Skip to main content
Loading video...

Light in the Dark - The Fires of Thokaia - Preview

Transcript 30:19

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, in today's video we are taking a look at The Fires of Thaya and this is a new expansion for A Light in the Dark. Now, A Light in the Dark is a game that uh we reviewed, I think sometime last year or maybe the year before. It's a little kind of small box solo dungeon crawl set in a world of pestilence where you are playing as a plague doctor and it's kind of an overland crawl, kind of a dungeon crawl where you are going around trying to rescue villages, fighting bosses, fighting monsters, and completing various quests. And I like this game. Okay, I didn't love it, but I think it's pretty good. It has some interesting things going and I had a couple of major criticisms of the first version here and that was one that the heroes didn't feel different enough. The classes, the different characters were basically just difficulty levels and they didn't feel thematically consistent. As an example, the fighter character starts with a lower attack value um than the explorer starts with or things like that. And I also thought thought that the iconography was nearly impossible to discern the abilities based on the icons used. So it wasn't very clear. You you couldn't look at the icons and determine what the items did. We'll show some examples of that as we go. And I think

they've kind of addressed both of those. Uh they've addressed the heroes more than the iconography, but we'll take a look at that as well. And so yeah, so this game was pretty cool. I liked the setting and it did some different things. Now, Fires of Thaya, this this expansion changes the rules of the base game in a very significant way, in many significant ways, I should say. And I'm almost wondering if it would be better if instead of releasing this as an expansion, if they brought the rules and components of the base game up in line with the changes made in the expansion and then released both together in a kind of deluxe second edition. because the way that the expansion changes the game is significant enough to where if you learn one of the games, you don't really learn the other. They play very differently.

And that could be kind of an issue. I think it might be better just to release a kind of big bigger it still would be a small box but to release a kind of bigger deluxe version deluxe second edition of the game. Now this prototype was sent to me to review and I do not believe that it is feature complete so I think we're going to be seeing other things. This is just kind of a small example of the things that you're going to get in this expansion. So yeah. So, let let me know if you guys agree with that assessment after we talk about all of the changes. If you would rather see just a kind of deluxe second edition of Light in the Dark that just brings everything together. So, from the base game, you actually aren't using a whole bunch of stuff. And this is one of the things that I'm talking about. So, you have to pull out a bunch of your items.

Now, I'm not going to be going into gameplay uh details about how to play the game. I do have my basic review for A Light in the Dark and I'll link that in the description below so you can watch that. You can get a better feel about the game, but uh these are the things that you won't use from your base game. So, all of these item cards are removed and these are basically your kind of potions and stuff. And what's kind of cool is these have been replaced by a new kind of item and I'll show those a little later. You also aren't using any of your terrain cards. So, none of the basic terrain cards will be used in when you play the expansion. The expansion comes with its own terrain cards because some of those have been changed a little bit. They've added some some dangerous terrain where you have to do a skill check in order to bypass these secret passages without taking damage. You also won't use your enemy tracker because each of the enemies now has its own card, and that's pretty cool. You also will not be using any of the basic uh quests that uh that you had in the base game. And so this is another thing that it's kind of a weird expansion because it doesn't just expand things, it vastly changes the game. Now everything else from your base game you will be using. So now let's talk about some of the stuff that comes with the expansion. First of all, you are going to get a whole set of tokens and cubes and everything that you will need to play this as a two-player game. So, the original Light in the Dark was purely a

solo game. This expansion adds the ability to play the expansion in a two-player mode, and you can play that either as a competitive game or as a cooperative game. I have not played the two-player mode at all, so I cannot comment on how well that plays, but I did want to mention that because it is very important. Okay, so let's take a look at one of my main issues was the heroes in the base game and how they didn't really feel different because they didn't have any kind of unique special abilities that would make the the rider feel different than the explorer or the supplier feel different than the fighter. They had some starting stats, but that just wasn't enough. Basically, these were difficulty levels, so you could play a harder game or an easier game. I also found it quite weird that, for instance, the fighter started with a one attack power, while the rider started with a two attack power. The fighter should start with more with more attack power.

So, what they've done for this expansion is these are basically just art. Now you are just picking the art that you like and you are playing that character. All of the characters now start with the same stats. They start with three I believe three on everything or 332 I believe it is. However, they're going to introduce or they are introducing new class cards. And in this expansion we have two different classes. I'm hoping there are a whole bunch more. maybe hopefully up to four or something so you can make a real meaningful decision. And these class cards will be paired with whatever character you choose to play as. So, you'll kind of ignore these starting uh pips there. And the rules tell you that each of the characters starts with the same stats, but you can start with a different uh different class. So, you could be the writer berserker or the rider medic. And there is a new experience system. One of the things that this expansion does is it makes the game feel a little more methodical, a little more kind of like a sandbox adventure where you have a little more freedom of what you are doing on each turn. And by making it more methodical, it kind of slows the pace of the game down a little bit, but the games don't get progressively longer. It just makes everything a little more concise, I guess you could say. So when you do certain things, when you heal villages or you kill certain uh

enemies, you will gain experience points. And as you move up these tracks, you will go from level one, you start at level zero, you will uh gain XP to go up to level one, then level two, then level three, and then each one of those levels, as you cross it, you will be able to choose one of these special powers. So there is a little bit of character building. There's a little bit of a skill tree here. That is great. Also, this introduces a new stat called intelligence. And at the beginning of the game, when you are at level zero, you start with zero intelligence. When you go up to level one, you have one intelligence, then two intelligence, and then three intelligence. Intelligence is used for certain types of checks, such as a new search check where you can search certain spaces on the map in order to find items, in order to find gold. So, it also introduces gold and gold you can spend at markets. So yeah, this game it's a lot different. This is not just a basic expansion.

So here are the two different classes again, medic and berserker. You can play any of these characters. The characters do still have I believe they still have their special uh combat ability which makes each of the characters more effective against a certain type of enemy such as wolves or trolls or bandits or cultists. So that is another thing that kind of separates out the characters. You also have a new round tracker that has all of your new kind of optional rules here or optional um actions that you can take. And that's another huge huge change to this game is the movement is now kind of an action point economy. It's a dexterity. And so the characters will start with three dexterity and for one point of decks you can or one movement point you can move from one node to the next. You can also take these actions. So in the original game, you could move up to three spaces and then take an action. And you would do that three times during your hero phase. Well, now you have to think more about how you are using your movement points and how you are spending your movement points on taking these optional actions. And the different actions are combat, heal, you can buy an item at an item store, an item token, you can harvest an herb, and the herbs are used to heal the villages of the plague. You can search at enemy spawn points. And when you search, you roll a d6 and add your intelligence, and then you follow this table here. So, you can fail or you

can get an item. Now, I think that is actually a misprint here on this small circle item because those are actually new items that you can find and those are these new item tokens. We'll talk a little bit about those in more detail. Uh you can rest at a at a village in order to heal yourself. Another huge huge difference in this game is that uh characters when they die, they respawn and you just lose a couple of victory points. So, you can keep playing. You don't lose by dying in uh this version here. Uh, we have these new terrain checks. And the terrain checks will be these little mountains, forest or water hex's that you have to pass through. And then you have to do a stat test, either testing your dexterity, your intelligence, or your combat value. And if you fail, you still move through the area, but you take some damage. So again, very, very different. And the quests are also actually pretty different as well. So, in the base game, you could mix and match your beginning, middle, and ending quest cards to make kind of a unique quest. And they didn't really have, you know, much story um story paths weren't very coherent. It was just more of kind of a a mixand match quest system. And I did like that.

That's one of the things that I really do like about the original. And here we have things that have more of a connecting story. And so the different quest, each different quest, you don't mix and match. You will play one quest or play the other quest. Now, the prototype came with two different quests. So, we have Signs of the Hunt stage one, uh, Cut Off the Pack, stage two, and Call of the Alpha stage three. So, this quest, of course, is all focused on the wolves from the base game. And this second quest here introduces a new kind of enemy type. These these flaming cultist, these cult of the flame or something. So, we have the cult of the cleansing flame, I believe. Stage one, stage two, and stage three. I have no idea how many uh quest paths are going to be introduced in the expansion, but I'm hoping it is a substantial number. Now, these work in the same way that the quest did in the base game. You will be keeping track of your timer and at the end of each full round that ticks up and you have to complete this quest before your timer moves on to the next stage of the quest.

If you succeed in doing what it says, you get this reward. If you fail to do what this quest says, you take a penalty. So, the quest stages now have pass and fail um mechanisms with them. So, I think that's really cool. And it's also neat that the quests also come with some really cool art. You know, the quests in the first game didn't have really any interesting art on them. So, the questing system is a little bit different. In addition to the new kind of questing system, we also have a deck of minor quests. And you will start the game with a minor quest revealed. And then as you heal villages, as you spend those herb tokens on villages to heal them, you will be able to draw additional minor quests. And these are just little side quests, little things that you can do. My prototype came with six. And I'm imagining there will be a whole a whole bunch more. So this one here, message for the living. You would gain a letter token, and if you draw this quest, you would gain this little token, and then you have to discard that at the nearest healed village. And if you do that, you gain a victory point and you gain an experience point. Uh here we have the herb stockpile or the blood and honor to defend their own the mountain flower and bearer of the black flame. And so just different little things to do that are in addition to your main quest. I think this adds a lot of flavor to the game and it also adds to that kind of sandbox feel.

So, the different uh terrain cards here, we have our starting our starting tile. And one of the things that does change pretty significantly in this expansion is that the map is no longer uh it's confined. The map is now confined to a 4x4 grid in any direction and the map loops. So you can't get those kind of odd situations in the base game where you might have a dead end and you can't get to where you need to go. So you can always get to where you need to go. And I do like the smaller uh kind of the smaller map. And so we also have some of these special terrain spots that I mentioned before and you will have to make these terrain checks to pass through those spots. So, if you wanted to go from this space to this space, you would have to, you know, go across this kind of lake or raging river or something and you would have to make a stat check. And then if you pass the stat check, you make it without taking damage. If you fail the stat check, you still make it across the river or the lake, but you take a point of damage.

So, I do really like that a lot. And some of these are used in quests such as the first stage of the wolf quest. you actually have to go to a space next to a mountain or a forest and search for clues for where the wolves have gone. And so it just seems to use the tiles. This this expansion seems to use the tiles in more interesting ways. I do want to set out um an example of the grid here. Uh we'll just do a 3x3 just so it fits on camera. Everything does have to you can't um rotate the tiles in any way you want. They have to be in reading reading order. So, we'll just set these up like that. So, we'll do a 3x3 just so it'll fit on camera here because I want to show some other examples as well. Yeah. So, if you were here and you were moving in this direction, this would loop back over to the other direction. It's a it's a looping map now. And I like that. And I like the fact that it's 4x4. or it just makes things a little more compact. I think it's really cool and it's just kind of a bummer that you can't use any of your old tiles in this expansion and that's what I would like to see more of a deluxe combination second edition of the game that just brings everything up in line with what is happening in this expansion.

So, another pretty big change is how enemies spawn and how enemies activate. And actually, let's talk about the enemies in general now. So, in the base game, you kept track of your enemy uh your enemy stats on this card here, and then you would also add little tokens to make them more powerful as the enemies leveled up at certain moments during the game. Now each of the enemies has its own stat card and you will set these out on the table and when the enemy is spawned you will take a enemy token and you will put that enemy token on the first slot on its card and then if they spawn again or if certain things trigger it then this moves up and as it moves up the enemies get stronger. if it moves up to the final slot on the enemy, then that uh corresponding boss will spawn. I think that is really cool because that's just a really neat kind of thematic element where, you know, if you let the wolves run freely too long, you don't control the wolves. They're out there killing villagers and things, maybe spread spreading this this plague, then the the the boss wolf comes onto the board. And so each of the enemies has its own corresponding boss. The bosses are from the base game, but the goal of this game is no longer just to defeat the boss. You have to go through the quests and and and follow the quest path and do what the quest says. So we have

the boss enemy. Uh those guys are new here. We have our cultist boss there. Then we have our bandit boss. And we have our our giant boss. Not trolls. Those are giants. So, I do like the new enemy system. I do like how each of the enemies has its own card now to keep track of their stats. Another huge, huge change is the enemies no longer just move towards the characters. They no longer just move towards the heroes. The enemies have a very rudimentary AI system now. And so the bandits when they activate they will move towards the nearest uh market token, destroy it and then they will move towards the hero. Uh the wolves here, the the trolls will move towards the nearest herb token. They will eat the token and then they will move towards the hero. The cultists always just move towards the hero. And the uh wolves will will move towards the hero if the hero is closest. If not, they will move towards a village and block the village. So, they will stand outside of the village to prevent the plague doctor from entering and cleansing that village. That is awesome. The expansion also introduces a new uh enemy faction.

So, we have the emberlings and these are kind of like a flame cult, a fire cult. And then their boss here, Ashcar Veil, the ember um arch prophet. And then you will mix these enemy cards into the enemy deck from your base game. And some of the expansions will use all of the enemy or some of the the scenarios, some of the quests use all of the enemies. And some of times you will remove cards from the enemy to have kind of a custom enemy deck for each quest. So again, pretty significant change. Another huge change is the way that the enemies activate on the map. So in the base game, if you had various enemies out in the spawn on the spawn spots, they and during the enemy turn, every enemy on the board would activate. And so you would have this situation where you were just constantly being surrounded by enemies. Well, they've kind of uh they've changed that by throttling it a little bit. Now, enemies only spawn and they only activate if they are on a orthogonally adjacent uh tiles to your hero. So, if I was here and I had to spawn enemies, enemies would only spawn here, here, here, and here. If I was here and I had to spawn or activate enemies, enemies would only spawn or activate here, and here. In addition to that, enemies are blind to all tiles

that aren't orthogonally adjacent. So, it just makes managing the movement and the placement of enemies a little more it's a little more manageable. So, I do also really really enjoy that. Now, the maybe the last we'll go over my list in a minute, but one of the big major changes is how items work. In the base game, you would place these item tokens wherever you saw this icon here, and if your character moved on to that item, they would remove that token and then draw an item. Well, that is no longer the case. Now, you have to buy items with gold. And you earn gold either by completing some quests or things or by saving villages. So you have to go, you have to spend an herb at a village in order to save it. You take the village token and that becomes a piece of gold.

And then you can buy items for one gold. You can also craft items now by spending tokens from enemies that you have defeated. And so we have these items. These are the items that we that are new here. We have this whispering blade, a fire sword, a reinforced cloak, padded boots, and a hunter spear. And as you can see, they did address the iconography system on these weapons. We no longer have these very random uh icons here. I mean, this is just such a great example of how poor the iconography is in the base game. This is the example I used in my original video. So, if a uh a three with an arrow up, a reroll symbol, and a four with an arrow down, I guarantee you nobody can uh decipher what that means without reading in the book. I'll give you a minute. But now, here is what this does. The war charm. After rolling, count the value of the higher dime roll twice and ignore the value of the smaller die.

I have looked at this card for many many minutes trying to wrap my brain around how how this is defined by its meaning. I Yeah, it's just it's kind of crazy, but you don't get new cards, so you will have to still use the book until you remember what they do. But the new item cards, they get rid of the iconography altogether, and they just tell you what you do. Spend a point of movement to gain plus one combat. you may spend a an enemy token, an extra enemy token to gain an additional plus one to your combat. And so the new items, I think, are much better. They're much more fun. But you will mix those in to your starting items. And remember, we did remove a whole bunch of items from the base item deck, and I'll show you why in just a minute. So, you will shuffle these up.

And then we also have these new crafting items. And these crafting items, as you defeat enemies, you will take the enemy token into your inventory and then at a market space, you can spend tokens in order to craft these very powerful items. Again, super cool. I love this addition. So, we have the cloak of embers, the axe of might, the unyielding blade, the wolf skin boots, and the portal medallion. So, we will shuffle these up. And then you build kind of a market a market deck here. So you take three of your normal items. So right now we have the basic shield, two basic shields, and a whispering blade. And you take three crafting items. These are the items that are always available when you go to any market on the board. So anytime you interact with one of those tokens, you remove that token and then you have an opportunity to shop. The items cost one. These have to be crafted with the enemy tokens. But additionally, we have these new small item tokens. And these replace the potions and things that we took out from the base game box.

And these also add a whole bunch of extra things. So, we have the herb mix, which is used for healing. We have an adrenaline shot, which gives you an additional combat. We have the uh plantapore. Plantaptopore poison remove one enemy die during combat. We have a map that let you go through terrain cards better. We have a climbing tool uh which allows you on climbing checks so when you're going over mountains and we have this blackfire torch and those are all on these tokens. So when you set up your market, you also draw three of these small tokens and put those either above or below the normal items. And when you spend one coin to shop for an item, you get to choose a combination of a card item and a small item. Very cool.

I really do like that. Again, it gives you just more choice and it makes it feel kind of more like that sandbox you where your choices matter more in what you are doing. So I believe those are all of the major changes. Uh let me look at my my checklist here. So yes, so there are now character classes. That is great. That addresses my main concern from point one up here that I had with the base game. The action point economy is very different. You no longer get to do one free optional thing at the end of each movement. You now have to use your movement points in order to to spend those on the actions. Uh the map is now confined to a 4x4 looping grid. Uh that difficult terrain does require skill checks to pass unharmed. Heroes can die and respawn. Enemy activation. Enemies have different targets. Enemies only spawn and activate on adjacent tiles.

Uh, enemies are blind to non-adjacent tiles. Uh, markets and items. Circle item tokens no longer just grant an item. They grant the ability to shop. Village tokens are coins. You can buy large items and small items. You can craft items using the gr using tokens granted by slain enemies. And also when you take that search action, if you roll a seven or higher, add in your intelligence, you also get to find one of those small items. But again, that does show the I the circle um item icon, and I don't think that's right. I think that should be, you know, a little square token, so you know that it's a small item. Uh let's see. The new items do not rely on iconography for ability explanation. They have full text of what they do. Much much better. are much clearer. You don't need to to consult a rule book about what each item does. Uh quest stages now have pass fail mechanisms and you can't mix and match.

And also the minor quest add something else to do while you are playing. So as you can see there are a lot of changes and there are enough significant changes that I would like to see a second edition of the base game to bring everything up in line with this expansion. And preferably, I would like to see just a second edition of the base game combined with the new stuff from the expansion and released in a kind of slightly larger second edition version of the game. It would still be it could still be in a small box. It could still be considered a small box game. And that's probably my main criticism of the expansion is that it's such a different game. You have to learn all new rules. the rules are changed that I think most people once they start playing the expansion, they'll never go back to just playing uh the base game because the base game is different and it's just not as good now. And so uh yeah, just make a second edition and just make this the new kind of base level for this game because you know, you have all of these different quests and these different quests really can't be used anymore unless you play with the old rules. And so bringing these old quests up in align with the new rules and mechanisms and things would just make this feel more like an expansion and rather and not a standalone game. So that is my that's my main criticism. On the plus sides, I think this is really cool. I think this kind of elevates the game to where I

wish it I wish it was when it was first released, but like I said, once I start playing the expansion, I really don't want to go back to just playing the base game. It kind of it it replaces the base game. So, that's a weird thing for an expansion to do. But, uh, yeah, this will be hitting crowdfunding soon. If I have a link, I I'll post post a link into the description. And um but you can always just uh Google fires of Thakaya. I'm not sure if they sent me a link to the landing page yet, but I'll find out and I'll post it either in the first comment a pinned comment or in the description below. So yeah, I hope you guys liked looking at the Fires of Thaya, the expansion for Light in the Dark, kind of discussing some of the changes and the new things and uh just looking at some of the new art is really nice. So yeah. Yeah, I'm excited for this expansion. I'm hoping that there is even more to it than what I have seen just in this prototype. We will talk to you later.

Progress saved