Skip to main content
Loading video...

Red Cathedral Contractors Review

Transcript 13:41

today we're reviewing the red cathedral expansion contractors i'm mark maya and this is board game coffee contractors is an expansion to the one to four player game red cathedral now i've already reviewed the red cathedral base game and spoilers i liked it but hey don't take my word for it just click here and take my word for it anyway in this video i'm just gonna focus on the new things that contractors brings to the table okay so first off one of my gripes about the original game was that there wasn't enough variety specifically when it came to the different guilds well that issue has been addressed and i couldn't be happier with the results well i could but we'll get to that in just a bit in the original game there were four guilds five if you include the promo thieves guild and each of those guilds had three cards to choose from but the variance between them got rather saney but now devyer has added 10 new guilds with three cards each bringing us to a total of 30 cards that offer a greater variety of abilities than the original guilds and i dig it man

this is fantastic you could have just packed these in a neat little box called the expansion the red cathedral guilds and i would have been happy it would have easily been one of those must-have expansions like prelude is to terraforming mars when i first saw all these guild cards i was like wow think of all the possible combinations but there's not as many opportunities for combo variations as you might think because well here's the rub the rule book states that to play with these new guilds you must continue to use the merchant craftsman and teamster guilds from the base game and only swap out the clergy but all the all the new stuff now i'm sure there's a reason for this decision maybe adding four new guilds all at once would introduce some game breaking behavior that would ruin the experience i don't know and i'll probably never know and why because i'm a stickler for the rules and if the rules don't say that i can fill the market with all new guilds then i won't and i didn't and that makes me a little sad because i want to play with all these guilds but i would have to play the game 30 times to experience all the things that these cards can do and i'm gonna take it right now as a board game media professional that has to play a lot of board games

that ain't gonna happen what i wanna do is mix and match the gills get crazy with the combos play god if you will maybe i'll have the jewelers next to the wholesalers they hate each other and then just for kicks maybe the archivists will show up acting all superior with their personal stack of contract cards looking down on the lesser deckless guilds and lawyers don't even get me started on the lawyers my cousin sally told me that uncle jim's college roommate saw a lawyer swapping resources with the head of the jewelers killed if you know what i mean they didn't they did no yep but as fun as it sounds to play marketplace matchmaker i'll never do it because as i said it's not the rules ipso facto we have all these great guild card mechanics stuck in this bottleneck situation like drinking a really thick milkshake through a skinny little straw because while it's still good i want more of it faster now you need to understand that the reason i'm disappointed is because i really like the new guild cards and if i didn't i doubt i would care as much as i do the new guilds add a bunch of new

abilities some of which even add new components like the archivist who has a deck of contract cards that act like separate little goals for you to achieve and earn more points or the jewelers that introduce diamonds that can be used as a wild resource or the brick makers with their reinforcement tiles that you can use for a bunch of different stuff and the other guilds do things that are just as interesting for the most part so in short the guilds add great content but are locked behind a drip feed system that slows down my enjoyment of that content i mean you could just home rule it sure that might break everything but maybe that won't matter but you know what that's enough about guilds let's move on another thing contractors introduces is it contractors not yet we're getting there is this black market die that works like a white die meaning anyone can pay to move it further when performing a market action on their check it even has its own slot in your workshop where's that i swear it was right here oh right you're also getting a workshop upgrade there it is now as you can tell by this stabby pointy shape normal tiles don't really fit in here that's where these come in but let's not get ahead of ourselves you'll also notice that a new basic

action and new optional action have been added to your arsenal of possible actions that can be done during your turn is this the contractor part almost the new optional action allows players to spend a prestige point to earn themselves a permit which they can hold up to six here and the permits are for the contractors yes brit the permits are for the contractors nailed it the actual contractor portion of the contractor's expansion adds a lot i mean you get these wooden little contractors that you can send out to recruit specialists which are represented by these pointy little pieces of cardboard and you got these big old tiles that sit above each tower that indicate which city will score you big to accommodate for the new stuff you can do the contractor's expansion has increased the number of available actions you have to choose from on your turn now instead of choosing one of three actions to take you get to choose from four possible actions now as a basic action you can send a contractor to moscow or one of its surrounding cities assuming they aren't closed for the day the cost to send a contractor to one of these cities is paid in permits equal to the number of contractors already there plus yours so in this case it would cost you three permits to send your little wooden person to moscow now when i was first reading how this map works i couldn't help but be reminded about

that little map that was printed on the board of the viticulture expansion both act as a place to send your workers for a temporary boost with the potential of a bump in your score based on their placement and in that regard this has a lot in common with that now although i don't have a preference of one system over the other i do think that the larger red cathedral application of this side map had a greater impact on the outcome of the game but not at first and that's only because we weren't using it to its full potential we were stuck in our old ways allow me to explain you see in the base game your focus was build the cathedral and have more presence on it than the other guy and it kind of still is but this time around your focus is split between sending contractors to this new map and completing portions of the cathedral with the market still playing its part to support both i mean you don't have to split your focus but if you play it right there is some huge point earning potential here just waiting to be taken advantage of before when you finished a tower nothing really happened it was just another completed portion to flip now when a tower of the cathedral is complete you'll take this little marker and place it x-side up on the matching city

then each player in that city counts up their contractor meeples and multiplies it by the number of banners that they have on the tower that was just completed and earn that much in prestige which are the bigger point values indicated by this golden pheasant i mean four contractors times four banners is 16 prestige that's huge and what's huge er is that it triggers for all players with contractors in that city regardless of who built the last bit of the tower so if you're not playing the contractor to city game you might find yourself left behind in the scoring department or not we'll circle back to that in just a little bit other than scoring a boatload of points sending contractors into cities also allows you to take one of these two cardboard ninja stars adjacent to that city unless it's moscow in which case you can take whichever ninja star you like these cardboard tokens represent specialists and for the low low cost of two rubles you can place your specialist in the black dye slot of your workshop now these spiky specialist tiles work pretty much like your run-of-the-mill non-spiky variety as in when you move the black die during the market phase you get to trigger the ability depicted but unlike their square cousins these tiles only trigger once then are taken off the board and stored tool side up

and if you keep doing that and collect yourself a set of different tools you score based on the number of different tools you have in that set which is indicated here so yeah like i said earlier there's a lot of scoring potential tied to this new map but here's the thing if you're playing with let's say a group of three people and one of those people let's call them chris forgoes this entire side of the table and is stuck in that base game mentality of just build the cathedral and screw everything else he could very well pick up the whole expansion experience for everyone at the table because you see the end condition of the game hasn't changed it's still triggered when a single player builds six parts of the cathedral so if one person is racing to the finish on the cathedral and you're over here dilling around on this new map then you're gonna miss out on the cathedral portion which still drives the majority of the endgame score so in response you and everyone else at the table turn your focus on the tower as well because how much is it going to suck if one player finishes all their cathedral bits and you spend all your time and resources over here on the map on a strategy that isn't going to pan out because chris is a dick and forced the end of the game while everyone else was

still trying to have a good time i'm sorry oh that's not cool no no i agree chris the dick anyway what i'm trying to say is that in my experience if one person presses for a quick into the game by just focusing on the cathedral it tends to draw everyone else's focus in the same direction pulling everyone away from the reason they came to suspension in the first place and i don't know how to deal with that i mean i really enjoy red cathedral and i like this expansion i would even go as far to say that if you already own red cathedral and like it you should get this because it's good but it does come with its own set of frustrations is it possible i was playing something wrong maybe maybe not but even with its faults i still really like playing contractors and i think you will too thanks for joining us if you like this video and you want to see more subscribe to our channel it's the best way to keep up to date with everything we do here at boy game coffee but if you want to see more right now we got plenty of videos to choose from and if that's not enough follow us on instagram facebook and twitter i'm mark maya and this is board game coffee and remember have fun keep gaming be social see you next week

Progress saved