Skip to main content
Loading video...

Yedo Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 10:25

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings which you really like to talk a load of bollocks a tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a worker placement auction game we're going to be talking about edo and in this game you will be placing your workers out onto the ball to take actions that will give you resources that will allow you to complete missions that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of also telling you what we do like we don't like then we'll come back and tell you whether or not edo is still worth your time with bother ten years after it's first released in 2012 so remember if you are new it please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button subscribe and all that youtube see you after this bollocks so edo how'd you play this game so edo is an auction worker placement game this game is split into seven phases the first phase is the prep phase where you'll be setting up for the oncoming round right the next phase is the bidding phase this is where you'll be bidding on a load of stuff that's going to give you action cards that you can use to disrupt people's plans you'll be bidding on bonus cards that will give you extra points for doing stuff at the end of the game you'll be bidding on a selection of weapons you'll be bidding on a load of annexes which are extra places where you can send your workers you might be

bidding on geisha you might be able to get extra workers and you'll be bidding on the chance to grab extra mission cards which is where you'll be getting the bulk of your resources and maybe victory points as well yorkshire is a little bit different to a lot of the other types of auctions you'll find in games the player that's furthest up on the billing track will always go further if they don't win the auction they'll go first again right once everybody has got something at the auction or they suffered from premature evacuation then you'll move on to the event phase you'll do the usual thing you'll remove some weapons from the weapons array and you'll repopulate it and then you'll reveal an event card and these are usually bad there's two types of events there's extra nasty events that you can put in the samurai events these are generally really really bad but we don't usually play with these because the game's hard enough as it is so you might have by order of the bakufu it says in player order each player might gain the top mission card from the mission deck of their choice or you might pull out the new moon and this says if the watch patrol ends its movement in the district containing any disciples these disciples escape arrest or you might have charity week and this says the red light district is inaccessible this round which is always disappointing so these events are generally pretty bad right so next thing you're going to do is you're going to move on to the assigning phase and this is where you'll be placing your workers out onto the central board to take actions once everybody has used all their workers then you move on to the watch patrol phase you'll see that there is a geyser that goes round around circles in the center of the board it's a bit like my life being stuck on a bloody island but you do you move them

to the next available space everybody gets a chance to play action cards that might interfere with his motives and then he'll arrest anybody that's in the district that he is in you have got a blackmail card that you'll be able to use to blackmail the guard but i'm sure you'll think of something if you get arrested you'll go to prison if you've only got two disciples then they'll just go back to playable then you've got the trade phase if you're in the marketplace or the tavern district you'll be able to trade with other players that are in the same district and then you'll move on to the action phase where you'll be pulling the workers off the board to take the different actions so there are a gazillion and one options here we're not going to go through all of them just going to go through a couple because i don't want you dying in your sleep so if you look at the gates district you might want to recruit an extra disciple for seven quid the talent district lets you build an annex for 11 money you can pretend to go to church and steal all their cash if you go to the harbour district at a red light district you can pay eight money to hire a geisha right you better buy weapons at the market district and in the castle district you'll be able to manipulate turn order so one of the other options you've got in the actual phases instead of taking the action on the location you're at you get to fulfill one of these mission cards right you'll see there's varying degrees of difficulty the green cards are the easiest the black cards are the artist and you'll see there are some requirements on each mission you'll have to have a disciple in a certain location that's listed on the card it'll ask you for a certain amount of resources you might want to complete the learn what will be on the taverns menu next week

you have to have a giza in the tavern district and this will give you five victory points there's also a bonus reward if you can fulfill the bonus requirements and this one if you've got a bloke in the red light district you'll get an extra five coins there is a black card here that will end the game prematurely if you manage to kill the shogun by having a bloke in four different districts two gosha you have to give up 10 money two annexes you have to have a blessing and three weapons this will give you 14 victory points and two bonus cards and it'll end the game doesn't mean you're going to win the game it's sneaky little you still have to win it via points when you always won you'll keep doing this you'll keep putting your workers out the board you keep trying to bit on the auctions the game says it lasts for 11 rounds so this is far too long right you're going to give yourself a brain aneurysm but you'll keep doing this once you've completed the set number of rounds you will look at your bonus cards you'll fulfill them you get victory points if you haven't used your blackmail card you get two points and then the player with the most victory points will be the winner of edo so what do we like so the first thing that we really like about this is the board it looks absolutely gorgeous done it right the colors on the board are absolutely super the artwork on the board is absolutely fantastic the ball might be a little bit too big you're going to be reaching over the ball quarterbacks it is quite wide a lot of the areas aboard are just taken up by houses that don't do nothing right this is still one of the most beautiful looking balls that we have seen the colors are really vibrant really really tasty so second thing we like about this game is that there is a huge range of options to take some people that i've played this with say

that there are too many options available but a lot of these options are just maybe taking the cards and shuffling them and placing them back on the respective deck right there's a nice contrast between the cheap but dangerous nature of the auction it's not worth putting all your eggs into the auction basket because you might not be able to afford it or even get anywhere near what you want but there's more reliable sources of resources in the main board but it's going to cost you a lot more money so there's a nice synergy going on with what's on the north side of the river and what's on the south side of the river so the first thing we really like about this game is that turns come round really really quickly because this game is divided up into seven relatively short phases it's not like merchants marauders when you do the port action where everybody's going to go through all these steps and it just drags and drags and drags and it feels like you're wading through a quagmire cow no this game is really really quick it's very very clever more often than you'll be putting something out on the board you'll be saying i want to bid this or you'll be taking something off you'll be taking a reward so there's not a lot of down time in this game it's just the downtime comes from people not using the time i got to figure out what they want to do beforehand some people can just look at the board and go into freeze frame mode right so what don't we like about edo so the first thing that we don't like about this game is it's too bloody long 11 rounds is far too long it's gonna take you about four hours to get through this beast but then six rounds is too short even nine rounds doesn't give you enough time to gain the momentum to complete those more lucrative mission cards so there's this weird disconnect between the mission cards needing you to

take your time to get the resources because it's not really an engine building game right and the length of time it takes to actually play the bloody thing so the second thing that we don't like about edo it is very very frustrating this leads on from the last point where the game requires you to take time to build up your resources and just when you want to pull the trigger to chain all those actions together somebody steps in and buggers you up with either an action card or they take the spot that you've been playing and go to for the last five rounds and then the game's over so the board is literally like a brick wall that keeps asking you to bang your head against so the third and final thing that we don't like about erlo is that the payoffs on the mission cards are really really feeble i mean this game is all about getting victory points but it's not until you get into the red or black cards that they're going to be providing you with fidget points and like we said these are really really difficult to complete unless you're playing the really long game which is going to drive you at the wall the green and yellow cards don't really focus on future points they focus on resources i know over the long game you're going to be completing the easier mission cards to get resources to complete the later ones but the black and red cards are so bloody difficult to complete because people keep disrupting your plans with action cards and even the events are going to disrupt your plans as well so there's too many competing factors to make this game flow as well as it should do so to summarize it's edo still worth your time on bother today and in the future so we're going to say probably not i'm not saying this is a bad game it's just that we played similar games that are better than this one

it's a decent enough euro that hides a lot of its frustrations behind a pretty looking board the myriad of options that this game seems to offer is ultimately hindered by too many obstacles being put in your path too often add to that the unsatisfying payoff on a lot of the mission cards and it's clear to me that the negatives of this game far outweigh the positives if you're looking for a game at this top i'd highly recommend checking out lords of what the or francis strike they've both got the same type of mechanisms the auction system in this is quite similar to the plymouth section of francis drake and lords of water deep just seems to have a nicer flow to it doesn't feel bitty or as frustrating so such we really can't recommend eddo if you really must play this just go and find yourself a brick wall and start head buying it so there you go that's eddie remember if you're new and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button subscribe and all that youtube we'll see you next time

you

Progress saved