Root Homeland (Plus FULL Tierlist!)
Transcript
Welcome back to the homeland. What an auspicious day in the forest. The clearings are abundant with the cute forest critters and are decorated with the intestines of your enemies. And it's all thanks to the newest Root expansion. Last time I did a big route video, my thesis was that it's a blank canvas. All the color, all the sweeping strokes, they come from the factions and how they paint the board with their adorable little meuples. So, at long last, we return home and we've got three new factions to meet. So, let's chat about it. The Twilight Council. The Twilight Council are the nocturnal governors of the forest. Half a peacekeeping force and half wanted to take ownership of all of your stuff. The way I see the bats in the broadest strokes is that they want to add red tape to everything that happens on the board. They open these governing assemblies which prevent players from placing, removing, taking, flipping, or crafting pieces in those clearings. Kind of like a corvid snare, but with some new mechanics. Like, I don't recall anything else preventing the flipping of pieces. Now, these assemblies do allow rivals to move into and battle in these clearings. So, the most straightforward counterplay is to just destroy these assemblies. But the bats don't want that because they score by having those governing assemblies in places where enemies have cardboard. And I know it sounds complicated, but the
gist of it is this. They win by taking ownership of the cardboard other people want to use and by holding on to it. That's the core idea. But how do they actually play? Well, the main mechanism is by placing cards down in their bird song to move, to recruit, to assemble, all that good stuff. But the twist is after they go to sleep in the day phase, they wake back up and they start to pick up those cards in the evening. So what this means is that every card gets used twice. By revealing a fox card to move some units, you can then use that same card to banish opponent pieces later in the turn. It's an incredibly flexible system with two distinct menus of actions for each card. And I really like this system. It kind of feels like the lizards but more streamlined, more refined and intuitive to play with.
Okay, that sounds cool, right? But what's the catch? Well, the bats really, really value their cards. It's their engine and their method of actually interacting with the board. So, crafting can be a harsh trade-off. And their card draw is kind of mid. Even some of the actions they do spends a card. Battling when an assembly is in the clearing if you assemble without ruling out the end of it. and agitated. Put simply, that's the tension of playing the bats. You're trying to govern a wide area and have rule over other factions pieces, but some of the most important actions will discard cards and weaken your engine as you play. Now, from the other side of the table, the bats are pretty decent to play against. I think because the bats aren't actively trying to destroy your pieces, there's kind of this mutual understanding between the bats and everyone else. It's like if someone stole your property because they really need it. They still tend to it. They still care about that property, but you as an individual can't use it. And there's also some really cool mechanics with the bats, like this peacekeeping ability, which helps out defenders in battle. And if worse comes to worse, you can use something called the intreatin ability, which is a weird one, but it essentially closes a governing assembly, but gives the bad player a loyalist, or they can actually place their loyalists in that clearing. These loyalists are kind of like a reserved army that lives on the player board, but can be dropped in by the bats at those assemblies. And I think a classic scenario is to imagine
the bats versus the cats. At first, the cats are like, "For sure, govern all my stuff. Keep it safe." And then they realize that their recruiters or sills and workshops are taken over and the cats can't actually use their buildings. Those buildings are now useless. So they get mad and try to get them back. But it's not that simple because the bats have these loyalists ready to go and hold on to whatever they got. And it's not just the cats. The crows and the naves all feel really good for the bats in a matchup. So yeah, I do find them kind of dependent on how much cardboard is actually put on the board and how easily those clearings can be governed, which actually leads to a really bad matchup against the general underpowered lizards. So yeah, it's actually pretty neat trying to figure out when to draft the bats and how you'll interact with your opponent's pieces. One last thing, they have this weird new combat mechanism called banishing. Essentially, nobody dies, but you push opponent's pieces to an adjacent clearing. I think it's cool. I don't find it really the defining mechanic of the bats, but it's a useful little thing that can be used with rivals to help them out as well.
So, neat new stuff. Anyways, let's drop the bats into the same power scale I used for my previous video. The Twilight Council gets a complexity 7 out of 10. Fun to play 8 out of 10. Fun to fight also 8 out of 10. Strength 6 out of 10. And overall quality 8 out of 10. the lily pad diaspora. Okay, next up we got the amphibious frog buddies. And I'm just going to come clean. I'm guilty of being a frog fanatic. I'm a toad truther. I think these amphibians are peak or kino or whatever positive trendy word makes you feel good. The lily pad diaspora are on a quest to reintegrate with the forest. And they'll do it in one of two ways. Through peace or through extreme unending violence. and they play into this amphibiousness with their militant and peaceful dance. So, let's get into it. The frogs spread these happy or angry enclave tokens. And the peanut butter and jam of it all is that these tokens act as a new suit.
When frogs are at peace, their enclave coexists with whatever the suit is already there. A fox clearing with a peaceful enclave is now both fox and frog for everyone at the table. But when the enclave goes militant, the amphibians are taken over, the clearing becomes purely frog and the other forest critters leave in amphibious fear. Now, with that new suit on the board, this also means that the frog adds in 14 new cards into the player's deck. The coveted frog suit. This new set of cards has the staples like the ambush cards and the dominance card. But they also add in unique frog cards like agitators, settlers, stewards, which all play with the diaspora and their mechanics. They even add in a pond where these frog cards get discarded face up and players can choose to draw directly from the pond. Now, I think this is fantastic.
these cards, that new suit. It adds that layered social richness to root in a very organic way. It feels like a fresh game for everyone involved without actually adding all that more complexity. For the lily pad player themselves, they come in from the river and rapidly encroach on all of the other forest critter lands. They use this provoke action to place militant enclaves either along the river or with one of their warriors. and then they spawn one frog on every single militant token or they can settle in a clearing which is kind of like a frog warrior vacuum action from all the neighboring clearings. The thing is the frogs are also super mad and in each and every melatin clearing they must also retaliate and fight in that clearing.
Then they get to integrate by spending a card and earning points for each peaceful enclave of that clearing type. I know that sounds like a lot, but don't worry, it actually plays super super easily. And that's their overall rhythm. Get mad, get peaceful, score points. The focus is this tugof-war between their two forms. And a lot of players approach it differently. Should I prioritize getting all my warriors on the board and then go peaceful? Should I just focus on one suit to score more effectively? Is it worth reconciling if someone else rules the clearing? There's a lot of push and pull mentally between the two sides of the enclave. And I think this balance of war and peace is an excellent puzzle to structure the faction around. I think for other players as well, there's a ton of meat to this puzzle.
Like if you're playing the eerie, having an entire suit to consider can be incredibly stressful. But because the peaceful enclaves add in a frog suit to an otherwise normal clearing, it can actually create more possibilities and more moments of brilliance than normal. Even for a faction like the crows, which are on the weaker side, they can feel impactful by a well spread out frog faction. And there is another mechanic I haven't touched on the something called fears come to pass which is when a player removes a peaceful enclave suddenly all the peaceful enclaves become milicant wherever that player has pieces. So like if a cat player removes a peaceful enclave from the board all the areas with cat pieces and frog enclaves become militant. It kind of like a rebellion and a retaliation from the frog player, which also adds to the sense of fragile coexistence of the frogs and everyone else. It changes the board suits on a whim and really adds to this evershifting uneasiness of coexistence with the lily pad diaspora.
And I think this kind of strange unique game possibility really opens and pushes up the frogs from just a really good faction to one of the best root factions in the franchise. So let's rate them. Complexity, they get a 5 out of 10. Fun to play 10 out of 10. Fun to fight 9 out of 10. Strength 7 out of 10. And overall quality 9.5 out of 10. Hey, this is Big Pasty from the future. just after I finished editing this video and I'm here asking for your help. My team and I are about to launch our first game, Sunlets Eulogy on Game Found, and we want you to follow us. If you like strange, cutthroat games with a ton of emphasis on asymmetry and social interaction, then Sunlety is made for you. It takes place moments after a religious prophet dies, and it's all about the dilemmas that arise for you as a disciple of a wavering faith. We spent a ton of energy on making a game that plays hard and really tries to push you into uneasy alliances of mutual conveniences. We want to celebrate the discomfort of fragile relationships and the experience you have when your beliefs are held lightly. And all of this through play. So, if that sounds even the slightest bit interesting, follow us on Gamefound for a $5 discount before we launch. and I don't have a Patreon or YouTube membership. So, the single best way to support us is to show your interest algorithmically on Gamefound. So, thank you. And let's get
back to Root. Next up are the naves of the Deepwood. Ah, praise be. The Naves of the Deepwood are here. I will now do a celebratory one-handed clap for their arrival. The naves are a new idea for Root, a true replacement. Literally, you can't have both the vagabond and the naves in the same game. And I, for one, am ecstatic and overwhelmed with glee. So, what's their thing? What's the vibe? Well, just like the Vega Bond, you can expect to sneak around the forest using items to take actions, and inevitably go on a murderous rampage. It's all here. But instead of one giga Chad mele, you get three bandit captains and a small crew of skunk warriors. It's a flexible remix version of the Veabond that tries to be more interactive and more counterable than the lonely pond.
Mechanically, the naves are a combative heavy insurgent faction. You're popping in and out of forest, picking fights, taking prisoners, and dropping a claim across the board. Those prisoners and a claim are the two methods of scoring. A prisoner is moved from a clearing to a forest when the captain attacks and then remain there until the naves take it easy. A claim is also placed after combat if a captain is there, but is also dropped around the board with some of the many unique actions that items can be used for. And then both a claim and prisoners score one point per two. and a claim in prisoners cannot be stacked in a specific clearing or forest. All of this is to say that you'll want to attack wide. You'll want to focus on different areas of the board with your merry band of skunks so that you can spread your acclaim far and wide and take prisoners across the board.
Now, the big thing is instead of having one mele king in the Vega bond, you have three nave captains and they too have special abilities to mix and match with. When you play the advanced setup, you actually draw four total captains and pick three of the four to play with. And I think it's super important to draft a good combination of items and abilities to really take advantage of the names. And there's tons and tons of combinations, but I find that there is a value in having item variety. And I think it's a really interesting system and really does make everything feel rather unique and spicy game after game. With that said, the naves do feel leashed in in comparison to the Vega bond. Card draw is not great even with your gift action, and you only have 10 of these skunk warriors. And it's not that easy to replenish your band of miscreants if they get destroyed by an opponent, which is speaking of which really punishing when someone actually destroys your captains. In a normal turn, you have a four action economy where it takes one action just to replace your captain and then another to move them out of the forest, which means that half of your action was just gained back into a clearing. So, what do you gain in flexibility of strategy with the captains and the abilities and the items, you lose a lot of that innate strength that stickier factions have.
The naves can be punished and can feel blocked if they lose their foot in. Last thing, the nave captain system means that you have to cycle through all three naves. You can play as the gladiator turn one, then the jailer, then the cheat, then take the three captains, and they replenish their items. They take it easy, and then they free a faction's prisoners. Only then you can actually go back and use your gladiator from turn one. And since a game of Route usually lasts like seven to nine rounds, you'll only use each captain maybe two or three times max. And this would be fine except for the fact that if you're in the lead, your exhausted captains are just like sitting ducks for like two turns. It's really really easy for people just to lay waste, ruin your action economy for the next set of turns, and make you feel like a weak little bandit. And this isn't to say that they're super underpowered. On the other hand, I really appreciate the ability and almost incentive of attacking them in comparison to that horrible prisoner dilemma of trying to fight the vagabond.
I also think some game states really highlight the naves and those unique mechanics like with those prisoners. These troops are locked out of the game until the captains take it easy and it only releases the faction that has the most prisoners. So, if you strategically target a faction with a low troop economy, like the Woodland Alliance, you can really be a scary counter. On the other hand, factions with a high troop count tend not to mind prisoners as much. It's an interesting wrinkle in what seems like a fairly simple mechanic. Overall, the naves satisfy a very specific itch of the root fantasy, a powerful group of the few. It's a specific fantasy of having highly concentrated power. And this has led to a lot of problems in the game's design, I think. But I think the naves are a giant leap forward. There is that power fantasy of taking prisoners laying a claim, but there still is vulnerability in that system. And I think it's a fun system. And for some people, they're going to love the naves game after game.
But for me, the naves get complexity 5 out of 10. Fun to play 6 out of 10. Fun to fight also 6 out of 10. Strength 5 out of 10. an overall quality six out of 10. Before we go to what you're really here for, you tier list sickos, let's talk a little bit about the new boards. Homelands comes with a very nice double-sided map. One side, the gorge, and the other side, the marsh. The gorge map, which I think was designed by YouTuber Sam Smith from Lord of the Board, is a fantastic map for a three and four player game. I think it's my new favorite root board, period. I love how it doesn't really add any new mechanics or pieces, but still feels like a step up from the base forest and winter map. It has this layered almost three-dimensional board aspect that really feels good to interact with. And I'll be honest, I think the landmarks are cool and all, but there's something magical about just having a clean, straight up interactive textured map that naturally builds from the base game of Route without adding any new mechanics. The marsh map is also amazing for the simple fact that it supports up to six players. It adds in three new but fairly simple landmarks that each represent a suit and bumps up the total clearings from 12 to 15. Now, I've actually played Route before on a six player fan-made map, and it was really cool. And now having an official product just helps make it easier to bring to the table. Of course, you can also
customize the map for four or fewer players by adding in these flood tiles. So overall, just good stuff. Enough pieces. Lastly, just in case, Homelands also includes enough additional tokens and pieces to support two simultaneous games of Route. It's a nice little bit of extra stuff. I think it's really, really cool that they included it. I haven't taken advantage of this yet, but I love that if it's ever possible, I could do a root tournament with like eight players and have two games run simultaneously without needing an extra set, which is really quite an excellent consumer friendly way to make a game. Updated tiers. Okay, I know what you've been waiting for, you tier list addicts. You guys love tier list. I have the YouTube analytics. You can't deny it.
You guys just gobble it up. And you want to know how the tiers have shifted over the years. and I'm here to oblige almost a gavage feed into you list after list. Here we go. Let's start off with complexity. So, I think I mostly got it right from before. So, let's just add in the three new factions from Homeland. And tada, it's all good. I still think the badgers and lizards are at the top. I'm going to put the Twilight Council right behind them. I also want to switch the otter and woodland alliance, but everything else can stay the same. The lily pad goes between the rats and the moles. And the naves are just behind the riverfolk because of all their variants and action combos. Perfect. Looks good. Let's move on. Okay, now let's talk about fun to play. And I'm going to do some quick revisions. I'm going to bump the badgers up to S tier. The more I play them, the more I find joy in their rather complex puzzle. There's a strength that they have in their individual units, but they feel incompetent with their troops starving and having to constantly play around the retinue. So, there's this balance of raw strength with a feeling of constantly tripping over their own feet. And I think that's actually super fun. I'm also going to bump the crows up. They're an acceptable level of fun, even if they are weak. Pulling off a great misdirect or spraying a bunch of troops, it all has that dopamine hit we love. I just wish their action economy was better and they should probably have three plots of each type, but alas, it is what it is.
Now, I need to confront a sad reality. I'm going to move the cats all the way behind the Corvid conspiracy. After a few dozen more plays with them, every single game, I start to like them less and less. I know people are going to say, "Oh, well, they're such a police enforce. They have so much board presence." But I don't really care. I don't think that's enough to make them fun. If you're constantly using a watering can to put out a forest fire, you're really not having fun keeping people in check. They have this terrible, incredibly weak action economy that just prevents any big plays like some other factions can do. Some of their mechanics, like the supply lines, just feel broken in a bad way when faced against these new factions. And with the Veabond's removal, the cats just feel building slot limited in more and more games. It's just not fun when you can't act. And if you can't have a moment in your game, I feel like they really just need a bit of a shove. Just an idea off the top of my head. I would start by moving their craft and action to the evening phase just as a start. Lastly, I want to bump down the otter a tiny bit.
They are highly dependent on the table. And sometimes if people just don't choose to engage with you, it's kind of miserable. It's not super often and it's kind of counterintuitive I would find, but it does happen. So, let's put them just above the moles for now. Lastly, lastly, and it's with sadness, I'm going to bump down the lizards a tiny bit. They're still good, but their gameplay just isn't as polished as these S tier factions are. Now, the good news is the new factions all score highly on this front. So, let's toss those baddies in. The naves go above the otter. A good, solid, fun faction all around. The Twilight Council goes above the Lizard Cult as the new crowned funnest insurgent faction to play. And my Moody Boys, the Frogs and Toads, get second place right behind the Eerie. A huge triumph for these new factions.
Next up, we have fun to fight. Before I put in the new factions, let's talk about some of the big changes. I'm going to start with releasing more sadness from my heart. I was wrong about the cats. I'm moving them all the way from the top position all the way down to just above the crows. I think the longer I play root, the less fun I have engaging with the cats. I think my mistake was I valued interaction very highly last time around. But if the interaction is just repeatedly punching the cat player in the face as they whimper away into a small corner of the forest, maybe it's not good interaction. Like they're a punching bag rather than a real threat. And there's little the cat player can do to feel threatened. I think they're fun to fight in the sense that it's enjoyable to have a target that's consistently in reach and available and willing to take a few hits, but they're not really all that fun to fight when you realize you're just bullying the faction that wants to be wanted. They're kind of like the anti-duche and Veabond. The cats are everywhere all at once and that makes them so easy to engage with. But they're spread so thin and they don't have any sense of making these giant plays that it's just not fun against them. Now, this is to say they're not the worst to play against. Not even close. But they aren't this apex of fun to play against like I previously had. I'm also going to move down the otter to just above the moles. They create this interesting prisoners dilemma sometimes, but more often than not, it's just too obvious to
buy their wares or to just not engage with them at all and watch them drown. Their whole idea of collecting meeples is often just not worth the cost for a lot of factions. And most otter just hoard whatever pieces they can until they can plant a ton of trade post near the mid late game. It just leads to a surprisingly stale game for a faction all about making deals. Now, when it comes to the new factions, the naves go above the cats. They are so so much more satisfying to play against than the vagabond, and I like this whole combative insurgent play style, which makes the whole match feel more aggressive. There is enough trickery that you kind of have to know how to prioritize the captains, but it's all manageable where counterplay is ample for everyone at the table. The bats also score highly here. They go just above their lizard brethren. I think the bats occupy this weird niche wherein they're the schemers behind a lot of the table's dynamics. A governing assembly or cooperative banish action or the fact that you can just close assemblies on your turn all feel fun to play with and to play against. I just think they're a great powerful insurgent faction that just works at a table. Lastly, we have the frog squad. They are fantastic. I think the big thing with the frogs is when you play against them, they change the puzzle route enough that the game feels fresh without feeling substantially different. They add in a new set of frog cards and their ability to change the clearing type within the game is just super interesting to play against. And I think some factions like the Eerie and the Badgers have pretty obvious interactions with their decree and the retinue that need to be addressed. But even factions like the Woodland Alliance and Riverfolk have to
play around the map puzzle that is made. The negotiations mechanic that players can use to flip militant enclaves becomes incredibly important and it creates a super interesting twist on route that really tickle the brain in a good way. Strength. Okay, just before we place the new factions, a couple of notes. I think strength is more complicated than just a simple tier list. It's all about the matchups. There will be some games where some factions will be at a disadvantage, even if they're powerful factions. That said, think of it this way. The top tiers really don't have a bad matchup. Like you really can't go wrong with the Mole and the Veabond because they can play well into any combination of factions. The Eerie and the Woodland are also super strong, but at certain tables they can have a gentle uphill battle. So, let's get started. The River Folk are moved down because some factions simply don't want to interact with their mechanics and some players just purposely ignore them, which can significantly destroy their whole prisoner dilemma of deals gameplay. They can absolutely roll over a table, but more often than not, it's something enabled by other players. And let's toss in the new factions before we get to the bottom tier. The naves are the weakest of the new factions. They have tricks, they have powerful combinations, but I think that a coordinated effort destroys their action potential. Like, if you remove their captain from the board, it's one action to place them back onto the board and another action to move them out of the forest. It's devastating. I know they have burst potential in the late game and they have enough trickery, but still the bottom half of the strength tier list feels
appropriate for them. The Twilight Council is a tier above. I think they're generally able to keep pace with other factions, but I do find them a bit volatile in their scoring machine. I didn't really talk about one of their actions, the empower action, where you toss a dice and lose units for points if you hold control of a clearing. It's a strange way to score points, but if you get really lucky, you can score a ton and still have momentum as long as all the stars align. I also find that the bats are also very matchup dependent. They want factions that place a lot of cardboard early and don't move it around too much. So, cats, naves, even the woodland alliance are good matchups. On the other hand, the lizards and the otter are really good into the baths because the lizards hold control of clearings with their gardens, and the otter usually hold on to their cardboard until much later in the game. Lastly, the Lily Pad Diaspora are the strongest of the three, but they're not in that sacred S tier. Their faction scoring is usually capped around four points per turn, which isn't bad, but it isn't spectacular. They do score a lot from destroying other pieces of cardboard, and they're very good at crafting as well because it's not that hard to get enclaves on the board, but it does take some RNG because you're going to be randomly tossing cards out when you provoke and even integrating cost a card as well. I think the lily pad have this very important last turn burst potential if everything is played right. And while they're not as bursty as a woodland alliance, they still feel threatening when they're behind on a table. So yeah, they're a strong faction, but definitely not one of those busted S tier ones.
Okay, now let's go back to the bottom of the tier. I've put it as this. The crows, then the cats, then the lizards. And I'll be honest, depending on my mood or what kind of energy drink I had in the morning, I see these three as fairly fluid in their placement. But what I do know is that there is a gap between these three factions and every other faction. Like the naves and the riverfolk company technically occupy the tier above these three, but there is a gorge between them. Both of those factions can still perform well even against the high tiers and are threats in normal games. The crows, the cats, and the lizards just kind of get shut down too easily. Their mechanisms are interesting and fun and whatever, but they just feel fragile compared to the systems that other factions use. And for that reason, they're the bottom tiers.
Overall quality. Okay, last but certainly not least, we need to discuss overall quality. Starting off, I've bumped the cats down like four positions from last time. I find that the other low tier factions and the lizards and the crows still have those highs that feel good. They can still pull off some sick bluffs or some nasty sanctifies that just flip the game around. They will probably still lose. They still feel weak overall, but at least their gameplay is still fun. But the cats, they are too slow, too clumsy, too predictable that they don't have any moments of brilliance or joy left in them. They feel almost tired, and it's almost a painful experience to see your supply lines collapse, to see the slots on the board fill up, and to be slowly snuffed out of any playmaking. Instead, you just become a speed bump in the game plan of other players. I think a lot of people might find this critique a bit off-putting because people generally start playing with the cats and it feels good. It feels good understanding root and I was there too. Just last time I made this tier list, I thought there are the cool cats, but now I see them as tired and stale and it's not the simplicity of their play style, but the fragility of their system that cripples them. So yeah, last time I critiqued the game design of the Vega Bond, but since now they're dead to me, I think the next worst designed faction is the cats, and the moles are closely behind them, but for completely opposite reasons. I think if there was going to be another redo of a faction, I'd probably do the cats, just make them a little bit stronger,
but still have that board presence. I think you would need to reassess their power curve, and instead of having all this influence at the start, maybe have it ramp up a bit more. Anyways, let's move on. Let's take a look at the new factions. Starting off with the naves. I'm going to put them smack dab in the middle of all the factions. They are a very decent faction to play as and to play against, and their strength is perfectly reasonable. I think they're a huge step up from the Veabond in terms of design. The power level went down, the interaction went way up, and they finally provide points for players engaging with them. This is all good. They aren't great. They aren't fantastic, but I am thankful for their existence purely as the executioners of the Veabond. Next up is the Twilight Council. I really, really like the Bats.
I think they have the details that make a faction sing. Their approach to controlling clearings and their unique interactions with other factions really does elevate them to the top of the insurgent factions for me. I find their whole puzzle of playing cards and using them twice is just ultra satisfying and they feel good in all aspects. And lastly, the Lily Pad Diaspora. I can't sing enough praise for these frogs and toads simply because they are the best faction in such a long time. I think that special sauce is really about those Enclave tokens. Having the board shift and alter throughout a game and with the control of the players really adds in that extra texture that pushes them into the S tier. The puzzle of knowing when to provoke versus settling is super satisfying to play with and they have that feeling of easy to play hard to master that mimics other S tiers. So yeah, fantastic faction.
Okay, phew. There we have it. Updated tiers. Let me know how I got things wrong in the comments. I think because Routt is such a meta-pecific game, who you play with will dramatically change how you see these factions. And so, yeah, let me know. I'm sure many of you will disagree with me on these cat takes. Anyways, what are my thoughts on the Homeland expansion and Root overall? I think Root is in that weird situation where I'm perfectly content with it, but it's never going to end. We have six official maps, three decks, 13 factions, tons of hierlings and landmarks and automated factions, and an endless supply of fan content, and I'm happy with it. But is it at its limit? I don't think so. The wastand of Root is functionally endlessly expandable. I think Root is the kind of game that can absorb an endless amount of material into the clay of the fundamental game.
Like really, a game of Root is really just a map, a deck, and a bunch of factions. You can add whatever spice you're in the mood for, for sure, but more material doesn't necessarily need to complicate the game. You can make another 12 factions or remix the current factions and keep making Root stuff for another decade. And this is to say that Root is the kind of game that can really engulf a certain person, someone who loves conflict, asymmetry, and the cute fuzzy animal aesthetic. It is in many ways the perfect game for a specific individual. On the other hand, I don't think Root is the perfect game for me as an individual with independent feelings and thoughts. I think the core of Root when you remove the factions and you remove the art, the actual rules of movement, of combat, of clearings, it starts to reveal itself more as a foundation that was imperfect. I think the perfect example of this is the whole ruins mechanic. With the removal of the Vega bond, there's now only one faction that directly engages with them. It kind of just feels like it was forgotten as the game evolved in a very strange way.
Even with all the factions, with all the flavors that go into the hunter soup that is root, there is an itch that I want something a bit more substantial. It's a game that's truly all about the factions I play. So sometimes it feels like the core is purely a functional scaffolding muted of any flavor. And this is the insane part. For the first hundred or so games of Root, I was enamored by this. I loved this whole process. I love the idea of four people playing four different games, but still having to interact with one another. But now, I see Root kind of like listening to my favorite song remixed 20 different ways. I still appreciate it, but the chord progression and the rhythm are unmistakable, and even with a new remix, it can feel a bit stale. I guess what I'm saying is that Routt is both endlessly upgradeable. You can make another 10 expansions and find new ways to engage with it. But the soup stock that you toss all that meat into is starting to become more and more prominent with each playthrough. And that stock isn't my favorite. I think that's why I enjoyed the frog so much in this expansion. It felt like it added something a bit spicier than the other factions into the soup. It was kind of pushing my boundaries in a way that still felt like Root, but more dynamic to play. And look, I've played well over a 100 games of Root. I'm not a pro by any means, but I mean, if you play over a hundred times a game, it still means I definitely enjoyed it. I still like Root. I still want to play it, and I want to play the new content with new people. So, yeah, I think Homelands is a great addition. It adds everything on my
wish list for Root, but it's revealing to me that maybe the core of Root isn't able to hold my attention for much longer. Route is at its best that it's ever been, but once you tinker around with each of the new factions, each play is starting to feel a little bit less enticing than the last. Finally, I would be remiss not to mention a lot of the design team that made Root has left letter for a new company. And I don't know what that means for the future of Route. I think there's going to be a lot left and I will probably buy it. But I'm happy if Homeland, if this was the end of Route. It added the two best maps I could want. It added two fantastic factions and a replacement for my most hated one. The new deck is super fun and I can play two games simultaneously. Honestly, what more could I want? Root is a great game. Homeland is the best expansion yet. And yet, I can feel the game's core formula becoming more and more prominent, and it's starting to show signs of age that aren't being fully addressed. And I think that's how I feel about Root in 2026. I guess that's it. As always, thank you so much for watching and bye.