Skip to main content
Loading video...

Charterstone vs. Village-Building Games (Going Analog: Episode 11)

Transcript 18:13

running a metropolis SimCity cell is a lot of work that's why we have village building games forget about zoning pollution traffic and major disasters just worry about constructing one useful building at a time and maybe trying to find a lost Maggie Simpson once in a while charter stone takes the quaintness of a village building game and puts it into a bigger legacy style campaign that means during and after each session you will permanently alter gameplay by changing the cards adding stickers to the board or opening secret boxes to unlock new components here's a quick spoiler free look at how charter stone works in the beginning of charter stone this is going to be a complete blank slate except for a few starter buildings in each individual charter over here so on your turn you're going to take a meatball one of your workers and place it onto a building so whatever you see on the left is what you're gonna pay so in this case a resource of some sort and on the right will be what you receive in this case a goal the point is basically to build more buildings in the beginning of each session you're gonna receive a certain number of cards some of which may even be stickers so if you have enough resources to build this building you can peel that sticker off and permanently affixed it onto a lot in your charter these buildings will give you new ways to gain more resources gain gold new workers or even gain some reputation in this fair land once somebody wins the session everyone records their progress onto one of these boxes and as you level up you're going to gain bonuses that will carry over from game to game as you

play through each session you're going to unlock new cards components and story all of which will gradually change charter stone as you play through this 12 game campaign but did the going analog reviewers think it was worth the time let's see what they think and but one small warning we do reveal some very slight minor details that some may consider a little spoilery but we promise that it will not ruin the game for you alright guys we just spent a lot of time over the last two three months or so playing this game the most time we've ever invested in a going analog review to play charter sewn this is a legacy game right so this is where there's permanent changes that happen to the game boxes that we unlock things that are gonna be surprises as you play so we're gonna talk a little bit about those things without actually revealing anything of importance okay so let's introduce you guys first Christina you're my co-host on the show and also my lover my wife okay so welcome back to the show and then you're gonna help but you were helping us review this game and you as well Joe you spent a lot of time with us playing these games I did welcome back to the show as well you are one of my co-workers at this unnamed video game company exactly yeah so we don't like to talk about where we work we're not supposed to talk about where we work but you and I work together there and we play a few sneaking a few games here and there at work just a reminder don't look at the cameras so much I'm making sure that I don't pivot my head did that direction

yeah the last time we're here you kind of sneaking off little glances my chain Albert yeah oh yeah it's totally totally okay so let's talk about charge stone all right Christina gave us an introduction about what the games about but what did you guys like Christina why don't you start us off I liked how they spaced out a lot of the discovery throughout this game so I love opening up exactly like exciting subscription boxes and gift boxes and stuff and I think the full the full game involved a lot of discovery of new new turn levels new interesting accessories to your game some exciting discoveries and a story does develop slowly through time but you could strategize the whole time too so I'm very into games where I know at least a few steps ahead not too far ahead and and that scratch match cool how about you Joe to that point it was almost like the perfect onboarding process you know I played tons of games before where the rule book incredibly massive it's very daunting for your first game where you're spending you know upwards of an hour trying to figure out the world and everyone's kind of stumbling the first time through and by virtue of this being in chapters it's almost like they're don't lean out the rulebook a little bits at a time you never feel completely overwhelmed with everything just when you're starting to get kind of comfortable like cool I understand this they introduce new concepts new character new gameplay components and it

doles out in a way that everything always feels fresh it really gets you like invested in like I want to know Western that come wanna see what the next kind of big gameplay element they add to it and again from like a onboarding process it really takes a lot of the drudgery of like having to slog through a rule book before you even start playing the game yeah totally like in the beginning when you first open this up like I'm gonna show it to the camera because I don't think you could read anything from this distance this was mostly blank in the beginning when we first started just a few of these things are filled out and then as the game progresses and open so like open up this card and open up this box and gets a card number 300 whatever and then they're gonna have stickers that you actually add so all of these boxes are additional instructions that are added to the game and then in the back of the book are additional story moments that are added to the game and it's like I thought the same thing like the best thing about this game is there are other legacy games style games but most of them I think are more hardcore than this one this one is like a great way to introduce people to this style of game with like work or placement of like I'm gonna put a guy out there and activate what's happening in that spot but this is a great game to show someone who's kind of new to that genre right because oh you only have to learn a little bit and then the game will teach you more and then more and it just keeps you surprised at all times so yeah totally what else did you think I thought it was really funny when we were setting up for the first time we were like not really sure how this works out but you literally open up the box and you reveal card after card and it it unwinds right in front of you so that

was really exciting yeah that's why I like this right here this is what resets board so we don't spoil anything for anybody but yeah this is edit some raw State on the back of that is our finished game which is like full of stickers and stuff that we've written on and things that we added to this and it's really different from how it looks care you name your village you name all the characters in the game so you end up kind of creating these bundle the moments where you know you name a character lunk for example looks like an offshoot link and it becomes this kind of honey no it becomes this kind of funny joke throughout the game and you create the little moments and these little stories because of the personalization aspect that are always gonna be unique to the people playing that game which you know you wouldn't get obviously we kind of Anan legacy type game so those rooms yeah kind of fun moments to kind of curry along the way I think more than other like sea kings that I played like I played risk legacy a pandemic legacy we played pandemic legacy seasons wanted to the lot of the surprises come at the end of the chapter like if you played one session and it's like now let's open up this a B and C to see what else is revealed that happens but you're also opening stuff as you play like surprises not only per session but within this session there's multiple surprises you might get these cards like oh I'm gonna build this crate and then you have to go into this chart to look up okay what cards do that now reveal and you're gonna adding those cards to your box and then these are permanent characters

you've unlocked or different buildings that you've unlocked and then it's like they have a cool system here to like these boxes your charter chests which is this is what you own and kick take with you it kind of keep throughout the entire campaign and you start to mark your progress as you go along and what skill or what sort of advantages and bonuses that you've unlocked in and you keep those going so mine isn't as cool as yours because I didn't win so many other sessions but it's it's an awesome a thing and all the things that you've unlocked yourself going here as well the one thing I wish I could spoil that I'm not gonna spoil is like there there's one thing that happens pretty late in the game let's say about three quarters of the way through or two-thirds of the way through was like I've never seen this device or this prop used in a game ever it's it's like I don't want to build it up but I pit up too much I'm like this is really cool like the game keeps surprising us like this so yeah lots of cool things that we wish we could talk about but plan again yeah this is you just have to play the game and it's not that long either it's like 12 games in a campaign about an hour per session yeah but the game moves in a pretty relatively brisk speed nothing ever thought like the game for too long David I almost felt like they were looking short at times but yeah they were good like get in a couple of couple in every night which guys think of the artwork super adorbs yeah it's just really really cute these are starting characters so it's not you know spoiling much but you know it's sort of cartoony and cute there's personality to it I think and

it's just very colorful so I was always excited to play it just because of how it looked because I'm superficial yeah I see you're named her Tata because we were watching narcosis on Netflix when we were starting to play this I named mine old whitey which he said was very racist of me I'd say that we're all thinking it so yeah you get to customize game and just have a lot of fun with it and it has that same like city building or village building charm the a lot of games have like this kind of 3/4 perspective of everything with this cute adorable buildings I think it's the arts also super push man all right now let's talk about what we didn't like about the game you know the games that each session maybe is a little bit spoiler but there's an objective that it's different from game to game right and that part is the part that feels different so I'm gonna make it some objectives here it might be like be the person who rolled the dice the most time be the person who places their workers the most time and that's a cool way to kind of change the way that you play I don't think working those strategies in necessarily meant that you won the game and I think there were some tried and true strategies that we were all employing that kind of didn't change her game the game I did find myself changing strategies a lot maybe just because I I like trying to try new things a lot for me what dictated my strategy was more character powers and then sometimes the the main objective there were definitely some things I did the same way and for

me the negative was near the second half or the latter third of of all of our campaigns we had discovered a lot of the boxes so I felt like that that excitement wasn't quite there in the same way so I was changing my wit my playstyle to just try to do interesting things instead mm-hmm and probably maybe like viewers should get more weight to what you're saying because like I got two victories through the campaign how many do you get joke for twice as many as me but thanks thanks for Christina so maybe you knew what you're doing more than us yeah I think I think if anything I would just kind of that would be my complaint was just like it didn't encourage me to kind of break out and try and go visit other areas and kind of explore this world like I said like viewers can't see this but this board is packed full of different buildings by the end like each one of these sections has like six different buildings related right and then those get updated and add more pieces on top of that to add additional buildings even after all the stickers are filled so it's pretty cool but I didn't really explore a lot of it just a little bit here and there but for the most part I kind of stuck to my old village one thing that I think we should have tried out at some point is we didn't try it with the AI mode and you can have the other players who aren't in the game since we had just three players here sort of actually do stuff during the game to make things maybe a little bit harder at least more interesting I have a co-worker who played this game

and said he found that really interesting when they added that in maybe my biggest gripe of the game is kind of tight interconnected is that it I didn't know if it was trying to be a story based game or like a competitive type game and the story while it was interesting and it had a couple twists and turns ultimately didn't feel like it really meant anything I'm like say like a pandemic legacy or even like a time to Tori's where the stories of those games are integral I think it was trying to be both but it didn't really succeed in either of them yeah well said I totally totally agree yeah I feel like the legacy model works so much better when you're cooperative everybody's on the same team and you're unlocking things together the story did feel sort of like an thought and it was interesting and maybe everything's colored because I want but there were some twists and turns because Joe was leading for I'd say a huge portion of the game and I thought that he was gonna run away with that so yeah yeah the there there were definitely moments I loved certain parts of the started like wow this is really cool I want to see where this goes but they came really far at the end and almost when it didn't matter anymore and then and then the game was over so yeah I didn't enjoy for the story so much but more the surprises and unlocking all that stuff last thing I'll say is like what I didn't like about this the stickers or all the stickers are really strong and it's like when I'm super you

know lieutenant so when I'm trying to line up on the rulebook just perfectly are on the board if it's just a little off it's gonna stay little you're not gonna be able to adjust that and readjust that so that was like cotton every time like you to hear me put on a sticker in a row but like damn it I'm messed up again but okay so let's get to our final thoughts as you guys know we're each gonna get a d20 die we're gonna roll them see how many words we get to make our final conclusions about this game so let's do that all right roll 11 Joe is gonna wait for us seven seven all right so he had seven 10 and 11 worse to give our final thoughts alright we're back with the most boring set of roles we've had on the show so far seven words ten words 11 words so I go first because I had the highest amount easy to learn colorful vibrant full of surprises but slightly repetitive right Kristina what are your final 10 words very adorable village building with a sprinkling of storytelling seven words for you that forever King is feeling kinda meh hmm okay cool all right so now we're gonna give our final votes on the game and now I think he just gave us a preview of how you're gonna vote here if you love the game give it two thumbs up if you like the game give it one and then if you're okay or man on the game give a sideways thumb if you

dislike the game thumbs down okay all right on three ready one two three oh that's what alright so got two thumbs up to like sand in one okay man on the game alright so thank you guys for all the time and all the hours we poured into this thing I'm glad we finally got to finish the campaign so now let's kick it over to Sean baby okay this is called Furby adventure game let me try to explain the game in its entirety you draw a card and then you go to that space that is you're done now add a bunch of little dead eyes looking at you and like sort of a second language element because when you do draw the card you're supposed to read it and it says in the manual you can read it in English or in furbish or both so for example you might draw a card and it would say mail aha I mean I don't have to explain to you what that means but what that means is hug me and that's a thing that you're just supposed to do in the middle of this game which look at the scissors for six players can you imagine trying to get anyone who's attention span is bad enough that they could enjoy this to sit through this with six other people it's impossible it's a de Lucas thing to even think about and this is [ __ ] hey I don't see you like it's just it's the [ __ ]

chittering 's of a madman written down on a card for children I'm not even least this is exactly how it came in the thing I didn't set these up to say I'll go let's stack some ridiculous ones this one just says calm me mean ulu which of course means I'm very happy it's just it it's just a nice thing to hear when you're playing Furby Adventureland I like this is what this card says which couldn't possibly be honest under any circumstances you know I was reading about this thing that happened were a bunch of the lunatics who collect this type of thing all called into the same radio show and all the fur bees we're gonna like talk to each other in unison this might be an urban legend someone please Google but they started to do it like hi I'm a Furby and then they're Furbys like oh I heard that I'm gonna say something too like for example I'm a Coco hit me again so this this started to happen they're all talking to each other over the radio and they all just died like they all just malfunctioned and died no one knows why it might not have ever happened it seems like a kind of thing you'd read about in the 90s that was of course not true you tickle me oon a uni ta ha normally this would probably mean like you made me laugh but in this case it's probably a command I don't like this game I don't trust this game and that's seriously that's the whole [ __ ] game for the adventure game we're done the end

Progress saved