A Message From The Stars Review! (Can You Communicate with Aliens?)
Transcript
hi everybody hello I'm Ryan I'm Bethany and we are Ryan and Bethany board game reviews and today we'll be talking about a message from the Stars this is designed by Clarence Simpson it is published by allplay but before we talk about a message from the store I have a message from the store yes I have a message for you Walgreen's announcement clean up on aisle 3 this is a message from the store C up on aisle three message from the store subscribe that was it I was just subscribe M Clean subscribe on aisle 3 yes yeah I'm whatever Isle you're on subscribe we're so weird thanks for watching guys I appreciate you I first played this game at geekway to the West which is a great convention kind of a regional convention down in St Louis I played in 2024 and instantly loved it it was was crazy it was weird and there's two ways to play you can play competitively or you can play cooperatively I'm going to mainly focus on the Cooperative version of the game that's my favorite way to play this game because it's already tough enough as it is all right so what's happening is this is kind of a close encounter of the Third Kind situation an alien has come down but they don't speak the same way that we speak we are trying to figure out how each other speaks so we we can communicate so we can figure out each other's languages all right so the way it's going to happen is there's going to be one person who's playing as the alien and then every the scientists on Earth
trying to figure out what the alien is talking about and they have a message they're trying to convey all right so they're going to the aliens is going to send us a word in addition to that word they're also going to send us a score of what that means now when I say score from here on out it's not victory points kind of a score it's just simply a score in terms of value value yeah a win lose Cooperative kind of thing scores there's no there's no points I'm just saying that as a that's how it is all right so they're going to give us a word and a score of that word now behind what's going on behind the scenes is they have a divider in that divider they have a bunch of letters of the alphabet they have a deck they're going to draw cards from that to fill in this board three of the letters of the alphabet are scoring letters they're worth one point per time they show up in that word then you have two more letters of the alphabet that are multipliers they're doublers every time they show up they multiply the score times two and then you have another letter of the alphabet that is a negative number so let's say you have they give you a word and it's a three but it's a negative three so you know that three of the letters that that show up in that word could be repeats of each other or not are on their scoring card as a value card that are worth one point a piece and because it's a negative number you know that the negative number is also somewhere in that word the negative letter is somewhere in that word um and so then you as a scientist have to figure out okay so we know know that one of these is a negative you know some of these might be scoring cards then you
come up with a word yourselves as the scientists you submit it to the alien they write what the score is and give it back to you all right so you're pass messing these words back and forth giving each other the scores for those so that way you can figure out what the aliens code letters are behind their divider uh but in addition to that they also have both the aliens are trying to give us a message we're trying to give them a message so the words that you choose not only are kind of have to matter because what letters they are CU you're trying to figure out what they all what the letters are behind the aliens divider but also you he trying to convey a message so like on the back of the box for instance there's a message that says are it's the alien talking to us there their end final message they're trying to convey was our species is dying we must acquire superheated air so there's three words that they were trying to get us to guess sup acquire superheated and air so over the course of the four rounds some of the words that they are sending to us in addition to helping with the score part of the word also trying to get us to kind of Clue Into the word acquire or Clue Into the word superheated in some way without of course saying the actual words as words they're writing down and we as a scientists are doing the same thing on the words that we submit to the alien they're also trying to Clue Into the thing that we are trying to talk about uh so uh it's a very we're also trying to messages as well as figuring out what the code is as well um it's a lot simpler than it sounds well the same same time being way more thinky than it sounds yes it's both you hear Ryan
describe it and it's like yes easier and harder than that one of the things that I thought was very clever about this game is the message um that you're trying to convey to your partner when you're playing this game or your teammates when you're playing this game and the reason why I think that's clever and good is you have all these letters and somebody like me struggles with just coming up with a word trying to implement those letters but when I have that it kind of Narrows my focus so not only am I trying to come up with the word but I'm trying to come up with now not only am I trying to come up with any word like literally any word just of the as long as there's these letters in it it kind of focuses the words that I can choose from and that helps me actually it narrows it a little bit so it's not so open-ended and you can do anything it narrows it down okay what's a word that involves these that involves that and it kind of brings it into more Focus and it actually makes it um I don't want to say easier to play but you're not just sitting there trying to think of just a word the whole time because you have a direction to go in so I thought that the message worked really well and making the game progress so the alien in this game they have all the information uh they're kind of their main goal is to kind of come up with clever words that help people figure it out but then also convey their message on the scientist side of things we have no information so you're using logic to try to figure it all out but based off the information that you have so it starts off earlier with inductive reasoning so you have no
or very little knowledge and you're just throwing out an answer probably conveys your message a little bit but you're throwing out a word to see what comes back to you and you don't have a lot of information so you're using inductive reasoning early on but then later on as you gain more and more reason information then you're using the deductive reasoning okay so because this this word had a score of zero we know that none of these words were over here they might simp be doublers but they're not over here okay this one was had a a score of four so it was either two * two or it was four individual ones or whatever the case is so you're trying to use as much deduction as possible so there's two different kinds of logic going on this is game is all completely just driven by that logic and multiple kinds of logic especially on the scientist side and the difficulty of the cards you don't really have to worry about so you do have these letters and you're putting them in and you're putting them in at random however all the slots are going to require certain types of letters basically common not so common and extremely rare are the the three categories and you can't have more than one extremely rare card so even if it pulls up when you're drafting the cards to put in these slots you just tuck it under and you draft another card so that helps you if you're the alien you're not going to be like I'm only going to have all these extremely I'm only going to have like VES x's and y's and I'm not going to be able to get you to guess any of these things it's not like that at all so you have it there there has to be some difficulty in the game right so there's some slots that require a uh like a medium or a harder uh relevancy letter but not all of them
are like that so that's that's good that it um gives you a span of things to work with I think the theming for this game was right on point so first off you have this this whole alien Spees thing a message from the Stars thing going on um but mechanically that also carried over it wasn't just like here's the theme now go do whatever you want no it was you actually felt like you were an alien in this in someone else sending messages back and forth trying to figure out how each other spoke had that theme really strongly interwoven in the theme as well as in the mechanisms and then furthermore that kind of took a step further with the messages that you're sending back and forth as far as the what you're trying to convey as your as your final message the aliens uh can either send sometimes their messages based off the dice rols are uh inquisitive what are you people about what is going on over here or maybe they're hostile we're coming to destroy you or maybe they are um here's something about us here's something you know whatever and as the humans we're doing the same thing maybe we're like um are you coming in peace or um we're ready to fight or or hey tell us something about this outer space that we don't already know or whatever the case is so all these messages that you're coming up with um based off the cards are they worked right on theme as well I felt the whole time not like an alien or not like a scientist but at the same time that we were in that world that communication was happening in that way that give and take I thought that was really cool okay so this is going to be really interesting because I can recognize that this actually is a great
game not just a good game but a great game it does something interesting it does something unique and it's able to pull that off however it's not for me I am not the gamer that this game is for I really struggle with word games and I really struggle with inductive reasoning so even though I was able to play it and you know I enjoyed myself a little bit but it's not something I'm ever going to gravitate towards but that's not because it's not a fantastic game it's because it's not a game built for me as a player and I wanted to mention another thing it it doesn't matter if you're a good speller or not because you're you're giving a score of whatever letters are in the word so you can spell a word wrong and it doesn't matter as long as the score matches up with the sheet behind there so it's kind of nice for those of us out there who are not excellent spellers you don't have to be an excellent speller because it has to do with the Le it doesn't have to do with spelling the word correctly so that is a positive it's just not a game that I am going to gravitate towards but that does not mean it's an excellent game it just means it's not a Bethany game so someone in your situation if they either had to play or when for the mood for whatever to play this game would you prefer they play the alien or the scientist I think the alien you just have a little bit more information so it's not as stressful where the scientist you don't have anything and you're trying to like like you said you're trying to do the inductive and deductive reasoning so if we were to play this together you would never get to be the alien that's fine yeah I would only be able to be I would
have to be the alien because I I think I'd be too um I just feel really dumb trying to figure it all out and I don't want to feel dumb when I'm playing the game so I mentioned I get to play this uh earlier at geekway I was instantly hooked and that stuff in the more we've played it has not changed this is one of my my favorite games that I've played this year of games that came out this year it is that good this is right at my alley the amount of thinkness that happens the the cleverness you have coming up with this these weirdo things and try then trying to read behind the lines of behind the words not what the scores but what are the words trying to say as well with the messages it's just so very very interesting to me it does something that I I I like logic puzzle I've seen other logic games and stuff that before this is something very different very different um and well it might not be a commercial success from a volume standpoint this is nonetheless a extremely fun and interesting game I highly suggest the little extra pack that gives you more Dice and the little little dice boards as well with the little holder those were really nice nice that makes it visually work out well as well as kind of tactically it works out nicely too um this is going to be a hard one to get more plays of because Bethany's not asking for it and when I'm asking for it she's like showing it uh so my birthday's coming up soon so I'll maybe I'll escort then we'll see I've got to find more people to play this with because I really really really like a message from the
Stars everybody clean up an aisle three okay everybody thank you so much for watching don't forget to uh subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out until then you can find us in all of these places see you next time everybody bye you guys thanks so much for watching uh this game was provided to us by a publisher for in exchange for a fair and honest review and if you want to see more stuff check out over here to see something we think you might like and over here we think that YouTube has picked out a great video for you're going to love thanks guys we see you next time bye