Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detective: City of Angels - Discussion

Transcript 35:40

viewer discretion is advised everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video head one welcome to the discussion for detective City of Angels now we did the classic mode spoilers by the way is we're going to be talking about at least the first case blood on the pier but they do have but they do have two modes actually they have a couple modes which would be two they have sleuth mode this is actually made to be solo or cooperative although it basically takes a way to roll the chisel and each each case I don't want to take it out each case basically has kind of like a grid system that will tell you like what cards to look at and and so on and so forth so if you don't like the somewhat the role of someone playing like the chisel or the gym you can do that then they also have uh no where is it like they have their this head-to-head mode so you can play if it's only playing with two players lunch is on one detective or or two let's see uh Orko offer the version with two detectives so hey they have a couple options because like the what makes this

game unique and different from detective modern crime or game Sherlock Holmes and you know Chronicle the crime is that it's not cooperative this is a competitive game so what do you guys think about that um I liked and disliked it yeah yeah I'm kind of in the same boat I think it's neat like cuz that's comps I imagine some cops see it that way like the more cases they solve right I'll advance their careers basically in like the 50s oh yeah um so I think that's the Matic I also don't like it because I didn't like competing with cat because I wanted us to both figure out and did it right right yeah what'd you think I felt like it was um it was it was just weird because like I can just piggyback off of what Josh was doing and it's like oh I found it out - yeah I think there's not enough there's not enough secrecy that like I can I can just start copying Josh you could because like if I go too far off I don't know it's it's weird it's interesting it's definitely a new concept I've got my tongue gotcha um there's a new concept but I don't know it was just it was just strange so here's here's actually why I very much like the competitive nature of it and it actually has it harkens down to

the role of the shizzle because they're basically the the heart of the game um so if you're playing the chisel and you have so yes you could easily copy what another detective is doing it really only working sent a three-player game you had one person go off of whereas and if there's more detectives they're gonna find more things and you can be like oh I'll go after that person so this one but you could do that however what prevents that from happening or potentially prevent that from being effective is the responses I choose to give you that's also true yeah so if you like he could go and I can be like okay I'll just give him the right answer because sometimes they were conflicting answers and I was giving you that word the most useful yeah um what when we got the one where dumbs like he likes girl like hot dog hot dog with all this like nonsense a life can't be this dog yeah yeah well there was there's time whenever you question Charlie and question Dee and I had them write each other out and so I could eat like and this is why I was actually at first I didn't like being the chisel because I all I did was hand you guys stuff but then I started doing things a little bit different way well it did different that made it fun for me so uh but yeah so you can follow him he could be getting nonsense and I could be giving you the exact same amount of nonsense or I could be giving you the right answer or I can give you nonsense

and he could choose not to challenge take for face value than I could you could challenge my back there you go he's actually right and now you have leverage on them which made it means like okay now I'm going to ask him about the body boom he has to tell me the right answer so you could do that and it would affect either one of you differently just by following here's why I like the role of the chisel and it happened whenever cat's first guests came to me and after it was kind of like uh Ziggy you know but you have a difficult decision to make do I want to be difficult like and just constantly keep like like for leverage on you like anytime I get going nope you can't ask that nobody can't snitch anything well what I really really like is this game gives that chisel the opportunity to help people out and hurt others so in a game like this where josh is particularly good at these kinds of games where as they're not your strengths there were times where I would give you the right answer to let you have fun and give you a chance might and I made it harder on him now whether you like that or not comes down to personal preference but I like it because it's like well whenever you gave me your answer you got none from right and so I was like okay so she she like isn't gonna like this game if I use these leverages against her yeah if you made it purposely impossible I haven't been like I don't wanna play this right again though so

knowing that a lot of times I gave you the right answer even if you asked the same thing that he did I gave him false answers lives in misdirections and some of them he but he took and others he challenged and and still got the right answer but he had the work harder for and at the end of the respect in the end result was he both or right you both got it yeah as before which is awesome yeah I do like that I very much like that um because in another game it would just be sorry yeah like you just don't feel [ __ ] daddy sir like Holmes I did it one yeah well I mean even if those things were competitive like there wouldn't be any of that or make it easier on me and harder on them there's none of that it's sorry you're just out of your league here this game lets such as look be like and this was an easy case and at what point did you guys figure out who what who it was right after after I picked so my first guess I picked D is the murderer mm-hmm and then oh we were different yeah oh because as soon as I realized how actually dum-dum is I'm like he do this she she had a pretty good answer when I said I thought I was in the Eleni situation I thought dum accidentally killed her because he saw Sally dragging his brother and oh he might have had a gun so he being you know not it was not

understanding of what murder is brother sure that's what I thought yeah it also helped cuz after she guessed and she said I thought it would be a linear situation I'm like it wasn't him okay I I don't like not being able to talk to Josh because like cuz I do I say things like that or like if he's like have certain reaction like you can be stone-faced like alright you have to be stone-faced but I don't play like that because very much of all of my facial expressions are typically how I feel in the moment and yes to like not even yet over this way that's a valid complaint because typically which this game probably wasn't that fun to do a renter roof because all of it is yeah you instead of like if we did Sherlock or detective or Chronicles which we've done all of them actually Sherlock's not on channel I deleted all of them I took I took off the the campaign because I ate it and so that's why I was like I want to do another one because it's corporate but you have to get that conversation going so for a recording it's constant you know back and forth yeah and here it was really silent yeah what kind of lady like I thought oh I would read this stuff to you like but then if I read something then she would know and so yeah it is a lot of me being quiet can you like yeah you're literally just quiet game it's weird yeah um you know the the it can come from the back and forth of me which I probably didn't really do that good of a job is uh

whenever you went to challenge I could have been like really seems like you don't you like I could have I could have tried it I play it up a little bit yeah and sometimes things like that is like oh he's asking me because there's a reason to and it's like no that's just the step like I have to give you the option to to challenge or bribe or then you make sure everyone picks their thing before before before continuing another thing I really like is that if you are left in the dark in a lot of cases which I can only imagine the because this one made it difficult I mean you guys won you know you won I don't like that tiebreaker rule the reverse tiger II went to me yeah those are sorry seat sirs yeah but you got the right answer so that doesn't it doesn't matter if he tried really hard and you didn't I like you both still got the right answer so the tiebreaker I think makes a little bit of sense because the way the information is displayed and how quickly it is to gather it and kind of how easy for the most part the first person kind of hasn't has a leg up she got to go to the location before you did okay so it's like she found information that you could not find first first so it's like oh great I know who it is so if a tiebreaker it's like you kind of had a leg up from doing four actions before

the other person or held that's only in a two-player game imagine a four player game were like the three other people get to the archived cards birth in the fourth persons like okay I guess I'll just talk to these people so then if they happen to get it just as well they kind of we're at a disadvantage because they didn't get to see those cards so if they figured out just as much as everyone else did the tiebreaker would go to them that's how I view it anyway but I can see a lot of people not liking it and it all comes down to how the chisel wants to play what I just imagine a scenario where the chisel wants to just be an [ __ ] and it's like oh [ __ ] yeah and actually it does it's actually the second way to play the role of the chisel is trying to win at all costs keep the detectives in the dark as long as possible and use all the tools at your disposal to frustrate and delay them if by the end of the game none of them are even close to the correct solution you've done your job well while all players are different we have generally found that playing the chisel in this manner can often result in a frustrating and dissatisfying game for the detective yeah I mean I can imagine playing this game is for children being an [ __ ] yeah like you give people misdirection to make it fun and be like oh okay cuz whenever I was seeing some of the reactions but never you know I'm asking about this sounds like oh Charlie's gonna Charlie says deed in it that could be fun and then you and that's d and then I was like oh he's gonna talk about Charlie so now you have to try and play

you've been around you know how the mob works I say anything and I'm as dead as that broad that's what I said yeah no that's not right now yeah I hate Charlie challenge I challenged it as I gave I gave him Charlie isn't an angel but he isn't a killer either scouts honor he's not the one that took out that Dame and then D not D Charlie yeah Charlie whenever he asked about where is it um oh yeah whenever he asked about whenever Josh fest Charlie buddy I gave him you want the truth he's the one who shot Sally right in the back so you have a lot of options based off of the none of you asked about why she was a drug addict and if you asked about her gun then if you asked about her we asked about her some of you did yeah yeah um how do we ask that she's like why she's a driver do you order this app yeah you probably would have said oh joy I asked about a yeah I thought somebody else I'm gonna here's something really fun is what I thought was hilarious every single one of dumbs options are the right answer he has no no he's just dumb ya know after that first one I'm like oh you guys oh you cos guessed about his brother and he's like dee do you like me and me like Dee do you also like Angie you know Angie he liked her like dumb like hot dogs Oh when they said that like he's either really good at misdirection or he's really like shiny bang bang and I was

like I'm gonna challenge this cake yeah another really good thing about this game is I actually made the characters seem like fleshed out as much as poss oh my god I [ __ ] searched 2d and he's like you're just gonna just gonna search me no warrant yeah okay yeah yeah and I had a memory I hadn't forgot that she searched him so the reason why I didn't give you the search location is cuz I actually forgot that cuz on the bag these are special ones like locations has that had been searched and so those are the ones that I that haven't hand you so I was looking for that on the back of these and doesn't say that for every location so I never I was looking I'm like oh yeah that's right and so there's 96 because they are special once 100 you could have gone to 96 43 and the other two guys and then all other locations so if you had searched [ __ ] 24 for whatever reason it would have been like you find that you don't find anything of note in your frustration you decide to take your anger out on the local wiseguy and you'll receive a scratch so when you either white boys guys guys hey your [ __ ] did you want any cuffs um so use verbally duh the only thing that I got wrong up until you read the epilogue was I figured Charlie gave the gun directly to dumb gotcha he gave it to D and D gave it to dumb yep yep he's like cleaning it up and then shot down wind stop about talking about the bang bang my finger Charlie

just give it to dumb ear play with this right um no the other thing that I really really liked about about this game and I and I kind of touched down a little bit was just how accessible the information is if one person is doing well you'd be like hey I'm gonna pay you to scratch to figure out what what you know like it doesn't even have to be something about that they're personally carrying like it could be oh hey you know Josh has knowledge about that then you can ask him about that and then you would also know it just seems like they did a really good job of making sure that people who are really good at this game it don't completely blow it out of the water for people who aren't really good at these kinds of games it's just al it's a little weird I think it's more weird just because we recorded the game oh you know very notable of how quiet it was I think if we were just playing regularly we would probably had some you know no more music and then very but it would've been even if it'd been more interesting and then you know try to ham it up as much as possible come another Brides right you were right as always sitting there like yeah they have they have multiple like this this was the first case and I think there's like let's see let me look at so that that one's gumshoe that one's gonna shoo so

there are there are three easy cases there once or veterinary minute veteran and then I think there's there's one two three there's three veteran and then a four-bedroom with the expansion and like it takes hard part oil starts because no.3 yeah I think like six hard-boil which which I mean and and I definitely I have a we haven't tried it with I probably like this more on the coop on the sleuth the sleuth one that's a little reason I like detective right right but there is it tell us he says this is accomplished with the aid of a paragraph book called the sleuth case book which includes hundreds of responses written specifically for this version of the game detectives will still need to determine when suspects are lying in when they are telling the truth but instead of the chisel choosing which response a suspect gives players will be instructed to read a specific paragraph in the sleuth book so yeah I mean it could easily easily work out really well I would very much like to try I want to try it on an easy one cuz with though is it's like okay cuz I mean I would very much like to try this on a hard-boiled yeah bite so we have six days by and that was because and the only reason is because each case has like special rules and this one in particular was since this is the introductory case it is intended to be shorter typically you have nine days in

a to Detective player game got to figure it out but since this was the first one that goes to six um I like the use of scratch like that those are very very helpful like goons to ensure that you're getting the right answers I'm gonna look up fly it's called scratch I'm gonna make sure I write what I said was right yeah and then officer you just go and then you hate you don't have to pay someone else snitch was super useful yeah remembering these word bike the most difficult part about being a detective yeah because I mean at the end of the day it it's also interesting and thematic because the example they gave him the rule book was you know someone had just enough money to to snitch but they chose not to but the information that someone god is like no I need to look at car death and it's like oh man I wish I had brought now it's like now they have to go out of their way to do that and you know but they still pay the money yeah now like sit sit and snitch they have to waste another turn to go to a precinct and and pay a cop yeah figure out what you found out yeah and we're going archive or not work I've kick back kick I got a mob location and get your money it's just this is really good and my biggest here's here's the next question between detective meet those tails I guess is another one okay

I'm waiting for that video demo chronicles of crime and all that do you think that this warrants owning between all of them if you if I since I own all of them I own all Sherlock's I own detective I own chronicles the crime and I own me those tales do you think this is worth having in that same collection because that was my biggest concern detective and chronicles came out last year in 2018 and I knew this was on its way at some point and I was like I'm worried that those two games being so good that this one is gonna be well another one I know my answer yes you think yes I think you should keep this I think it's worth keeping it well not that me personally that's it being in general do you think if someone owns those games do you think that they should also on this one if if they're into having a competitive nature of it yes very much so I agree I'm definitely keeping it I've Airy much liked it at first I was like man I really don't like being the chisel but I'm also never the DM mm-hm and I don't like stuff like that so like Devin my Laurell didn't relish at being the chisel Knight and I would like to play and if you as look as you guys DM i-i've I like being in the story I don't like knowing the story I like doing both yeah especially because and who knows and that's why I said I want to try a hard-boiled one because I could have a lot more fun there's a lot more options it's easier for me because the case is a

lot more difficult to solve so the the easier the case the harder it is for the chisel and vice versa so who knows I'm I'm very much like being that chiseling a harder one cuz I get to play around more there wasn't really a whole lot of options for me to give once I kind of figured out oh you probably know it there's three people to [ __ ] talk to yeah limited limited amount of suspects and involved locations um weapons and there were two weapons and then the victim was a drug addict yeah it's but it was pretty easier piece together after I figured out that gun and after i'ts I went to solve and I was almost up I was almost hundred percent sure that if it came down to it it was either D or mugs right right and that's and that's usually I was gonna be but like looking at the the next gumshoe one there's way more options already from that so a lot more ways to mess with you a lot lot like in in that there is weather 34 55 it's 55 in that grid and they all have multiple responses whether to misdirect and lie and so I will say this game if you choose to be the chisel you have to know the game inside and out and you also have to know that scenario inside that just like we would a scenario in that Gainey book because

it's like well I might answer this and there are a lot of times where it's like okay how did they respond but that and that's fine like it's like I have to know I'll do all the show with this ones we just did it that's what it looks like the Reds misdirection and lies in the black is the most useful answer and I also really like that I like how I accessible and easy the game actually is but I also like how the most peaceful answer isn't always like aha because they could have easily been met it could have been like wow G said this about the gun well that tells me the answer right away it because it doesn't I mean I don't even know about the gun oh that's the Dames a little peashooter she stuck it in my face and threatened me if I didn't give her the dope that's when she got popped in the back and some people could have been like I'll be shocked but then I go it's in the back hold and it would've been him yeah I was like what has to be a second person it's just yeah it's just really really neat and things like that yeah in the beginning case you're like okay it was indeed so there's only two other people dumb broad and kept I mean kept it's all your your initial answer was like okay it made sense some people might not like this based off the restrictive nature of questioning because but I'd like to question a about B or whatever yeah like it suspect one it's very on the nose but I think that

if you want extensive questioning like that play detective a modern crime board game or Chronicles a crime kick you can gather information and go back and scan them say I really like both of those yeah I don't remember if I gave them scores when we played them you did not because we had not recorded them we just played it that's correct um but ya know this game this game is actually is really good and I'm very happy with it this was also a Kickstarter game freak's couldn't tell if we used to tell could yeah no I really couldn't um it's it's fantastic they made they made another Kickstarter game called the big score which was about the heist the problem I played it that one's a lot of fun too it's the only game I've ever won and don't know oh yeah you just win this one now but I wasn't competing against you so it's a false [ __ ] where's the tally sheet um I'm actually gonna look up how much this cost um I a big complaint is the tiebreaker thing I realize it if more players just for this particular situation feels real shitty right but I mean since it's not a cooperative game and makes sense and I'd be like you both win yeah I mean and at the end of the day like since you and the only reason there was a tie breakers because you both got it right that's even a day then it doesn't really matter like CAG could be like I still got it

like but she got like if she's her answer was still zero out of three it's like but where is my participation I also really like that like the suspense is because it even told me not to say you won until after I read the epilogue he's gonna wait it's a Bugatti but through at least that one in particular you could most likely be like yeah okay it tells me right then and there who who did it um there's this I paid eighty nine dollars for this I don't even know that was a thing it was just like hey it's up reading the thing did just go to our website and we have to professional voice reporting which that was really really good yeah I really like that and I'm glad because I thought because in the end of you know thing had told me you you know wind up flip cards and when to get everything set up I was really worried that there was gonna say that like it was too many like yeah something in sally foote got a little egg salad with no dessert [ __ ] like that I love those like those one-liner things those are great but then I thought was gonna be like flip case hey and like it would break the tension but whenever it didn't do that I was like oh no tusen they're like where's where's 99 where's the honey yeah we're 96 ahead we're trying to help you were like what yeah it's doing missing it but yeah like I can't really think of anything else like I did a

really good job with the the response cards and just little packets like here you know only you can see it so you don't actually see other things I like the variance in card size I like the artwork yeah the artwork is really nice I like the even though it's like your typical like cardboard stuff I do like it it looks printed correctly yeah the other thing I really like player AIDS or vegan chicken how do you open this you have the casebook like don't look at the other ones well I guess doesn't matter if you're but like it yeah you have a case book and it tells you like what it says I like the player aid on the back that is really nice on the back this is like typical cardboard but yeah which we didn't even we didn't read this yeah so I think yeah I think this is just available to you that would make say yes you would have had the case booking that you opened it which I realized I didn't really know I never did it so scale of 1 to 10 cat could do this is probably lower than both ours no working again I mean I don't want to write it too low I just didn't I just dislike the I dislike the competitive nature but knowing that

it does have a co-op option brings it back to life I'll give it up right I'll give it a seven okay for what it is and what it does I personally didn't like it as a competitive game I would like to see what it's like as a co-op game or maybe maybe competitive with more people I don't know if that would also make it worse or if it would make it better yeah I'm trying to I'm trying to think I never know how it would work I don't know I think with this the competitive nature with this style game I think it would work great at any number yeah like a null reality because movement is not a hassle so it's really like if a person's over here and then there's no look another one over here it's not like it's gonna take forever to just be like oh maybe five turns to get over there no it's just like boom boom boom and then you're there which is great I'm so glad I made it that easy instead of like oh you can give four ways to move or any of that yeah like look you can get to your people the game is not about how you're gonna finish it's gonna it's about how you were interact with with the suspect and and solve the case it's just a little stuff around it comic detective has the same thing like travelling costs an hour right oh crap okay something something about that then we have to go with it over time exactly yeah um but

yeah I'll give it a 7 okay don't shrink or give it a eight and a half in 8.5 I yeah I think about 8.5 as well with definite potential to go off oh yeah but I think based off right now 8.5 because I was teetering on the chiseled and I liked it at the end so yeah because I was like because I was trying to be like oh yeah like because it gave me two options on how they made the chisel I'm like I'll just be generic and helpful but then I'm like well Josh already probably figured it out cats not anywhere close oh I'll just be more difficult on Josh and then so he'll get the challenge and which ie I was welcoming right so I like the that this game provides I like it too um I also like the one salt thing because that reminds me of deception murder in Hong Kong it's like because if you get it right if you're like I like to solve on my turn in to the right then then it's a game and you want and I'll read the epilogue that's a lot of tension because at any moment someone could be like I'm gonna solve Anita crap I was gonna solve on my next turn but if everyone's wrong then it goes to final guess and everyone gets another chance but then you have to figure it out and if none of you got it right then I would have been like ooh case cold another negative that people could have is that you could never play the skin yeah that you can do that

that's with all of them like they're all that way so and I would argue and be like that sucks oh I haven't even finished the first [ __ ] Sherlock Holmes I was gonna say you didn't have as many games that's true humble brag but if you a problem um if you didn't have like as much to do or just a constant influx yeah I'm just new games then yeah I can see like I can't play that's kind of lame yeah like I'm gonna have nine times to play it but if you're casual like that like it your eligible if you're just playing it to have a good time like how often are you really gonna get to the table exactly so even if you play these over a year how many did you say there were thirteen fourteen thirteen thirteen total total so break that up I mean want someone play one once a month on a big game night so I mean yeah and to me that's worth it and I will say this even though I gave it a lower score than you guys it's just that voice acting alone was really funny yeah he did a really good job that was not true thank God but when they said professional thought they were like professional in-house it was the designer but you're right so some people but like I said there's ten cases in the first Sherlock Holmes box and we've done at this point think we've done five or six of them yeah and now it came out years ago and

that's two other big boxes with ten in each of them so and it's the detective then there's Chronicle to crime and there's just so much to this that and I guarantee you people aren't running to the [ __ ] table to play these insane like we're not getting it right I just thought I'll burn Lincoln I want to think yeah so that's never a negative on my end but eight point five it's not good enough to be a nine but it is far better than an eight yeah it's it could easily be a nine depending on other cases and things like that but I will say in relation to detective and chronicles this does not this as of right now it does not beat them it does not but I really think that cooperative nature is really cool I think it's a really cool twist because whenever I was looking at this I was like you're gonna be a really neat table RPG a detective sleuth style game I can't think of any tabletop RPGs they're all high fantasy or I sci-fi or you know weird mythological stuff none of them are actually ever set in real world stuff like this and this essentially does that and I think that's a really cool really cool twist on it so that's what everyone bets or thoughts on detective City of Angels loads number you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a

little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you

Progress saved