Wandering Galaxy: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm doing a discussion over Wandering Galaxy, a crossroads game designed by someone. I don't know who designed it. Uh Jerry Hawthorne, I knew that. Uh published by Pla Hat Games. And this is the technically fourth iteration of their crossroad systems. The first of course being Dead of Winter. Uh but then shenanigans happen. Oh wait, they did have Gen 7, but we don't really talk about that. Atrocious game. Uh but then they reformed it, got back together and designed Forgotten Waters, which was their pirate themed one. Couple years later they did Freelancers fantasy and now here we are with sci-fi. And I got to say, I was very excited for this one whenever it was originally announced because I love Forgotten Waters and Freelancers. I think both of them are excellent oneshot uh you know, storytelling games that uh have immaculate voice acting and hilarious writing uh while still feeling kind of a little bit like an epic. you know, you pick a scenario and you play them and once you're done, you know, different things will happen even if you play the same scenario, but you know, you're done. And then come wandering galaxy.
This one is actually a little bit more campaign driven where it it's not super campaignheavy, but it definitely has uh things that carry over from play to play where you have uh reputation and stuff based off your characters and those are being upgraded along with your ship. Still scenario-based, but things do carry over. And after having played this, well, originally when I played it, the app wasn't done and I feel like it was completely unbalanced because they just riddled you with threat. I didn't want to do the review back whenever we had first, you know, first touched it. I wanted to give it some time to breathe and have the app be completely finished. Now that it is and we have played through it, I gotta say I don't I I don't this one just doesn't quite hit the same. And I'm not entirely sure why. I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that I mean the the mapbooks are still the same, you know, where you have your your standy, you pick a location you want to go to, go into the app uh and see what happens there based off a few checks. I think that this game is a little bit too ambitious. There is way more mechanisms that are happening in this. In fact, it's not even just in Freelancers. It was literally like a map sheet that you just kind of picked an icon to go to on a pre on a, you know,
pre-generated path. In this one, you actually have a space log that you will travel around and this a lot of stuff can happen. So, this game is bigger. It is more epic. I just don't know if that's necessarily the best case. I was really hoping that this was mainly going to be freelancers but sci-fi and of course with a little bit different systems to accommodate that and this game does have that. It's just it feels a little a little much. And even when it comes to the way the characters are created, I I almost feel like the humor was kind of sucked out. It doesn't feel as witting, you know, witty. I was going to say I don't know what I was going to say. Uh, witty or charming. It is. I mean, you just have these characters. Hell, even when you take a look at the characters, you have questions that you answer. But that's literally it. And then based on if you have more A's than B's or vice versa, that tells you your backstory.
But what they did in both Forgotten Waters and Freelancers that I thought was one of the best ways to even make a backstory was do a Mad Lib style. And maybe people hated that. I don't know. I I loved it. I thought it was super funny. Uh because you got something wacky every time you made a character. Hell, even in Freelancers, you had a character and a class that you could mix together. Here, nope. you pick a character and that's that's what you got and you have some whatever backstory that pretty much gives you the same starting item or card. There's a few differences, but every character relatively feels the same. And I think the biggest difference is the characters will change over the course of the campaign based off the deck you're building. So, at the core of this one, it is a deck builder, and there's items and other cards that you will uh that you'll get that will kind of be as a part of your kit, but I don't feel like this game needed any of that. That's kind of my overall issue is they had some some cool elements where you have a ship that you're kind of the story that you start out with is you have a ship that you're that's a loner and you're your entire goal every single scenario is to raise seven money and that's kind of when you can trigger the end of a scenario uh before threat ramps up. And if you do that you can kind of like buff up your ship. if you make permanent upgrades to that. And it seems the whole campaign is
scheduled around four game sessions. And the other thing about this one is maybe I missed it or something, but I never I don't remember this game advertising itself as a campaign. And you might not think a four session, you know, connected sessions is a campaign, but that's literally what it is. It's not a long one, but you do have a deck that carries over items that carry over and an app that keeps track of all that. So, I I think I just much would have much rather had this game be literally like all the other ones. And it's just a oneshot. You pick a scenario to play. It's that. And even then, even though they have this whole map of things to do, it's not as if it's open world. Uh it's it you're still on rails. Yeah, you can kind of go left or right, but you could could have done that with freelancers.
Uh so that feels bloated. Uh the writing, while still good, is not as charming. So it feels kind of flat. Or if it's trying to be funny, I I guess I don't get it. all the different little uh um roles that people can play it because in in a given session, you're constantly drawing from this threat bag. And that threat bag, you draw every every five seconds. the person who is that role who is supposed to be running the threat bag, they might as well just keep their hand in the bag the entire time because you're constantly drawing from this thing with not really enough mitigation to be able to uh you know seed it with positive tokens. So, it's mainly always bad tokens, which then every time you move, you have to spend energy and half the time you're having to pause so that you can do some ship actions. And half the time, everyone's ship actions is doing ways to give them supplies or energy.
Very rarely are you doing anything uh as you know, the sciences where you can get a science token and move it up and that'll flip and that'll turn into something different. uh the navigation waypoints m you know you you might place the plot marker so that when you draw from the bag you can draw two and keep one all other times you're kind of managing supplies and the supplies that you're managing are mainly used to eventually go sell. So if you don't naturally complete jobs then oh okay well at least we can finally go sell something and sell all these goods for the seven profit that we need. And the game has a ton of things to do. Uh, this is the deck here. I gotta got to pull this thing out.
This is the deck. Yeah, I mean, this is the entire deck of of different jobs. So, there's there's a ton of content in the game. I just don't know if I particularly care about any of it, which is unfortunate because the bones of this game are the exact same as the other two. And hell, the length of the the game each session is pretty much the length of the other ones. They're, you know, you get your money's worth for sure. Although, actually, in this game, the the box is pretty is pretty light. Maybe it could be because I have a a 3D insert, but everything that the game comes with fits in this insert that I've printed off. Um, and what's also kind of strange is this is, you know, I don't know why I was about to lift that cuz I can just pull this out. This is the the card box for that's that's it. Even if you sleeved it, you'd probably only have to maybe remove this one. So, the game feels extremely bloated where I don't really feel the same way about the other two games. Um, so if this game was going for a campaign feel, they don't provide you with really enough content unless all that content is in the app. But then, you know, why make this massive box besides just to fit the the map sheets, which again, I absolutely love. I think that they do a lot of cool things here.
I it I don't know. This one has has certainly let me down and the feelings that I had towards it whenever we first jumped into the game. It's kind of the same feelings I had once I let it all, you know, finish. I let the app complete and jump into it, did the tutorial, uh, you know, had the game teach you, which again it does an excellent job at doing with its tutorial. uh but then you know went through the first mission went through a few missions or scenarios after that it doesn't really justify its campaign aspects. So, the campaign isn't necessarily needed by any means. Uh, because, you know, it's not that long.
And I think that's kind of where if you're doing a sci-fi campaign, uh, let's just say Stars of Aarios, that's a that's a 40hour campaign. And I understand that not any not everyone has that time uh you know that time to commit but if I don't know I don't know who's wanting a four session campaign and then you know be like man that was a great campaign it's it I feel like a lot of people would have just much rather had this be oh let's pick a scenario and just see what happens and it's all you wipe your you know wipe your hands clean of it and then you're pack it all up, do a different build the next time you play. Play the same scenario and and then play a different character and then have make different decisions or you know you have a different character that has a different keyword or something. Uh so you just can't really explore that because you still have the aspects of a campaign. So the campaign is not rest not really all that great. The characters I feel are extremely watered down. And if they're not watered down, then they just aren't it's just not as fun to make them. So, I don't really like the characters. I think the roles are way too involved. I think the the deck building, it's not even really a deck builder. I mean, it is. You have a deck of of cards, but really all the deck all the cards are are for tests. So, whenever you have a
test come up, you flip over a certain number of cards and you're looking for icons. So, you you will have a character that is particularly good at something and a lot of the extra cards that you will be drawing or putting into your deck let you draw more. So, your deck does just get get better as time goes on. But, it I mean, not really do anything cool with the deck. it just becomes a better way for you to achieve on skills or skill checks. Uh I don't like the way that the bag works because you're constantly riddled with threats, so you can't explore a lot of the extra stuff. You're kind of having to beline it towards your mission. Uh and maybe if a side quest is on the way, then you can do it, but you can't. If a side quest is left and your mission is right, you can't really go left all that much to be able to course correct. you're just going to be riddled with threat too much and there's not really any ways to remove threat.
Uh I will say that the game feels uh way more balanced because the first time we had played this we died almost instantly and it just felt everything was constantly giving you threat and uh whenever we jumped back into it that seemed to have been more tame. So yeah, I mean and here's the thing is like the game's not bad by any means. I I still have fun playing it. That's that's the weird part about this whole discussion is uh I'm not necessarily on the game. I think it's just in compar if this was the first one that came out. Uh again, I don't really compare these the wandering galaxies and the others to Dead of Winter. Dead of Winter kind of feels like it's its own thing at this point, but if this was the first one that came out, I probably would be praising it a lot more. But it's unfortunate that it didn't. You have to compare it to its other its predecessors. And I just personally find I I think Freelancers is the best one that they ever did. It felt it felt like a oneshot D&D campaign. And this unfortunately does not feel like a oneshot Starfinder campaign.
Um it so you by comparing it to the other two, I think it's worse than Freelancers and I think it's worse than Forgotten Waters. And because they have the same structure of of game and and I can't play this as a oneshot once we're done with our own campaign because we only got halfway halfway through it. Uh I don't really feel like this would hit the table all that much. Whereas Freelancers and Forgotten Waters I can take to a game day because everyone can play it and once we're done we're done. We don't have to commit to a campaign. And the fact that it doesn't feel as if it's advertised at that as that. It almost seems like you might be side sidelining. Not sidelining. Um what's the word I'm I'm looking for?
Uh I can't think of the word, but where blindsiding you're blindsiding people with, "Oh, by the way, yeah, no, this is a campaign. Gotcha." Uh which is probably how I get most of my people to play games with me. Yeah. So it it's fun. This game is still is still fun. The writing is still enjoyable. The sound design is really good. Uh Pla Hat has kind of nailed their apps for these kinds of games. I like that the cross the crossroads systems. I mean, there's there's, like I said, a lot of of variation within the jobs alone. Hell, even if you're doing the first scenario, if you follow the main job that you get, there's v, you know, various locations that when you get there and it says, "Hey, what job are you doing here?" And there are seven options. So, the game does have a lot of content for it in the app. It's not a lot of content physically.
And it and I think that's kind of where you might have to decide whether or not at the end of the day if you're looking at these three games and I hope they keep making them. I I really do. I I still think these Crossroads games are an absolute blast. But if you are jumping into one a, it's going to be based off of your theme preference, honestly, because the games still are you still have the role system in all of them. So, if you don't have a large group to hand out one to every single player, uh you're going to have to do two. And this game actually does a good job of giving you, okay, I'm we have three people. I'm one and two. You're three and four. They're five and six. And those roles kind of go hand in hand. So, uh so it's going to be do you like pirates? Do you like fantasy? Do you like sci-fi?
uh that I mean ultimately might just be the deciding factor because in terms of its gameplay, well, funny enough, Freelancers and uh Forgotten Waters both have this kind of competitive edge to it. There's this uh um like ranking system that you're kind of trying to be in the lead for, you're vying for. It is a cooperative game, but you're kind of vying for XP or for money so that you get more ahead on your end story. Uh, this game doesn't have any of that. It is fully cooperative. You're not trying to be the best bounty hunter in the world to dick over your other players. There's none of that in here.
So, it comes down to if money is not an issue, which they're probably all the same price, and you don't really care, you like all three of the themes, well, then it's going to come down to do you prefer to have a a mini campaign or a oneshot. And for me, with this kind of game, I much prefer the oneshots. So, uh that's it. I mean, I can't really think of anything else about about my thoughts on on this game. It is it is a little bit of a letdown whenever I compare it to the other two, but still fun. So, I don't know. Maybe maybe whenever we finish the the full campaign, I might have a a different uh opinion on it. But as of where we're sitting right now in our playthroughs, uh it is my least favorite of the three while still being good. If I'm sitting at I mean, let's see. Let's see where I have put freelancers. I mean, I'm pretty sure I know what I have freelancers at, but So, freelancers I have at a nine. Yep. And I'd probably keep it there. Forgotten Waters. Forotten W.
I also have it a nine. You know, I'll probably throw forgotten Waters as an eight. I will actually lower that. I do think it's uh probably a a point less. And then with Wandering Galaxy, it's weird cuz I didn't really talk about any of the positives. I didn't I felt like I just on the game the whole time. But it's not that I think it's bad. I just think it's not as good, which is kind of a weird discussion to have. I'm gonna give it a seven. I think this is still good. I have fun playing it. Whenever I'm in the app, I'm invested. You know, I'm involved and I'm listening. It's not like I'm looking at my watch waiting for them to shut up. Uh, you know, you still have choices to make. I think the skill checks in the game are serviceable. Everything is just good. It's not great. It's not I mean, yeah, probably my my least favorite part is that they they water down the characters, so I don't really care who I'm playing.
Um, so it's it's good. I I think it's I think this is good. And that's that's pretty much it. So that's my thoughts on Wandering Galaxy. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.