The Quacks of Quedlinburg: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30 day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the quacks of quedlinburg uh which is the game that actually won the caster spiel in 2018 the what it's the game of the year oh forever the german stuff kendrick right kendrick diaz it's not not evil no no not evil different germans different germany gotcha anyway so one uh it's basically like i think it's like the best kids game of the year yeah um so what do you guys think it was really neat i enjoyed it quite a bit uh i like bag building games in general um early ons all the planet was still pretty good um so it's fun but the problem is with a bag building game you don't have shitty bags like that's that's probably my biggest complaint you know what one better than this bag a sock just a sock a pocket [ __ ] would be a little bit better than this i mean while a little harder to handle like maybe like little like marbles or something i don't know it might be it might be infinitely more expensive you know it's funny that you say that because there's a game that called potion explosion which is basically um
oh wait what would like candy crush well it would work if they had if they had holes yeah but that would break the price quite a bit yeah i mean it's not bad i'm just no these aren't i mean these are your standard bags but for one where your bag gets really full because there's no way to mitigate your bag like to take stuff out of it like a lot of bag builders kind of like deck builders you have ways to trash stuff so your ways to remove now there probably is with the different sets of of the things but we've done set one for this one and but yeah that's that was actually just extremely just frustrating because i always felt like either the the tokens were getting like greasy or they'd stick together and i'd be like reach and then get in the middle but then i'd feel over him there's like 10 chips in the [ __ ] corner and i'm like where are all my whites and they probably made it to where the whites are a little heavier so they fall into the middle you pull them so you draw them no there's another game that did that the arkham the living card game
it's a weird concept to me and i i just don't feel like it's super random i feel like a lot of them like the pile yeah and then it's yeah so for aesthetics that's not the best however i think the game is a lot of fun yeah i think because you were saying what were you saying blue was the way to go yeah i definitely think blue is extremely helpful certainly but i don't know because i let's see what was my main distribution in this oh look there's all my whites uh one two three one two three four five six i had six blues cat had one two three four five six seven eight blues if you go blue heavy you can really really control what's coming out but you still didn't win you beat devon who had no blues yeah but that's correlation more than anything i think also the randomness of the cards we're like get a free token get a free blue get a free level two level four yeah um i think i guess pumpkin heavy maybe the reds would pay off a little more i think there's a lot of strategy to the different sets i think your strategy was was very valid with going for the uh the yellows to mitigate getting those whites out but still keeping your spot right um but god they yeah i wish i had gotten more and they don't work well with the blues because then it's like oh look i drew a yellow after a blue yeah like if i choose to pick that then i can't cancel a white yeah so that's luck based and unfortunately
was not working this game into my [ __ ] early pop there i i will actually say yeah the the game is still extremely luck heavy and i knew that going in um that it's it's a press your luck uh like luck luck fest you could draw all your whites all at once and then be like what the [ __ ] uh i got one point and it and rounds five and that's why i'm saying that there needs to be something in the game that lets you mitigate in this particular set it was the blues the blues at least let you draw a number and be like do i want to place any of these or not uh but yeah cat what do you think let me think about the strategy of the game what do you think about the variety here uh i mean it's good like i i really enjoyed playing off the blues because they can cascade off each other and i think that's fine um uh yeah i mean i like the fact that the gold like if you get lucky if you have enough gold um especially early on if you can afford it um it's good to be able to put a white bag yeah i think yeah if you're smarter about the pumpkins because i think i definitely think yeah the yeah the pumpkins are early game because that's going to be early game it just it does feel like that there are there is like some type of cascading ability where it's like you want to go red and pumpkin maybe because then you're gonna have a lot of pumpkins out and then you're gonna start moving your sixes which can get you higher on points and then also higher on
you know buy buy power um the black you deserve that the the black was extremely helpful in just gaining the the free potion because like what was it i think i just bought one and then you guys didn't buy one so i just had to draw one and then place it in there and then it's like okay that's at least a free movement but that's one free movement and as we were playing you guys were like well we'll just let them have it then cat reluctantly decided to not tell us anything about that she was also secretly competing i didn't mean to um but even then it's just like okay like all the really i mean the frustration was more of the principle not the fact that i was losing that because all i didn't get was a ruby like cause i still beat you so i still got to go up cat got to go up because she'd be both of us and got a ruby so it's not that's it's not that super powerful but that's the thing each one of these which is a game or in games that i really like each one of these has a valid strategy versus like oh well that's the obvious strat if we play this i'm never not going to go that strat right so and i mean it's still like you know it's a pull it's a random bowl exactly i mean i mean they all have different effects like you know my yellows could have been really sexy if i just pull them after the white right but i never did like once or twice right and then but you also have the flask yeah that helps right it's a once in a lifetime [ __ ] like if you can't get a goddamn really save your life right if you don't
build green right and end on a [ __ ] green um i i like the green that's like promotes you what you want me to quit early no that's for [ __ ] oh i didn't even read this this part oh um did we do something no i don't even know what that says but i uh the what was i gonna say um oh yeah i remember what i was looking at for the final um let's see okay i was basically checking to see if you could spend rubies um oh yeah at the end of the turn players can carry out the following actions more than once by spending rubies so there is a valid strategy with this one because or purple because you'll get a lot of rubies you can do this multiple times if you spend six rubies you move your potion up three times yeah so there is a strategy with the rubies hell even end game strategy with the rubies um just like save them up yeah just save them up and i like that now the elephant in the room is the ketchup mechanic that is thrown in this game which you suffered from the whole which i suffered from the whole game but actually i started off losing and then i took off um i don't like it any kind of ketchup mechanic like that when you're in first place you feel like uh exactly it's not fair exactly yeah i mean it felt like it was very nice no here's what i mean here's the point that i wanted to make so
as we saw in the game i mean yes you kept your lead i mean we got our our boons that kind of kept us within like the same rank as you on on the uh on the potion like fullness level yeah but like you still if anything that kept us about in the same neck when it came to what we were gaining from the pot itself yeah and but you still benefited from your engine build which was your purples and your blacks and getting little points here and there and your rupees and whatnot i mean thus proving like uh your build was still working right despite our catching mechanics so i felt like it was executed very nicely right the point i'm making is it still feels shitty being in first i got you that's what i'm saying i mean i'm not saying it didn't work i mean it very much did you guys were still on par able to keep roughly around you know if i was making it to 30 you guys would be around 30 right or 20 or whatever um or like the high 20s i'm not saying that'll work i'm just saying that a ketchup mechanic always feels shitty it happens in power grid power grid the first player is heavily nerfed because they get knocked back i still want empower grid by staying at first and people getting the free resources or cheaper resources and card card drawers i'm just saying it feels shitty because of this reason i because of my build i had to work for i mean not really you don't really work for anything you get a lot of all these cards or just take three fours take take free get 10 points for free you
know just these free cards here i'm just saying that it's like through through the situation i have to spend my rubies to bump up i have to go for black and spend my ten points to bump up so i have to spend instead of getting a level two eight or green for eight i had to spend the ten to try and beat out cat who got three to bump up so it's like i had to put an effort to do that and it's like oh okay yeah also through randomness is the only reason i was ahead you know because of the random draw comes around that it turns out that it's like oh okay well i'm gonna place my rat and uh with you i ended up at 11 and it's like okay well what do you want okay uh i'm at i'm at four i get to go up to 15. and then the final card where it's like it's doubled this is like it it rewards shitty players no even with that i i just i mean i get it if you think that it feels shitty but uh i i felt like it was executed pretty well and it kept a decent balance right i mean you certainly won so uh and i felt like i was still kind of involved no that's okay that's great yeah but i'm not saying it didn't work i'm just saying being in first it's just like why do you guys get something for free it's the capitalist mentality you're very heavy liberal you're very heavy liberal you don't want to you don't want to work you want free [ __ ] i put in all the effort why should i have to suffer for you being inadequate and that's what this
game this is a very heavy liberal game um no but i know that that's a complaint for a lot of people i'm not saying that it's not an efficient ketchup mechanic i'm just saying that it's not that i felt cheated ever it's just like huh okay well i worked to get to 11. you guys just got to 15 for free all right cat what do you think of the ketchup mechanic i mean pretty much um that uh i i understand both sides of it like wow i'm sorry it's because i'm a libra it's cause you're heavy libertarian you can't even pick a side there's only two sides cat democrat and republican you can't be in the middle okay make this game all about politics so but did you like it yeah um i mean i i didn't have a personal problem with it especially when i started to catch up like you're supposed to with a ketchup mechanic and i was like oh oh now i'm only getting three right um and it's kind of like well that makes sense because now i'm doing well yeah i'm not too salty about it what would have really pissed me off is because of the ketchup mechanic i started losing that would be [ __ ] up yeah because it's like okay now you just gained all these points because like what could have happened to you i mean this game's all random i mean yeah because there's a very variance in the how far you go i mean right but it's like okay well if all the car if all the stuff that i worked for by spending don't pan out and i bust and then it's like oh man because i was all the way at 20
with my thing i got to go higher than you not because you could pull the same thing that i pull and still get higher than me because of the free ketchup mechanic kit right i gotcha and what i'm a little higher i mean the spread i think compensates for it enough with like the randomness of how far we're gonna go i mean we still accumulate i mean a varying amount of points it's usually we're accumulating around the same amount of points yeah and i feel like we there's enough of a spread that it doesn't cause too much of a problem
okay you know what i like to say agree to disagree i mean we're obviously not gonna agree i still end up winning even with the ketchup mechanic i'm just saying it's there there is a catching mechanic and it's a complaint or not by numerous people yes yes that is that was actually specifically what i was told by multiple people before even playing this game was it's extremely luck heavy and the major complaint is the ketchup mechanic for it which i think they made a variant for but i don't don't quote me on that part um i'd have to play it more times to give you more succinct dance right maybe if you were in the lead the whole time maybe and i was just like oh man what really does suck taking the lead oh man i'm not in the lead anymore because that ketchup mechanic very heavily favored that person once but it didn't you're in the lead you're in the lead at the beginning like i got touched like a [ __ ] point for like one [ __ ] round you were waiting uh what do you guys think of the event cards i liked them i thought they were okay i like the purple ones i i we only drew purple yeah no we have three like three blue we have three blue i like the purple ones they were literally right here i guess yeah at the end of the round all flasks get a free refill in this round extra chip is moved one extra space forward and then strong ingredient that was the very first one we drew beginning with this if you stopped with it out and explosion you draw the five chips you
may place one of them in your pot uh and then the rest of them all five of them were or uh or purple so so yeah and then yeah then you have the other one double the ingredients i like them i think uh i mean this game is just once again it won the kenner spiel it's a kid's game and that's why the heavy cheaty ketchup mechanic is in there to make your kids feel better when you stomp them you play with your kids and you're like god you're at five points i'm at thirty jeez okay well put your rat thing up to 90 and win get a free 15 points um your participation points anyway the game is a lot of fun i like to push your luck i would have liked to push your luck to be a little bit more involved they were only centered around whites yeah i didn't feel like um i remember even saying like okay if we actually explode like we stopped like yeah that's it like we just stopped and you don't get to roll the die yeah the darts is nice it is yeah i mean it it's just i mean frankly i think that's what kept you kind of crawling ahead despite our ketchup mechanic was you kept you consistently rolled the dice i also never pushed my luck yeah like the whole game you yeah you also were if i got to seven or six i'm just like boop you were a lot ahead of us too so i so you could be like yeah i mean it's a free ruby or free points free pumpkin free blood drop move whatever um i think the die is fun uh but yeah i
definitely like what would be the oh all right yeah they definitely changed so the set one for like the green for example is for each green ship you know in the last next you get a ruby the level two already is already busier like for each green chip that is last or next to last shipping take one of the indicated ingredients so you just get free chips if it's a level one you get a pumpkin level two you get a blue or red level three or level four you get a yellow or a purple what was the other one what's the level two blue level two blue if the pot explodes within the next one two or four chips you get victory points and money during the evaluation phase so it's incentivizing youtube pop yeah yeah what's the black the black level two is if you draw as many black chips as the other player moves up if you draw oh sorry that's for uh number players yeah sorry the the orange and black are always in play gotcha but yeah your yellows that you went heavy on if the next if the next chip that is placed is moved ahead twice as far as its number indicates so it affects your next chip so like the next chip that is placed is moved ahead twice as far as this number indicates so the r4 moves eight nice that's pretty good the purple you may exchange the purple chips in your pot for the indicated bonus oh so they're they're like so you turn in one for a black a point in a ruby no so just having them yeah and then there's so there's level that was this is set one then there's set two there's three and four for each of them so
that's pretty cool nice that's pretty cool oh they all actually have names there is the crow skull which is blue toadstool which is red mandrake yellow uh african death's head hawk hawk moth for black garden spider for green and then ghost's breath for purple so those those were all those what was the pumpkin pumpkin um i don't know any complaints from you guys to quell your thing the the ketchup mechanic is actually not not a complaint on my end i'm just saying this still feels shitty so a complaint well no because it didn't work and uh devin so i mean devin's making all the correct points he's saying it kept like if if that wasn't in here like you guys would be consistently where if you don't actively move it you guys would be around 20 or whatever like so it definitely works i'm just saying the feeling isn't nice when you're in first but i'm that's for any game with any ketchup mechanic for the first player gotcha so i'm agreeing with you okay but the feeling that the point i was making was the feeling isn't fun but that's a thing to this is people's complaints that's for any ketchup mechanic in any game gotcha so we're on the same point okay dj khaled it's suffering from success i can't believe i made a [ __ ] political connection with the [ __ ] ketchup mechanic in a kids game you can't escape it i'm so lazy it's not
my birth or the poor family or anything oh jeez where's your hand outside there's your 17 rat tails yes okay let's go i can really catch up with that guy who's got a billion goddamn dollars someday i'll be as rich as big babies where's my billion did you have any complaints yeah what were your complaints the fact that you couldn't cheat in this game without getting called out yeah no i really did not mean for it to be afraid to go like that um no i just was consistently confused and uh i tried listening so hard and clarifying so many times um about like the drop movement and just like movement in general because i think it uh is odd that it's always like one step ahead yeah um that was just that was it did not click with my little uh auditions hard well it was just stupid it's like okay i landed on 30 oh and the next one is what you get yeah because i was like why can't you just be the one i landed on i like that i thought that was easy well i mean everyone in a game where it's uh you know uh you want it well a lot of things are covered up you don't want to move a lot of [ __ ] around yeah yeah and i guess that being it's going to be open because it is the one yeah so that way you're not like you know oh oh no oh no right you really need that green so you're
like oh no oh sh oh no no i'm all oh man green okay right um yeah so there's also a game variation [ __ ] crazy oh yeah that's what i was about to explain i was like yes yeah the game variation um from game to game choose a different set of ingredient books the ingredients have each set with uh have been selected so that they blend well with one another but more experience can also put together their own sets so essentially you kind of fill up your these vials with like ingredients um so the board's nice and aesthetic it's i i actually i like the game i really like my um quite a bit i like to like my bowl so on the scale of one to ten devin i'm gonna give it a big fat eight eight you know ten awesome even though you [ __ ] the bad nomination you were the only one and that was actually through your own you didn't even push your luck to bust that well i had that one really bad one i mean you you had a solid lead there and that was because like i was ignoring the dice right i mean oh oh i will play you know i was i took part in my own failures so um no it was a cute game i liked it yeah it had good strategies to it um it's enough luck to keep it interesting yeah so yeah i would definitely like i would play this again i will probably buy this game really yeah i think there's an expansion out for it too oh cool um if i'm not mistaken once
again i don't know for some reason i just don't remember if there's a variant for the ketchup or if there's an expansion i don't know um but yeah i could definitely see why i won the the kendrick spiel cat what are you at i think i was also going to give it an 8. i like it awesome um yeah i am right there with you guys i think an 8 out of 10 is is a really good a really good score for it if there is an expansion i'm probably going to get it i'm excited to play with different sets um i think it'd be interesting to do the game variation where because you don't have to do set one overall book set two for all books you can have a set four for red and things like that and it'd probably be perfectly fine they even said hey like they each set each set has been selected so that they blend well with one another so maybe that's why but you could have a swinging game put them all in right uh god so yeah and just nice aesthetics they have an almanac of what each of the things do which is heavily missing in a lot of games where it's like because i was actually double checking throughout the game that okay well technically you don't draw you know the bag it says draw four pick one and place it so i was like okay that could be a technicality i then draw it to do the ability you know how we were stacking the blues together it doesn't even say if the newly laid ship has also has bonus it can also be carried out immediately thank you thank you northstar games for putting in clarification for the different books uh
yeah so eight out of ten for quacks of quedlinberg for all of us let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you