Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shackleton Base - Board Game Review - Is The Moon That Exciting?

Transcript 34:39

the moon Tes

sing hi I'm Luke ector and this is the broken meele a show where I devote my time to raving and ranting about board games but Beauty more the ranting part and the award for the most buzzed about Game of this year goes to Shackleton base Jesus Christ This one is constantly talked about I am seeing review scores of like 4.5 out of fives I've seen nine out of 10 10 out of 10 everybody is going absolutely nuts crazy about this game now when I actually tried to play aeson I couldn't I stood at a table waiting for a demo for 45 minutes only to then be told after the game finished that it was a bookable system and yet they didn't make it clear that it was a bookable system slightly miffed by that but oh well it just meant I had to be patient to get the game when it released on retail back in like November time so this is not a review copy this is me going out of my way to grab this because I just had to find out what was going on with this designed by fabiio Lano and Nestor mangon I have no idea if I pronounced those correctly but basically these two designers have made made a bit of a name themselves with midweight Euro games they've got a bit of a popularity going with them can't say I followed too many of their previous games but there are some that I've come across and gone hm this is pretty good but this one is essentially a midweight Euro where you're placing astronauts on the moon to do different actions but its main sort of selling point is the idea that you've got these corporations where you mix in three out of I think seven or eight different potentials into the game and

they change up the way that you will try and score points you know you have to focus on all fre to some extent you know you might be able to ignore one and focus on just two but the idea is is that these will change up the way the game system flows now it's a tool order to do something like that that is not an easy thing to do in a game but I just had to jump into this and every time I looked at this at s on the table when people were playing it two things kind of stuck out to me one it looks pretty bland like not a particular looker on the table we'll get onto that later but also I just couldn't quite tell where things were going for what reason like the the graphic design was done in such a way that I couldn't see how things were flowing together it just looked a bit confusing to me at first but you know got to dive in so I dived in completely blind as to how it played or anything like that and just thought let's find out the truth let's find out if this is really as amazing as people are saying or whether this is another one of those titles where the buzz is high but the result is not quite there everything is proceeding as I have foreseen in chum Bas your goal is obviously to get the most victory points of course and to do this you need to satisfy the needs of three corporations there are seven in the game and three will get picked out at random each one has their own rules reference sheet each one has their own components each one has their own kind of mini game mechanic that you satisfy in order to score points each one can also have cards that are associated with it that give you little special bonuses and endgame scoring opportunities but the main premise is the use of these astronauts

so you have three different colors you got blue yellow and red each one kind of gives you some other sort of different bonus or some different ability to trigger in the first part of each round you have a shuttle phase where players will choose and draft from these shuttles these give you some starting little resources they give you a turn order sequence but also dictate Which astronauts you're going to get for the rounds or if I pick this one for example I get this collection of astronauts and these are my six actions for the turn you only get 18 actions in the game it's quite tight in that respect and then during the main phase you are essentially placing them primarily on this command track down here to trigger specific actions like building bases on the moon like buying particular project cards for those free corporations I mentioned or triggering what is called kind of like a an a corporation action which each of the different boards has their own specific Corporation action but it also reforms around this reputation track where the higher you are the more bonuses you can get that's kind of like the main thing you'll do you are able to switch up your astronauts for different ones via the lunar Gateway so you can kind of exchange one for a different color and get some money if you're really strapped for kind of really need a red one right now there's a red one there I don't have a red one here fine I'll do an exchange quite useful but then also you can place your astronauts around the side of the moon and Trigger the line in which to get different bonuses so you can get money you can get Corporation actions you can trigger the different tokens that are on the board but this is done by way of an area majority system so you might build a base say in this region

here it's worth three I might build another one here it's worth to and the idea is is that when you trigger a particular row you look at the sections where you've got a building and it will give you the reward based on that however if other players have majority in certain sections and you're not present you may have to give them money or pay more money in order to actually trigger that entire line so there is a pseudo area majority feel to this game but it's not quite the same as like oh I've blocked you out of an action it's just you might make the action a little bit more expensive by being there the astronauts as I said play a key part in actions you do if I use yellow on the Command action then this allows me to build a lot of structures on my board and these structures have different during the game and endgame rewards depending on which I build if I build some of my little twers hubs here and then slot some astronauts of the right colors in them they give me abilities and like discounts throughout the game but then if I use the freehub for example and put them out and Slot different astronauts in them I can get like instant money but also some endgame scoring and build your big Hub and you really want to get your reputation up because that can score you Mega points if you build your giant Hub it's kind of like how the board in Terror mystica Works where you can build different levels of buildings and it's like do I want to build a big Hub or do I leave it till later now the idea with the red ones is that they allow you to get different cards so as I mentioned these different Corps they've got their own components but they've also got their own cards their own little project cards unique to that Corporation each one has a cost and requirement usually comprising enough money and energy which is another resource you're going to manage but these give you special

bonuses special endgame scoring opportunities or in the case of emus Taurus here give you a way to slot these astronauts onto the cards in order to score points and get bonuses it's quite a Nifty little mechanic and then finally you got the blue kind of utilitarian astronaut I like to call them these ones go on here and they mainly generate Corporation actions what those actions are Depends entirely on which corporations you're using I mean if I use it with say the selenium research one I can pay certain resources I've got during the game and get a tile that gives me some extra bonus and points okay cool but then if you use it with arous tours and you get to collect these astronauts and you get to slot them onto cards it entirely depends on what the Corp does alternatively you can simply just gain bonuses from the reputation track which is a sort of high risk but high cost thing you know it gives well no sorry High reward high cost it can get a lot of B you can get a lot of bonuses from this track and get a lot of nice stuff and points but when you get to the end of the round you have to pay maintenance costs for everything you've built and everything on the reputation track and this can add up to quite a lot of money if you're not careful after the astronauts being placed you have as I said the maintenance phase where you will pay costs based on where you on a reputation track and what you've built you'll also collect your income from various buildings and cars that you have made so anything with the universal hand of giving as I call it for the uh Universal Euro icon gives you income but then also you get to retrieve astronauts on the board and potentially place them in the slots on your board that you've opened up in order to get those discounts or bonuses as I mentioned you then rinse and repeat this for another

two rounds do 18 actions throughout the whole game six astronauts in each round and of course once you get to the end after you've total up the end game scoring points what do you think so we'll start with the way that this game is packaged now I do not think this game is a looker I would say from an artwork perspective this is a very Bland looking game it is one big colar of gray with some icons dotted around not a lot of color in fact the main use of color is the astronauts other than that you don't have a huge amount of it and n it's not really going to turn heads when somebody passes by that being said as a storage solution top marks this is really cool we just make boxes here you know yes the production quality is a little bit on the cheap side you know these these astronauts are probably the best component in the game but everything else is kind of standard cardboard not particularly interesting even these player boards are these foldable ones so they're kind of like the fake fitable ones but you don't actually stick them down they don't provide any adhesive for you to stick the board down so you just basically have this loose thing that you like just leave it as it is that's kind of weird I mean I I guess I don't need it to be stuck down but it is another way of cutting costs but you do get a lot of other stuff in here I mean all the corporations have got their own player board so each of these has got their own sort of detailed layout for how they work you've got reference aids for each of the corporations themselves but Kudos has to be given to this Tuck boox System this is how I want more games to start being packaged you know um Tim Eiser

from weird City Games makes a big deal of this in a lot of his games well here it works just the same because it makes setup easier now I'm not going to say that well we'll get on to setup a bit later but the you know having a box for all your astronauts in it having a box for all your shuttle stuff in it you know all these primary components are well and good but the corporations are nicely in their own little box so if I want to select free at random all I got to do is just sort of you know without looking just pick three out of the tuck boxes so this time I'm going to do one two free here we go Skywatch selenium research and Evergreen Farms all the components are in here I can then put the rest in the box and ignore them it's just a very nice neat clean system a cookie no it's not a cookie not a cookie M and while we're on the subject of these corpse this does add a nice amount of replay value to the game now don't get me wrong these corporations do not fundamentally change the game you know the core of the game with placing the astronauts using the the area majority row system for income and the corporation actions and such You Know That Remains the Same no matter what these corporations do not suddenly change the game from being a resource management game to a deck building game to a bag building game like such it's not like right Evergreen Farms is area majority and selenium research is bag building and sky watch is deck building that's not how it works they're just subtle little differences mainly again revolved around Resource Management it's just changing kind of what the resource is and what it does when you get it now even with as side that still adds a

decent amount of replay value because you will have some different games from time to time you know based on which ones you pick but just don't get into this idea that you know the game is going to be fundamentally different or you're going to have like memorable experiences or like oh yeah do you remember that game where I used space robotics Evergreen and selenium you remember that weird combination of what that did no it's not quite as impactful as that it's just little subtle changes that you know do add up and make for you know yeah if you didn't have these Corps this game would be a pretty Bare Bones Affair and not have much to sell itself for these really do kind of make the game you know this is Shackleton base it is all about these Corps now they do range in difficulty you know they have reference aids to help you and so you've got like you know details for all the cards on them you've got the rules for setup and solo integ and stuff like that and it's like you know these are cool I'm glad that they did this although the complexity rating does need to be bear in mind because they give you free to use for the first game like the complexity ones Skywatch and to Mar's her are complexity three and four and woo um yeah you're going to need to be careful with some of these some of these are very easy to integrate some of these are a little bit more on a fiddly side to the extent where when you look at how much you're going to play these modules you're probably going to play three or four of these modules 90% of the time and then the rest once in a blue moon unless everybody knows the game inside out I wouldn't recommend any of the complexity ones for new players it will

just completely overwhelm them there'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return as a midweight Euro game the rules overhead is not as high as I would expect for a lot of other games but by no means perfect we'll get on to the floors a little bit later but generally there's not a huge amount of rules to teach at the start of the game other than having to add those Corporation actions on like I mentioned before but if you stick to some of the low complexity ones it won't take you that long to get those bits across and they all kind of share the same graph design and the shame kind of rule set for Corporation actions so they do blend together a little bit but yeah you're not going to be sat there for a huge humongous teach like you would would say you know Arc Nova or hemman or like you know a really big Euro game this is definitely more in the midweight category which does allow you to get going quicker the game both a pretty impressive time length I mean it says 60 to 120 minutes which sounds amazing on paper and yeah for the most part you should be able to keep to that 120 Minutes timeline you know you're talking 2 and 1 half hours hours for like a first game teaching AP players four players that kind of thing but yeah 2 hours is reasonable that you should be able to achieve after a couple of games or maybe with three players only 60 Minutes is a bit of a pipe dream I'm sorry I would love to see a two-player game of this or a solo game of this finish in 60 minutes it is not going to happen I mean solo the setup for this game is a bit of a chore in multiplayer it's not so bad you can kind of give a Corp to a player with the reference sheet and say just follow the directions and set up the Corp that speeds the setup from that respect but man you try and do the setup yourself with three

different Corps having to remind yourself what the rules for the corpse are and get all the pieces out and the AI board and all that stuff called blurry yeah you are not doing that in anything less than 15 minutes you know 20 minutes maybe and then you think you're going to play the rest of the game in 40 minutes or even 60 Minutes at all BL me yeah no solo game has ever taken 60 Minutes no two-player gameer is going to take 60 minutes it's just not physically possible but you know 90 to 120 is achievable you know 2 an hour hours is probably a bit more realistic for most gaming groups with new players Etc but it doesn't feel like it outstays its welcome I think it does as much as it needs to in the time length given maybe 2 and 1 half hours is a little bit long but again you shouldn't be in that bracket that often maybe just for your first couple of games you should be able to get it closer to to two hours and at that length particularly with four players I think that's a good length for what is offered here and the meat from this game is essentially in that resource mechanic and the utilization of the three different colors of astronauts the free actions themselves don't feel useless although you are mainly going to be doing the Command action for 75% of the time occasionally you'll need to jump on an income track and occasionally you might go to the Luna Gateway they're by no means useless actions but they're just not as necessary as the command one plus the command one gets more expensive the longer the round goes on so you're going to want to get in there early ideally but this is definitely quite a tight game for resources you know there are times where somebody might have quite a lot of money depending if they've managed to do a good combo but yeah with the metals and the rare ore

and the energy and stuff like that there's a lot of planning required a lot of timing aspects and you know you're definitely going to have to plan ahead with these colors of astronauts I mean if I get a shuttle that gives me a bunch of the yellows well okay so I can do a lot of building this round but do I want to do a lot of building and if I am going to that means I'm going to need a lot of minerals where am I going to get them I kind of maybe need to generate some income first maybe you know what I don't want this many yellows I'm going to swap this for a red in the Luna Gateway now I can get some cards really want there's a lot of decent things that you have to think about which aren't like overly complicated to get in your mind but the the real Crux of this is how to get from A to B it's never as obvious as you think because you've got the different ways you can get income from here you have got the different Corporation bonuses and various things on those you know these different boards and that where you can gain more resources and of course you've got just simply slotting astronauts onto your board could discount your maintenance phase it could make make it cheaper to get cards it can make it cheaper to you know build buildings Etc so there's a lot of different things that can link together nicely to get you to where you need to go and it's not always obvious how to do it it's definitely a more thinky Euro in the midweight category it doesn't quite reach heavy weight but yeah I would be reluctant to put anybody who was not used to you know tight euros into this one now that does carry a little bit of a flaw that this game does get you into situations now and again where you feel kind of useless you you want to get you want to do this but you

don't have any money but you don't have the astronauts or the facility to get a lot of money and if you do it's not going to be a lot and not enough for what you really want to do so with only 18 actions in the game especially as the actions get more and more expensive I mean with another player they could literally just fill up the road that you really wanted to do and suddenly the action is too expensive for you to do which completely neuters your ability to do that action for this round it's a little bit annoying when that happens and I've seen it happen to a fair amount of players this is not an uncommon situation you know we're not talking the likes of Cooper Island here in terms of oh my God I'm punished there's no way I'm going to win this but certainly yeah there are going to be times where you know somebody making an action that little bit more expensive or you know somebody building a spot on the map nearby you is just going to make life that little bit harder and possibly take you out of the action that you want to do and you might sometimes feel that you can't recover stop whining now I mentioned this isn't the best looking game in the world fair enough we'll gloss over that bit for the most part the graphic design is decent but not always present where you want it certain actions like the income action and the lunar Gateway action are nicely labeled where you can remember how they work probably without needing to look at the rule book too much for them or perhaps not entirely but then the iconography for the Command action is pretty much non-existent yeah you know that yellow is build and it gets to trigger tokens out afterwards that's about it but that's not the whole action the action has a lot more nuances to it

and even though I said that there's not a huge amount of initial overhead you do still have the site problem that you've got three corporations that are different every game that you have to understand how they work how they set up and how you know how they function in terms of points this is additional rules that you've got to deal with and if you use more of the complex cuse this does add a little bit to the setup and the complexity of the game but also the rule book is fine the rule book's got a decent amount of pictorial examples and it does rinse and repeat a few things now and again and it's laid out okay from the initial learning what I do find is problematic with this one though is when somebody asks an FAQ question because this game does have a lot of Niche rules hidden hidden within rules yeah you get to build something off your board there's the cost there's a little bit more to it than that there's usually War hang on what if somebody's there and somebody's there or what if I've got this and not that or what if the energy is at this level wa do I get reputation points when I go up one spot or for the whole lot you know there's a lot of things where the FAQ makes this a little bit hard to reference and so you as much as the initial overhead is not that bad if you're not if you're learning this game for the first time or somebody's not teaching it that well you could find a lot of questions being asked and not a lot of easy ways to be able to answer them and this is compounded by the fact that as much as you do have these cool reference aids for each Corporation I mean Kudos that you have these this is is great having to constantly pass these things around the board when people need to know how they work is a little bit

annoying but it also means that there's no player reference aids for the player surely you can't be serious I am serious and don't call me shirely seriously you have a game where there's multiple different Corps you have a game where there's actions not entirely laid out on the board you have rules within Niche rules and you don't give players a reference Aid of any kind that is why you fail seriously that could have been a really easy thing for you to do and it would have made a lot of things a lot better you maybe don't even need a reference card to do the lunar Gateway and the income action because they're pretty well done but okay you could have a reference card that does it and it would be take minimal space but seriously if you're willing to print out entire A4 sheets for one particular corporation would it really hurt you to do a card maybe about this size that just basically lists out step by step how all the different command actions Works particularly building cuz I think the building action does get quite fiddly in places about how it works and the nuances and FAQ moments that's definitely the most fiddly action in this game by far as well as also explaining maybe a little bit more about the graphic design on your board for how the buildings score you points and bonuses cuz these are not particularly clear in some respects some of them are more obvious than others but you know I do sometimes forget what these free infrastructures are meant to do instantly and what they're meant to do later it's a little bit on the like how does this work now so you know just a little bit of a nice fix would have made the game a lot smoother we're sorry player interaction this game is kind of bare bones as well the main two

things that players will do to infuriate you is one of twofold firstly this command track here when players place you know astronauts on here it progressively makes the action more and more expensive now you have some idea of how that's going to play out based on the shuttles that players take but given that you can exchange astronauts at the Luna Gateway that's not always as apparent as you might think but this is kind of like a one thing that players might do to get in your way they're not necessarily doing it to screw you over it's just the fact that they need to do it as cheap as they can it just happens to be the one thing you want to do the other thing is the area majority on here but it's not really as involved as you might think people aren't really blocking you to an extent yes you might go to a hex put their two building down it's like I fancy going there oh well you could always just go somewhere else I mean there's plenty of decent spots for you to go but the main aspect of this is just simply that if I put my astronaut on here and pay a credit I might have to pay an additional credit to do a hex on this line when I didn't have to but again it it's annoying but it's not quite as much player interaction as I maybe would have liked you know and you don't know when somebody's going to trigger a particular line or when somebody might build and where exactly they're going to build you know that's it's not something you can really plan out it just kind of happens so there is a little interaction but not a ton hooray people are paying attention to me this also causes a bit of a problem with the player scaling aspect because yes this command board scales with players so at least you have the uh the right amount for astronauts over here but in terms of the map it doesn't

scale at all they don't take out hexes they don't block off areas or anything which is kind of a bit of a misstep because if you play this one or two player this map is kind of inconsequential you know you'll build a few things you can get some income and you get some tokens but what the opponent does is not that interesting and frankly if they build in a hex over there you could just go in one of a million directions and just go away from them if you really want to you know you practically don't need to see each other you could at the start of the game go right you have this half of the Moon and I'll take this half of the Moon okay cool and then you would never see each other again it's just not that interesting fre players is not bad but really I actually for once think you actually need the Full Count of four players to get the most out of this map mechanic but then that of course means you're taking the game to probably a two and a half hour length two hours at the best you're going to have more AP and downtime because obviously this game can generate a lot of analysis paralysis with the different options you could be sat there waiting for a while for someone to take their turn it's just there's no real player count that I think is like the chosen B maybe free is the best but even at three you know the map is can be it can be contested it might not be I still think you probably need the Full Count of four you just have to accept it's a longer Affair I don't think any of us expected him to say that the game doesn't have a runaway leader problem per se but you do sometimes find in some games you can call the winner pretty early this is an engine building game as well as Resource Management so you know I'm doing things to get points and I might have just found a combo of corpse and cards that's

really giving me good stuff well by the point you get halfway through the game you should realize that somebody has built something that is just working and all they got to do is just keep rins and repeating it and utilizing it to its Max and they will score a bucket load of points somebody who has started off bad in round one is unlikely to claw their way back in round two and three there just simply isn't enough to do so and so especially in a four-player game you you find yourself in a situation where right we played this for half the game length things haven't gone well for me I don't think I'm scoring many points you're doing pretty well yeah you're going to win I'm going to come third or fourth and then lo and behold that exact prediction comes true which does kind of make the second half of the game a little bit antic climatic you know the points have never been tight you know the point markers go up to stupid levels I mean this thing laps to 50 points and yet your markers go to 200 I'm not even sure it's physically possible to get over 150 let 250 what the hell but you know maybe you could do over 150 if you do blindingly well but Jesus Christ 200 250 how the hell do you score that many points in this game you know did the other the other players have to be literally tied to the chair death dumb and blind for this to happen it's like no no way I've never had a game where somebody has had like right I've got 190 points and are you just ahead of me with 191 I couldn't have called that now you can call the leader and the Victor pretty easily by the time you're at least halfway 2ir of the way and at that point

you're just kind of going through the motions the game does come with a solo mode although we are going to talk about good and bad here I mean from a good perspective it's relatively easy to Pilot all you've got is a small deck of cards you flip one over match it with the one before and essentially you check which letters are the same or which one are highlighted then go top middle or bottom with the astronauts that the ai's got left and perform that action with that respective Corporation not very difficult at all really and because you are using the different corpse each game the solo cards for each of the corpse are integrated nicely and you simply just go right Moon mining a selenium Research b Artemus Taurus C and there you go and this is how the AI is going to score points it's smooth to operate in a decent system to the fact where you actually might consider what is avered multiplayer certainly in terms of interaction we'll get on to that a bit later but there are some negatives firstly you know the graphic design on some of these like cards is not the most intuitive eror like I swear I still don't quite get how the moon mining one's meant to work but it's also quite a cheaty AI it doesn't use resources and there are times where it seems to do an action and go that got me a point that didn't seem like that worth an action and then there'll be another time where it does something and just goes oh yeah I get a million points because I can get all the arous astronauts in the world for no effort compared to you who has to jump through a million Hoops to do so it's like that feels a little bit frustrating when an AI just cheats its way to a million points but it also does make the points for the AI a little bit erratic you know I would say that you should win this on easy but if you play

this on higher difficulties that sness is going to make it anywhere between you know a cak walk to insanely impossible to beat it depending on what corpse you've got but also the as we'll talk about a little bit later the the board is not that interesting when you have less players you know one two players does not generate enough contest on this board if the AI builds in certain areas you just simply go off elsewhere you don't really need to be in each other's faces that much and if the AI is focusing on a particular Corp I mean it will try to spread itself out but for example I had one game where it focused pretty heavily in arimus tours okay fine I just went and did selenium research instead yeah do what you like with the tours I don't really care I'm not going to try and stop you you just do your thing and I'll just do my thing over here doesn't feel like you're really battling the AI as much as simply trying to score more points than it does by way of its cheaty system and if you're going to do an AI like that you might as well just simply go right I'm playing this on normal difficulty I must beat a threshold of 150 points okay go and then you don't have to do any piloting of the AI cuz that's about as much interaction as you have with it during the game well that's a lot less hard Shackleton base is one of the most buzzed about games I've heard about this year man you try and find a board game critic that will say anything bad about this game it's not a common thing although you know what I'm like but you know you talk to players who play this and again a lot of people like this but some people do go it's fine you know not that massive a fan but you know it's

decent and there's a lot of good stuff the game has I particularly like the variation with the cors I think this is a neat idea I love that it's in Tuck boxes and it does add a little bit of replay value to the game but what you need to understand is that these do not fundamentally change the game okay they just simply add a little mini mechanic for scoring points which again yes is variety and you have seven of them you only pick three of them so there's a lot of different combinations there but it's not like you're going to make this game drastically different from one to the next cuz you are still utilizing the same system with the resources the astronauts and your player board but it is still cool you know it's not that long of a game it's not too much of a rules overhead although the rules do kind of need a little bit of work I think the rule book could have been improved in terms of referencing Niche rules the lack of a player aid for the basic actions I think is kind of unforgivable I mean seriously you've got a game with interchangeable corpse and I do appreciate that you give a reference Aid massive proportions for each court but would it have killed you to done some player aids for players that would have been nice especially as the graphic design is fine but a little bit lacking in in certain areas particularly with the command action where it's pretty much non-existent there's just little things that kind of trip it up here and there there's not a ton of player interaction people get in your way and make things a little bit more expensive but it's mainly just by cause an effect rather than somebody actually actively trying to screw you over and with the player scaling you've got the issue that the map becomes inconsequential at one to two players is kind of there at three

and only really functions at its best in four which then means more AP more downtime more time length so with more players carries that caveat is the solo mode is pretty decent but again you have the inconsequential map but you know the smoothness of how it operates does mean sometimes you might want to play it solo rather than multiplayer there's there's little bits here and there that I do quite like but there's a few areas where it does trip up and kind of take it out of that region where I'm not quite understanding where people are coming from with this ho it's the game of the year absolutely fantastic N9 10 out of 10 I don't quite see that but I do see how you can enjoy this game and have good fun with it so if people are giving this seals you know saying oh yeah this is at least a 7 eight out of 10 for me I think this is a good game a great game maybe a top 10 of the year for them I could see that happening for me it doesn't quite meet that but I still think it's decent I would not want to own this game I'm probably going to sell this one on I probably wouldn't suggest this one for a game night but if you put it on the table and said I fancy playing some Shack in base I'd play it yeah and I'd get some enjoyment out of it this one for me gets a decent high so close but yet so far 6 out of 10 for above average it's decent it's a fine game I get enjoyment out of it I like some aspects of it but I think that maybe just with a little bit more little bit more development in certain areas they could have made this just that little bit smoother that a little bit more like interactive or just made the player scaling a bit more meaningful I mean in

2024 nearly 2025 we should not be making errors on player scaling to this extent this is something that should have been ironed out a long time ago but I respect the storage system I respect the variety it does have and I respect what it's trying to do to make a little bit different from other Euro games you know this is not quite the most Innovative game ever but you know I would like to see more games utilize stuff like this I mean a game called Sierra West came out a while ago and that was a bit more fiddly and a bit more complicated to introduce the different rule sets you could have with that one this one is a bit easier so it does that one and improves on that but yeah it's a decent 6 out of 10 with a little bit more refinement in some areas I could have probably given this a seven out of 10 and given it a seal of endorsement as it is it kind of Falls a little bit shy not likely to be a top 10 of the Year for me and certainly I'm not getting nine or 10 out of 10 Vibes here I could see people saying that there's is seven or eight out of 10 i''d be totally cool but N9 and 10 I think you're being a little bit forgiving so uh Shackled and base it's decent but not quite game of the year you're going to burn in a very special level of hell so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up in YouTube and fumb up on Bor gang geek when it goes live on the page you know this all sharing and engagement it's what keeps this Channel alive check out the patreon if you want to donate even just a dollar a month to keep this channel going the costs for running this channel have increased you know they keep increasing year on year and I need to keep it running because it it's just a hobby it's not my job and so it's only with the support of you guys that this

channel is able to keep producing the content that it does bear it in mind I have to do this in my spare time of course check out the rest of the yesing content I've done and let me know your comments about this game you know if you love the game then fair enough but by all means let me know in the comments why you love it as much as 9 10 out of 10 if you're one of the few people out there that actually does not like this game I'd be interested to know why you don't like this game because I feel like there's not enough of you on the internet talking about it in that way you know I mean the internet does hate on people for talking negatively about a game but I want to hear both sides of the coin you know do you like it and also let me know which Corp combinations you like more you know out of the seven Corps three that just made the game for you why did those three make the game for you be interested to know so until next time remember regard regardless of which Corporation you represent it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved