Board Game of the Year 2026 | Who Should Win? Who Will Win? | Spiel Des Jahres 2026
Transcript
Ditto. Jinx You owe me a show soda. That type of thing.
A soda.
Yeah, like
a pop.
No, the saying is Jinx, you owe me a soda.
A Coke. You mean?
No.
Hello everybody. My name is Ilia.
And my name is Tyler. Together makeup com. A couple that loves to play board games
and evaluate board games and make predictions with our brains.
We are here to make predictions as we have been doing for the last few years.
Is this our fourth year or fifth year?
I think it's our fourth year. But what exactly are we going to be making predictions about? Well, we are making our predictions on the winner of the spiel dearis.
Now, what is this award, Tyler?
It is the Germany board game of the year award. And realistically, it's the board game of the year award.
It is. It is the most prominent award a board game can possibly receive. Some of your favorite games have likely received this award if you know about them. And generally, it's one that's very coveted and everyone strives to go for. So, the nominees are always hot and piping. And we are here to predict who will win and who should win.
Sometimes they're the same. Sometimes there's they're different. You're going to have to stick around and find out.
I will say I have gotten it right for who will win.
Every single time.
Every single time.
I was wrong last year.
So, every year there's a little bit more pressure.
Mhm.
Because in the beginning it doesn't matter if you can predict one or two years. I think this year is going to be very easy for me to be honest. But let's see if my who and should win will line up. With that said, let's bring on the nominees to the table. Bam.
And voila, we have three games.
Three very prominent nominees for the Spiel Desarus.
Did you know that this award originated in 1979?
Wow. Fun fact.
That's older than me. Not Tyler, though.
Well, we're going to begin by giving you a brief overview of each of the games. how they play and the core functions of maybe why they were nominated this year.
Where should we get started?
Morty Sorty.
Let's do it. Now, in Morty Sord's Magic Shop, you'll be drafting magical ingredient jars and carefully organizing them on your personal shelf. Each jar has a value, an ingredient, and a lid color. And all three of these matter. Values in every row on your shelf must increase left to right, while the lid color determines where the jar can be placed. Gold jars can go anywhere. Silver jars limited to the middle and the bottom rows, while black jars are only placed in the bottom row. Every round, you'll be evaluating which jar best fits your plans, while knowing any unclaimed jars are removed from the game forever. As you build your display, you'll be pursuing multiple scoring opportunities at once. Creating columns with three different ingredients unlocks powerful special jars that can be placed in any row, helping you overcome tricky placement restrictions. Throughout the game, you'll also collect magical kittens by passing at the right time, completing rows on your shelf or and being the first player to claim certain achievements. These kittens can be spent to bend the rules, allowing you to flip a newly acquired jar to its opposite side or place matching values next to one another. Once there are no longer enough jars remaining to create a full display, the game will end and players will score points for completed shelf rows, ingredient collections, shelf objectives, achievements, and any kittens they have left over. The player with the most stars is named Morty Sordy's top apprentice.
Top apprentice.
The best.
Now, let's move on to Cozy Stickerville. In Cozy Stickerville, you'll work together to build a village over the course of 10 years. Each year, you'll uncover new events, make decisions that shape the future of your town, and place stickers directly onto the map to watch your village grow. There are no winners or losers here. Instead, the focus is on creating a story together, developing your community, and seeing how your choices impact the people and places of Stickerville. On your turn, you'll draw an event card that presents a new opportunity, challenge, or story moment. Then you'll take an action to expand your village, develop new locations, or continue on an ongoing storyline. As the years pass, you'll gain resources, welcome new residents, unlock milestones, and make permanent changes to the map. By the end of the campaign, you'll have created a cozy village that's completely unique to your group with an ending shaped by the decisions you've made along the way.
Along the way, that's cozy sticker.
Cozy cozy. And last, we have Jinxo or Ditto as known in some countries.
Yes, in Jinxo, you'll be trying to think just enough like the other players to score points, but not so differently that your answers end up all alone. Over three rounds, you'll fill up your boards with answers to series of prompts. Then, you'll take turns revealing them one by one. The catch here is that the best outcome isn't having everyone matching your answer. Instead, it's finding one person, your BFF. If exactly one other player wrote the same answer as you, you both shout jinx, meaning you'll score extra points for that answer. As answers are revealed, you'll be looking for those ideal onetoone matches while also trying to complete rows and columns on your board for additional points. Once the round is over, you'll repeat this twice more. Will your answers be unique? Will you stand alone? Or will you find your BFF along the way?
Yeah, high five.
BFF's baby. Let's go.
Now, with all that out of the way, these are the three nominees. They are legends of 2026. They will go down forever in history.
Yes,
cuz being nominated is great in itself.
Although, there can only be one winner.
There can be only one.
And today we will tell you in our format who should win the spiel dearis and who will win it.
Mhm. The difference being who should is more likely our opinion than anything. Whereas who will is we've taken into consideration like the broader aspects of everything.
Who should win is fact cuz our opinions are fact.
I mean yes our opinions are facts.
Where should we start?
Well, obviously with who should win.
Okay. Ready? We always point at the same time.
Ready?
Yeah.
Three, two, one.
Okay. You're probably thinking party game, the spiel has been won so many times by party games. Well, because the essence of the award is the celebration of games. We want to find games that will bring more people into our hobby so we can build board gaming as a grander hobby and this game exemplifies that to the team.
Now, initially, what I I guess do you want to go first in explaining or do you want me to go first?
No, go ahead.
Okay. Initially, when I first because I always read the rule books. They announce all the nominees. I'll read the rule books and I make my first impressions. I will say I discounted this one slightly
because it doesn't seem that different. You're going to write answers. You're going to see who you match with. You're going to see where the commonalities are. You'll have conversations about there's a lot of games that do that in the genre. What makes this game uniquely special is the way you reveal your answers. Yes,
because there is that unique element of where do you put things on your 3x3 grid? There is some strategy to it where your confidence can lead you to put something where you can potentially score more points from rows and columns. But the decision of which of your answers you want to read to see if it matches the room is particularly interesting because you have the choice to be, hey, do I want to say something that I know everybody's going to say? Then we're all going to raise our hands. We're going to circle our answers. We're going to cheer. or am I feeling vulnerable? Do I want to maybe say my riskier answer and really hope that someone knows the '7s movie that I'm referencing and that we can be bffs and I'm going to say it and oh my goodness, I match
or you did not.
I am a BFF. I get the star and it just feels good. And the pacing of it, how quickly it goes. It's the scoring is almost an interactive experience in itself.
Yeah. which is the main reason why I think this game should win the game.
I the
I will like push that a little because I kind of disagree. I like that we get to announce all of that stuff. It's fun, but I think sometimes it can be a little dragged out. It is really fun when there's like three prompts because you're never going to mention the prompts again. So like something I put down on my board might have been for prompt one, but the same thing could have been put down by Ilia and that could have been for prompt three. So there's like really fun interactions or the common joke is like there was a fears one and something and something about eating the type of food you like. Somebody put apples and they're like who's afraid of apples? So like there's a lot of table talk that happens around the table that is quite enjoyable, gets a lot of laughs. My thing with this game is it's extremely approachable. I think that it's taking something we all know quite well and flipping it on its head.
And the nostalgia, especially for me, of having that Jinx or like ditto jinx you owe me a show soda. That type of thing.
A soda.
Yeah. Like
a pop.
No, the saying is Jinx, you owe me a soda.
A coke. You mean?
No. But anyways, I think that this game does a really good job with the prompts. And I think that it creates like a lot of fun table talk while being approachable, while being easy to learn, while being pretty replayable. And all of those things are things that the judges will look for when they're evaluating who should win this award.
I think the prompts in this game are particularly extremely well written. There's some really clever stuff in here that I have not seen in other games like this.
Okay, moment of truth. So, we think JO should win. Why should it win over
the other two?
Yep.
Well, I had more fun playing Jinxo than I did Morty sorty. Let's just say that. I think that this is a party game that I thoroughly enjoyed. I think Morty sorty
just fell a little short for me. I'm not 100% I can't really explain why. I know that sounds really bad, but just from like experience,
it fell short.
It did hit the gut.
It didn't Yeah, it didn't like the initial gut reaction was not there. Okay.
And uh for Cozy Stickerville,
it is a board game, but I think Jinxo is more of a board game. Okay. I know that also seems weird, but this is like a choose your own adventure with stickers on a board. Like if if I was to quickly explain it to people, that's how I would explain it. Okay, Jinxo, I would have to use a I would have to say it is a party game. Like that is how I would start off explaining the game. I think that that um is a good capture of what this is. Of course, I also think that because this game I think this is the most approachable game of the three.
So I agree with that. Yeah,
I think for me the only thing I'll add is one thing. In 20 years, I want this game to be around. I feel like people would play it. I feel like people would have a ton of fun with it. I don't think I can say that for either of these two games.
Fair. Fair. Do you think also that maybe Cozy Stickerville is something that can be recreated?
Yeah, definitely. I think it can be The system is interesting. I want to see what can be done with the system. I don't think it's reached its full potential. Exactly. Well, we're here. The moment of truth. Who will win the spiel dearis?
I don't know.
Raise your finger.
3 2 1 Oh, that was a nice simultaneous finger tap.
I think that was mostly just you. I like love tapped it.
Let's see.
Love poked it.
That's not how you did it. Instant replay. Why do you think cozy sticker will veil? I cannot say veil.
Cozy stickerville will win.
Why do I think it will win?
Yes.
I think the masses have spoken.
The masses have spoken.
Honestly though, I think that there have has been such a huge crowd behind Cozy Stickerville, both in the hobby space and like outside of the hobby space. So, I think that speaks volume to what the game is capable of doing. That being said, it is simply put a choose your own adventure put onto a board game. And I think that is a very clever thing. It's one of those like aha moments of, "Oh, hang on. Why hasn't this type of thing been done before? Yes, it is a legacy game. Yes, you can play it cooperatively, but it doesn't give off the same vibe as some of the other like sticker sticker games. This is the main mechanic of this game is putting stickers on things.
Stickering,
right? You you answer questions, you deal with the outcomes, and you put stickers on things.
Should we have a stickering month?
No.
No, because we played this game in two days and that's all we needed.
I think that's what I will say. I think the approachability factor of being able to play a legacy game in a span of a day or two.
I don't even know if we should consider this as a legacy game. Yes, it's one of those games that you can only play twice, but I don't know if it actually like is considered a legacy on its own.
It's sort of like a campaign game, but it's I don't know if campaign games necessarily fall under legacy either.
Fair.
Maybe it's its own on its own little pedestal,
which is another reason why I should win because maybe it's creating its own category.
I think so. I do think what I will say about this game is I do think it felt a little short for me for the storytelling in the game. I think there's a few tropes that I just didn't appreciate. I'm not going to say any spoilers. No spoilers, I guess, but there's some stuff that was not cozy. And for a game that is supposed to be cozy Stickerville.
It's in the name.
It's in the name. Why can't you be cozy? But there's aspects and the bones of this game is really interesting. And I look forward to seeing different implementations and mechanics of this game. Kind of like we mentioned earlier, if it's based on a different IP or maybe there's a different storyline that kind of fine-tunes some of the core mechanics, keeping the same DNA, I feel like that maybe will be more worthy and maybe should win this spiel.
Maybe will win.
Well, this one I think will win regardless, but I don't think it should win.
Ah, there you go.
There you go. Now, lastly, similar question. Why do you think it will win over these two?
I think I've already talked about that. Isn't that what we just answered? I think that the thing about the Cozy Stickerville, even though I would say it's not my favorite amongst the three, I think
the vast majority of people enjoy Cozy Stickerville. That's the game that they want to play out of all three when you line them up. I think based on cover alone, sometimes based on story alone, based on mechanic, like there's a lot of things that it checks off that immediiacy of a customer would be like, "Yeah, I want to play this." So, I think that that has to be taken into consideration, especially the wave that is already that it's already making.
Yeah,
it just has to be taken into consideration.
I think if the jury was to play all three, I think this one does have that immediate like, "Oh, wow. We can actually finish this whole game. Wow, there's so much story. There's so much content. It kind of shine. It's like a big bright light.
It's like, "Hey, look at me. I'm Cozy Stickerville." And then these other two, maybe you'll you'll remember them later on and you'll be like, "Huh, those were pretty great. Why didn't we play more of them?"
Yes.
Which is why I think Jinxo should win. #20-year campaign for Jinxo.
Well, that has been our who should win and who will win the Spiel dearis. Do you agree? Do you disagree? Do you have thoughts? Have you played any of the three? Leave them in the comments down below.
Mhm.
But if you liked this video, make sure you hit that thumbs up button, hit that subscribe button if you new are new here.
If you are new,
if you're new here,
and you can hit that little bell cuz you know when our next videos come out, we can all partake in the joy of board gaming.
Exactly. Well, we have some Kenner Spiel days yus games to play and compare and to critically think about because that's what's coming next.
Stay tuned. But until next time, we'll see you later.
Bye. Yeah.