Kemet Blood & Sand Review: The Pinnacle of "Dudes On a Map" Games - By Board Of It
Transcript
hi everyone talia and farrell here from board of it and welcome to our review of comet blood and sand a big box filled with giant scorpions sphinxes and angry ancient egyptian gods of war for between two to five players this is a pretty classic dudes on the map game did you say dogs on a mac no we said dudes on a map oh okay but there's enough twists in this big box to make it incredibly engaging and fun so engaging in fact that even tally enjoys playing blood and sand is an updated version of the classic game from the matagot dude on the map trilogy of kiklardi's kimet and innis with the new art direction upgraded components and a slight smoothing out of the rules for new players so should you get comet blood and sand if you have original command what's it like a different play accounts why does tally like it despite not really liking dudes on the map games all good questions all of which we plan to answer so let's hop to it
is played over a series of rounds with each round broken into two phases the day phase where players will take their actions and the night phase which is where players will gain income and score the aim of the game is to have nine or more fame points which is just a silly name for victory points at the beginning of your turn in the day phase however the twist comes in that some fp are permanent and some are linked to area control on the main board so they can be taken away from you you can earn fp in a variety of ways by winning a battle as the attacker by controlling a temple by controlling two temples by controlling a level four pyramid and by controlling the temple of all gods in the night phase and sacrificing two soldiers the actions players can do on their turn are actually quite straightforward the first is you can pray to gain prayer points which is the game's currency the next is to move the move action gives you the option to do a teleportation and a land movement so a land movement it's just moving one adjacent space or a teleportation is paying two prayer points to teleport from the temple you control to any obelisk on the map you can recruit which is to pay prior points equal to the number of troops you want to recruit and then to recruit those troops from your supply and put them in a district in your city you can increase the level of one of your pyramids which is to
pay prior points equal to the level that you're bringing it up to finally you can purchase a power tile of a color of a pyramid you control what level of power type you can buy is related to the level of pyramids you control this being a level 3 red pyramid would let you buy level 3 and below red tiles this being a level 1 blue pyramid will only let you buy level 1 blue tiles the power tiles will provide you with bonuses upgrades new actions in all areas of the game much of the game is area control and when one player moves a troop into another area controlled by another player a battle occurs a battle is done through card play where both players pick one card to play and another card to discard then they add up the combat value on that card along with the number of soldiers they have in an area any divine intervention cards and any power up tiles that add combat bonuses and the highest value wins commet blood and sand also has relatively simple player actions but these combined with the multiple ways to score fp and the wonderful variety of power tiles to create real depth of gameplay these simple actions also mean that unless someone is starting trouble player turns are pretty quick
so commet avoids the usual long stody turns of battle game but if someone is starting trouble it's pretty engaging for both those players we're glad to report that the battle system in comet blood and sand is quite excellent even though it's a simple card driven system it's actually quite multi-dimensional you see each combat card you have has different symbols on it which means that throughout the game you'll have a variety of tactical options available to you even better actually winning a combat doesn't kill the enemy troops they just have to retreat to an adjacent region or that player who lost could return them to the supply to gain prayer points for them to actually kill troops in combat you have to play combat cards with red blood drop symbols on them but this can be counteracted by the defensive player playing a combat card with a shield on it unless there is a black blood drop in play this means that different players can aim for different things in the same battle if someone comes at you and you really have no way of winning you just can aim to kill as many of their soldiers as possible if you kill them all even if they win the battle they won't score a fame point because they don't hold the territory plus because every player begins the game with the same deck of eight cards you have to discard one every time there's a battle there's uncertainty around which players have which cards left so there's a tactical aspect to that you could pick on a player with any two
cards left and that could be an easy win plus combat it's just generally pretty low risk if you lose you might not even lose any of your soldiers but if you do they're pretty cheap and easy to recruit back into your city and the thing is this combination means that the game and the battle is light and breezy in terms of player frustration but with enough depth to allow intelligent tactical maneuvering another aspect of the game that's worth talking about are these wonderful divine intervention cards these are little one-use bonus cards with a wide range of effects that can affect any area of the game one might let you remove an enemy soldier anywhere on the map another might give you instant prey points to spend there and then we're big fans of these and they're all really useful in their own right but a lot of them are directed at giving you a little edge in battle and you can play them secretly which means that your opponents can be in for a wonderfully nasty surprise and it just gives combat yet another little twist which is what makes it so great these are wonderfully tactical and they can really make a plan that you form your head pop plus if you can actually get any tiles which increase how many you can draw you're going to be laughing so speaking of we can now finally discuss the best part of commet blood and sand power tiles the base game comes with four different types you've got pokemon red you've got pokemon blue you've got pokemon diamond and you've got pokemon
onyx each one does its own little thing so red tiles are attack focused blue tiles are defensive focused diamond tiles are about upgrading your engine so maybe if you do prayer action you get an extra prayer point or your pyramids cost one less prayer point to build things like that and onyx is a bit of a mix of everything but mainly combative and defensive and there's things such as you can actually buy a bunch of extra troop figures for your army to increase your total potential army pool the designers have absolutely nailed this aspect of the gameplay as pretty much all of the tiles are useful to the majority of players most of the time these tiles allow players to create near asymmetric factions in exactly the manner they'd like and provide wonderful wrinkles to otherwise straightforward gameplay the highlight is of course the giant miniatures which are linked to certain tiles and if deployed with a tree provide movement and combat upgrades i mean who doesn't want a troop with a giant scorpion crucially commit blood and sand also includes a wine list as shut up and sit down term them for every player these lists describe what the effect is of every tile that's in the game and also what all of the divine intervention cards do this is so important for enjoyable gameplay obviously players don't want to have to ask what a divine intervention card does because then they give away their advantage and players will often spend time in between turns perusing the list and deciding on
a future strategy we cannot stress enough how important it is that every player has their own especially when so few games do something like this when it's really needed it's not all positive though see the rule book can be a bit of a tough read even though it's quite short and straightforward i think rather than being poorly written it's more of a translation issue in being translated from french it's just that the sentence structure isn't quite there and sometimes things can be put a bit awkwardly and it just leads to things being more confusing than they have to be and leaving things open to interpretation which is really the last thing you want in a highly interactive game also the endgame of comet can either be terrifically exciting or terribly long and drawn out because it's a crabs in a bucket game as soon as one player crosses this line every other player's goal is then to pull them back down or the game's over which they can often do because of some vp being linked to territory control and what this means is you just have players jostling back and forth one player going front being pulled down another player going in front being pulled down and this can artificially extend the game you know this is a game where you can win on your next turn and then the game goes on for another 50 minutes and while this cycle does eventually break often it's after the game's gone on for uncomfortably long and it's also often down to just simple things like attrition turn order or a bit of luck which can be disappointing on the other hand
this often allows all players to catch up and be in contention for the win we've never had a game where all players didn't have their nose up against the finish line which is nice to keep everyone involved also if it doesn't go on too long the end game can be wonderfully tense and exciting now comment blood and sand is full between two to five players and it probably is a little more interesting at those higher player counts the game was definitely shaking up a bit when we played at four compared to when we played with two or three and all of this comes from the map being opened up so there's more spaces to inhabit and also just that there's more players to attack now the negative of having these higher player accounts is that you're going to have more battles more times and particularly in the early stages if two other people that aren't you are having a battle you're not really that interested in the minute details of it you just want to see the aftermath and because turns can be so quick it creates a real choppy flow to the game like a real stop start which isn't so great but you know it's actually a game that's good at any play account and it's not one that would say buy if you're only going to play with two players but if you have it it's definitely worth playing at two players we will say though we're not huge fans of how the board is altered depending on the number of players the board is a pretty decent size but comet is a bit of a table hogging game so there's not much space around you but weirdly they've decided to split the board lengthways depending on how many players there are so if you're playing with
three or less you're all using the same side of the board which seems like a bit of a waste of table space and it's always going to be awkward for at least one of you bit weird so should you get this if you own comment already no we don't think so it just seems to be original comment just updated and revised a little bit i think there's some new tiles updated artwork maybe some new figurines that's about it they actually had in the same kickstarter a version 1.5 upgrade kit for the original commet and that might be worth looking into we never played the original so we might be wrong but a quick scan of the original rule book showed no drastic changes so final thoughts this is one of the best examples of the dudes on a map genre that even managed to draw in non-fans with its simple core actions mixed with depth of gameplay from the huge variety of power tiles ways to score fp and the tactical combat options this is really a game we'd recommend to a very wide range of people like it's fun it's just really really fun but if you have comment original you don't need it and if you're not going to be playing it with at least three plus players most of the time you don't want it and that is our review of commet blood and sand so thank you for watching sven stop licking me and if you guys could subscribe if you're not already it would be incredible and also comment like all the usual stuff but we do want you to comment so we can discuss the game with you hear what you think about original command
power tiles scorpio miniatures all of it but thanks for watching as always we really appreciate it oh my god