Skip to main content
Loading video...

Point City vs Point Salad | What's New & Different in this Follow-up?

Transcript 20:50

foreign how's it going everyone I am Dylan this is all you can board and today I'm taking a look at the brand new game coming out to Kickstarter right away Point City and comparing it to the classic Point salad now obviously these games have a lot in common but there are some differences and with any game that's coming to crowdfunding there's always the question should I back it is this game for me but especially in this case because this is so closely related two point solids you might be wondering hey I loved points out am I going to like Point City what's different what's changed what's the same or maybe Point style didn't land for me should I revisit this series now with Point City will I like it if I didn't like Point style there's a lot of questions you might be thinking when it comes to back in this game and I thought this video would be really useful kind of comparing these two games and answering a lot of those questions now right off the bat these games are both designed by Robert Sean and Molly over at flato games they both have artwork from Dylan Mangini and there's a lot of other similarities that we'll get into it and like I mentioned a lot of differences so what I'm going to do is I'm going to start by going over the things that are similar with these two games the things that you know are shared DNA between them and so that way if you're coming from point style you'll know hey these are the things I liked are they still present in Point City these are the things I didn't like are they still present in Point City we'll go over some of those similarities and then after that I'll go into the differences the things that set point City apart evolve the formula and make it a very different game in some respects to point salad and hopefully with all of that you'll be able to have a better idea of whether Point city is for you and if you want to back it if you want to wait for retail whatever the case may be at the very end of the video

I'll also give you my thoughts on which of these two games I prefer based on my time spent with them and in case that is helpful to you or you're just curious you know where I land on on that side of the debate you'll get that answer at the end as well so let's Jump Right In okay so the first similarity I want to get into that I think is really important to touch on is that this is still very much an accessible quick plain small box card game now that's probably obvious given the size of the box and the similarities in the way that they look but in case you're wondering you know sometimes when it comes to sequels uh follow-ups board games there's this you know idea that we have to kind of up the ante so to speak you know we're going to add some more we're going to add some more complexity we're going to add something and for sure this game is adding stuff but it's been done in a way where nothing is being made more complex so if you're coming from point salad and one of the things you loved about it was that it was easy to teach you know you could bring it out in almost any situation you could play with people who don't play board games or card games very often um it was a great filler game you know all those types of things I would say that they're all true for Point City it's staying very much in that same Lane in that same genre and it's going to fill that same Niche it's just changing up the way that it's you know it scores and different things that we'll get into later to kind of make it a fresh experience but it's still very much in that realm so for someone who really loved Point salad I think you're going to find that you love Point City for many of the same reasons that being said on the flip if you did not enjoy Point salad there's a chance that you're not going to find enough here to kind of change your mind but as we get into the differences I think there are actually some key differences to it that that might not be the case so again to that in the differences section but I just really wanted to touch on the fact that this is still very much a quick playing

easy easy to access easy to teach small box card game I think that's important for people who are coming from point solid to know second thing is that even though we'll get into the gameplay rules and and all the differences around those in the next section you are still very much just picking cards from an available Market in order to score uh you know objectives based on how much you've collected of certain resources now those resources and point solid were veggies in this game it's a variety of things to do with constructing the city I'm not going to go over every single one of them but you'll you'll notice even just from like the side of the Box all the different resources listed here are very similar to all the different resources listed here so it's just a different theme and different resources in that respect but your goal is still ultimately to collect the right ones at the right time to be able to score points so if that's something you liked about Point salad was just that point solid feel to it of here's my score and objectives how well can I do with it you're still going to find a lot of that in Point City it just is executed a little bit differently and the last similarity I'll mention this is kind of it might seem a little bit vague but I just really want to stress this and that is just that they both still retain that Genius of simplicity and what I mean by that is that they are very simple games I like I touched on the first point very uh simple to learn to teach to introduce and everything but there is this level of you know um depth there's this there's this strategy to it that as the more you play the more you realize you know how you can refine your your ways of playing how you can refine the way you approach the game to to do better to be a little bit more competitive all that is still

present in poinsettia and in many ways is probably you know taken to the next level in a in a good way of retaining that Simplicity but giving you more things to kind of add to the variety of each session and you know to come back multiple plays so those are the similarities I want to talk on that being said the bigger topic here are the differences because there are a lot of differences and I think it's important to know that you're not just getting a reskin of Point salad with a City theme this is a different game it retains a lot of that DNA from point salad but it evolves it in a different uh you know different style of games so let's get into the differences first one is the gameplay we got to talk about this because it is different even if it does share a lot with Point solid in point solid obviously you had the 2x3 Market you had three rows of two and you had the uh the deck on each row that you can either take any Too Faced up veggies that you wanted or you could take a single point card from the top of one of the decks which are obviously on the back of the veggie cards um to score on at the end of the game and so you were kind of debating which of these scoring conditions do I want to take or do I want veggies to meet some of the scoring conditions that I already acquired this game also has our Point City also has a market the market is now four by four so it's a much bigger market and there's no Decks that are at the top that have the face up Point cards every card is still double-sided but they're all going to be face up in that 4x4 Market at the start of the game it's going to all be resource cards that's all that's going to be available but as you draft cards whatever side of a card you drafted it's

replaced with a card of the opposite side so if I draft a resource from the market and then the card that I replace with is now going to be on the building side which is the scoring side so that's how the building cards get added in as you go and eventually you have this Variety in the market of resources and of buildings now all your scoring objectives uh in point salad were calculated at the end of the game so you were just kind of doing everything you could to collect efficiently as you went for Point cards for resource cards and then you scored at the end of the game and then you saw who did better your scoring as you go in Point City now you're not you're not calculating your points as you go but the you're you're only allowed to take a building card which is essentially like a point card from point solid if you have everything you all the resources to be able to to claim it so whereas in point solid you were collecting to score at the end of the game here you're collecting to be able to draft to Able or be able to buy uh one of those building cards so that's that's the fundamental difference here and the biggest comparison I can make to the gameplay in that regard is so game called Splendor which is very similar in a lot of ways to Point City and I want to bring that up because blender is obviously a very popular game but it'll help you kind of understand the flow of gameplay in Point City every building that you collect from this Market is not everyone but a lot of the buildings you collect from them from the market are going to have the resource symbols on them and whenever you have a building that has a resource symbol on it that is now a permanent uh number of that resources that you now have so you can almost look

at it as like a discount for all future buildings so if I'm gonna I'm gonna forget the name of all the resource cards because I am notorious for just like pointing at something and being like Oh the red one instead of calling it like fire or whatever it's called so uh the energy resource the lightning bolts resource in this game for instance you might have a build in that costs you know two of those if you've already built another building that has a permanent lightning bolt symbol on the top of it I now have a permanent discount of one lightning bolt for every building that I'm purchasing beyond that so it's very similar to the gems in splendor it's just been inserted into this uh into this different game into this card game so you have this Market your drafting resources or you're drafting buildings if you have the resources to pay for them if you do have the resource to pay for them you're cashing those into the discard pile and claiming those buildings buildings also okay I can have points on them they can also have Civic token icons on them these Civic tokens are essentially end game goals so these ones you will score at the end of the game but they are not going to be scored by everybody they're going to be available from a like a shared Supply and every time you draft you build a building that has one of those Civic tokens symbols on it you're going to be able to claim one of them of your choice and that's going to be something that you privately will now score for at the end of the game so as you can see like the formula is still very much there that was introduced in point solid but it's been evolved you know before you only had six cars to choose from before and you were just taking two veggies and replacing them with Point cards that then became veggies and point guards were always available there was always three available the amount of buildings and the amount of resources and points they

are available changes and fluctuates throughout the entire game and I should have mentioned the two cards that you're drafting I keep saying drafting that you're selecting from the market I have to be orthogonally adjacent as well so you're that's you know adding a whole other layer of you might want a car that's in a corner but you don't want anything that is touching or you can't afford anything that's touching then you can't draft it so that is influencing your decision as well making you plan ahead and obviously other people are taking cards from that same shared market so as you'll see the gameplay is very different but it still very much has the essence of what was introduced in point salad it's just been evolved and Incorporated like I said some elements from Splendor that again I don't think it really over over complicates it it might be you know me explaining it here might in some ways seem like it is but in general all you're doing on your turn is you're just taking two cards you're looking at it and you're saying I'm going to take two available cards that are next to each other or I'm going to take two cards blind off the top of the deck and and that's that's it that's the entire function of a turn and you're just doing that I can't remember if it's 11 times or something like that or 14 but it's a set number of times and then you're just calculating Whoever has the most points at the end of the game so still very much a simple playing card game just as a different way of presenting the cards to you and and differentiating which ones are available at which point another difference I wanted to touch on even though this starts as a similarity is that both games the art was done by Dylan Mangini but the artwork is very next level so to speak in Point City so obviously in point style the artwork was limited just to the vegetables uh that were present on the cards and the style

of artwork was great and it still maintained that it maintains that same style in Point City but there's tons more variety the the every every building has its own little design to it or different color scheme or whatever and there's tons of cards in the game so I found myself often just sort of like admiring the cards I was getting when it wasn't my turn or the ones that were available because I just I think the artwork is really really great and it fits the same style you look at both these games you can tell even without even if the name wasn't there the the common name that they share you can just tell by the artwork that they're from the same line um but yeah it's a clear evolution in Point City and I can just tell Dylan was having a lot of fun designing the artwork in Point City it shows it's really colorful it's vibrant and it's Unique and I love it so I just wanted to touch on that if you know if you're a fan of the style of Point salad yes that's a similarity that the Styles maintained but get ready to be impressed by how much it's been evolved on as well another key difference is the variety I would say that there is a lot more variety to Point City obviously Point salad had a lot of ride in the sense that every game you could be going for different scoring conditions or having you know different success success levels with the scoring conditions you're going for and what vegetables are available that's all still present in Point City with a larger market that is going to be more varied than Point salads was and present more opportunities on top of that you're you're scoring as you go so you're like in the same way that you could have a game of Splendor which I'm going to compare it to again and and you know go into one where you had a bunch of red gems from the start and that kind of dictated what you were trying to buy and

how your game went that could have that could function the exact same way in Point City where you know you could collect a lot of the coin resources and have a vastly different game than another one where you just weren't able to get your hand on any coin or resources so if that all all coupled with the Civic tokens which are essentially end game goals which weren't present in points out per se like all the cards were end game goals this is like separate from the cards and game goals in Point City those all add variety because you might achieve or get access to different ones each game different ones might be in play every single game so that on its own adds a whole lot of variety just in general I think you're going to have way more games of Point City before you feel like you've had two similar games then that would have been the case with Point salad so a lot of variety here if you're someone who wants an accessible uh card game a really easy to teach one but that doesn't feel like it's growing stale or that every session feels the same I think Point city is going to be a great one for you because I think you'll find that there's just a lot changing from each session of the game that you get to the table okay so which of these two games do I prefer I could only have one which one would it be before I reveal that I just want to do one more last one last comparison here so a really popular game that came out you know in the last couple years was the uh the crew of The Quest for planet nine and then we have the follow-up which is the crew mission deep sea and and we had done a comparison for those games as well and you know the overall consensus that we had and that we've been shared with a lot of you know a lot of content creators a lot of people that have played both games is that mission deep sea you know in many ways just replaces the Quest for planet nine um yes there

are different missions so that you you still have that purpose to play you know one to experience the missions that aren't present in the other but in general it's the exact same game exact same formula just improved on just better better missions you know better um interaction with with the players of the table it was just a better version of the game so it became down to like I remember saying I don't think I'll own both I just want to have Mission deep C it's the better version I bring that up because this is not the same situation but what's interesting here is that even though they have a lot of shared DNA and it's at Point city is a clear Evolution on point salad um they are different enough that I could see multiple situations where you'd want to play one or over the other or have a group that gravitates to one more so than the other not just because of the theme you know the the salad veggies theme and the City theme but also just in the style and the way that it plays they're similar enough that you can you know have that a lot of rules and and know how carry over from salad to city but it's not like City necessarily needs to replace salads so I only bring that up because if you're someone who has Point solid and you're thinking well you know I I already went I already decided to go in on point salad I don't know that I need a the City themed version it is a different playing game and there will likely be a spot in your collection for both if especially if you loved Point solid and it's they're they're affordable games it's not it's not like a huge it's not like you're saying I have to buy two seventy dollar games so I you know I only need to choose one these These are really affordable card games and it'll be easy to get them in your collection

if you if you you know you want both so all that being said the lead in here uh I actually much prefer Point City and this is coming from someone who already thought Point style was a great game point city is just such a great Evolution on it and it just so happens that I'm someone who loves Splendor and and you know project Ellen games with that sort of building up your engine uh to be able to afford things more easily uh Point City introduces so much of that that it just spoke to me right away uh scratch that itch on top of sort of taking all that and putting it in the point salad formula so everything about Point City felt like an improvement or if not an improvement just a great and interesting Evolution on an established and you know great game already so I I loved that and and you know even though I would still definitely go back to point salad I'm sure I will and play it Point city is gonna be my preference to jump into just because I found there was way more to be excited about on top of like already being excited about seven point solid and just like I said before way more variety and more reasons to come back and feel like this session I played was very different than the other session I played last thing um because I just realized I didn't actually mention this in the differences is that point City can be played solo so uh Point salad was not a solo game but it played two to six point city is a solo game but it plays one to four so that is that is a key difference here to to mention I probably should have mentioned remember to mention this earlier is that if you or someone wants to play solo you only really have one option that is Point

City if you're someone who wants to play with groups of five and six your your one option is Still Point salad so very very important to to kind of recognize that uh obviously the the two to four player account you're gonna vote both games um I will actually say that the solo mode in point city is pretty good I I kind of go into games skeptical with solo mode just because I I often find some games they're great uh oftentimes with uh with games these days there has been more of an inclination to add solo modes to games that don't necessarily need it or they just kind of feel like half baked and not really you know the way the game is meant to be played and they were just added on to to you know attract more people in whatever the case may be I found that I I kind of I just assume that that's going to be the case when I go into games and whether or not it was with poinsettia I just I actually really enjoyed the the solo mode and that's because they do this thing where the Civic tokens that are these end-game goals are still in play but because you don't you don't have another player competing to uh to grab certain ones different ones are going to disappear in order from left to right as the game progresses depending on what the CPU player is drafting from again I'm saying drafting is selecting from the market and so you look at these end game goals and you say okay you know that one is going to be really good for me to score but you can kind of start to plan ahead and say oh but that one's going to be scooped up by the CPU next turn or there's a chance it could be next turn or how can I manipulate the market so that it doesn't get scooped up next turn so that just added another layer of complexity that was fun to to do in the solo mode and

the solo Mode still plays quick if anything you know I played it a couple times and I found that I won both and I didn't really feel like I was close to losing so it might be a case of it being you know maybe a little too easy but that also just could have been my experience and getting lucky with the solo mode but regardless having that option having it you know function well well it is a key difference with Point City to point solid you will be able to play this version solo if that's something you felt was missing from point salad so all that being said uh what is really exciting about this is that to me this is a great a great example of a sequel a follow-up done right you know you you another great example you know would be the Azul lines the Azul lines take shared DNA from across those games but they give you a new game with that DNA and there's aspects that remain the same you know Azul has the tile draft and The Remains the Same for the most part maybe slight changes like in Queen's Garden but in general you can kind of feel at home with those mechanics and yet you're getting and you could have paint a new gameplay style new strategy to uncover Point City feels like that it feels like it's taking you know the foundation that was established in point solid evolving in the places that it needs to be a different game and giving you a different experience but still still feels like you're coming home to a game you're familiar with and to me that was the best part of Point City if you loved Point salad if you liked Point salad I think there's a pretty good chance you're going to have a lot to love in Point City and you should probably check it out so all that being said when you're watching this video it's either already on Kickstarter or it's coming to Kickstarter within the next you know five days or so depending again when

you're watching this so there'll be a lot more details on there if you have any other questions for me you can post them in the YouTube comments below I'll be happy to ask and if I don't know the answer I'll defer you to someone who hopefully can answer this for you but overall the big takeaway here is that I really really enjoyed Point City and I should have said this at the beginning too this is not a paid preview this was just we were interested in uh Point City because especially or I should say I was interested in Point City a lot uh because of my my interest in point style and how much I you know fun I had playing it I played it on tabletop similar during the pandemic as well and it was just such an easy accessible game so I was really interested in Point City this is not paid this is just my opinion but again take it with a grain of salt because everyone's opinions are different so that's all I got for you if you want if you like I said if you have any other questions let them know let me know in the comments below otherwise we have a Discord channel that you can join if you want to be a part of our community get bet a little bit you know better access to us where you can talk to us on there or just you know talk with any of the great people that are in our community also a patreon if you want to if you're looking for ways to support us and you get some extra perks on there as well otherwise thank you so much for watching and we will see you next time

Progress saved