Windmill Valley (Blooming Sails) - Board Game Expansion Review
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm the broken meatball. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you. Welcome to another Beyond the Base game video. This one's been in somewhat high demand by one or two people. I don't know. I haven't seen many people talk about this expansion. This is the Windmill Valley Blooming Sales Expansion. So, Windmill Valley, I've done a video on this, I believe. So, by all means, check out my full thoughts on the game, but suffice to say, I like it. It's still IN MY COLLECTION.
WINDMILLS DO NOT WORK THAT WAY. GOOD NIGHT.
I DON'T GO MAD for a lot of Danny Garcia's games. It's definitely a bit more of a mixed bag, maybe skewed towards less rather than more, but this is one that I actually quite enjoyed. Bright colored, nice, simple rules.
Mikey, I think he likes it.
But it wasn't without some flaws. And the main flaw of the game was that the foreign trade action sucked. It really did. I mean, it was a minor action in the game, so I kind of just ignored it for the most part and focused on other stuff. But yeah, it's a problem. The foreign trade action in that game is just not interesting. It's not even that lucrative at times. Occasionally, I might use it, but for the most part, I'll find another way. What the whole point of Blooming Sales is, though, is to fix that entirely. to completely revamp how the foreign trade action works, introduce a bit more in interesting gameplay for it, more opportunities for scoring, more bonuses, and just generally, you know, change how that action works so that it's a more interesting part of the game. Does it succeed? Let's find out.
Wingers, Dingus, listen up.
So, as I said, this expansion completely revamped the foreign trade action. The starting part is the same. You have a new inlay tile to reflect like some rules changes, but you still have these cards where you basically can put a tulip on. You get the two bonuses either side or you can take all the tulips off, you know. So, that bit is still the same. Where things differ though is when you focus on this board here because after you have decided to place a tulip on the uh foreign trade card, you're able to then move your ship with the use of tools and deliver tulips to these different ports. So, these ports have different requirements for like a what color tulips they want. But what you do is you basically with a spare tulip that you have, you know, let's say I'll just take a red one here. You have now got between players, I'm just going to tip this little box out here, these little crate tiles that you keep at the start of the game. And so, if I want to deliver a red tulip to this particular port here, I place my crate down. It will score me points at the end of the game for how many crates I've delivered, but it will also get me the bonus for the specific port. Now, the port may just get me like another card, you know, let me plant some tulips and that. But what it might also do is essentially allow me to customize my board slightly.
So, there's a couple of ways it can do that. You have tiles that can customize how many points you score for your rows and columns. So, that's a nice little neat bit there. You can also gain double tulip tiles which effectively plant on your board and cover up, well, you've guessed it, two spaces. So, it's basically getting two tulips for nothing effectively. But you can also obtain sometimes these single patch tiles. And these will also be dotted out on the main board where certain windmill spots will let you get them. But what these single patch tiles do is they customize what bonuses you get off your board. So for example, you know, I might have some spaces here and I might add a two money bonus or another plant or a, you know, get another um what do they call it? You know, enhancement card. But you can even cover up bonuses that you previously had before. You won't get the bonus, but it's like, you know what? I don't need a tool for my next bonus. I would quite like two money though, so I'm going to put a two money spot there. Plant the tulip, get the bonus. It just enables you to customize what bonuses you get off your board, but you can also obtain them by the initial windmill actions as well. And the other part that changes is this calendar board. This calendar bit was basically the timer for the game. So when you span your wheel round, you moved up a space. Well, now you've got two versions of a revised board, which effectively has not only some bonuses below, which is first come, first serve, but also an income space. Depending where your ship is on this board, as you sail it down, there's effectively three different regions. There is a income bonus for getting spare tulips or doing
a lot of planting depending how far your ship is down. And the path is not strictly linear. I mean, you have to kind of curve around and, you know, go to a fair few ports. And if you're trying to visit all eight to get the maximum points for this, then well, you're going to be sailing quite a bit there. But it's a nice little bonus you get every time you go through the stages of the calendar tile. So, there's not much more to say. That is what this expansion does. A few more enhancement cards, single patch tiles over here, but for the most part, it's this board and the foreign trade revamp. And even though that's only a small aspect, it makes a big deal here. The foreign trade really just wasn't interesting in the base game, and it was a big issue. Here though, this board completely changes it up and makes it so much better. You You only lay out eight of these tiles at the start. There'll be one or two spare. So, they've got differing, you know, variations as to what needs to be delivered. But, it's not these that's important. It's the bonuses you get with them. You've got a good well, I forget exactly how much, but yeah, around like 13 plus tiles here. And you only use eight of them, and they're going to be in different spaces because these are not fixed. This one here, for example, gets me that um row scoring tile upgrade that I mentioned, you know, this one here. But this you take it out. So, this is customized at the start of the game.
So, this tile might be instead free money as a bonus. It might be an enhancement card. It might be free tulips. You know, it can be all sorts of different bonuses. And they are randomly arranged at the start, which means this board is heavily, you know, varied from game to game. You know, you may only want to sail a little bit because you like the bonuses or you might make it the focus of your entire strategy. And I did that in the first game. First game I put this expansion in. I thought I'm doing full shipping. Let's see what happens. It's harder than you think to get eight of these crates out. Believe me, I couldn't get eight of them out, but I was able to do quite a lot of the bonuses from shipping and do well on that. So, foreign trade has now become a legit action. It's not fallen to the danger of power creep where if you focus on the shipping, you're going to completely demolish everybody no matter what. I I suspect it's worth doing a little bit of the shipping area. So, you can't just ignore it completely entirely. I think you should at least do a little bit of it, but it's not it doesn't have to be the focus of your game. You could ignore it entirely if you want to and just focus on windmills and planting just like you did in the base game. But I like the fact that you now have the situation where on your cog wheel of actions, the foreign trade doesn't feel like one you just automatically skip. Now it's like, you know what? Yeah, foreign trade. I'll get those bonuses and then I can sail to this one. I got a spare violet tulips sitting around here. So, let's deliver it. Oh, cool. I get another um extra action wheel thing. So, that's actually not too bad. And this sort of thing elevates the action so much. And it kind of makes this expansion, I would say,
borderline essential. It, you know, everything it does for this action is an improvement. None of it is bad. It's all good. I like the fact that you've got different things here. I mean, you you won't even necessarily have the ability to get both of these enhancements to your main board in the game. There's two bonuses that reflect to these. If they're not in the game, they don't turn up, but if they do, you've got something else you could do. And if you're planning to plant a lot of tulips in the various rows for bonuses, then you might do enough shipping so that you can grab this tile and make the points more lucrative. Definitely worth it. So, it just adds that little bit of extra variety and improves an action that was previously essentially defunct. The double tulip tiles, they're great, you know, for speedy completion of a board. Uh you don't get many of them, but you know, it's nice to get one or two of those. Uh the like customizing with the single patch tiles, that can be pretty cool, especially if you're doing a lot of windmill actions. you might get quite a few of those. And again, bonuses, bonuses, it's all good. It's all positive. And if you want to focus on the shipping for the scoring, well, then you can, you know, do so. It's good that there's another use for the tools as well, because sometimes in the base game, I found that if you you end up with so many tools, you don't know what to do with them, cuz it's not often you need to spin the wheel that much, especially when you can juggle around the water level. Well, now the tools can be spent on moving your ship from port to port. So, tools never feel redundant anymore or never feel useless. It's like, well, I don't need to do much my action wheel. Well, I might as well move the fast because if I go all the way down, my income bonus is better, even if I do no deliveries whatsoever.
That in itself is a plus. But maybe the tiles I want or the bonuses I want are at the bottom of the board. In which case, I bet a sail down there post haste. You know, it it just does a good job of making it a lot more interesting. Not to say else, it's it doesn't add to the time length. I mean, apart from adding a little bit more on the teach, obviously, it doesn't make the game longer, you know. Yes, this action will take a little bit more time, but not drastically, you know, and you could be ignoring it. So, I never found that the game went on too long as a result. Uh, it doesn't really add that much complexity to the game. You know, if you can understand this, you can understand this, fine. It's good enough to just throw into a normal game of this. I don't see why you would remove this expansion and teach a lesser version of the action to new players. You know, you want to get people interested in the game. Why would you teach them a subpar version when this is just infinitely better in every way? It's small. It's not the cheapest expansion in the world.
I think it was in the mid20s or something, although, you know, it's not too bad. Um, if you've got the folded space insert like I have, you'll notice I've got the UV printed version here. It will fit the expansion in as well. So you should even without the insert, you should have no trouble getting all the components of this into the box. So you don't need to have this as a secondary thing. So that's all good. It's just exactly what an expansion should do for a game. Fix the problems, not add too much complexity, add a bit more variety, and there you go. That's all you need to do. Oh, and be like easy to teach and incorporate it. You especially for like new players where you can just throw it straight in. If you tick all those boxes, you have a fantastic expansion. And that's what this is. It's a fantastic expansion. If you have Windmill Valley, you're doing yourself a disservice by not buying this. You know, the game is not broken if you don't have it. So, okay, it's not like if you buy the game, you must at all costs buy the expansion. No, but you are going to notice that foreign trade action being a bit, you know, so you're probably going to want to invest in this shortly after your first couple of games of Windmill Valley, I would say. Like if you just buy the base game, try the game, and if you enjoy it, get the expansion. Like, full stop. If you don't enjoy it, this game is not going to this expansion won't, sorry, won't like improve it to the extent that you suddenly like it now. That's not going to happen. You have to like the stuff that Windmill Valley is about to appreciate the expansion because the improvement of one action is not going to suddenly convert
you from hate it to love it. No, it's not going to work like that. But I think if you're a fan of the game, it's needed. You know, there's very little negative I can really say about it. It does exactly what it needs to do. I'm giving it a 10 out of 10. This is an expansion that I would damn basically damn near call essential. really, you know, you don't have to buy it instantly when you buy the game. Fair enough. And typically with 10 out of 10, I tend to go for that. Although that makes it difficult for an expansion to get a 10 out of 10, period, frankly. But, you know, I think for this, it is one of those where if you are buying the game and you think you're going to like it, you might want to buy it straight away just so that you get the best experience out of the gate. I love it. It's in the box. It's never going to get taken out.
I'm going to teach it with the expansion all the time. It's just a great addition. Well done. You fixed the biggest problem with the original game. Thumbs up.
SHUT UP AND TAKE my money.
So, that's it for me on this episode of The Broken People. If you like what we see, then please thumb it up on YouTube, Facebook, Board Game Geek, wherever you see this video, by all means, share it. Get it out there. Stick it on Born and Dice's website. You know, do whatever you can to share it and get it out on the algorithm. Of course, let me know your thoughts down below. Do you enjoy Windmill Valley in general, or do you hate it? in which case while you're watching this video, but also have you tried the expansion? What do you think of the foreign trade action in the base game? You know, do you think the base a the base game version is fine? You know, doesn't need improvement. Do you think this expansion fixes the problem or do you think it's just adding too much extra? Like I say, let's get your thoughts down below. Until next time, remember, it's only a game. And I'll see you on the next Broken People video. Take care, everyone.