Citadels - Boardgames 4K Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally like to talk aloud bollocks but tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking about a classic character selection game by Bruno for Doogie - his name is and we'll be talking about Citadel's and in this game you will be selecting characters that will give you a special ability you'll be taking money trying to build districts that will give you more points than anyone else that will allow you to win the game so in this video we'll be giving you a very brief overview the rules would be telling you what we do like don't like and we'll come back I will tell you whether or not Citadel's it's still worth playing ten years after it was first released in 2010 so remember if you are newer and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in our section down below we'll see you after this so see those how did you play this game so said those comes with a bunch of character cards it comes with a bunch of district art and what you're going to do you're gonna shuffle the eight different character cards and it will take a
random card to place it facedown in the center of the table and this card will be hidden throughout a gun so you don't really know which characters are in a game and which ones been put to one side so next when you do the oldest player will look through all the different characters and they'll choose one and put it facedown in front of them and then I'll pass the character deck to the player on their left and then they will choose a character and then we'll go around and till everybody has chosen a character or until all characters have either in the senator table or been chosen or whatever versus no characters left so all the characters have a number from one to eight and this is the order in which they'll be activated once you're in the next phase and they also all have a special ability so we'll give you a quick run through of which characters are in the core game of cerdo so don't bother with the bonus characters that are included in this game i so here are the core characters so character number one is the assassin and this card will allow you to nominate another character that will be basically taken out of game when they are activated so it's nice and simple yeah basically you can eliminate a character and of player who it's character is eliminated we'll miss the eternal city of the game until the next round so number two is the FIFA and what you'll do you'll nominate a character and when they are activated you will announce who it is and then when that coat has activated you'll Nick all of that lovely juicy gold did I got stashed away under
their mattress and our main so number three is the magician and what you can do you can exchange all the cards in your hand with somebody else's cards regardless of how many you got and how many I got or you can discard a certain number of cards up to you how many discard to control how many replacement cards from the deck of district cars won't so number four is the king I'm what you do you'll get one Gold fool every yellow district card that is in the game right and these district cards have got suit they've got color right and as far those and also they've got enough points value this down the side we got remember you can never have to identical types of districts in your city so the king will give you one gold for every yellow district this in you'll see and you'll also get the first player token which is that weird-looking yellow thing that looks like a piece of mutated sweet corn so number five is the bishop and you'll get one gold for every religious or blue district in your city and you've got the added bonus of your districts not being able to be destroyed by the warlord and that is power for so number six is the merchant and you'll get one gold for every trading green districts in your city and also once you've taken an action which we'll talk about after this then you get to take an extra gold so it's a good way of building out your gold supply in it so number seven is the architects and you get to draw two additional district cards on your return and also you can build three districts
on your turn rather than one I mean if you if you want to be a bit of flush get bit real estate on jubail the architects are black to go to in it so number eight and the final character we're going to talk based the warlord and you'll get one gold for every military all red districts in your sea and you'll also get the choice of destroying another districts even your own or somebody else's and all you got to do is you got pay one less gold than what that district is worth and you'll just destroy it so having your finger on the red button in it so once everyone's got a character all two characters if you're playing a free player or North Platte variant then what you'll do or in your turn you'll get to take an action and you've got two choices when you take a nation you can either take to gold Stroud a bank or you can decide to draw two cards from the district deck choose one to put in your own and then choose one to stick under the deck and discard it you know I mean so the second thing you can do when you'll turn is you get the choice to build a district card all you got those you've got paid of money that's on the card and you'll put it face out in front and that will be part of you will see in some of the purple cards have got special abilities so you might have the Great War and it says the cost for the warlord to destroy any of you other districts is increased by one gold or you may be choose to build the library in which case if you choose to draw cards or when you take an action you get to keep both the card so you have drawn my sass were really powerful so these purple cards do ramp up the tension in this game quite
being on me so each character latrice it's got a special ability you can use at any time when you're term you can use it once and then step four once all the characters are mccord you go through from one to eight and they'll all be returned to the deck and you'll go again until someone has built their eight districts you'll finish the round and then your go to building game score and you know me so you hand out all the points that is on your districts in your addemup if you've got at least one districts in order five Karla then you'll get an extra three points who is first to build a district will get another four points and all the other players and manage to get eight districts in but after the first player called about districts in will get in our two points and a player with the most points you'll be the winner I've said those so what do we like about said Alice first finger we like about this game is to his scales really really well you can play this with two players okay that's not ideal but when you get into three players to up to eight players it works really well with all Perkins mr. Fuji has been kind enough to present us with some really really well worked out variants that allow three players seven players to play this game adequately well and when you play three players all you going to do is that you're going to have to roll cards instead of one and it works really really well so to gain the scale surprisingly well for a tiny little card game of this you know so the second thing that we like about said that was is that I only do you get the core game with the eight characters but it also
gives you some extra bonus characters and it also gives you some extra bonus buildings so some of the bonus characters you've got you go to which and it says after you take an action announce the top of another coat oh you wish to be which in an immediately annual turn whenever which character is called upon this player must show his character card take an action and then immediately end his turn which character cannot use his characters ability before you take open or mean so that's quite powerful where you've got the Emperor as well so you receive one goal for each noble yellow district in your city and when the Emperor is called you immediately take the crown from the player who has it and give it to a different player the player who receives a crown can choose to give you evil one gold or one district from their hand it goes on there is another nine maybe ten if you conclude the I stand the Queen together there's ten extra characters and the fact that you've got like basically one Mouse to an expansion in the call box way is phenomenal value for money so per duper so the first thing that we really like about Citadel's is that you get this feeling that you really wanna take control of every character in the game you know I mean when you actually saw on a plan what you're gonna do and whatever applies are going to do you're thinking I really want the assassin you know cuz I really need to make sure that I'll kill off that fief because I've got a heap of gold yet but you also want to use that gold to build as many districts so you can see your fingers you're like at a architect as well so you your constantly trying to wipe up what's best for you and also what is gonna deprive the other
pious of doing you damage and there's this lovely sort of binary opposition in choices you're thinking am I gonna take a calculated risk or is that calculate risk actually just a foolhardy gamble and that's a--that's a really really nice tussle you gotta come to terms with in your mind when you're playing this game and that's really fantastic we're really really like about these small selection games especially said those so the final thing that we really like about Citadel's is that it's not the first player that gets to eight districts it's gonna win the game it's the player who has the most points so if you go mental and you stick to yours five or six link buildings you might only have maybe three or four in and that could still win you the game is you only gonna take the architects maybe once or twice or maybe you're just gonna go all out and build as many two or three point buildings as you can I'm gonna get you a lot gold with the King and with the bishop and all that sort stuff so in fact that it's not a race to see who can build as many buildings as quickly as possible it's who can be most efficient when they're building buildings and that's that's really good way so what don't we like percentiles so the first thing that we don't know about said though is the fact that when you take your turn and so connection you can just scoop up two gold now seems like a sort of bit of a cop-out you know what it feels like to us that you just sort of the designer was just thinking you know holy that it's not enough
golden a time what could we do I will have an option to just take to go from the bank home why why would you take to why would you just get to gold I mean okay you say well it's income but you've got the option taking it so for matically that makes no sense and pay it might be it easy way to get money in the window shopping again but for matically that doesn't make any sense to us so angle clue so second thing that we don't like about sit those is it can drag on a little bit too long so listening to all mate in the pub tell the story and it just goes on and on and on and you end up thinking oh my god - Paolo - tell him to shut that up you know and this game wast is fun it may be a districts was a little bit of a stretch you know because this game can drag on we've played this for nearly an hour I know it's a horror show but that is a reality that sometimes especially when you've got a warlord in play court beer which is going to destroy a few districts that could lead to you banging your head against a brick wall so the final thing that we don't like about Citadel's is that you're gonna have to get yourself a really decent player hoping you get this for the first time because there are quite a few exceptions is quite difficult well it's but for us it is because we're stupid but it's quite difficult to remember what each character does and what the exceptions are when you activate them because I think one of them is where you can't do
something to the assassin order player that the assassin is targeting or something like that and we always forget that and we could be downloaded play right and some of these nuances weren't on the play around it's like oh crap and they're in the rulebook of course so you got to be passing this rulebook around when your first player and you know okay so minor quibble but it's still pain in the neck nonetheless so to summarize is citadel's worth playing today and in the future so we're going to say yes we enjoy Citadel's to this day we've been playing this for donkey's years and will continue to play till the cows come back it's a groundbreaking classic that redefined what could be done with these Bowl selection games took the order from Puerto Rico with the world selection and it picked up and ran with it you know that role selection mechanism morphed into something new and fresh and it could be seen as slightly dated because subsequent games like maybe mission trip planner and masquerade which is also designed by Bruno for duty he's sort of took the same sort of thing and it sort of improved on it it's somewhat that's another video it's still fun it's still a wonderful game recently reprinted a years ago in like a big box version which we had a look at but said those we're gonna give it a 4/5 we still really enjoy this tool this or mayor game it goes on in your head where you trying to second-guess what your opponents are trying to do so there you go that's it though so remember if you know it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in our section down below we'll see you next
time