Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wyrmspan v. Wingspan: An eagle eye view of components and mechanics comparison

Transcript 21:22

hello everyone and welcome to the mill this week I'm going to try to take a little different approach to the wingspan worm span comparison so what I'm going to do is I'm going to mostly take you through looking at the different components of Base Wings span versus base worm span to kind of give you an idea of what they look like and I'll naturally talk about the mechanics as well as I go but just a little bit so if you just want to visually see the differences and oh we have a helper she wants to catch the bird and the dragon so I'm going to pause and I'll gu us back to the table and yeah we will show you what the differences are all right so it seems natural to start with the boxes and as you can tell wingspan fits perfectly on top of worms span and you put them next to each other I have a ton of components out on my table right now can see there's been some people love the comparison between the two and how they're both the outstretched wings and then you also have the title on the bottom obviously a different font and you have different designers but you do have worm span being developed by Elizabeth hardgrave our designer for wingspan all right we have different illustrators um both Stone Meer atoma Factory and both beautiful art along the edges all

right so boxes quite similar their own way yes I stillo my original wingspan box I did not get the nesting box all right so there's the boxes all right next let's see what I got on my table here we have eggs so do eggs and containers so in worms span you get these two containers well I put the eggs in them I think some people put put them in one and the eggs are speckled the original one is that these are actually wood so they're probably a little bit lighter so you can see how they are speckled the other couple other few colors up here so there are your worm span eggs now wingspan just in the base box and I have the first print run so these are the nonwood ones technically now they are wood as well right so there are your differences in the bases um other options that we've got along the way for wingspan obviously that one has two expansions so we got purple and yellow and red eggs through expansions and at one point there was even speckled eggs you can ordered but you can see the old speckle eggs definitely look different in comparison to the warm wor spand speckled I personally like the worms band speckled

a lot all right so there's eggs also in the original wingspan box you got containers more like this like so many people I upgraded tokens but it came with a bunch of these little containers and then newer versions come with these they're more environmentally friendly I had mine from the wingspan Asia box the other container a lot of people loved in wingspan this is the old version I believe there's a new version out now all right and this is where you would hold the cards that is not in worm spand so that's kind of component wise different containers all right now since we were talking about cards let's look at some cards so we have our worm span cards and and our wingspan cards all right both quite beautiful all right and with these cards you definitely have some differences so I'm going to pull out a few examples here so in worms span the different types of cards you get are different than different types you get in base wingspan so you have your hatchlings which there is not a comparison to that in wingspan cuz the hatch Lings will let you every time you do whatever is on top you get

to do something so this they're a different type of engine so in this case when you run your engine based on that little guy you get to tuck a card from your hand here and any time you tuck a card on this hatch and you get milk third time you do it then you get a special bonus so you don't have any kind of hatchling cards in wingspan now if you can see see pull his variety out this is also where you see which cave they can go in okay so obviously that's a different iconology than let's say wingspan here where it tells you here which of the three habitats they can go in or if it can be all three so that's different color coding also if you look that text there definitely bigger in worm span so that's very nice for that kind of user friendly accessibility okay um no wingspan numbers here like you have here on the cards um you do have your victory points just in different ways okay um not different types of Nest so wingspan you have the different types of Nest whereas in worms mat just says if they're a small medium or large Dragon you don't really have that type of Nest it's a little different um but they both have egg capacity there as well now to do a little side by side comparison they do both have dragons or birds that have

a wind plade so kind of a similar icon there so this is a onetime wind plate here a one time wind plate here which is the white power and that symbol there okay the one that wingspan has that worm span doesn't are these pink powers which are once between turns and those don't exist in worms span uhum like a lot of people were very happy about that since these were a little bit harder to keep track of so they just didn't do them in worm span all right and then Brown Powers so these are similar so the brown power is kind of the equivalent of your little Explorer guy in worm span so these are whenever you're running your one habitat or your one cave these are the different powers that you activate but but they're different order so you're going from right to left in wingspan and left to right in worms span but those are your similarities where the brown power that's kind of your equivalent Brown power in worm span all right now that covers base wingspan I will bring up so as you got expansions like the European expansion and added the end of round which were the teal Powers whereas in there we go that we focus where's a workspan you have that right in the base and so this symbol is very similar it's the end of round powers for worm span so they both

have them you see an expansion form in wingspan and then once again end of game Powers you needed the Oceania expansion to get that in wingspan and that was the yellow whereas this little flag guy here those are right in the base game when it comes to worm span fan so you're kind of getting some ideas of where you see similarities but you need some of the expansions to get those similarities for wingspan so those are Dragon versus bird cards okay now other parts that are similar I'm just kind of going through my piles here we have these larger tiles for end of round goals which you have those in both games all right so common group goals okay there size difference definitely a size difference there which once again helps with accessibility so those are fairly similar all right now we can going get these eggs and containers out of the way all right we have Ru books so once again I'm going with the original ones okay worm spand definitely a little bit smaller also have the appendix all right so you have the appendix of dragon facta for worms span

which is smaller and quite thick whereas it's a pretty thin a little bit bigger one for wingspan so it's your kind of appendix and dragon fact and then your atoma rublo all right smaller thicker with worm span very thin and a little bit bigger for wingspan but they both have them speaking of atoma in worm span here's your atoma deck you can either play Ravel mode or the regular mode said I've played this I have a if you're curious where I kind of also talk about more of the mechanical differences I have a solo playthrough of the normal deck just the first round but it goes through all the differences so it's a very smooth atoma so if you ever wanted to try one solo I definitely recommend it and then the atoma cards sorry I might have some of these mixed up from the expansions when it comes to wingspan but yep these are e those were kind of how they would score differently there versus kind of have that written on the actual objective top for worm span and then some of those cards kind of told you what round they did so those are the atoma cards in here all right now one thing that's in

wingspan that we don't see in worm span are these secret goals those are taking taken out of worms span you kind of get to build your own goals through your birds a little bit more in base worm span than you do in wingspan so but wingspan lets you get more of these so it's kind of that give and take it's just done it's definitely done in a different way and I think worm span probably gives you that a little bit more flexibility with these goals all right okay so now action tiles so in wingspan here's your cubes so these are counting your actions in wingspans those are your color cubes there whereas in worms span to count your actions you're using the coins and what's cool in worm span is you can actually get more all right so you never and you never lose them so in wingspan you lose your cubes every round to put them here and scoring all right so as I was saying sorry if there's a weird cut there you always get six coins at the end of a round in worm span sorry at the beginning of a round in worm span so you will always minimally have an ability to take six actions depending you don't spend them on an expensive Dragon still have these cubes that you're going to

use for scoring at the end of the round you can kind of see the very big once again accessibility difference and a lot of reminders of what you're doing between rounds all here on the worm span mat and it tells you you get six coins and one egg at the beginning of every round which is very nice and convenient and you have ways to get more coins throughout the game so you can have these really awesome combo tastic turns where you're getting more coins so you can get more actions and feel like you're getting more done so that is one of those differences that you see from worm span to wingspan is that ability to get get more actions and not lose actions between rounds even though you start with more cubes and more action tokens in wing span and gradually lose them so if you went straight up they'd be close to the same amount of turns but you tend to get more in worm span which I think a lot of people seem to like that all right so we talked about the case for wingspan and how you have Birds there this is your mat for worm span so you can put your Dragon cards up here and one of those other big differences then is that in worm span you have cave cards which there really is no equivalent to that in wingspan CU you need a

cave down on your player mats to actually be able to entice a dragon to it cuz Dragon just not going to go anywhere they need a cave to stay in so you have a little bit different mat here here versus the container or mats and wingspan now while we're talking about mats that's probably one of the bigger differences so here is our worm span mat and I'll put them both out so you can kind see the size difference okay so there that is put right on top and your original wingspan mat each game came with five of these so that and as you can tell the worm span mat is definitely bigger okay so once again a lot of effort put into accessibility in this okay so some of those key differences as I said you have to put the cave cards here you you are limited how many times you can activate a row there's nothing like that here um both of them tell you what actions you can do so here play a bird gain food lay eggs draw birds if you are in worms span you can excavate entice explore all right and those are all of it uh the difference here to play a bird you can use any two resources as one whereas in worm spans you see down here at any time you can convert two resources to one it doesn't just have to

be to play a dragon and so you have the cost for the actions here as well cuz you always need a clean all right to do any of your actions as it reminds you versus the cube right then the cost printed on the cards which would be the same as if you're were playing a bird and wingspan there's just a lot more of these kind of reminders here and there's a maximum here of how much total cards total coins and total resources you can have at the end of your turn you'll also notice the difference here for that base camp and that's where your little Explorer guy goes okay so you don't have that in wingspan as well so your Explorer will go and explore caves as he goes through and he gets three sources based on as we talked about the symbol of him whereas in wingspan you would have a cube I'll use one of my cubes from wor band here and you would get to go on every card going the other direction to activate all your brown Powers so there's kind of a lot of your differences between the mats physics and then some of the actions and how you're using them um some of the other big differences you have this Dragon Guild that is in worm span this is another way to kind of get resources and also add some variability when you put the different guilds in there right so you get extra items as

you go around it and that's the symbol for it don't I don't believe there's any equivalent really to this in wingspan but kind of gives you another way to interact with people around you which is nice I know a lot of people like some more interaction but not too much and then we have our score pads okay there's an old there I said once again these are original I don't know if they've been updated in the future printings all right and then like some of the future printings had quick start guides so you actually in wingspan had different players and you had the quick start guides that would tell you'd give them a certain card and would tell them where to go and what to do again through the first few turns um rman they didn't feel like they needed it but it does give you suggestions for a quick start here so especially if you're teaching this might help people get through so it still has some part of that in there all right actual food tokens get some of these out okay so your resources in worm span meat gold we like to call it butter gems and milk okay and then in

wingspan let's see I don't even know if I know the The Originals the classic Stone me games col them whatever they look like versus they're actually called all right um in vertebres or what we like to call worms fish Cherries Berries wheat and your rats or rents put them next to each other so you can kind of see them obviously the wings spand ones are much older I don't use them much they are really close to the same size I think worm spands might be slightly bigger there but wingspans may be slightly thicker at least from original printings but yeah there is all of your different resources one worm span does come with counters as well okay so especially if you have said both games you can catch food on them so these can be very helpful when you're catching food right I think those are most the big components there is the first player token but I could not find my original Wing SP first player tokens my husband got me the little upgrade but it would be the same guys on them just looks pretty much identical to this but with this guy oh and one more big difference as you can tell in worm span you get food from the dragon deals you get food from usually get you always get choice of which food usually whereas

wingspan it was more random cuz you have the bird feeder and I have the dice for Oceania and the original in here so this is something that a lot of people liked because worm standand gets rid of a lot of the randomness when you put the food in the bird feeder you never know what's going to come out um nectar helped a lot with that Randomness if with the Oceania expansion since it was a wild resource but it went away after every round if you didn't spend it so the randomness from the dice is gone in worm span because as you can see from the scale usually you get a choice cuz that simple always means one resource of any of them so the gem the meat the gold or the milk and that's one of those other key differences that you see with components and rules all right so I think that pretty much covers our differences between wingspan and worm span com with in regards to components and also pretty much a a lot of those mechanical differences if you have any questions about either game or the differences feel free to leave comments below and we'll get back to you thanks bye

Progress saved