Scythe Board Game Review - Stonemaiergames
Transcript
it's big it has mechs and it has stunning artwork but is it any good let's review it this is the review for the game site the good and bad about it by the end of this review you will know if this game is for you we have 7 burning questions to answer about this game but before we do that janice what is this game all about scythe is a competitive economic strategy game where players control nations in an alternate history where right after world war one there are mechs players have workers and mechs and they build structures and they're trying to gain points from all these things and by the end of the game who has the most victory points wins the game in your turn you use this pawn to place it on one of the four actions available to you and the interesting thing is if you did one of these actions in your previous turn you can do it again on this turn each of them have two parts one part is for example producing resources and it's more connected to where you are at the map and the other thing is more upgrading your faction and getting better at you know the game you either do the top action the bottom action or both or none those are your options each time so these actions help you upgrade your systems build new facilities on the map build max these are some things right there or just upgrade something so you are more efficient in your future turns and the game ends when one player has placed six stars on the board and you play stars by achieving different things for example having eight workers or four mechs and so on and so forth
we're gonna talk a lot more about this game in this video but now it's time to go to the questions and the first question is who would you buy it for three two one hello civilized diplomats and you have i have your gamers all right let's go with your very fun euro let's go it's for euro gamers i mean it's for people who like economic games with almost no conflict and you're gonna go whoa there are mechs in here how is there no conflict we'll talk about that later in this game i really enjoyed the diplomacy part just talking about with other players you're not gonna go there right please no and yes as you said there's not a lot of conflict that's why civilized it seems like maybe it could be a war game it's not at all though it depends on players i've heard that some players don't talk at all in this game in my gaming group we really enjoyed talking apart to be sneaky and taking some territories or some resources away from others next question what is the best player count three two one i added two to five and i thought it's probably good with any amount but i thought since i'm looking for that conflict and with just two there's less chance to have that like you said diplomacy so and with three to five there's just more ways of you know communicating with other people yeah with five probably the games are going to be longer even though you just have to pick one action and do that there's still a lot of calculations involved in that okay do i pick this one will i be
able to build this with five people it might take a bit longer i agree that two player game is pretty good it's fine but the problem was that the board is so big and if each of you start from like different sides there's so many encounters that you can get there's no problems with getting any resources fighting for regions and spaces is missing but it's uh fine i would play it with two it's not that big of a deal but i thought that four is the best amount because yes cold war element is much more powerful when you have more players it's really brilliant with four and that's what it's kind of meant to be before we jump to the next question there's something you need to do and that is subscribing to our channel and liking this video we would really appreciate it what's the best alternative i'm warning you i'm gonna cheat a bit but you can be mad all right no promises but okay three two one let's go got it cut cut this is a board game show funny thing there is a board game warcraft 3. without you knowing that is a good alternative this was one of my childhood classics and it's not a board game it's like well i guess it is a board game now but i played it as a computer game and sight really brought the same emotions to me it's something similar you start from one spot being like a small faction there and trying to upgrade to get more control over your area and when everybody else this brings me back to so many memories if somebody has played this as well and was thinking hey what this game could look like as a board game then you know this could be
it minus the fighting minus building a lot of units and trying to destroy other people's villages minus that right probably everyone at this point or most everyone has played katan at least once and if you haven't you should give it a go it is a classic if you add cities and knights it improves the game massively for me it has barbarians attacking you can develop your cities way more so there's a lot of more options and the game obviously is longer and heavier this way but it also feels like similar here where you're just you know economically growing and there's some area control and you probably say wait wait wait katan is a very simple light game yes but add in cities and knights and not anymore another thing we need to talk about is the pricing of this game and it is 90 is the suggested retail price and i'd say well deserved well worth it and a good price for the game i would say it's cheap for what you get inside there's so much stuff all of these little pieces the map is huge max and everything it's a really good price for this game really good price yeah i agree next question what is the worst thing about it might get samey there's not a lot of things that change from game to game the first few times you're gonna play this game you're gonna be super excited it's interesting it's different it's really really fun but then after i don't know five times you actually will have played with all of the factions probably as well as these player boards they are different so you can mix up the combinations but other than that a lot
of the game is the same all the time i'm not sure how long can you go without buying the expansions this game costs 90 euros as we talked before and then expansions will cost a bit more so it might get pretty expensive but now sit back relax and let's start trashing this game for reals i had expectations of this being one of the first euros where i would really feel the theme and then there's mechs that you can get to fight other players and there's a whole deck of events that i felt oh my gosh this is going to be like eldritch horror but in a euro game world this is going to be amazing which it was not first thing is the max they're pretty cool miniatures all the factions have different variants of them and that's it they have no special things those mechs and the conflict with those mechs is gonna happen what once twice per game maximum sometimes maybe no times where where's the there's no it's next thing is the event cards essentially it's the same three things you can pay nothing and get a little bit you can pay a little bit of something and get a bit more or something or you can pay a lot of something and get way more or something and it's essentially the same three things on all event cards sure there's a little bit of theme there at least they try to put it in but they're not thematic and i felt oh man i wanted i wanted theme i wanted events that you know bring out the theme and there's none of that and obviously you say hey honest what were you thinking
it's a euro game what what are you heading what did you expect and i said well that's what i expected i expected thematic you know fighting different events that's what expected and there's none of that and it might be just me most likely it is just me right it comes down to what are you expecting from this game visually it might look like it's heavier it might look like it will involve a lot more uniqueness but it is awesome if you understand what it is next question what is the best thing about this game three two one go it's a simple game in disguise grand scale inaccessible way it seems this massive thing with like fighting in events and can take hours when in fact it is not that complex of a game gives you the feel of playing this big massive fighting game in a simple way in a short amount of time explaining the rules might take a few minutes because there's some intricacies but overall after the first round everybody will understand how to play it you just have to move this pawn do the things that's written there and that's it the things you mentioned that the worst things i think if there would be tons of mechs and powers and stuff like that it would be too complicated for this game it looks great i mean the artwork the game was created because the author saw the artwork and he thought i need to create a game around this artwork that board is amazing the pieces are amazing the looks of it is amazing next question when would you play it
with cold beverages oh and i'm played with only with fenris and uh fenris is not a friend of mine or ours fenders is an expansion for this game fenris fixes my problems with this game it adds theme it adds a little bit more conflict no spoilers because it is like a legacy type of expansion where you play a game and then you unlock more stuff but it's easily resettable you can put everything back in the boxes and play next time again and obviously the moment of excitement is going to be gone i'd play it only with the rise of fenris which addresses the i wouldn't say problems with this game for me but the disappointments because it's a simple game but it takes a lot of time to play it it's 115 minutes here i think but it's a lot more than that i think where was this time how long have you played yeah 115 minutes yep that's very specific i would love to play this game when you get comfortable you have a good time you have a lot of time to play it you get some cold beverages because it also helps with the conversations that you have which i really enjoyed about this game you can play it of course a lot more serious and have more strategies but you can also play it more more calm down and just enjoy your time and now the final rating hangover okay or is it i have it fantastic or a must-have for five games it comes back to where
you said it's gonna get samey right yeah absolutely i think if you enjoy euro games if you would like everything that we previously mentioned how this game goes with the diplomacy and all that then i think you must play this you must have this but be warned that yeah after five games it might get samey and as jans mentioned you have to have the expansion to make it more interesting it was absolutely must-have for me and my five games and i think it's still must-have for me and i'm actually looking towards buying maybe the expansion as well because you sold it to me if you watch this review you know now what to expect from this game and if what you can expect from this game is something you enjoy then it's a must-have for you as well for me it is okay as a vanilla game but if you add defenders i think and i was thinking if it takes me up to fantastic or really good but i think it does take me up to fantastic fantasy just adds ton of stuff there's actually a story now and there's some mystery to what's happening there so it takes me up to a fantastic my biggest problem was just okay because i had such high expectations just lower expectations and you'll probably love this game so now you know if this game is for you and if you enjoyed this type of reviews then be sure to subscribe like and share and i'll do all the good stuff that will help us a lot and thank you for watching and see you next time
you