Boonlake Review: So Themeless We Couldn't Think of a Snappy Subtitle
Transcript
hi everyone tally and farrell here from buddhavit and welcome to our review of boone lake the latest complex euro by alexander fister that includes both cows and boats move over great western trail and maracaibo in boone lake you'll be exploring settling and modernizing the beautiful abandoned area of boone lake now this game has many classic euro troops and even alexander phista tropes but it does feel unique to any of his other games that we've played now it comes with a snappy rundle system and cloud deployment so you can be sure there's a lot here that'll keep you engaged but there's also a few rough edges that make the game a little more complex harder to teach harder to learn than it needs to be so where does it fall in our collection let's find out in boone lake on your turn you'll take one of these action tiles and you'll work through it from left to right the first action is usually going to be to play a card or discard a card then there'll be a private action that only you can do then a public action that everyone around the table can do after you've completed your tile you'll move your boat up to as many spaces as
it says from where you took the tile pop it back push it up and it is then the next player's turn now boom lake is quite a linear game with the main point kind of being to clear your player board of all of these pieces and play a lot of cards and how you go about this is you'll discover the area around blue lake by laying tiles down and getting a little reward when you do so once you have some land discovered you can send inhabitants then these can be upgraded to little houses and then houses can be upgraded to settlements and like this you start clearing your board the one thing i don't get is that every inhabitant is represented by a great western trail cowboy meeple so i don't really get how the populations are booming but i like to think that they reproduce by mitosis and that's how they can build settlements so damn fast
you can also place cows on the main board on special pasture tiles which will provide you with vp if they're placed next to settlements aside from this you're going to be playing a lot of cards to get bonuses move up tracks and score vp as you move down the river there'll be four interim scorings that are triggered and each time you'll get coins and vp depending on where you are on the tracks and what you've taken off your player board then after the fourth entry in scoring there'll be a final scoring of a few extra bits such as cards that you've played throughout the game that might have end game scoring and then the most vp wins so boone lake yeah it's good it's all right it's honestly a bit of a tough one to review because it's such a middle-of-the-road generic euro nothing here is new or exciting but there are no serious flaws either what we will say is it sits in a strange place in terms of its design and we're not quite sure who it's for it's a fairly complex game with quite a few tricky to grasp aspects so you think it would appeal to people who like helio games however problem is i think people who play heavier games and heavier euros that have all these branching routes and different paths to victory they're going to find this quite one-directional and too narrow because you do kind of have to go through the same route every time you play and i think eventually they'll get a little bit repetitive for them on the other hand this narrowness would make it great for people looking to maybe step up their complexity in gaming
but there's a lot of weird kind of finicky concepts at the edge of this game and there's a lot of symbology that is sure to throw off that type of player now what we mean by one direction is that the point in every game really is to clear your player board play as many cards as you can and score the scoring tiles this is really the only route to go and at the end of the game everyone else is also going to be in the same position plus or minus a few played cards and buildings off the board every game you and everyone else is going to be placing tiles on the board putting ranches on those tiles replacing the ranches with buildings and then replacing those buildings with settlement and for us it's had two effects the first is that it's rather nebulous to try and figure out at the end of the game why you came dead last or maybe one by half of the board because you did the same things as everyone else and the second is that it makes every game feel kind of similar and looping back to what we termed finicky concepts i think there's one that we wanted to highlight because there are just some strange choices at play here in terms of the design and the main one are these scoring tiles because players picked them at the beginning of the game and they kind of had two halves where the top half acts like a card that you can buy instead of buying a card and you pay money and resources and it gives you goods and vp and this bottom half is this objective that you have to meet at an interim scoring but what objective you have to meet changes with each interim scoring and there's
different ones and you have different tokens but you can only use them in specific interim scorings and it's generally quite a tough concept to get your head around and even tougher concept to explain to other people and the problem is it feels quite tacked on and arbitrary it doesn't streamline into the game at all it takes up a lot of time doing it and explaining it and the vp you get if you do it or don't or lose if you don't do it is so minor that it has no real effect on the game and what makes it worse is that some of these objectives are really varied between the tiles so some like have three settlements out by the end of the game that's something that almost everybody will have done without trying because it's kind of the point of the game and the direction you're pushed whereas another one that in end of the game it wants you to spend 25 coins that is a lot of money that could be used better elsewhere another thing that we found strange is the inclusion of resources that you both spend when you use them you put them back in the supply and resources that just kind of exist in the other and act as a prerequisite to playing something rather than something you spend what we mean is our inhabitants phases of money when you use them you put them back in the supply but then you have four resources over here that are used to play cards and these
are not physical resources they can only kind of exist on your board and you never spend them you just have them and if you have them you could play a card and it kind of makes the game a little more confusing to have both these because they're at odds with each other and we've recently been playing a lot of games with a friend's new partner and she's new to the hobby but she is incredibly astute at picking up new board games and she's also a really good sounding board for what concepts are really tricky to get across or the stumbling blocks in the game and she really liked boom link but the biggest issue she had in the entire game was the fact that you had this going on over here then you also had coins you spend and she couldn't get why when she was playing a card she was spending these but not spending these or what was going on with the boats moving around and it just kind of further said to us that it is a little bit of tooth to have both of these concepts in one game when one or the other would have done we think overall it doesn't really help that the theme in boone lake is rather loose because it makes connecting all of these niggly elements more difficult because there's no strong theme to understand why you might be doing something also the fun mechanics kind of lose their lustre due to the drabness of it all this is definitely the kind of game where the theme comes secondary to the mechanics and by having a stronger theme it would really improve the whole game i mean the game is called boone lake but
where is the lake on the map shouldn't it be called boone river since you spent the entire game traveling down the river but it is important to note for every weird element there's another one that is excellently designed in boone lake the action tile system immediately springs to mind because not only does it provide a wonderful rundle system it also smartly keeps players engaged at all times not providing investment in other players turns particularly when they're not short and sharp can be a real killer in a game but here by having the actions include another action that can be done by everyone it keeps players invested in which tile each player is picking and then thinking about what they can then do with that importantly it never feels like it's not your turn because often these actions allow you to do the main actions and the actions are very cleverly done each one is simple to grasp yet when connected to the wider game they really open up your decisions and give you difficult dilemmas on how to spend your limited resources furthermore because there's only seven action tiles and they're part of a rondelle system and you're always watching what other players are doing alexander fisto has again does what he does best which is aiding the understanding of a game through subtle repetition within a few turns all new players will have seen all the actions multiple times and because there are four interim scorings they will very quickly grasp what they need to do to generate victory
points and speaking of one of our favorite aspects of boone lake is the use of victory points as a sort of pseudo currency because throughout the game you're going to have opportunities to spend them in exchange for something else be it six coins when you build or perhaps you'll be able to get a settlement out for one inhabitant less and as tally says you've got to speculate to accumulate so it gives the game this real crunchy and risky aspect but it also provides interesting gameplay experiences and strategies in one game we had a player who must have spent at least 40 victory points throughout the game spent the entire game about half the board away from us and everyone else in victory points and while they didn't win they did come quite close and they were mainly spending these victory points as a way to get settlements out in the same area and this was allowing them to score a lot of points from cows and i find that interesting because while they might have got that strategy a tiny bit flawed they did generate more victory points than anyone else in the entire game obviously i just find that quite interesting and it's just a mechanism i really enjoy we also find the levers which for some reason farrell cannot stop calling levees worth discussing on the right hand side of your board you have a bunch of spaces for which you can buy levers which will provide you with alternate actions or bonuses when you're
doing other actions these are a really nice addition because by giving you these little boosts they might allow you to do something that you wouldn't have otherwise been able to do and the more you buy the more end game vp you get so there's certainly incentive to buy them boone lake is for two to four players but what player count you prefer at will depend on how you like your euros because the size of the board doesn't change at two players the board is much more open and there's much less pressure to be able to do what you want because really you can do it all and get most of your production upgraded to level two the more players you add the tighter and trickier it becomes the board seems to shrink there's a race to put the tiles on the spaces on the board that give you the upgraded production you might not be able to take the action tile that you want or the space on the river that you were after in particular the cows scoring next to settlement mechanism gets much more spicy personally we find it more interesting to play at three to four players but it will really depend on how tight you like your gameplay so final thoughts boone lake is a fairly good game it has a lot to like some crunchy decisions to be made and is excellent at keeping players engaged at all times however it has some elements which are overly complex without giving much back in return it also sits in this weird space where a lot of the game is quite fiddly and it's on rails more or less every game so the people who are most likely to be interested in it are also the people who are most likely to
find it repetitive after multiple plays particularly when compared with other more dynamic games and the bottom line is that if you're interested in this game if you're thinking about getting it and you do get it you're gonna have a good time it's a good game just i think the biggest problem for us is that hello sven is that we wouldn't recommend it over other games in our collection that occupy similar space i think the best way we can put it is that if this was one of the first euros you'd played or one of the first heavier euros you'd played you'd probably be blown away with it and have a great time but if like us you've played a lot of euros everything here is what you've seen before and because the theme isn't really there there's nothing to grab onto to kind of keep you coming back to it i think yeah but that was our review of boone lake if you have any questions feel free to ask us and if you haven't subscribed it would mean a lot to us if you subscribe because the dogs are writing because they want subs and thank you for watching most of all and see you next time bye