Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wallenstein Review (2nd Edition) - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 24:50

hey everybody today I'm talking about wallenstein which is a board game designed by Dirk hen and published by Queen games this one accommodates three to five players and takes 90 to 120 Minutes to play so wallenstein has actually been probably at the top of my want list for a long time but it's been out of print and recently a Kickstarter has been has been fulfilled um so that more players have access to it but before I get into my thoughts on wallenstein I just want to give a shout out to kiienda UK who are my go-to online retailer in the UK so back to wallenstein so wallenstein is a strange type of game so it's kind of a a hybrid of a Euro and war game um and it has some kind of or the mechanisms are basically combat and you've got some programming and lots of different things going on but I think the best way would just be to show you how it's played so I've kind of randomly set up the board here it's going to look a bit like this but I've done this without much Rhyme or Reason so you've got all the different cubes on the different regions here on this big map of Germany and this map is divided into different regions so you've got the different colored regions and within those regions you've got the actual different I suppose different cities um you've got all the different colors here again all representing a different color um and you see I've got a five player game here but if there was say a three player game um some of these regions are closed off you know with these white borders so the fewer players there are the bat does get a little bit tighter so some of the other features of the board here are of course the score track which goes around the outside you've got this

um these bonus tiles here which will affect player order I'll give you a bonus uh depending on which one of those you claim you've got the reach track here which is important because you need to feed the different counties you have um because again you need to actually feed your your kind of War um efforts uh you've got the little track here which I'll explain a bit later and towards the bottom of the board you've got this card row which all relates to the different actions you can take throughout the game and from round to round these are going to be randomized and that's going to determine the order in which these actions are resolved in there's also going to be some events so basically the game is divided into two halves and each of those houses divided into four rounds like Seasons so you've got up three basic rounds then you've got a winter face which is basically your scoring and when you have to feed your different counties and that's what these cards correspond to so for each each round you're gonna have either a bonus or at the end you're gonna have to when it comes to Winter you're going to potentially take a hit when it comes to losing weight so you've got some kind of potential to lose even more wheat than you might anticipate each player setup is going to look like this where you've got your own player board here you're going to have a bunch of cards and all of those cards are going to correspond to the different regions that you control so as you can see here I am the yellow player so therefore I have all the different regions all the cards relating to the regions where I've got yellow cubes so that's what I've got here you've also got some individual player cards here um and each player's got an identical set of those and they can let you kind

of manipulate turn order and things you've got all the other resources of the common resources you've got money you've got three different types of buildings you've got these palaces you've got these churches and you've also got these kind of little townhouses which I'm not sure the correct terminology you've got Revolt markers um which can play quite a significant factor in the game and I suppose more important than all you've got the cube Tower here which I've just knocked and knocked a cube out of which is going to be how combat is going to be resolved in the game but we'll talk about that in a little bit so as you've probably imagined um because this game's got a score track here the winning objective is to get as many points as you can when it comes to the end of that second year and you're gonna get points when it comes to you know the winter which is the fourth round of each of each year you're gonna get points for each of the different regions you control so controlling regions is is great because it's going to get you points and you're also going to get points for each building you control and no matter what they are but also for each each type of building is going to give you a number of points depending on if you have the majority in each of those regions so if you have the most palaces in a region you're going to get three points um churches you're gonna get two points and these ones here you're only going to get one point but so how does the game actually work so as I mentioned earlier this one does have quite a strong element of uh programming so on your player board here you've got 10 different actions you can take and they again correlates to the different card row here so this is going to be randomized um and that is going to be or let you do lots of different things such as being able to build the different buildings and the value of

those is going to depend on the you know the strength of this building so the palace is going to cost you three money and these ones are only going to cost you one and you can harvest wheat which is of course going to be an important factor when it comes to the end of the year to feed your different counties and to potentially stop revolts happening and potentially Stop The Peasants kind of overthrowing you and you've got to tax the different regions and that's going to be how you're going to keep getting income uh you've got to kind of bolster your forces you could spend three to add five cubes or two to add three cubes you can move cubes around from region to region by spending one Cube so if say I wanted to move um these two cubes here into this one I could do that by taking the action and always being sure to leave at least one Cube behind because you can't just leave a a territory unoccupied and then you've got the A and B here which is your basically your Combat Action so if I was to take one of those actions then I would go into an adjacent region and attack that region but the way you resolve these actions is by simultaneously programming them so out of all your different region cards who are going to allocate them to these different spots so for example I could say you know maybe in this um in this region here which I'm not going to really pronounce attempt to pronounce I might say I might want to build a palace there so I'm gonna put that face down on that here which means that you know I'm planning on building a palace there and therefore building that you know once it gets resolved I'll put this um you know in that region as you can see here that all these regions have a number of different um cities in them um and that depends so some of them just

have one but some of them have potential to have more and that is the capacity to the amount of buildings that that particular region can hold um but yeah you're going to do that for all the different things here you don't have to take that particular action um that's what these kind of cards are used for because you can see they have the same backs and you can use that as a kind of a bluff so if I was to put that here like this so my opponents can't just look over at my board and say look I'm not taking a bolster action you know they're not going to know if that's a dud or not and I've also got this additional spot here which is why the uh the coin value is important because let's say I bid 2 on this region here I'm going to put it face down that is going to be your basically your bid for turn order and depending on who's bid the most uh are going to get priority in choosing where they want to go in the turn order so you can go you can just go first when the actions resolved or you can choose to go last but as you can see here you've got the um the variable order or the bonuses that are assigned to that particular um turn order which will let you do different things such as um when you attack you might get an extra attack Cube or when you harvest crops you won't get an extra crop or when you defend you get an extra Cube or when you tax you get an extra coin or when you add those five um five Cubes To The Ball to bolster you can get a six instead of the five so yeah these are really useful tools and that can really um be a conflicting decision because you might want to go fast but you might want a particular bonus so once everybody's hacky with how they've programmed their board you're going to reveal all those cards simultaneously like so and then you're going to start resolving them based on

the order of that particular card row at the bottom of the main board there so I'll just continue flipping these over and then we'll show what all the actions do and some of the different kind of details on how they actually work okay so uh as you can see here five of these cards are face up and five of them are face down so you've got a pretty good order and what a good idea of what's going to happen during the first time half of the resolvement but the second half is a bit more muddy and you don't quite know um the order that they're going to be resolved in which can be a big big factor and because you might say want to uh boost a particular region because you might fear that it's going to get attacked but of course if the all the attacks come before the um the kind of muster action then um that's not going to be much help at all so it the turn order and the way things are resolved is a big factor on the decision space and how this game actually works but let's um let's show you how these work anyway so as you can see here the first thing here is going to be um to harvest the Grain and as you can see here on my player board at the Harvest Grain action I've used the in Lundberg so Limburg basically the card shows a number of different details that shows how much coins you're going to get when you tax that region how much food you're going to get when you're going to harvest crops and um also how many towns are in that region to build buildings in the first place and there's a really useful little key at the bottom of the board here to show all the different regions do and because of course you're not going to have all the cards in your hand and other players might control them but let's show you how this um Harvest action work so I'm gonna have a look here so on Holt

um I'm gonna get uh sorry not on Lundberg I'm going to get five crops for doing that so I'm gonna move up my crop marker up to the five region just show I've got that and this can be done simultaneously because this one doesn't particularly matter on the player order however whenever you tax or harvest crops you are going to place a Revolt marker uh this was in Lundberg uh in that particular region like so and that's kind of like shows the exhaustion of the particular peasants and the more you do that potentially the The Peasants are going to start fighting against you by adding green cubes to the cube Tower and and they will kind of pair off and potentially kill each other which we'll talk about a bit later because combat is quite a big factor in this game so you've got to be very careful not to keep exhausting the same region again and again even though that region might be particularly good at taxing or taking um or taking crops from so once that's done you're going to go on to the next one which is the uh the Boost by I spent two to get three cubes in there again I'd have a look at my player board here so spend two to get three is in this region here so of course I'll spend the money back to the supply and then I would add three cubes of my color to that particular region like so and which I can use too again just either scare people or Venture into new regions because as you can see here some of the regions aren't actually controlled by any player and when you reach when you fight into them you only have to fight a neutral green Cube which is quite an easy thing to claim but of course more more regions means more points

the attack action is one of the main ones so as you can see here my attack a is in this region here um pronounce it um and when I do that I'm going to have a look at that particular region and see how many cubes I have there and then I can commit any of them to go and attack a an adjacent region so let's just say um I want to move these two yellow cubes into this region here because I want to claim it as my own I'm going to take those and then I'm going to add them to the cube Tower like so and that is going to show a battle outcome so these are going to start pairing off with each other so I believe it was the blue cube I attack there um so these are going to actually pair off and they're going to kill each other and they go back to the common Supply and I've only got one remaining um and but that means I am now controlling this region and I can take that card to give me more dominance of the board but as you can tell that a lot of the time the cubes get stuck in the cube Tower meaning that the effect and outcome of future battles can be you know can be affected by that so you've got to be very careful about kind of keeping a tally on what's in that Tower and what can potentially come out and haunt you later because even though you know there's quite a strong luck Factor here on how it's going to get resolved if you keep getting bad luck then eventually your cubes are going to come out and start smashing your appearance so it will generally balance out and um that's generally a good thing in my opinion anyway and so some of the other regions are okay very simple how they're going to get resolved how they're boosting up um again the story is not going to build a church but I've not built a church

here because I've just taken that kind of dud action there's a bit of a bluff and then these are going to get started getting resolved and bearing in mind I didn't know the order which these were going to come out in so um these are very simple you can just spend a single coin like I've done here in this um hessen Castle I'll just spend a coin and add one of my um townhouses here to one of these cities um which is going to be great for getting points at the end of the round I should have said as well at the at the beginning of the uh particular round you're going to have a look at the event because out of the four that I draw randomly at the start of the round they're gonna get jumbled up and One's Gonna affect this particular round for example this one I'm gonna get capped at only be being able to tax uh five coins in this particular round so if you're a bit short of money this one can catch you off guard but these do lots of cool things such as you know when you uh when you I think it's just when you defend um and you have a palace you get an extra Cube to Chuck in the tower which is obviously good and going to help you win fights this one here basically protects you from being attacked if you have a church in a particular region um that one's the same uh you've got ones here that's let you kind of remove Revolt tiles if you place these houses so again you can really kind of calm the uh calm The Peasants and stop them revolting against you and trying to overthrow you and they do lots of different things and as you can see here when it comes to Winter the bottom half of the card is um it ranges massively so this one actually doesn't affect you at all um but this one can lose you a massive seven crops which can be huge and pretty

crippling um if you don't have enough wheat to uh you know to deal with that um and that's gonna tie into this winter phase here so let's just talk roughly through the way the scoring works so as I said you're going to get a point for each region you control which is basically each card you have um a point for each building you control and then a point if you've got the majority of each type of bit or sorry points depending on the building types if you've got the majorities on them so three two are one depending on that strength of those buildings but you're also going to have to pay a number of crops for each card here so let's just say I had um seven cards in hand and I only had five crops so I'm gonna be too short so I'm gonna have a look at this track track here so I'm gonna be two cards short which means um sorry two food shorts which means that an opponent gets to pick a card randomly from my hand and that is going to get revolted um by the uh neutral green Cubes at a strength two um I think it's plus every Revolt token in that region so again the more you don't feed your people uh The More Chance is going to come back and haunt you and potentially lose your regions and lose your points and create opportunities for the other players so yeah all you do is do that twice two whole years and who have got the most victory points at the end is going to be the winner so let's talk about some of the mechanisms and decisions you have to make in wallenstein so first off and programming is generally something I enjoy if done correctly and I might say um quite confident this is probably one of the best examples of programming that I've seen there's a lot going on here however it is quite simple on the way it

works and I love the way you know it functionally works by just allocating the particular regions to those particular actions um and but the Fallout of that decision is pretty huge because you have to kind of guess and second guess what your opponents are going to do and you know do you have to um you know invest in in bolstering a certain region before somebody else comes in and attacks it because you might just have that nagging tension that you know this is easy pickings for somebody else to take from me maybe you've already invested in passes and churches there to get them more points as well so it is a real kind of balancing act of Defending regions but also attacking the regions as well to claim those again those buildings and regions in the first place but maybe you don't want to go and take take on too many regions and you just want a more steady manageable uh kind of Empire because you need to feed them and feeding them is a massive nagging tension throughout the game but I think it works really well um I think maybe some of these cards are a bit too punishing and you know particularly if you've got the you know the sixes or sevens coming out the end that are going to lose you that many crops before you even get started and that can be quite significant but maybe uh you know you have at least you have an idea of what's coming up throughout the year and um gives you an idea to prepare for that so by you know harvesting food from those particular um you know uh industrious regions which are going to be more uh you know more profitable for Duke so but yeah it all ties in to the programming and the order in the first place which is going to be resolved in and the fact that the the second half of the round is all blurred anyway so you don't really know the order they're going to get resolved in sometimes you just have to take a bit of

speculation and say you know let's let's hope um I can attack this region before they add more troops there to defend it which is going to probably make me lose the battle because once you commit to something and you can complete that action you have to do it so um yeah it adds that much more weight to the decision and everything you do is important so I love that constant tension of you know keeping hold of what you've got but venturing into new land as well making sure you have enough food and trying to keep those peasant revolts down and trying to utilize the current um event because again you can use that to your advantage if you if a particular scenario works in your favor and bearing in mind that the turn order is important as well and also the bonuses for that turn order because you know if you're if you're doing really well defensively this round by having this bonus then maybe you don't have to worry so much about boosting but yeah absolutely so well done Andy again the wrinkles and the Fallout of these decisions is pretty huge and the timing uh essence of that is just a really strong and a real kind of crunchy but not overly paralyzing decision to make just just that that real cool satisfying tension I suppose one of the gimmicks I suppose you can call it that but actually I'd hesitate to call it a gaming because it is such a cool mechanism is the way the combat works so of course you know if this region wants to go and attack this region here um you're gonna have to leave one key behind and then you're gonna add all these to the cube Tower and see how that battle goes and um that could create some real cool random moments sometimes you're gonna have big crunching defeats where you didn't anticipate it and sometimes times you know even if you

well prepared for a fight it can go against you simply because of that element of luck and Randomness but it's it's mitigated luck and it's balanced luck so it's not going to be unpredictable at least to a point you've got a good idea of what's going on that Cube Tower and how that's going to get resolved and it's just a simple resolvement by just and you're pairing them off and then putting the remaining cubes in that particular region and um two set dominance and who's going to get that card but it all works so well so smoothly and um I I think it's probably one of my favorite combat systems um that that is still pretty random in how it works but yeah I've got no issues at all it just fits the game really well and it actually adds to the experience and kind of excitement to the game so I really like that system so yeah in terms of decisions and mechanisms I think this game is fantastic so much to enjoy and balance wise um you know despite this again semi-random uh combat system I always 100 feel like the best player is going to win this game um whoever plans the most you know if schemes and plans and plots most efficiently is going to do better than the other players no question about that at all so there's no point at all no there's no point in the game where I think you know what there's a big luck swing in someone's favor and that's going to decide who's going to win or lose the game no the player who's paid consistently well from start to finish is going to win time investment you know the game does take 90 to 120 Minutes more likely that 120 Minutes to to play and particularly if you want to play it you know four or five pairs which I think is probably where this game shines

strongest um but I don't find myself bored at any time you're always trying to stay on top of the board State trying to stay invested and try to make sure that you're not gonna let anything slip past you um because it does leave you feeling quite paranoid at times so it's not a gaming you're going to get bored or lose interest I'm despite you going quite you know a bit longer than I'd normally um like a game to go so I've got no issues at all that and it certainly um feels like the game length is appropriate for the actual game type the uptime as well is pretty fantastic because you are programming all at the same time uh yeah there is a little bit of scope for AP but that just adds to the satisfaction of the decision and it kind of makes you mull over your mistakes and things and that's the kind of the talking point of the game you know I did this when I should have done that so I've got no real issue with the kind of uptime or downtime whatever you want to look at it either I always feel engaged and yeah sometimes players might take longer than others and we'll look at the decisions but again it's because the decisions are meaningful so yeah happy with that um interaction fantastic you know this is as I said a borderline war game um so of course other players actions and board state is gonna um completely Depend and be a pivotal part of the game on how the other players are doing and what they're doing I'm anticipating what they're going to do are they going to attack you um is it now the time to attack them before they do so um so yeah everything is based on player interaction here and it's a pivotal part of the game and aesthetically and production um I think the ball looks okay at best you know normally I like these dry

looking boards uh this one I would like to have seen a bit more kind of texture to it it does feel a bit flat like a like it's made in some kind of generic um free map maker kind of software I'm not I'm not massively enthused by the way the actual map looks um but the actual the design of the map is great because it's kind of doesn't leave that much opportunity for turtleing and stuff like that um but yeah the actual visuals aren't the best some of the symbology in that of the cards are fantastic I've got no issue at all with the kind of functionality of the game the player boards are pretty great to be honest and considering how much information is stored on these player boards um I think they've done a good job I suppose the only issue of the game is that it is a massive table hog you know it takes a lot of room um because these player boards are so huge and there's a lot of stuff going on so yeah there's certainly a sprawling game um the actual physical components are all good no issues at all uh perhaps some of these tokens are a bit basic and a bit small um but I suppose in this particular version I'm getting the upgraded upgraded components the little acrylic tiles from Queen and but they just haven't come yet but the basic stuff is fine it works perfectly fine and there's no real issue in terms of the production so final thoughts on wallenstein so I have to say I really enjoy this game it's such a change of pace for the kind of games I normally play but still feels somewhat familiar because you know some of my favorite games like El Grande have a lot of shared DNA here scenario majority Style game and regain points for controlling regions map dominance that kind of thing um but

spliced with the wargaminess um it just makes us feel different and I will say you know normally these kind of more confrontational war games where you're smashing into each other cleaning regions competing opponents they don't normally it's not normally my cup of tea um however I think some of the additional mechanisms here like feeding your people such as the you know the card resolution the actual programming itself and of course the fun combat uh all does take that kind of hard edge off what you'd expect from a war game and it just makes it fun you know the fun factor is really strong on this one you always kind of invested uh it's not the game I kind of get to the table really regularly because I think it's not going to be for everybody I'd be part of that's probably the way this game looks it's not going to be um you know visually appealing to a lot of people but that gameplay is fun despite it being I suppose pretty stuffy in its approach that that fun is really there and I think a lot of people could enjoy and get a lot out of this game very happy with this one this is a strong recommendation for me and was certainly worth worth the wait uh over that many years because this was out of print as I said um if you're not too um too keen on the whole Woolen steam German theme um there is the exact same game out there called Shogun um which is simply a more a kind of Asian theme and the map's slightly different so um you know maybe if you like that Asian theme or go for that one instead but this one is going to get my shield of quality uh no question it's going to stay in my collection a real unique spot in my collection and um if you want to play that you know a more really interactive confrontational game for

three to five players then this one is going to be a strong a candidate for that thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because I am a woman operation and I don't get any support from Publishers then please consider backing it on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much I'll see you next time

Progress saved