kind of snakes back to room so that's gonna be one two points because as you can see this room here has the garden symbol because it's a garden room so that's going to score me two points this one here the fish pond is going to score one point but every food room in my castle I don't have any my castle but let's hope in the second lot of drafting then we would have that something that's important as well these these garden rooms the ones with these blue borders excuse me I'll just try to focus nothing can be placed on top of them so they kind of have to be the the pinnacle of your castle you can build around them but just not place anything on top of them because obviously you can't put anything floating in the sky this will here against scores for any dining room so I'm in the future I'd look to get more dining rooms this will here cuz scores one point but every connected utility room again I don't have any cells not really thought about this one to you well this one here scores 1 point per every utility room surrounding it so that one's going to score one point there the study here it's gonna score one point but every picture frame surrounding it so that's going to be another sorry another shield around it's that's going to be one one point there and this one here it's going to score one point for every living room above it so this is a downstairs room so that's going to score one two points for that one because as you can see there are two living rooms above the jewelry so that's basically how the points going to work so once that's done in the first round you going to draw another nine tiles and then you're going to pass round the other way and basically do the
same thing trying to get as much points as possible something that is also important is once you place your third room of any type you go to get a little bonus so if you place your third food room of a type you're going to draw five tiles from the from the very nice insert box here and you're going to draw five and place one of them in that castle the living room if you were going to once you place your third one you're going to place one of these little royal advisors into your castle and they score points per each of these decorations they're going to throw throne-room like this so from then on I've scored one point to every set of swords in my castle and as you can see some of these Hopi I've got one here there you go but every one of these symbols in my castle add score a point the utility room so that you draw three of these bonus cards here and they will they will score you points according to the criterion them so for example you'd score an extra two points for each food room in your castle what else have we got we've got the outdoor rooms here so once you place your third outdoor room you can place a fountain which score you a straight five points you can just place a tower if you've if you place your third sleeping room and their towers call you one point per every room below it so that's quite formatic so the taller you want the better with those towers the corridors that you place a grand foyer these very
cool corridor looking things where you score one point but every room surrounding it you want as many rooms as you can to surround your grand foyer and finally downstairs rooms let you choose any other bonus out of the others and another little thing it completes your fifth room of any type then you get to place any of these three rooms either the fountain the tower or the ground for you so as I said you're going to go another round of nine tiles each are discarding the last one and then the scoring mechanism is basically the play the the castle so your weakest Castle out of you the two that you have a known and should ownership in is going to be your final score so you want to completely balance the kind of attention you're going to give to each castle because if you neglect one that is going to be your final score so you cannot neglect a castle so you're going to get a bunch of these erm scoring scoring sheets and you're going to basically one-by-one calculate the points of each room and calculate your total and that's how you play between two castles of Mad King Ludwig as you can see these these component Ares are really really useful really really nice the tiles here are they they look very nice they are very small actually I understand that because this game does take a lot of table space and can play up to seven players so that will be a hell of a lot of table space and if they're only bigger there'd be no feasible chance that you could actually get this played and the symbology on them is although
it's good it's so small that the way it's printed on here now about players complain and that they can barely read it personally I don't have a big problem with it but I have had more than one person say how small is that and they find it very difficult and kind of not very functional the quality here these tiles are quite thin and I've had a problem with some of them fraying already so not the best of quality on these tiles but you do get a lot of these tiles that's hundreds of these tiles from loads of variability these little castles that represent the where you put your excess drafting tiles are very nice and these throne rooms are nice as well they look really good and I've kind of like the aesthetic appeal to it where you're looking sideways onto the castle it just looks it looks really cool but component-wise a bit of a mixed bag these they're very thin very small not the best quality but these trays are absolutely fantastic so so good for setting up and packing away okay so I hope that gives you an idea about how the game works I give you an idea how not to play the game very well because that was a terrible example of how to get a lot of points but you know you get the gist of how the game works so as I said in the intro and the castles imagine a big is a truly excellent game and all my friends are very very keen on it we really enjoy it but the problem was it was capped four players and you know I often have more than four players in my game group and we can't often play it because of that reason now what are the kind of main things that made me kind of buy this game is the fact it supports up to seven players and you know a game that supports that many players there isn't kind of a party game or a social
deduction game they're always going to catch my attention the idea of drafting is always a great one for that many players because the downtime is really reduced because everybody's playing at the same time you know doing their own thing and you don't really have to worry about what the players on the other side of the table are doing because you're just doing your own thing with each of your neighbors the drafting in this game does work really well you know as any other drafting game does it's a very elegant mechanism and as I said the idea of you having to balance both of your castles or at least kind of make them as as possible the fact you can't completely neglect one and just completely pimp one out is really good because as I said the lower of your two castles are going to be your final score that is really interesting to me and it's always going to be interesting to me I love that idea that idea that kind of classic Reiner can it's your scoring mechanism even though he's got nothing to do with this game there are two little things that I wasn't so keen on and the the idea of you drafting both of these two tiles and then kind of negotiating on where you want these tiles to go at each of your castles it almost doesn't ever work because you have such a clear idea of where you want these tiles to go when you draft them that you kind of uninterested in putting them in the other castle you just instantly just go there straightaway and just place them and also because the game encourages negotiation you kind of like waiting your turn to talk to the other player or you know something like because you can't talk to everybody at the same time can you so it's just a little thing that kind of hinders the game a little bit for me also the fact that you can you know there are so many different ways these tiles score not
only you thinking about the ones that are already on the board how you going to get points but you have to kind of combine that with the one you're placed in which is really interesting you know you having to think about two ways you're going to score points but again the fact that there are so many different scoring criterias which is what ironically what I thought would be the problem with the original game between two cities not having enough eyes that it kind of is very very hard to focus your points when you the kind of strategy you want to go for because all these different tiles score in such different contrasting ways that you just kind of like getting a couple points here a couple of points there a couple points there I would have really liked to have seen those kind of huge synergies which I'm sure you can do but you'd have to do that a huge expense of something else and just yeah I'd love to have seen that big jumps and points instead of just getting a couple here and a couple there so a couple little nibbles there I'm sorry to get the game the review off to a a kind of not a negative stuff but not so sort of a positive start to continue down that track my favorite thing about the the original game the castles of King Ludwig was the was the master builder mechanic that was the kind of most intriguing thing for me but I understand it wasn't completely feasible in a game like this it's a drafting game but I throughout the whole duration of the game I was thinking I would rather be playing that game it's a better game in my opinion that's an excellent game this one is it's decent but it's just
not a lot level and I appreciate that it's not going to be as in-depth because it is a drafting area it is a game that supports seven players but just I have that niggling thing in my head work is it worth me sacrificing the experience of the first game just to play with more players I'd rather just hold out until I do have the correct play account if that makes sense but that being said the game is the concept is also really really cool I love the idea of building your own castle I again I love the idea of having to work with your neighbors to do it as best as possible I like the the kind of visual appeal of it because this one is not like a bird side view of the castle it's one from the side of the building you've cut off the side is very easy to see where your ground level is what's below ground what's above ground the the thematic ties of having to place those kind of towers on your tallest pillars and your grand foyer surrounded by rooms so it's very thematic it looks really really nice all the rooms are very unique I think there's any Jupiter rooms apart from the bonus ones you got some duplicates scoring criteria but they've all got their own illustrations they've all got their own names and it's very nice to see your own little castles form and they all look very different and unique that being said is with a game like this it I said in the indie kind of how to play section of the review that the tiles are very small I understand why because it's such a sprawling game at that hypercam it covers so much table space and you cannot physically have the large tiles on this one so that there
are kind of a stuck in between a rock and a hard place then because they need to make them small so you can play it but then again it's hard to see so I don't really think that's not a criticism for me it's something that other players have said in my opinion it Vic tiles are too small but I can understand why and I'm not bashing them for that at all the game pays in a very nice amount of time it's literally two draft rounds of nine tiles one of them being discarded you know you get those bonuses every now and then I placed in the third room but it's pretty obvious where these tiles are going to go this game doesn't have the analysis paralysis as the original castles American look if it does or it's prone to I don't have a problem with it but this this one is a lot more kind of breezy it's a lot more just choose what's going to fit best and not too not too you know heavy on the choices but you know again you are making those meaningful choices so it's got a good decision space is it plays in a very good amount of time about 45 minutes to play a game of this and a Senate it does it does kind of feel like it's a quick game the balancing of the game is very good I mean I think the all the different ways the room score is it's interesting as I said it's very conflicting so it's hard to kind of maximize your points as much as you'd like to but yeah they are very interesting they are very kind of all the rooms score in a very different way and you can choose to kind of do a kind of a jack-of-all-trades approach or very focused on one or two of those huge scoring criteria on each of the room types the uptime is good as a very crafting game you know it does a great job of keeping players engaged to the
whole game and I really like that replace bility wise there are so many tiles in this game there are literally hundreds of different tiles so you're not going to ever get the same kind of feel to it sometimes you stuck with tiles that you just don't know what to do with which is really cool you kind of have to make as much you know do as much as you can with as little little resources but that's you know that's paramount we've all kind of owed raft in games a player interaction with again unless you think there'll be more interaction than what there actually is because as I said when you've got those towels you kind of got in your mind where they're gonna go the negotiation part of the game isn't really it didn't really hit the spot for me that being said it could have just been in the games that I've played that it wasn't really applicable that I negotiated as much as I could have it might have just been that you know it was pretty obvious where these tiles should go and there's no way I'll change my mind take it from that one to put it in that one so I don't know just something that didn't really hit the spot for me that one either as I said I like the look of the game very very a nice visual appeal theme really great I love the idea of building around cars fantastic and a set-up time is absolutely brilliant and they're something that's really worth mentioning those trays that come in the game are fantastic literally you can just pluck all the different stacks of nine tiles in the boxes and just get those trays out and get going straight away and the nice little wooden castles that you use to kind of place the tiles for the next player a really nice they are very different they look best bright colors nice wooden pieces there and yeah there are so many different ways to score
points which is a bonus and and a hindrance to the game because you've got that diversity but it is quite niggly it's quite fiddly as against scraping points here and there also the scoring at the end of the game while those score pads are really really good they're very useful it does take a bit of effort to do it and the fact that you're particularly playing this game with you know different players at the time it's it's hard to kind of trust that everyone's going to get it right so you kind of have to go through each castle on their own just to make sure that everybody's happy with each other's points rather than just letting one player kind of mark their own own sheet and potentially give themselves or take away points that they believe and so overall it's a people love me because I really wanted to love this game and to be honest I didn't I think it's a decent game completely there's no cano completing the game it's just not quite for me what I'm looking for right now I if I if I reviewed this game a year or so ago I would have really really rated it a lot higher than I do now make my tastes have changed to something a bit a bit meteor that being said this game is going to have an audience people who have players groups of you know up to seven players to get a good game here one that isn't a party game as I said one that isn't a duck suit reduction game and players who really like the concept of the first castles of making looper game but weren't keen on that master bit of mechanic which I'm sure I know for a fact that a lot of players aren't too keen on is a very controversial mechanic some people feel
very strongly about it feeling being good and some people really hate it because of the potential ap that it kind of produces but people who don't like that part of the game i can i love this and i know people who really do love that who like the original game like this more personally I don't I think the other game is a league or two above this but that being said there is a market for it it's very affordable loads of variability here lots of think about a little bit fiddly but you know that's just just the nature of the way the game scores the idea of it is fantastic out this the way the scoring works you know the best players worst Castle is the winning condition is very intriguing so that's my review of between two castles of matram they're certainly a decent game just not one quite for me didn't quite hit the mark so I hope you enjoyed this review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye